-
Convergence of Approximate and Packet Routing Equilibria to Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Infinitesimally small agents aim to travel from a source to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form based on the deterministic queueing model whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Are equilibria in t…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Infinitesimally small agents aim to travel from a source to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form based on the deterministic queueing model whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Are equilibria in this model meaningful as a prediction of traffic behavior? For this to be the case, a certain notion of stability under ongoing perturbations is needed. Real traffic consists of discrete, atomic ''packets'', rather than being a continuous flow of non-atomic agents. Users may not choose an absolutely quickest route available, if there are multiple routes with very similar travel times. We would hope that in both these situations -- a discrete packet model, with packet size going to 0, and $ε$-equilibria, with $ε$ going to 0 -- equilibria converge to dynamic equilibria in the flow over time model. No such convergence results were known. We show that such a convergence result does hold in single-commodity instances for both of these settings, in a unified way. More precisely, we introduce a notion of ''strict'' $ε$-equilibria, and show that these must converge to the exact dynamic equilibrium in the limit as $ε\to 0$. We then show that results for the two settings mentioned can be deduced from this with only moderate further technical effort.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Demand-Aware Network Design with Steiner Nodes and a Connection to Virtual Network Embedding
Authors:
Aleksander Figiel,
Janne H. Korhonen,
Neil Olver,
Stefan Schmid
Abstract:
Emerging optical and virtualization technologies enable the design of more flexible and demand-aware networked systems, in which resources can be optimized toward the actual workload they serve. For example, in a demand-aware datacenter network, frequently communicating nodes (e.g., two virtual machines or a pair of racks in a datacenter) can be placed topologically closer, reducing communication…
▽ More
Emerging optical and virtualization technologies enable the design of more flexible and demand-aware networked systems, in which resources can be optimized toward the actual workload they serve. For example, in a demand-aware datacenter network, frequently communicating nodes (e.g., two virtual machines or a pair of racks in a datacenter) can be placed topologically closer, reducing communication costs and hence improving the overall network performance.
This paper revisits the bounded-degree network design problem underlying such demand-aware networks. Namely, given a distribution over communicating server pairs, we want to design a network with bounded maximum degree that minimizes expected communication distance. In addition to this known problem, we introduce and study a variant where we allow Steiner nodes (i.e., additional routers) to be added to augment the network.
We improve the understanding of this problem domain in several ways. First, we shed light on the complexity and hardness of the aforementioned problems, and study a connection between them and the virtual networking embedding problem. We then provide a constant-factor approximation algorithm for the Steiner node version of the problem, and use it to improve over prior state-of-the-art algorithms for the original version of the problem with sparse communication distributions. Finally, we investigate various heuristic approaches to bounded-degree network design problem, in particular providing a reliable heuristic algorithm with good experimental performance.
We report on an extensive empirical evaluation, using several real-world traffic traces from datacenters, and find that our approach results in improved demand-aware network designs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Thin trees for laminar families
Authors:
Nathan Klein,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
In the laminar-constrained spanning tree problem, the goal is to find a minimum-cost spanning tree which respects upper bounds on the number of times each cut in a given laminar family is crossed. This generalizes the well-studied degree-bounded spanning tree problem, as well as a previously studied setting where a chain of cuts is given. We give the first constant-factor approximation algorithm;…
▽ More
In the laminar-constrained spanning tree problem, the goal is to find a minimum-cost spanning tree which respects upper bounds on the number of times each cut in a given laminar family is crossed. This generalizes the well-studied degree-bounded spanning tree problem, as well as a previously studied setting where a chain of cuts is given. We give the first constant-factor approximation algorithm; in particular we show how to obtain a multiplicative violation of the crossing bounds of less than 22 while losing less than a factor of 5 in terms of cost.
