-
$O(k)$-Equivariant Dimensionality Reduction on Stiefel Manifolds
Authors:
Andrew Lee,
Harlin Lee,
Jose A. Perea,
Nikolas Schonsheck,
Madeleine Weinstein
Abstract:
Many real-world datasets live on high-dimensional Stiefel and Grassmannian manifolds, $V_k(\mathbb{R}^N)$ and $Gr(k, \mathbb{R}^N)$ respectively, and benefit from projection onto lower-dimensional Stiefel (respectively, Grassmannian) manifolds. In this work, we propose an algorithm called Principal Stiefel Coordinates (PSC) to reduce data dimensionality from $ V_k(\mathbb{R}^N)$ to…
▽ More
Many real-world datasets live on high-dimensional Stiefel and Grassmannian manifolds, $V_k(\mathbb{R}^N)$ and $Gr(k, \mathbb{R}^N)$ respectively, and benefit from projection onto lower-dimensional Stiefel (respectively, Grassmannian) manifolds. In this work, we propose an algorithm called Principal Stiefel Coordinates (PSC) to reduce data dimensionality from $ V_k(\mathbb{R}^N)$ to $V_k(\mathbb{R}^n)$ in an $O(k)$-equivariant manner ($k \leq n \ll N$). We begin by observing that each element $α\in V_n(\mathbb{R}^N)$ defines an isometric embedding of $V_k(\mathbb{R}^n)$ into $V_k(\mathbb{R}^N)$. Next, we optimize for such an embedding map that minimizes data fit error by warm-starting with the output of principal component analysis (PCA) and applying gradient descent. Then, we define a continuous and $O(k)$-equivariant map $π_α$ that acts as a ``closest point operator'' to project the data onto the image of $V_k(\mathbb{R}^n)$ in $V_k(\mathbb{R}^N)$ under the embedding determined by $α$, while minimizing distortion. Because this dimensionality reduction is $O(k)$-equivariant, these results extend to Grassmannian manifolds as well. Lastly, we show that the PCA output globally minimizes projection error in a noiseless setting, but that our algorithm achieves a meaningfully different and improved outcome when the data does not lie exactly on the image of a linearly embedded lower-dimensional Stiefel manifold as above. Multiple numerical experiments using synthetic and real-world data are performed.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Topological Data Analysis of Electroencephalogram Signals for Pediatric Obstructive Sleep Apnea
Authors:
Shashank Manjunath,
Jose A. Perea,
Aarti Sathyanarayana
Abstract:
Topological data analysis (TDA) is an emerging technique for biological signal processing. TDA leverages the invariant topological features of signals in a metric space for robust analysis of signals even in the presence of noise. In this paper, we leverage TDA on brain connectivity networks derived from electroencephalogram (EEG) signals to identify statistical differences between pediatric patie…
▽ More
Topological data analysis (TDA) is an emerging technique for biological signal processing. TDA leverages the invariant topological features of signals in a metric space for robust analysis of signals even in the presence of noise. In this paper, we leverage TDA on brain connectivity networks derived from electroencephalogram (EEG) signals to identify statistical differences between pediatric patients with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) and pediatric patients without OSA. We leverage a large corpus of data, and show that TDA enables us to see a statistical difference between the brain dynamics of the two groups.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Learning on Persistence Diagrams as Radon Measures
Authors:
Alex Elchesen,
Iryna Hartsock,
Jose A. Perea,
Tatum Rask
Abstract:
Persistence diagrams are common descriptors of the topological structure of data appearing in various classification and regression tasks. They can be generalized to Radon measures supported on the birth-death plane and endowed with an optimal transport distance. Examples of such measures are expectations of probability distributions on the space of persistence diagrams. In this paper, we develop…
▽ More
Persistence diagrams are common descriptors of the topological structure of data appearing in various classification and regression tasks. They can be generalized to Radon measures supported on the birth-death plane and endowed with an optimal transport distance. Examples of such measures are expectations of probability distributions on the space of persistence diagrams. In this paper, we develop methods for approximating continuous functions on the space of Radon measures supported on the birth-death plane, as well as their utilization in supervised learning tasks. Indeed, we show that any continuous function defined on a compact subset of the space of such measures (e.g., a classifier or regressor) can be approximated arbitrarily well by polynomial combinations of features computed using a continuous compactly supported function on the birth-death plane (a template). We provide insights into the structure of relatively compact subsets of the space of Radon measures, and test our approximation methodology on various data sets and supervised learning tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Toroidal Coordinates: Decorrelating Circular Coordinates With Lattice Reduction
Authors:
Luis Scoccola,
Hitesh Gakhar,
