Showing 1–22 of 22 results for author: Pankratov, D

Renting Servers for Multi-Parameter Jobs in the Cloud

Authors: Yaqiao Li, Mahtab Masoori, Lata Narayanan, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We study the Renting Servers in the Cloud problem (RSiC) in multiple dimensions. In this problem, a sequence of multi-parameter jobs must be scheduled on servers that can be rented on-demand. Each job has an arrival time, a finishing time, and a multi-dimensional size vector that specifies its resource demands. Each server has a multi-dimensional capacity and jobs can be scheduled on a server as l… ▽ More We study the Renting Servers in the Cloud problem (RSiC) in multiple dimensions. In this problem, a sequence of multi-parameter jobs must be scheduled on servers that can be rented on-demand. Each job has an arrival time, a finishing time, and a multi-dimensional size vector that specifies its resource demands. Each server has a multi-dimensional capacity and jobs can be scheduled on a server as long as in each dimension the sum of sizes of jobs does not exceed the capacity of the server in that dimension. The goal is to minimize the total rental time of servers needed to process the job sequence. AF algorithms do not rent new servers to accommodate a job unless they have to. We introduce a sub-family of AF algorithms called monotone AF algorithms. We show this family have a tight competitive ratio of $Theta(d mu)$, where $d$ is the dimension of the problem and $mu$ is the ratio between the maximum and minimum duration of jobs in the input sequence. We also show that upper bounds for the RSiC problem obey the direct-sum property with respect to dimension $d$, that is we show how to transform $1$-dimensional algorithms for RSiC to work in the $d$-dimensional setting with competitive ratio scaling by a factor of $d$. As a corollary, we obtain an $O(d\sqrt{log mu})$ upper bound for $d$-dimensional clairvoyant RSiC. We also establish a lower bound of $\widetilde{Omega}(d mu)$ for both deterministic and randomized algorithms for $d$-dimensional non-clairvoyant RSiC, under the assumption that $mu \le log d - 2$. Lastly, we propose a natural greedy algorithm called Greedy. Greedy, is a clairvoyant algorithm belongs to the monotone AF family, achieves a competitive ratio of $Theta(d mu)$. Our experimental results indicate that Greedy performs better or matches all other existing algorithms, for almost all the settings of arrival rates and values of mu and $d$ that we implemented. △ Less

Submitted 23 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 11 Pages, 2 figures

The En Route Truck-Drone Delivery Problem

Authors: Danny Krizanc, Lata Narayanan, Jaroslav Opatrny, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We study the truck-drone cooperative delivery problem in a setting where a single truck carrying a drone travels at constant speed on a straight-line trajectory/street. Delivery to clients located in the plane and not on the truck's trajectory is performed by the drone, which has limited carrying capacity and flying range, and whose battery can be recharged when on the truck. We show that the prob… ▽ More We study the truck-drone cooperative delivery problem in a setting where a single truck carrying a drone travels at constant speed on a straight-line trajectory/street. Delivery to clients located in the plane and not on the truck's trajectory is performed by the drone, which has limited carrying capacity and flying range, and whose battery can be recharged when on the truck. We show that the problem of maximizing the number of deliveries is strongly NP-hard even in this simple setting. We present a 2-approximation algorithm for the problem, and an optimal algorithm for a non-trivial family of instances. △ Less

Submitted 1 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Temporal Separators with Deadlines

Authors: Hovhannes A. Harutyunyan, Kamran Koupayi, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We study temporal analogues of the Unrestricted Vertex Separator problem from the static world. An $(s,z)$-temporal separator is a set of vertices whose removal disconnects vertex $s$ from vertex $z$ for every time step in a temporal graph. The $(s,z)$-Temporal Separator problem asks to find the minimum size of an $(s,z)$-temporal separator for the given temporal graph. We introduce a generalizati… ▽ More We study temporal analogues of the Unrestricted Vertex Separator problem from the static world. An $(s,z)$-temporal separator is a set of vertices whose removal disconnects vertex $s$ from vertex $z$ for every time step in a temporal graph. The $(s,z)$-Temporal Separator problem asks to find the minimum size of an $(s,z)$-temporal separator for the given temporal graph. We introduce a generalization of this problem called the $(s,z,t)$-Temporal Separator problem, where the goal is to find a smallest subset of vertices whose removal eliminates all temporal paths from $s$ to $z$ which take less than $t$ time steps. Let $τ$ denote the number of time steps over which the temporal graph is defined (we consider discrete time steps). We characterize the set of parameters $τ$ and $t$ when the problem is $\mathcal{NP}$-hard and when it is polynomial time solvable. Then we present a $τ$-approximation algorithm for the $(s,z)$-Temporal Separator problem and convert it to a $τ^2$-approximation algorithm for the $(s,z,t)$-Temporal Separator problem. We also present an inapproximability lower bound of $Ω(\ln(n) + \ln(τ))$ for the $(s,z,t)$-Temporal Separator problem assuming that $\mathcal{NP}\not\subset\mbox{\sc Dtime}(n^{\log\log n})$. Then we consider three special families of graphs: (1) graphs of branchwidth at most $2$, (2) graphs $G$ such that the removal of $s$ and $z$ leaves a tree, and (3) graphs of bounded pathwidth. We present polynomial-time algorithms to find a minimum $(s,z,t)$-temporal separator for (1) and (2). As for (3), we show a polynomial-time reduction from the Discrete Segment Covering problem with bounded-length segments to the $(s,z,t)$-Temporal Separator problem where the temporal graph has bounded pathwidth. △ Less