Our result compares to the natural LP relaxation. As a consequence, our results show that given a $k$-edge-connected graph and a laminar family $\mathcal{L} \subseteq 2^V$ of cuts, there exists a spanning tree which contains only an $O(1/k)$ fraction of the edges across every cut in $\mathcal{L}$. This can be viewed as progress towards the Thin Tree Conjecture, which (in a strong form) states that this guarantee can be obtained for all cuts simultaneously.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Long term behavior of dynamic equilibria in fluid queuing networks
Authors:
Roberto Cominetti,
José Correa,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
A fluid queuing network constitutes one of the simplest models in which to study flow dynamics over a network. In this model we have a single source-sink pair and each link has a per-time-unit capacity and a transit time. A dynamic equilibrium (or equilibrium flow over time) is a flow pattern over time such that no flow particle has incentives to unilaterally change its path. Although the model ha…
▽ More
A fluid queuing network constitutes one of the simplest models in which to study flow dynamics over a network. In this model we have a single source-sink pair and each link has a per-time-unit capacity and a transit time. A dynamic equilibrium (or equilibrium flow over time) is a flow pattern over time such that no flow particle has incentives to unilaterally change its path. Although the model has been around for almost fifty years, only recently results regarding existence and characterization of equilibria have been obtained. In particular the long term behavior remains poorly understood. Our main result in this paper is to show that, under a natural (and obviously necessary) condition on the queuing capacity, a dynamic equilibrium reaches a steady state (after which queue lengths remain constant) in finite time. Previously, it was not even known that queue lengths would remain bounded. The proof is based on the analysis of a rather non-obvious potential function that turns out to be monotone along the evolution of the equilibrium. Furthermore, we show that the steady state is characterized as an optimal solution of a certain linear program. When this program has a unique solution, which occurs generically, the long term behavior is completely predictable. On the contrary, if the linear program has multiple solutions the steady state is more difficult to identify as it depends on the whole temporal evolution of the equilibrium.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
A Short Proof of Convexity of Step-out Step-in Sequencing Games
Authors:
Coulter Beeson,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
The Step out-Step in sequencing game is a particular example of a game from the sequencing game framework of Curiel, Perderzoli, and Tijs, where coalitions of players in a queue may reorder themselves to improve the their overall cost, under some restrictions. Musegaas, Borm and Quant proved, in two papers, that a simple greedy algorithm correctly computes the valuation of a coalition, and that th…
▽ More
The Step out-Step in sequencing game is a particular example of a game from the sequencing game framework of Curiel, Perderzoli, and Tijs, where coalitions of players in a queue may reorder themselves to improve the their overall cost, under some restrictions. Musegaas, Borm and Quant proved, in two papers, that a simple greedy algorithm correctly computes the valuation of a coalition, and that the game is convex. These proofs entail rather involved case analyses; in this note, we give short proofs of both results.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Continuity, Uniqueness and Long-Term Behavior of Nash Flows Over Time
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Leon Sering,
Laura Vargas Koch
Abstract:
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Users control infinitesimal flow particles aiming to travel from an origin to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Despite lots of interest, some very basic q…
▽ More
We consider a dynamic model of traffic that has received a lot of attention in the past few years. Users control infinitesimal flow particles aiming to travel from an origin to a destination as quickly as possible. Flow patterns vary over time, and congestion effects are modeled via queues, which form whenever the inflow into a link exceeds its capacity. Despite lots of interest, some very basic questions remain open in this model. We resolve a number of them:
- We show uniqueness of journey times in equilibria.
- We show continuity of equilibria: small perturbations to the instance or to the traffic situation at some moment cannot lead to wildly different equilibrium evolutions.
- We demonstrate that, assuming constant inflow into the network at the source, equilibria always settle down into a "steady state" in which the behavior extends forever in a linear fashion.
