-
Heterogeneous Treatment Effects in Panel Data
Authors:
Retsef Levi,
Elisabeth Paulson,
Georgia Perakis,
Emily Zhang
Abstract:
We address a core problem in causal inference: estimating heterogeneous treatment effects using panel data with general treatment patterns. Many existing methods either do not utilize the potential underlying structure in panel data or have limitations in the allowable treatment patterns. In this work, we propose and evaluate a new method that first partitions observations into disjoint clusters w…
▽ More
We address a core problem in causal inference: estimating heterogeneous treatment effects using panel data with general treatment patterns. Many existing methods either do not utilize the potential underlying structure in panel data or have limitations in the allowable treatment patterns. In this work, we propose and evaluate a new method that first partitions observations into disjoint clusters with similar treatment effects using a regression tree, and then leverages the (assumed) low-rank structure of the panel data to estimate the average treatment effect for each cluster. Our theoretical results establish the convergence of the resulting estimates to the true treatment effects. Computation experiments with semi-synthetic data show that our method achieves superior accuracy compared to alternative approaches, using a regression tree with no more than 40 leaves. Hence, our method provides more accurate and interpretable estimates than alternative methods.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Tightness of prescriptive tree-based mixed-integer optimization formulations
Authors:
Max Biggs,
Georgia Perakis
Abstract:
We focus on modeling the relationship between an input feature vector and the predicted outcome of a trained decision tree using mixed-integer optimization. This can be used in many practical applications where a decision tree or tree ensemble is incorporated into an optimization problem to model the predicted outcomes of a decision. We propose tighter mixed-integer optimization formulations than…
▽ More
We focus on modeling the relationship between an input feature vector and the predicted outcome of a trained decision tree using mixed-integer optimization. This can be used in many practical applications where a decision tree or tree ensemble is incorporated into an optimization problem to model the predicted outcomes of a decision. We propose tighter mixed-integer optimization formulations than those previously introduced. Existing formulations can be shown to have linear relaxations that have fractional extreme points, even for the simple case of modeling a single decision tree. A formulation we propose, based on a projected union of polyhedra approach, is ideal for a single decision tree. While the formulation is generally not ideal for tree ensembles or if additional constraints are added, it generally has fewer extreme points, leading to a faster time to solve, particularly if the formulation has relatively few trees. However, previous work has shown that formulations based on a binary representation of the feature vector perform well computationally and hence are attractive for use in practical applications. We present multiple approaches to tighten existing formulations with binary vectors, and show that fractional extreme points are removed when there are multiple splits on the same feature. At an extreme, we prove that this results in ideal formulations for tree ensembles modeling a one-dimensional feature vector. Building on this result, we also show via numerical simulations that these additional constraints result in significantly tighter linear relaxations when the feature vector is low dimensional. We also present instances where the time to solve to optimality is significantly improved using these formulations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Optimizing Objective Functions from Trained ReLU Neural Networks via Sampling
Authors:
Georgia Perakis,
Asterios Tsiourvas
Abstract:
This paper introduces scalable, sampling-based algorithms that optimize trained neural networks with ReLU activations. We first propose an iterative algorithm that takes advantage of the piecewise linear structure of ReLU neural networks and reduces the initial mixed-integer optimization problem (MIP) into multiple easy-to-solve linear optimization problems (LPs) through sampling. Subsequently, we…
▽ More
This paper introduces scalable, sampling-based algorithms that optimize trained neural networks with ReLU activations. We first propose an iterative algorithm that takes advantage of the piecewise linear structure of ReLU neural networks and reduces the initial mixed-integer optimization problem (MIP) into multiple easy-to-solve linear optimization problems (LPs) through sampling. Subsequently, we extend this approach by searching around the neighborhood of the LP solution computed at each iteration. This scheme allows us to devise a second, enhanced algorithm that reduces the initial MIP problem into smaller, easier-to-solve MIPs. We analytically show the convergence of the methods and we provide a sample complexity guarantee. We also validate the performance of our algorithms by comparing them against state-of-the-art MIP-based methods. Finally, we show computationally how the sampling algorithms can be used effectively to warm-start MIP-based methods.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2022; v1 submitted 27 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