Submitted 25 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

Online Vector Bin Packing and Hypergraph Coloring Illuminated: Simpler Proofs and New Connections

Authors: Yaqiao Li, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: This paper studies the online vector bin packing (OVBP) problem and the related problem of online hypergraph coloring (OHC). Firstly, we use a double counting argument to prove an upper bound of the competitive ratio of $FirstFit$ for OVBP. Our proof is conceptually simple, and strengthens the result in Azar et. al. by removing the dependency on the bin size parameter. Secondly, we introduce a not… ▽ More This paper studies the online vector bin packing (OVBP) problem and the related problem of online hypergraph coloring (OHC). Firstly, we use a double counting argument to prove an upper bound of the competitive ratio of $FirstFit$ for OVBP. Our proof is conceptually simple, and strengthens the result in Azar et. al. by removing the dependency on the bin size parameter. Secondly, we introduce a notion of an online incidence matrix that is defined for every instance of OHC. Using this notion, we provide a reduction from OHC to OVBP, which allows us to carry known lower bounds of the competitive ratio of algorithms for OHC to OVBP. Our approach significantly simplifies the previous argument from Azar et. al. that relied on using intricate graph structures. In addition, we slightly improve their lower bounds. Lastly, we establish a tight bound of the competitive ratio of algorithms for OHC, where input is restricted to be a hypertree, thus resolving a conjecture in Nagy-Gyorgy et. al. The crux of this proof lies in solving a certain combinatorial partition problem about multi-family of subsets, which might be of independent interest. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Maximum Weight Convex Polytope

Authors: Mohammad Ali Abam, Ali Mohammad Lavasani, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We study the maximum weight convex polytope problem, in which the goal is to find a convex polytope maximizing the total weight of enclosed points. Prior to this work, the only known result for this problem was an $O(n^3)$ algorithm for the case of $2$ dimensions due to Bautista et al. We show that the problem becomes $\mathcal{NP}$-hard to solve exactly in $3$ dimensions, and $\mathcal{NP}$-hard… ▽ More We study the maximum weight convex polytope problem, in which the goal is to find a convex polytope maximizing the total weight of enclosed points. Prior to this work, the only known result for this problem was an $O(n^3)$ algorithm for the case of $2$ dimensions due to Bautista et al. We show that the problem becomes $\mathcal{NP}$-hard to solve exactly in $3$ dimensions, and $\mathcal{NP}$-hard to approximate within $n^{1/2-ε}$ for any $ε> 0$ in $4$ or more dimensions. %\polyAPX-complete in $4$ dimensions even with binary weights. We also give a new algorithm for $2$ dimensions, albeit with the same $O(n^3)$ running time complexity as that of the algorithm of Bautsita et al. △ Less

Submitted 26 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Advice Complexity of Online Non-Crossing Matching