One of our main conceptual contributions is to show that the answer to the first two questions, on uniqueness and continuity, are intimately connected to the third. To resolve the third question, we substantially extend the approach of Cominetti et al., who show a steady-state result in the regime where the input flow rate is smaller than the network capacity.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2024; v1 submitted 12 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Majorizing Measures for the Optimizer
Authors:
Sander Borst,
Daniel Dadush,
Neil Olver,
Makrand Sinha
Abstract:
The theory of majorizing measures, extensively developed by Fernique, Talagrand and many others, provides one of the most general frameworks for controlling the behavior of stochastic processes. In particular, it can be applied to derive quantitative bounds on the expected suprema and the degree of continuity of sample paths for many processes.
One of the crowning achievements of the theory is T…
▽ More
The theory of majorizing measures, extensively developed by Fernique, Talagrand and many others, provides one of the most general frameworks for controlling the behavior of stochastic processes. In particular, it can be applied to derive quantitative bounds on the expected suprema and the degree of continuity of sample paths for many processes.
One of the crowning achievements of the theory is Talagrand's tight alternative characterization of the suprema of Gaussian processes in terms of majorizing measures. The proof of this theorem was difficult, and thus considerable effort was put into the task of develo** both shorter and easier to understand proofs. A major reason for this difficulty was considered to be theory of majorizing measures itself, which had the reputation of being opaque and mysterious. As a consequence, most recent treatments of the theory (including by Talagrand himself) have eschewed the use of majorizing measures in favor of a purely combinatorial approach (the generic chaining) where objects based on sequences of partitions provide roughly matching upper and lower bounds on the desired expected supremum.
In this paper, we return to majorizing measures as a primary object of study, and give a viewpoint that we think is natural and clarifying from an optimization perspective. As our main contribution, we give an algorithmic proof of the majorizing measures theorem based on two parts: (1) We make the simple (but apparently new) observation that finding the best majorizing measure can be cast as a convex program. This also allows for efficiently computing the measure using off-the-shelf methods from convex optimization. (2) We obtain tree-based upper and lower bound certificates by rounding, in a series of steps, the primal and dual solutions to this convex program.
[...]
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Improved Approximation Algorithms for Inventory Problems
Authors:
Thomas Bosman,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
We give new approximation algorithms for the submodular joint replenishment problem and the inventory routing problem, using an iterative rounding approach. In both problems, we are given a set of $N$ items and a discrete time horizon of $T$ days in which given demands for the items must be satisfied. Ordering a set of items incurs a cost according to a set function, with properties depending on t…
▽ More
We give new approximation algorithms for the submodular joint replenishment problem and the inventory routing problem, using an iterative rounding approach. In both problems, we are given a set of $N$ items and a discrete time horizon of $T$ days in which given demands for the items must be satisfied. Ordering a set of items incurs a cost according to a set function, with properties depending on the problem under consideration. Demand for an item at time $t$ can be satisfied by an order on any day prior to $t$, but a holding cost is charged for storing the items during the intermediate period; the goal is to minimize the sum of the ordering and holding cost.