Johnathan Bush,
Nikolas Schonsheck,
Tatum Rask,
Ling Zhou,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
The circular coordinates algorithm of de Silva, Morozov, and Vejdemo-Johansson takes as input a dataset together with a cohomology class representing a $1$-dimensional hole in the data; the output is a map from the data into the circle that captures this hole, and that is of minimum energy in a suitable sense. However, when applied to several cohomology classes, the output circle-valued maps can b…
▽ More
The circular coordinates algorithm of de Silva, Morozov, and Vejdemo-Johansson takes as input a dataset together with a cohomology class representing a $1$-dimensional hole in the data; the output is a map from the data into the circle that captures this hole, and that is of minimum energy in a suitable sense. However, when applied to several cohomology classes, the output circle-valued maps can be "geometrically correlated" even if the chosen cohomology classes are linearly independent. It is shown in the original work that less correlated maps can be obtained with suitable integer linear combinations of the cohomology classes, with the linear combinations being chosen by inspection. In this paper, we identify a formal notion of geometric correlation between circle-valued maps which, in the Riemannian manifold case, corresponds to the Dirichlet form, a bilinear form derived from the Dirichlet energy. We describe a systematic procedure for constructing low energy torus-valued maps on data, starting from a set of linearly independent cohomology classes. We showcase our procedure with computational examples. Our main algorithm is based on the Lenstra--Lenstra--Lovász algorithm from computational number theory.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2023; v1 submitted 14 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
FibeRed: Fiberwise Dimensionality Reduction of Topologically Complex Data with Vector Bundles
Authors:
Luis Scoccola,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
Datasets with non-trivial large scale topology can be hard to embed in low-dimensional Euclidean space with existing dimensionality reduction algorithms. We propose to model topologically complex datasets using vector bundles, in such a way that the base space accounts for the large scale topology, while the fibers account for the local geometry. This allows one to reduce the dimensionality of the…
▽ More
Datasets with non-trivial large scale topology can be hard to embed in low-dimensional Euclidean space with existing dimensionality reduction algorithms. We propose to model topologically complex datasets using vector bundles, in such a way that the base space accounts for the large scale topology, while the fibers account for the local geometry. This allows one to reduce the dimensionality of the fibers, while preserving the large scale topology. We formalize this point of view, and, as an application, we describe an algorithm which takes as input a dataset together with an initial representation of it in Euclidean space, assumed to recover part of its large scale topology, and outputs a new representation that integrates local representations, obtained through local linear dimensionality reduction, along the initial global representation. We demonstrate this algorithm on examples coming from dynamical systems and chemistry. In these examples, our algorithm is able to learn topologically faithful embeddings of the data in lower target dimension than various well known metric-based dimensionality reduction algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2023; v1 submitted 13 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Move Schedules: Fast persistence computations in coarse dynamic settings
Authors:
Matthew Piekenbrock,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
Matrix reduction is the standard procedure for computing the persistent homology of a filtered simplicial complex with $m$ simplices. Its output is a particular decomposition of the total boundary matrix, from which the persistence diagrams and generating cycles are derived. Persistence diagrams are known to vary continuously with respect to their input, motivating the study of their computation f…
▽ More
Matrix reduction is the standard procedure for computing the persistent homology of a filtered simplicial complex with $m$ simplices. Its output is a particular decomposition of the total boundary matrix, from which the persistence diagrams and generating cycles are derived. Persistence diagrams are known to vary continuously with respect to their input, motivating the study of their computation for time-varying filtered complexes. Computing persistence dynamically can be reduced to maintaining a valid decomposition under adjacent transpositions in the filtration order. Since there are $O(m^2)$ such transpositions, this maintenance procedure exhibits limited scalability and is often too fine for many applications. We propose a coarser strategy for maintaining the decomposition over a 1-parameter family of filtrations. By reduction to a particular longest common subsequence problem, we show that the minimal number of decomposition updates $d$ can be found in $O(m \log \log m)$ time and $O(m)$ space, and that the corresponding sequence of permutations -- which we call a schedule -- can be constructed in $O(d m \log m)$ time. We also show that, in expectation, the storage needed to employ this strategy is actually sublinear in $m$. Exploiting this connection, we show experimentally that the decrease in operations to compute diagrams across a family of filtrations is proportional to the difference between the expected quadratic number of states and the proposed sublinear coarsening. Applications to video data, dynamic metric space data, and multiparameter persistence are also presented.