Authors: Ali Mohammad Lavasani, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We study online matching in the Euclidean $2$-dimesional plane with non-crossing constraint. The offline version was introduced by Atallah in 1985 and the online version was introduced and studied more recently by Bose et al. The input to the problem consists of a sequence of points, and upon arrival of a point an algorithm can match it with a previously unmatched point provided that line segments… ▽ More We study online matching in the Euclidean $2$-dimesional plane with non-crossing constraint. The offline version was introduced by Atallah in 1985 and the online version was introduced and studied more recently by Bose et al. The input to the problem consists of a sequence of points, and upon arrival of a point an algorithm can match it with a previously unmatched point provided that line segments corresponding to the matched edges do not intersect. The decisions are irrevocable, and while an optimal offline solution always matches all the points, an online algorithm cannot match all the points in the worst case, unless it is given some side information, i.e., advice. We study two versions of this problem -- monomchromatic (MNM) and bichromatic (BNM). We show that advice complexity of solving BNM optimally on a circle (or, more generally, on inputs in a convex position) is tightly bounded by the logarithm of the $n^\text{th}$ Catalan number from above and below. This result corrects the previous claim of Bose et al. that the advice complexity is $\log(n!)$. At the heart of the result is a connection between non-crossing constraint in online inputs and $231$-avoiding property of permutations of $n$ elements We also show a lower bound of $n/3-1$ and an upper bound of $3n$ on the advice complexity for MNM on a plane. This gives an exponential improvement over the previously best known lower bound and an improvement in the constant of the leading term in the upper bound. In addition, we establish a lower bound of $\fracα{2}\infdiv{\frac{2(1-α)}α}{1/4}n$ on the advice complexity for achieving competitive ratio $α$ for MNM on a circle. Standard tools from advice complexity, such as partition trees and reductions from string guessing problem, do not seem to apply to MNM/BNM, so we have to design our lower bounds from first principles. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2022; v1 submitted 15 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Group Evacuation on a Line by Agents with Different Communication Abilities

Authors: Jurek Czyzowicz, Ryan Killick, Evangelos Kranakis, Danny Krizanc, Lata Narayanan, Jaroslav Opatrny, Denis Pankratov, Sunil Shende

Abstract: We consider evacuation of a group of $n \geq 2$ autonomous mobile agents (or robots) from an unknown exit on an infinite line. The agents are initially placed at the origin of the line and can move with any speed up to the maximum speed $1$ in any direction they wish and they all can communicate when they are co-located. However, the agents have different wireless communication abilities: while so… ▽ More We consider evacuation of a group of $n \geq 2$ autonomous mobile agents (or robots) from an unknown exit on an infinite line. The agents are initially placed at the origin of the line and can move with any speed up to the maximum speed $1$ in any direction they wish and they all can communicate when they are co-located. However, the agents have different wireless communication abilities: while some are fully wireless and can send and receive messages at any distance, a subset of the agents are senders, they can only transmit messages wirelessly, and the rest are receivers, they can only receive messages wirelessly. The agents start at the same time and their communication abilities are known to each other from the start. Starting at the origin of the line, the goal of the agents is to collectively find a target/exit at an unknown location on the line while minimizing the evacuation time, defined as the time when the last agent reaches the target. We investigate the impact of such a mixed communication model on evacuation time on an infinite line for a group of cooperating agents. In particular, we provide evacuation algorithms and analyze the resulting competitive ratio ($CR$) of the evacuation time for such a group of agents. If the group has two agents of two different types, we give an optimal evacuation algorithm with competitive ratio $CR=3+2 \sqrt{2}$. If there is a single sender or fully wireless agent, and multiple receivers we prove that $CR \in [2+\sqrt{5},5]$, and if there are multiple senders and a single receiver or fully wireless agent, we show that $CR \in [3,5.681319]$. Any group consisting of only senders or only receivers requires competitive ratio 9, and any other combination of agents has competitive ratio 3. △ Less

Submitted 26 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Renting Servers in the Cloud: The Case of Equal Duration Jobs

Authors: Mahtab Masoori, Lata Narayanan, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: Renting servers in the cloud is a generalization of the bin packing problem, motivated by job allocation to servers in cloud computing applications. Jobs arrive in an online manner, and need to be assigned to servers; their duration and size are known at the time of arrival. There is an infinite supply of identical servers, each having one unit of computational capacity per unit of time. A server… ▽ More Renting servers in the cloud is a generalization of the bin packing problem, motivated by job allocation to servers in cloud computing applications. Jobs arrive in an online manner, and need to be assigned to servers; their duration and size are known at the time of arrival. There is an infinite supply of identical servers, each having one unit of computational capacity per unit of time. A server can be rented at any time and continues to be rented until all jobs assigned to it finish. The cost of an assignment is the sum of durations of rental periods of all servers. The goal is to assign jobs to servers to minimize the overall cost while satisfying server capacity constraints. We focus on analyzing two natural algorithms, NextFit and FirstFit, for the case of jobs of equal duration. It is known that the competitive ratio of NextFit and FirstFit are at most 3 and 4 respectively for this case. We prove a tight bound of 2 on the competitive ratio of NextFit. For FirstFit, we establish a lower bound of 2.519 on the competitive ratio, even when jobs have only two distinct arrival times. For the case when jobs have arrival times 0 and 1 and duration 2, we show a lower bound of 1.89 and an upper bound of 2 on the strict competitive ratio of FirstFit. Finally, using the weight function technique, we obtain stronger results for the case of uniform servers. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2021; v1 submitted 27 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Online Domination: The Value of Getting to Know All your Neighbors

