-
Automated Classification of Model Errors on ImageNet
Authors:
Momchil Peychev,
Mark Niklas Müller,
Marc Fischer,
Martin Vechev
Abstract:
While the ImageNet dataset has been driving computer vision research over the past decade, significant label noise and ambiguity have made top-1 accuracy an insufficient measure of further progress. To address this, new label-sets and evaluation protocols have been proposed for ImageNet showing that state-of-the-art models already achieve over 95% accuracy and shifting the focus on investigating w…
▽ More
While the ImageNet dataset has been driving computer vision research over the past decade, significant label noise and ambiguity have made top-1 accuracy an insufficient measure of further progress. To address this, new label-sets and evaluation protocols have been proposed for ImageNet showing that state-of-the-art models already achieve over 95% accuracy and shifting the focus on investigating why the remaining errors persist.
Recent work in this direction employed a panel of experts to manually categorize all remaining classification errors for two selected models. However, this process is time-consuming, prone to inconsistencies, and requires trained experts, making it unsuitable for regular model evaluation thus limiting its utility. To overcome these limitations, we propose the first automated error classification framework, a valuable tool to study how modeling choices affect error distributions. We use our framework to comprehensively evaluate the error distribution of over 900 models. Perhaps surprisingly, we find that across model architectures, scales, and pre-training corpora, top-1 accuracy is a strong predictor for the portion of all error types. In particular, we observe that the portion of severe errors drops significantly with top-1 accuracy indicating that, while it underreports a model's true performance, it remains a valuable performance metric.
We release all our code at https://github.com/eth-sri/automated-error-analysis .
△ Less
Submitted 13 November, 2023;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Human-Guided Fair Classification for Natural Language Processing
Authors:
Florian E. Dorner,
Momchil Peychev,
Nikola Konstantinov,
Naman Goel,
Elliott Ash,
Martin Vechev
Abstract:
Text classifiers have promising applications in high-stake tasks such as resume screening and content moderation. These classifiers must be fair and avoid discriminatory decisions by being invariant to perturbations of sensitive attributes such as gender or ethnicity. However, there is a gap between human intuition about these perturbations and the formal similarity specifications capturing them.…
▽ More
Text classifiers have promising applications in high-stake tasks such as resume screening and content moderation. These classifiers must be fair and avoid discriminatory decisions by being invariant to perturbations of sensitive attributes such as gender or ethnicity. However, there is a gap between human intuition about these perturbations and the formal similarity specifications capturing them. While existing research has started to address this gap, current methods are based on hardcoded word replacements, resulting in specifications with limited expressivity or ones that fail to fully align with human intuition (e.g., in cases of asymmetric counterfactuals). This work proposes novel methods for bridging this gap by discovering expressive and intuitive individual fairness specifications. We show how to leverage unsupervised style transfer and GPT-3's zero-shot capabilities to automatically generate expressive candidate pairs of semantically similar sentences that differ along sensitive attributes. We then validate the generated pairs via an extensive crowdsourcing study, which confirms that a lot of these pairs align with human intuition about fairness in the context of toxicity classification. Finally, we show how limited amounts of human feedback can be leveraged to learn a similarity specification that can be used to train downstream fairness-aware models.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2023; v1 submitted 20 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Latent Space Smoothing for Individually Fair Representations
Authors:
Momchil Peychev,
Anian Ruoss,
Mislav Balunović,
Maximilian Baader,
Martin Vechev
Abstract:
Fair representation learning transforms user data into a representation that ensures fairness and utility regardless of the downstream application. However, learning individually fair representations, i.e., guaranteeing that similar individuals are treated similarly, remains challenging in high-dimensional settings such as computer vision. In this work, we introduce LASSI, the first representation…
▽ More
Fair representation learning transforms user data into a representation that ensures fairness and utility regardless of the downstream application. However, learning individually fair representations, i.e., guaranteeing that similar individuals are treated similarly, remains challenging in high-dimensional settings such as computer vision. In this work, we introduce LASSI, the first representation learning method for certifying individual fairness of high-dimensional data. Our key insight is to leverage recent advances in generative modeling to capture the set of similar individuals in the generative latent space. This enables us to learn individually fair representations that map similar individuals close together by using adversarial training to minimize the distance between their representations. Finally, we employ randomized smoothing to provably map similar individuals close together, in turn ensuring that local robustness verification of the downstream application results in end-to-end fairness certification. Our experimental evaluation on challenging real-world image data demonstrates that our method increases certified individual fairness by up to 90% without significantly affecting task utility.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2022; v1 submitted 26 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Quantifying the Effects of Enforcing Disentanglement on Variational Autoencoders
Authors:
Momchil Peychev,
Petar Veličković,
Pietro Liò
Abstract:
The notion of disentangled autoencoders was proposed as an extension to the variational autoencoder by introducing a disentanglement parameter $β$, controlling the learning pressure put on the possible underlying latent representations. For certain values of $β$ this kind of autoencoders is capable of encoding independent input generative factors in separate elements of the code, leading to a more…
▽ More
The notion of disentangled autoencoders was proposed as an extension to the variational autoencoder by introducing a disentanglement parameter $β$, controlling the learning pressure put on the possible underlying latent representations. For certain values of $β$ this kind of autoencoders is capable of encoding independent input generative factors in separate elements of the code, leading to a more interpretable and predictable model behaviour. In this paper we quantify the effects of the parameter $β$ on the model performance and disentanglement. After training multiple models with the same value of $β$, we establish the existence of consistent variance in one of the disentanglement measures, proposed in literature. The negative consequences of the disentanglement to the autoencoder's discriminative ability are also asserted while varying the amount of examples available during training.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