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023; v1 submitted 25 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Approximate and discrete Euclidean vector bundles
Authors:
Luis Scoccola,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
We introduce $\varepsilon$-approximate versions of the notion of Euclidean vector bundle for $\varepsilon \geq 0$, which recover the classical notion of Euclidean vector bundle when $\varepsilon = 0$. In particular, we study Čech cochains with coefficients in the orthogonal group that satisfy an approximate cocycle condition. We show that $\varepsilon$-approximate vector bundles can be used to rep…
▽ More
We introduce $\varepsilon$-approximate versions of the notion of Euclidean vector bundle for $\varepsilon \geq 0$, which recover the classical notion of Euclidean vector bundle when $\varepsilon = 0$. In particular, we study Čech cochains with coefficients in the orthogonal group that satisfy an approximate cocycle condition. We show that $\varepsilon$-approximate vector bundles can be used to represent classical vector bundles when $\varepsilon > 0$ is sufficiently small. We also introduce distances between approximate vector bundles and use them to prove that sufficiently similar approximate vector bundles represent the same classical vector bundle. This gives a way of specifying vector bundles over finite simplicial complexes using a finite amount of data, and also allows for some tolerance to noise when working with vector bundles in an applied setting. As an example, we prove a reconstruction theorem for vector bundles from finite samples. We give algorithms for the effective computation of low-dimensional characteristic classes of vector bundles directly from discrete and approximate representations and illustrate the usage of these algorithms with computational examples.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024; v1 submitted 15 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Sliding Window Persistence of Quasiperiodic Functions
Authors:
Hitesh Gakhar,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
A function is called quasiperiodic if its fundamental frequencies are linearly independent over the rationals. With appropriate parameters, the sliding window point clouds of such functions can be shown to be dense in tori with dimension equal to the number of independent frequencies. In this paper, we develop theoretical and computational techniques to study the persistent homology of such sets.…
▽ More
A function is called quasiperiodic if its fundamental frequencies are linearly independent over the rationals. With appropriate parameters, the sliding window point clouds of such functions can be shown to be dense in tori with dimension equal to the number of independent frequencies. In this paper, we develop theoretical and computational techniques to study the persistent homology of such sets. Specifically, we provide parameter optimization schemes for sliding windows of quasiperiodic functions, and present theoretical lower bounds on their Rips persistent homology. The latter leverages a recent persistent Künneth formula. The theory is illustrated via computational examples and an application to dissonance detection in music audio samples.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2023; v1 submitted 7 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Adaptive template systems: Data-driven feature selection for learning with persistence diagrams
Authors:
Luis Polanco,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
Feature extraction from persistence diagrams, as a tool to enrich machine learning techniques, has received increasing attention in recent years. In this paper we explore an adaptive methodology to localize features in persistent diagrams, which are then used in learning tasks. Specifically, we investigate three algorithms, CDER, GMM and HDBSCAN, to obtain adaptive template functions/features. Sai…
▽ More
Feature extraction from persistence diagrams, as a tool to enrich machine learning techniques, has received increasing attention in recent years. In this paper we explore an adaptive methodology to localize features in persistent diagrams, which are then used in learning tasks. Specifically, we investigate three algorithms, CDER, GMM and HDBSCAN, to obtain adaptive template functions/features. Said features are evaluated in three classification experiments with persistence diagrams. Namely, manifold, human shapes and protein classification. The main conclusion of our analysis is that adaptive template systems, as a feature extraction technique, yield competitive and often superior results in the studied examples. Moreover, from the adaptive algorithms here studied, CDER consistently provides the most reliable and robust adaptive featurization.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Künneth Formulae in Persistent Homology