Authors: Hovhannes Harutyunyan, Denis Pankratov, Jesse Racicot

Abstract: We study the dominating set problem in an online setting. An algorithm is required to guarantee competitiveness against an adversary that reveals the input graph one node at a time. When a node is revealed, the algorithm learns about the entire neighborhood of the node (including those nodes that have not yet been revealed). Furthermore, the adversary is required to keep the revealed portion of th… ▽ More We study the dominating set problem in an online setting. An algorithm is required to guarantee competitiveness against an adversary that reveals the input graph one node at a time. When a node is revealed, the algorithm learns about the entire neighborhood of the node (including those nodes that have not yet been revealed). Furthermore, the adversary is required to keep the revealed portion of the graph connected at all times. We present an algorithm that achieves 2-competitiveness on trees and prove that this competitive ratio cannot be improved by any other algorithm. We also present algorithms that achieve 2.5-competitiveness on cactus graphs, $(t-1)$-competitiveness on $K_{1,t}$-free graphs, and $Θ(\sqrtΔ)$ for maximum degree $Δ$ graphs. We show that all of those competitive ratios are tight. Then, we study several more general classes of graphs, such as threshold, bipartite planar, and series-parallel graphs, and show that they do not admit competitive algorithms (that is, when competitive ratio is independent of the input size). Previously, the dominating set problem was considered in a slightly different input model, where a vertex is revealed alongside its restricted neighborhood: those neighbors that are among already revealed vertices. Thus, conceptually, our results quantify the value of knowing the entire neighborhood at the time a vertex is revealed as compared to the restricted neighborhood. For instance, it was known in the restricted neighborhood model that 3-competitiveness is optimal for trees, whereas knowing the neighbors allows us to improve it to 2-competitiveness. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2021; originally announced May 2021.

Graph Exploration by Energy-Sharing Mobile Agents

Authors: J. Czyzowicz, S. Dobrev, R. Killick, E. Kranakis, D. Krizanc, L. Narayanan, J. Opatrny, D. Pankratov, S. Shende

Abstract: We consider the problem of collective exploration of a known $n$-node edge-weighted graph by $k$ mobile agents that have limited energy but are capable of energy transfers. The agents are initially placed at an arbitrary subset of nodes in the graph, and each agent has an initial, possibly different, amount of energy. The goal of the exploration problem is for every edge in the graph to be travers… ▽ More We consider the problem of collective exploration of a known $n$-node edge-weighted graph by $k$ mobile agents that have limited energy but are capable of energy transfers. The agents are initially placed at an arbitrary subset of nodes in the graph, and each agent has an initial, possibly different, amount of energy. The goal of the exploration problem is for every edge in the graph to be traversed by at least one agent. The amount of energy used by an agent to travel distance $x$ is proportional to $x$. In our model, the agents can {\em share} energy when co-located: when two agents meet, one can transfer part of its energy to the other. For an $n$-node path, we give an $O(n+k)$ time algorithm that either finds an exploration strategy, or reports that one does not exist. For an $n$-node tree with $\ell $ leaves, we give an $O(n+ \ell k^2)$ algorithm that finds an exploration strategy if one exists. Finally, for the general graph case, we show that the problem of deciding if exploration is possible by energy-sharing agents is NP-hard, even for 3-regular graphs. In addition, we show that it is always possible to find an exploration strategy if the total energy of the agents is at least twice the total weight of the edges; moreover, this is asymptotically optimal. △ Less

Submitted 25 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 21 pages, 4 figures, full version of the paper appearing in the proceedings of SIROCCO 2021

The Bike Sharing Problem

Authors: Jurek Czyzowicz, Konstantinos Georgiou, Ryan Killick, Evangelos Kranakis, Danny Krizanc, Lata Narayanan, Jaroslav Opatrny, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: Assume that $m \geq 1$ autonomous mobile agents and $0 \leq b \leq m$ single-agent transportation devices (called {\em bikes}) are initially placed at the left endpoint $0$ of the unit interval $[0,1]$. The agents are identical in capability and can move at speed one. The bikes cannot move on their own, but any agent riding bike $i$ can move at speed $v_i > 1$. An agent may ride at most one bike a… ▽ More Assume that $m \geq 1$ autonomous mobile agents and $0 \leq b \leq m$ single-agent transportation devices (called {\em bikes}) are initially placed at the left endpoint $0$ of the unit interval $[0,1]$. The agents are identical in capability and can move at speed one. The bikes cannot move on their own, but any agent riding bike $i$ can move at speed $v_i > 1$. An agent may ride at most one bike at a time. The agents can cooperate by sharing the bikes; an agent can ride a bike for a time, then drop it to be used by another agent, and possibly switch to a different bike. We study two problems. In the \BS problem, we require all agents and bikes starting at the left endpoint of the interval to reach the end of the interval as soon as possible. In the \RBS problem, we aim to minimize the arrival time of the agents; the bikes can be used to increase the average speed of the agents, but are not required to reach the end of the interval. Our main result is the construction of a polynomial time algorithm for the \BS problem that creates an arrival-time optimal schedule for travellers and bikes to travel across the interval. For the \RBS problem, we give an algorithm that gives an optimal solution for the case when at most one of the bikes can be abandoned. △ Less