Our approximation factor for both problems is $O(\log \log \min(N,T))$; this improves exponentially on the previous best results.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Algorithms for flows over time with scheduling costs
Authors:
Dario Frascaria,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
Flows over time have received substantial attention from both an optimization and (more recently) a game-theoretic perspective. In this model, each arc has an associated delay for traversing the arc, and a bound on the rate of flow entering the arc; flows are time-varying. We consider a setting which is very standard within the transportation economic literature, but has received little attention…
▽ More
Flows over time have received substantial attention from both an optimization and (more recently) a game-theoretic perspective. In this model, each arc has an associated delay for traversing the arc, and a bound on the rate of flow entering the arc; flows are time-varying. We consider a setting which is very standard within the transportation economic literature, but has received little attention from an algorithmic perspective. The flow consists of users who are able to choose their route but also their departure time, and who desire to arrive at their destination at a particular time, incurring a 'scheduling cost' if they arrive earlier or later. The total cost of a user is then a combination of the time they spend commuting, and the scheduling cost they incur. We present a combinatorial algorithm for the natural optimization problem, that of minimizing the average total cost of all users (i.e., maximizing the social welfare). Based on this, we also show how to set tolls so that this optimal flow is induced as an equilibrium of the underlying game.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Performance of the smallest-variance-first rule in appointment sequencing
Authors:
Madelon A. de Kemp,
Michel Mandjes,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
A classical problem in appointment scheduling, with applications in health care, concerns the determination of the patients' arrival times that minimize a cost function that is a weighted sum of mean waiting times and mean idle times. One aspect of this problem is the sequencing problem, which focuses on ordering the patients. We assess the performance of the smallest-variance-first (SVF) rule, wh…
▽ More
A classical problem in appointment scheduling, with applications in health care, concerns the determination of the patients' arrival times that minimize a cost function that is a weighted sum of mean waiting times and mean idle times. One aspect of this problem is the sequencing problem, which focuses on ordering the patients. We assess the performance of the smallest-variance-first (SVF) rule, which sequences patients in order of increasing variance of their service durations. While it was known that SVF is not always optimal, it has been widely observed that it performs well in practice and simulation. We provide a theoretical justification for this observation by proving, in various settings, quantitative worst-case bounds on the ratio between the cost incurred by the SVF rule and the minimum attainable cost. We also show that, in great generality, SVF is asymptotically optimal, i.e., the ratio approaches 1 as the number of patients grows large. While evaluating policies by considering an approximation ratio is a standard approach in many algorithmic settings, our results appear to be the first of this type in the appointment scheduling literature.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2020; v1 submitted 4 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Approximate Multi-Matroid Intersection via Iterative Refinement
Authors:
André Linhares,
Neil Olver,
Chaitanya Swamy,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
We introduce a new iterative rounding technique to round a point in a matroid polytope subject to further matroid constraints. This technique returns an independent set in one matroid with limited violations of the other ones. On top of the classical steps of iterative relaxation approaches, we iteratively refine/split involved matroid constraints to obtain a more restrictive constraint system, th…
▽ More
We introduce a new iterative rounding technique to round a point in a matroid polytope subject to further matroid constraints. This technique returns an independent set in one matroid with limited violations of the other ones. On top of the classical steps of iterative relaxation approaches, we iteratively refine/split involved matroid constraints to obtain a more restrictive constraint system, that is amenable to iterative relaxation techniques. Hence, throughout the iterations, we both tighten constraints and later relax them by drop** constrains under certain conditions. Due to the refinement step, we can deal with considerably more general constraint classes than existing iterative relaxation/rounding methods, which typically round on one matroid polytope with additional simple cardinality constraints that do not overlap too much.
We show how our rounding method, combined with an application of a matroid intersection algorithm, yields the first $2$-approximation for finding a maximum-weight common independent set in $3$ matroids. Moreover, our $2$-approximation is LP-based, and settles the integrality gap for the natural relaxation of the problem. Prior to our work, no better upper bound than $3$ was known for the integrality gap, which followed from the greedy algorithm. We also discuss various other applications of our techniques, including an extension that allows us to handle a mixture of matroid and knapsack constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