Authors:
Hitesh Gakhar,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
The classical Künneth formula in algebraic topology describes the homology of a product space in terms of that of its factors. In this paper, we prove Künneth-type theorems for the persistent homology of the categorical and tensor product of filtered spaces. That is, we describe the persistent homology of these product filtrations in terms of that of the filtered components. In addition to compari…
▽ More
The classical Künneth formula in algebraic topology describes the homology of a product space in terms of that of its factors. In this paper, we prove Künneth-type theorems for the persistent homology of the categorical and tensor product of filtered spaces. That is, we describe the persistent homology of these product filtrations in terms of that of the filtered components. In addition to comparing the two products, we present two applications in the setting of Vietoris-Rips complexes: one towards more efficient algorithms for product metric spaces with the maximum metric, and the other recovering persistent homology calculations on the $n$-torus.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Coordinatizing Data With Lens Spaces and Persistent Cohomology
Authors:
Luis Polanco,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
We introduce here a framework to construct coordinates in \emph{finite} Lens spaces for data with nontrivial 1-dimensional $\mathbb{Z}_q$ persistent cohomology, $q\geq 3$. Said coordinates are defined on an open neighborhood of the data, yet constructed with only a small subset of landmarks. We also introduce a dimensionality reduction scheme in $S^{2n-1}/\mathbb{Z}_q$ (Lens-PCA: $\mathsf{LPCA}$),…
▽ More
We introduce here a framework to construct coordinates in \emph{finite} Lens spaces for data with nontrivial 1-dimensional $\mathbb{Z}_q$ persistent cohomology, $q\geq 3$. Said coordinates are defined on an open neighborhood of the data, yet constructed with only a small subset of landmarks. We also introduce a dimensionality reduction scheme in $S^{2n-1}/\mathbb{Z}_q$ (Lens-PCA: $\mathsf{LPCA}$), and demonstrate the efficacy of the pipeline $PH^1(\;\cdot\; ; \mathbb{Z}_q)$ class $\Rightarrow$ $S^{2n-1}/\mathbb{Z}_q$ coordinates $\Rightarrow$ $\mathsf{LPCA}$, for nonlinear (topological) dimensionality reduction.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2019; v1 submitted 1 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Approximating Continuous Functions on Persistence Diagrams Using Template Functions
Authors:
Jose A. Perea,
Elizabeth Munch,
Firas A. Khasawneh
Abstract:
The persistence diagram is an increasingly useful tool from Topological Data Analysis, but its use alongside typical machine learning techniques requires mathematical finesse. The most success to date has come from methods that map persistence diagrams into vector spaces, in a way which maximizes the structure preserved. This process is commonly referred to as featurization. In this paper, we desc…
▽ More
The persistence diagram is an increasingly useful tool from Topological Data Analysis, but its use alongside typical machine learning techniques requires mathematical finesse. The most success to date has come from methods that map persistence diagrams into vector spaces, in a way which maximizes the structure preserved. This process is commonly referred to as featurization. In this paper, we describe a mathematical framework for featurization called \emph{template functions}, and we show that it addresses the problem of approximating continuous functions on compact subsets of the space of persistence diagrams. Specifically, we begin by characterizing relative compactness with respect to the bottleneck distance, and then provide explicit theoretical methods for constructing compact-open dense subsets of continuous functions on persistence diagrams. These dense subsets -- obtained via template functions -- are leveraged for supervised learning tasks with persistence diagrams. Specifically, we test the method for classification and regression algorithms on several examples including shape data and dynamical systems.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2022; v1 submitted 19 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Topological Time Series Analysis
Authors:
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
Time series are ubiquitous in our data rich world. In what follows I will describe how ideas from dynamical systems and topological data analysis can be combined to gain insights from time-varying data. We will see several applications to the live sciences and engineering, as well as some of the theoretical underpinnings.