Submitted 23 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

ACM Class: F.1.1; F.2.2

Online Coloring and a New Type of Adversary for Online Graph Problems

Authors: Yaqiao Li, Vishnu V. Narayan, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We introduce a new type of adversary for online graph problems. The new adversary is parameterized by a single integer $κ$, which upper bounds the number of connected components that the adversary can use at any time during the presentation of the online graph $G$. We call this adversary "$κ$ components bounded", or $κ$-CB for short. On one hand, this adversary is restricted compared to the classi… ▽ More We introduce a new type of adversary for online graph problems. The new adversary is parameterized by a single integer $κ$, which upper bounds the number of connected components that the adversary can use at any time during the presentation of the online graph $G$. We call this adversary "$κ$ components bounded", or $κ$-CB for short. On one hand, this adversary is restricted compared to the classical adversary because of the $κ$-CB constraint. On the other hand, we seek competitive ratios parameterized only by $κ$ with no dependence on the input length $n$, thereby giving the new adversary power to use arbitrarily large inputs. We study online coloring under the $κ$-CB adversary. We obtain finer analysis of the existing algorithms $FirstFit$ and $CBIP$ by computing their competitive ratios on trees and bipartite graphs under the new adversary. Surprisingly, $FirstFit$ outperforms $CBIP$ on trees. When it comes to bipartite graphs $FirstFit$ is no longer competitive under the new adversary, while $CBIP$ uses at most $2κ$ colors. We also study several well known classes of graphs, such as $3$-colorable, $C_k$-free, $d$-inductive, planar, and bounded treewidth, with respect to online coloring under the $κ$-CB adversary. We demonstrate that the extra adversarial power of unbounded input length outweighs the restriction on the number of connected components leading to non existence of competitive algorithms for these classes. △ Less

Submitted 21 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Advice Complexity of Adaptive Priority Algorithms

Authors: Joan Boyar, Kim S. Larsen, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: The priority model was introduced to capture "greedy-like" algorithms. Motivated by the success of advice complexity in the area of online algorithms, the fixed priority model was extended to include advice, and a reduction-based framework was developed for proving lower bounds on the amount of advice required to achieve certain approximation ratios in this rather powerful model. To capture most o… ▽ More The priority model was introduced to capture "greedy-like" algorithms. Motivated by the success of advice complexity in the area of online algorithms, the fixed priority model was extended to include advice, and a reduction-based framework was developed for proving lower bounds on the amount of advice required to achieve certain approximation ratios in this rather powerful model. To capture most of the algorithms that are considered greedy-like, the even stronger model of adaptive priority algorithms is needed. We extend the adaptive priority model to include advice. We modify the reduction-based framework from the fixed priority case to work with the more powerful adaptive priority algorithms, simplifying the proof of correctness and strengthening all previous lower bounds by a factor of two in the process. We also present a purely combinatorial adaptive priority algorithm with advice for Minimum Vertex Cover on triangle-free graphs of maximum degree three. Our algorithm achieves optimality and uses at most 7n/22 bits of advice. No adaptive priority algorithm without advice can achieve optimality without advice, and we prove that an online algorithm with advice needs more than 7n/22 bits of advice to reach optimality. We show connections between exact algorithms and priority algorithms with advice. The branching in branch-and-reduce algorithms can be seen as trying all possible advice strings, and all priority algorithms with advice that achieve optimality define corresponding exact algorithms, priority exact algorithms. Lower bounds on advice-based adaptive algorithms imply lower bounds on running times of exact algorithms designed in this way. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2022; v1 submitted 2 October, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

ACM Class: F.2.2

Exploration of High-Dimensional Grids by Finite State Machines

Authors: Stefan Dobrev, Lata Narayanan, Jaroslav Opatrny, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We consider the problem of finding a treasure at an unknown point of an $n$-dimensional infinite grid, $n\geq 3$, by initially collocated finite state agents (scouts/robots). Recently, the problem has been well characterized for 2 dimensions for deterministic as well as randomized agents, both in synchronous and semi-synchronous models. It has been conjectured that $n+1$ randomized agents are nece… ▽ More We consider the problem of finding a treasure at an unknown point of an $n$-dimensional infinite grid, $n\geq 3$, by initially collocated finite state agents (scouts/robots). Recently, the problem has been well characterized for 2 dimensions for deterministic as well as randomized agents, both in synchronous and semi-synchronous models. It has been conjectured that $n+1$ randomized agents are necessary to solve this problem in the $n$-dimensional grid. In this paper we disprove the conjecture in a strong sense: we show that three randomized synchronous agents suffice to explore an $n$-dimensional grid for any $n$. Our algorithm is optimal in terms of the number of the agents. Our key insight is that a constant number of finite state machine agents can, by their positions and movements, implement a stack, which can store the path being explored. We also show how to implement our algorithm using: four randomized semi-synchronous agents; four deterministic synchronous agents; or five deterministic semi-synchronous agents. We give a different algorithm that uses $4$ deterministic semi-synchronous agents for the $3$-dimensional grid. This is provably optimal, and surprisingly, matches the result for $2$ dimensions. For $n\geq 4$, the time complexity of the solutions mentioned above is exponential in distance $D$ of the treasure from the starting point of the agents. We show that in the deterministic case, one additional agent brings the time down to a polynomial. Finally, we focus on algorithms that never venture much beyond the distance $D$. We describe an algorithm that uses $O(\sqrt{n})$ semi-synchronous deterministic agents that never go beyond $2D$, as well as show that any algorithm using $3$ synchronous deterministic agents in $3$ dimensions must travel beyond $Ω(D^{3/2})$ from the origin. △ Less

Submitted 10 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

An Experimental Study of Algorithms for Online Bipartite Matching

Authors: Allan Borodin, Christodoulos Karavasilis, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We perform an experimental study of algorithms for online bipartite matching under the known i.i.d. input model with integral types. In the last decade, there has been substantial effort in designing complex algorithms with the goal of improving worst-case approximation ratios. Our goal is to determine how these algorithms perform on more practical instances rather than worst-case instances. In pa… ▽ More We perform an experimental study of algorithms for online bipartite matching under the known i.i.d. input model with integral types. In the last decade, there has been substantial effort in designing complex algorithms with the goal of improving worst-case approximation ratios. Our goal is to determine how these algorithms perform on more practical instances rather than worst-case instances. In particular, we are interested in whether the ranking of the algorithms by their worst-case performance is consistent with the ranking of the algorithms by their average-case/practical performance. We are also interested in whether preprocessing times and implementation difficulties that are introduced by these algorithms are justified in practice. To that end we evaluate these algorithms on different random inputs as well as real-life instances obtained from publicly available repositories. We compare these algorithms against several simple greedy-style algorithms. Most of the complex algorithms in the literature are presented as being non-greedy (i.e., an algorithm can intentionally skip matching a node that has available neighbors) to simplify the analysis. Every such algorithm can be turned into a greedy one without hurting its worst-case performance. On our benchmarks, non-greedy versions of these algorithms perform much worse than their greedy versions. Greedy versions perform about as well as the simplest greedy algorithm by itself. This, together with our other findings, suggests that simplest greedy algorithms are competitive with the state-of-the-art worst-case algorithms for online bipartite matching on many average-case and practical input families. Greediness is by far the most important property of online algorithms for bipartite matching. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 37 pages, 36 figures, 3 tables

Advice Complexity of Priority Algorithms

Authors: Allan Borodin, Joan Boyar, Kim S. Larsen, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: The priority model of "greedy-like" algorithms was introduced by Borodin, Nielsen, and Rackoff in 2002. We augment this model by allowing priority algorithms to have access to advice, i.e., side information precomputed by an all-powerful oracle. Obtaining lower bounds in the priority model without advice can be challenging and may involve intricate adversary arguments. Since the priority model wit… ▽ More The priority model of "greedy-like" algorithms was introduced by Borodin, Nielsen, and Rackoff in 2002. We augment this model by allowing priority algorithms to have access to advice, i.e., side information precomputed by an all-powerful oracle. Obtaining lower bounds in the priority model without advice can be challenging and may involve intricate adversary arguments. Since the priority model with advice is even more powerful, obtaining lower bounds presents additional difficulties. We sidestep these difficulties by develo** a general framework of reductions which makes lower bound proofs relatively straightforward and routine. We start by introducing the Pair Matching problem, for which we are able to prove strong lower bounds in the priority model with advice. We develop a template for constructing a reduction from Pair Matching to other problems in the priority model with advice -- this part is technically challenging since the reduction needs to define a valid priority function for Pair Matching while respecting the priority function for the other problem. Finally, we apply the template to obtain lower bounds for a number of standard discrete optimization problems. △ Less