Time series are ubiquitous in our data rich world. In what follows I will describe how ideas from dynamical systems and topological data analysis can be combined to gain insights from time-varying data. We will see several applications to the live sciences and engineering, as well as some of the theoretical underpinnings.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Sparse Circular Coordinates via Principal $\mathbb{Z}$-Bundles
Authors:
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
We present in this paper an application of the theory of principal bundles to the problem of nonlinear dimensionality reduction in data analysis. More explicitly, we derive, from a 1-dimensional persistent cohomology computation, explicit formulas for circle-valued functions on data with nontrivial underlying topology. We show that the language of principal bundles leads to coordinates defined on…
▽ More
We present in this paper an application of the theory of principal bundles to the problem of nonlinear dimensionality reduction in data analysis. More explicitly, we derive, from a 1-dimensional persistent cohomology computation, explicit formulas for circle-valued functions on data with nontrivial underlying topology. We show that the language of principal bundles leads to coordinates defined on an open neighborhood of the data, but computed using only a smaller subset of landmarks. It is in this sense that the coordinates are sparse. Several data examples are presented, as well as theoretical results underlying the construction.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2019; v1 submitted 24 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Twisty Takens: A Geometric Characterization of Good Observations on Dense Trajectories
Authors:
Boyan Xu,
Christopher J. Tralie,
Alice Antia,
Michael Lin,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
In nonlinear time series analysis and dynamical systems theory, Takens' embedding theorem states that the sliding window embedding of a generic observation along trajectories in a state space, recovers the region traversed by the dynamics. This can be used, for instance, to show that sliding window embeddings of periodic signals recover topological loops, and that sliding window embeddings of quas…
▽ More
In nonlinear time series analysis and dynamical systems theory, Takens' embedding theorem states that the sliding window embedding of a generic observation along trajectories in a state space, recovers the region traversed by the dynamics. This can be used, for instance, to show that sliding window embeddings of periodic signals recover topological loops, and that sliding window embeddings of quasiperiodic signals recover high-dimensional torii. However, in spite of these motivating examples, Takens' theorem does not in general prescribe how to choose such an observation function given particular dynamics in a state space. In this work, we state conditions on observation functions defined on compact Riemannian manifolds, that lead to successful reconstructions for particular dynamics. We apply our theory and construct families of time series whose sliding window embeddings trace tori, Klein bottles, spheres, and projective planes. This greatly enriches the set of examples of time series known to concentrate on various shapes via sliding window embeddings, and will hopefully help other researchers in identifying them in naturally occurring phenomena. We also present numerical experiments showing how to recover low dimensional representations of the underlying dynamics on state space, by using the persistent cohomology of sliding window embeddings and Eilenberg-MacLane (i.e., circular and real projective) coordinates.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2019; v1 submitted 19 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A Brief History of Persistence
Authors:
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
Persistent homology is currently one of the more widely known tools from computational topology and topological data analysis. We present in this note a brief survey on the evolution of the subject. The goal is to highlight the main ideas, starting from the subject's computational inception more than 20 years ago, to the more modern categorical and representation-theoretic point of view.