Submitted 28 July, 2018; v1 submitted 16 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Comments: 29 pages

Greedy Bipartite Matching in Random Type Poisson Arrival Model

Authors: Allan Borodin, Christodoulos Karavasilis, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We introduce a new random input model for bipartite matching which we call the Random Type Poisson Arrival Model. Just like in the known i.i.d. model (introduced by Feldman et al. 2009), online nodes have types in our model. In contrast to the adversarial types studied in the known i.i.d. model, following the random graphs studied in Mastin and Jaillet 2016, in our model each type graph is generat… ▽ More We introduce a new random input model for bipartite matching which we call the Random Type Poisson Arrival Model. Just like in the known i.i.d. model (introduced by Feldman et al. 2009), online nodes have types in our model. In contrast to the adversarial types studied in the known i.i.d. model, following the random graphs studied in Mastin and Jaillet 2016, in our model each type graph is generated randomly by including each offline node in the neighborhood of an online node with probability $c/n$ independently. In our model, nodes of the same type appear consecutively in the input and the number of times each type node appears is distributed according to the Poisson distribution with parameter 1. We analyze the performance of the simple greedy algorithm under this input model. The performance is controlled by the parameter $c$ and we are able to exactly characterize the competitive ratio for the regimes $c = o(1)$ and $c = ω(1)$. We also provide a precise bound on the expected size of the matching in the remaining regime of constant $c$. We compare our results to the previous work of Mastin and Jaillet who analyzed the simple greedy algorithm in the $G_{n,n,p}$ model where each online node type occurs exactly once. We essentially show that the approach of Mastin and Jaillet can be extended to work for the Random Type Poisson Arrival Model, although several nontrivial technical challenges need to be overcome. Intuitively, one can view the Random Type Poisson Arrival Model as the $G_{n,n,p}$ model with less randomness; that is, instead of each online node having a new type, each online node has a chance of repeating the previous type. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2018; originally announced May 2018.

Comments: 15 pages, 4 figures

Stabbing Planes

Authors: Paul Beame, Noah Fleming, Russell Impagliazzo, Antonina Kolokolova, Denis Pankratov, Toniann Pitassi, Robert Robere

Abstract: We develop a new semi-algebraic proof system called Stabbing Planes which formalizes modern branch-and-cut algorithms for integer programming and is in the style of DPLL-based modern SAT solvers. As with DPLL there is only a single rule: the current polytope can be subdivided by branching on an inequality and its "integer negation." That is, we can (nondeterministically choose) a hyperplane… ▽ More We develop a new semi-algebraic proof system called Stabbing Planes which formalizes modern branch-and-cut algorithms for integer programming and is in the style of DPLL-based modern SAT solvers. As with DPLL there is only a single rule: the current polytope can be subdivided by branching on an inequality and its "integer negation." That is, we can (nondeterministically choose) a hyperplane $ax \geq b$ with integer coefficients, which partitions the polytope into three pieces: the points in the polytope satisfying $ax \geq b$, the points satisfying $ax \leq b-1$, and the middle slab $b - 1 < ax < b$. Since the middle slab contains no integer points it can be safely discarded, and the algorithm proceeds recursively on the other two branches. Each path terminates when the current polytope is empty, which is polynomial-time checkable. Among our results, we show that Stabbing Planes can efficiently simulate the Cutting Planes proof system, and is equivalent to a tree-like variant of the RCP system of [Krajicek98]. As well, we show that it possesses short proofs of the canonical family of systems of $\mathbb{F}_2$-linear equations known as the Tseitin formulas. Finally, we prove linear lower bounds on the rank of Stabbing Planes refutations by adapting lower bounds in communication complexity and use these bounds in order to show that Stabbing Planes proofs cannot be balanced. In doing so, we show that real communication protocols cannot be balanced and establish the first lower bound on the real communication complexity of the set disjointness function. △ Less

Submitted 17 March, 2023; v1 submitted 9 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

A Simple PTAS for the Dual Bin Packing Problem and Advice Complexity of Its Online Version