Persistent homology is currently one of the more widely known tools from computational topology and topological data analysis. We present in this note a brief survey on the evolution of the subject. The goal is to highlight the main ideas, starting from the subject's computational inception more than 20 years ago, to the more modern categorical and representation-theoretic point of view.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2018; v1 submitted 10 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Chatter Classification in Turning Using Machine Learning and Topological Data Analysis
Authors:
Firas A. Khasawneh,
Elizabeth Munch,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
Chatter identification and detection in machining processes has been an active area of research in the past two decades. Part of the challenge in studying chatter is that machining equations that describe its occurrence are often nonlinear delay differential equations. The majority of the available tools for chatter identification rely on defining a metric that captures the characteristics of chat…
▽ More
Chatter identification and detection in machining processes has been an active area of research in the past two decades. Part of the challenge in studying chatter is that machining equations that describe its occurrence are often nonlinear delay differential equations. The majority of the available tools for chatter identification rely on defining a metric that captures the characteristics of chatter, and a threshold that signals its occurrence. The difficulty in choosing these parameters can be somewhat alleviated by utilizing machine learning techniques. However, even with a successful classification algorithm, the transferability of typical machine learning methods from one data set to another remains very limited. In this paper we combine supervised machine learning with Topological Data Analysis (TDA) to obtain a descriptor of the process which can detect chatter. The features we use are derived from the persistence diagram of an attractor reconstructed from the time series via Takens embedding. We test the approach using deterministic and stochastic turning models, where the stochasticity is introduced via the cutting coefficient term. Our results show a 97% successful classification rate on the deterministic model labeled by the stability diagram obtained using the spectral element method. The features gleaned from the deterministic model are then utilized for characterization of chatter in a stochastic turning model where there are very limited analysis methods.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
(Quasi)Periodicity Quantification in Video Data, Using Topology
Authors:
Christopher J. Tralie,
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
This work introduces a novel framework for quantifying the presence and strength of recurrent dynamics in video data. Specifically, we provide continuous measures of periodicity (perfect repetition) and quasiperiodicity (superposition of periodic modes with non-commensurate periods), in a way which does not require segmentation, training, object tracking or 1-dimensional surrogate signals. Our met…
▽ More
This work introduces a novel framework for quantifying the presence and strength of recurrent dynamics in video data. Specifically, we provide continuous measures of periodicity (perfect repetition) and quasiperiodicity (superposition of periodic modes with non-commensurate periods), in a way which does not require segmentation, training, object tracking or 1-dimensional surrogate signals. Our methodology operates directly on video data. The approach combines ideas from nonlinear time series analysis (delay embeddings) and computational topology (persistent homology), by translating the problem of finding recurrent dynamics in video data, into the problem of determining the circularity or toroidality of an associated geometric space. Through extensive testing, we show the robustness of our scores with respect to several noise models/levels, we show that our periodicity score is superior to other methods when compared to human-generated periodicity rankings, and furthermore, we show that our quasiperiodicity score clearly indicates the presence of biphonation in videos of vibrating vocal folds, which has never before been accomplished end to end quantitatively.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2018; v1 submitted 26 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Multiscale Projective Coordinates via Persistent Cohomology of Sparse Filtrations
Authors:
Jose A. Perea
Abstract:
We present in this paper a framework which leverages the underlying topology of a data set, in order to produce appropriate coordinate representations. In particular, we show how to construct maps to real and complex projective spaces, given appropriate persistent cohomology classes. An initial map is obtained in two steps: First, the persistent cohomology of a sparse filtration is used to compute…
▽ More
We present in this paper a framework which leverages the underlying topology of a data set, in order to produce appropriate coordinate representations. In particular, we show how to construct maps to real and complex projective spaces, given appropriate persistent cohomology classes. An initial map is obtained in two steps: First, the persistent cohomology of a sparse filtration is used to compute systems of transition functions for (real and complex) line bundles over neighborhoods of the data. Next, the transition functions are used to produce explicit classifying maps for the induced bundles. A framework for dimensionality reduction in projective space (Principal Projective Components) is also developed, aimed at decreasing the target dimension of the original map. Several examples are provided as well as theorems addressing choices in the construction.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2017; v1 submitted 8 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