Authors: Allan Borodin, Denis Pankratov, Amirali Salehi-Abari

Abstract: Recently, Renault (2016) studied the dual bin packing problem in the per-request advice model of online algorithms. He showed that given $O(1/ε)$ advice bits for each input item allows approximating the dual bin packing problem online to within a factor of $1+ε$. Renault asked about the advice complexity of dual bin packing in the tape-advice model of online algorithms. We make progress on this qu… ▽ More Recently, Renault (2016) studied the dual bin packing problem in the per-request advice model of online algorithms. He showed that given $O(1/ε)$ advice bits for each input item allows approximating the dual bin packing problem online to within a factor of $1+ε$. Renault asked about the advice complexity of dual bin packing in the tape-advice model of online algorithms. We make progress on this question. Let $s$ be the maximum bit size of an input item weight. We present a conceptually simple online algorithm that with total advice $O\left(\frac{s + \log n}{ε^2}\right)$ approximates the dual bin packing to within a $1+ε$ factor. To this end, we describe and analyze a simple offline PTAS for the dual bin packing problem. Although a PTAS for a more general problem was known prior to our work (Kellerer 1999, Chekuri and Khanna 2006), our PTAS is arguably simpler to state and analyze. As a result, we could easily adapt our PTAS to obtain the advice-complexity result. We also consider whether the dependence on $s$ is necessary in our algorithm. We show that if $s$ is unrestricted then for small enough $ε> 0$ obtaining a $1+ε$ approximation to the dual bin packing requires $Ω_ε(n)$ bits of advice. To establish this lower bound we analyze an online reduction that preserves the advice complexity and approximation ratio from the binary separation problem due to Boyar et al. (2016). We define two natural advice complexity classes that capture the distinction similar to the Turing machine world distinction between pseudo polynomial time algorithms and polynomial time algorithms. Our results on the dual bin packing problem imply the separation of the two classes in the advice complexity world. △ Less

Submitted 4 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

On Conceptually Simple Algorithms for Variants of Online Bipartite Matching

Authors: Allan Borodin, Denis Pankratov, Amirali Salehi-Abari

Abstract: We present a series of results regarding conceptually simple algorithms for bipartite matching in various online and related models. We first consider a deterministic adversarial model. The best approximation ratio possible for a one-pass deterministic online algorithm is $1/2$, which is achieved by any greedy algorithm. Dürr et al. recently presented a $2$-pass algorithm called Category-Advice th… ▽ More We present a series of results regarding conceptually simple algorithms for bipartite matching in various online and related models. We first consider a deterministic adversarial model. The best approximation ratio possible for a one-pass deterministic online algorithm is $1/2$, which is achieved by any greedy algorithm. Dürr et al. recently presented a $2$-pass algorithm called Category-Advice that achieves approximation ratio $3/5$. We extend their algorithm to multiple passes. We prove the exact approximation ratio for the $k$-pass Category-Advice algorithm for all $k \ge 1$, and show that the approximation ratio converges to the inverse of the golden ratio $2/(1+\sqrt{5}) \approx 0.618$ as $k$ goes to infinity. The convergence is extremely fast --- the $5$-pass Category-Advice algorithm is already within $0.01\%$ of the inverse of the golden ratio. We then consider a natural greedy algorithm in the online stochastic IID model---MinDegree. This algorithm is an online version of a well-known and extensively studied offline algorithm MinGreedy. We show that MinDegree cannot achieve an approximation ratio better than $1-1/e$, which is guaranteed by any consistent greedy algorithm in the known IID model. Finally, following the work in Besser and Poloczek, we depart from an adversarial or stochastic ordering and investigate a natural randomized algorithm (MinRanking) in the priority model. Although the priority model allows the algorithm to choose the input ordering in a general but well defined way, this natural algorithm cannot obtain the approximation of the Ranking algorithm in the ROM model. △ Less

Submitted 29 June, 2017; originally announced June 2017.

Random CNFs are Hard for Cutting Planes

Authors: Noah Fleming, Denis Pankratov, Toniann Pitassi, Robert Robere

Abstract: The random k-SAT model is the most important and well-studied distribution over k-SAT instances. It is closely connected to statistical physics; it is used as a testbench for satisfiability algorithms, and average-case hardness over this distribution has also been linked to hardness of approximation via Feige's hypothesis. We prove that any Cutting Planes refutation for random k-SAT requires expon… ▽ More The random k-SAT model is the most important and well-studied distribution over k-SAT instances. It is closely connected to statistical physics; it is used as a testbench for satisfiability algorithms, and average-case hardness over this distribution has also been linked to hardness of approximation via Feige's hypothesis. We prove that any Cutting Planes refutation for random k-SAT requires exponential size, for k that is logarithmic in the number of variables, in the (interesting) regime where the number of clauses guarantees that the formula is unsatisfiable with high probability. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2017; originally announced March 2017.

Variations on the Sensitivity Conjecture

Authors: Pooya Hatami, Raghav Kulkarni, Denis Pankratov

Abstract: We present a selection of known as well as new variants of the Sensitivity Conjecture and point out some weaker versions that are also open. We present a selection of known as well as new variants of the Sensitivity Conjecture and point out some weaker versions that are also open. △ Less

Submitted 1 November, 2010; originally announced November 2010.

Comments: 16 pages, 1 table