A Duality Based 2-Approximation Algorithm for Maximum Agreement Forest
Authors:
Neil Olver,
Frans Schalekamp,
Suzanne van der Ster,
Leen Stougie,
Anke van Zuylen
Abstract:
We give a 2-approximation algorithm for the Maximum Agreement Forest problem on two rooted binary trees. This NP-hard problem has been studied extensively in the past two decades, since it can be used to compute the rooted Subtree Prune-and-Regraft (rSPR) distance between two phylogenetic trees. Our algorithm is combinatorial and its running time is quadratic in the input size. To prove the approx…
▽ More
We give a 2-approximation algorithm for the Maximum Agreement Forest problem on two rooted binary trees. This NP-hard problem has been studied extensively in the past two decades, since it can be used to compute the rooted Subtree Prune-and-Regraft (rSPR) distance between two phylogenetic trees. Our algorithm is combinatorial and its running time is quadratic in the input size. To prove the approximation guarantee, we construct a feasible dual solution for a novel linear programming formulation. In addition, we show this linear program is stronger than previously known formulations, and we give a compact formulation, showing that it can be solved in polynomial time
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
On the Integrality Gap of the Prize-Collecting Steiner Forest LP
Authors:
Jochen Könemann,
Neil Olver,
Kanstantsin Pashkovich,
R. Ravi,
Chaitanya Swamy,
Jens Vygen
Abstract:
In the prize-collecting Steiner forest (PCSF) problem, we are given an undirected graph $G=(V,E)$, edge costs $\{c_e\geq 0\}_{e\in E}$, terminal pairs $\{(s_i,t_i)\}_{i=1}^k$, and penalties $\{π_i\}_{i=1}^k$ for each terminal pair; the goal is to find a forest $F$ to minimize $c(F)+\sum_{i: (s_i,t_i)\text{ not connected in }F}π_i$. The Steiner forest problem can be viewed as the special case where…
▽ More
In the prize-collecting Steiner forest (PCSF) problem, we are given an undirected graph $G=(V,E)$, edge costs $\{c_e\geq 0\}_{e\in E}$, terminal pairs $\{(s_i,t_i)\}_{i=1}^k$, and penalties $\{π_i\}_{i=1}^k$ for each terminal pair; the goal is to find a forest $F$ to minimize $c(F)+\sum_{i: (s_i,t_i)\text{ not connected in }F}π_i$. The Steiner forest problem can be viewed as the special case where $π_i=\infty$ for all $i$. It was widely believed that the integrality gap of the natural (and well-studied) linear-programming (LP) relaxation for PCSF is at most 2. We dispel this belief by showing that the integrality gap of this LP is at least $9/4$. This holds even for planar graphs. We also show that using this LP, one cannot devise a Lagrangian-multiplier-preserving (LMP) algorithm with approximation guarantee better than $4$. Our results thus show a separation between the integrality gaps of the LP-relaxations for prize-collecting and non-prize-collecting (i.e., standard) Steiner forest, as well as the approximation ratios achievable relative to the optimal LP solution by LMP- and non-LMP- approximation algorithms for PCSF. For the special case of prize-collecting Steiner tree (PCST), we prove that the natural LP relaxation admits basic feasible solutions with all coordinates of value at most $1/3$ and all edge variables positive. Thus, we rule out the possibility of approximating PCST with guarantee better than $3$ using a direct iterative rounding method.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
A Simpler and Faster Strongly Polynomial Algorithm for Generalized Flow Maximization
Authors:
Neil Olver,
László A. Végh
Abstract:
We present a new strongly polynomial algorithm for generalized flow maximization that is significantly simpler and faster than the previous strongly polynomial algorithm [Végh16]. For the uncapacitated problem formulation, the complexity bound $O(mn(m+n\log n)\log (n^2/m))$ improves on the previous estimate by almost a factor $O(n^2)$. Even for small numerical parameter values, our running time bo…
▽ More
We present a new strongly polynomial algorithm for generalized flow maximization that is significantly simpler and faster than the previous strongly polynomial algorithm [Végh16]. For the uncapacitated problem formulation, the complexity bound $O(mn(m+n\log n)\log (n^2/m))$ improves on the previous estimate by almost a factor $O(n^2)$. Even for small numerical parameter values, our running time bound is comparable to the best weakly polynomial algorithms. The key new technical idea is relaxing the primal feasibility conditions. This allows us to work almost exclusively with integral flows, in contrast to all previous algorithms for the problem.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2020; v1 submitted 6 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
A note on hierarchical hubbing for a generalization of the VPN problem
Authors:
Neil Olver
Abstract:
Robust network design refers to a class of optimization problems that occur when designing networks to efficiently handle variable demands. The notion of "hierarchical hubbing" was introduced (in the narrow context of a specific robust network design question), by Olver and Shepherd [2010]. Hierarchical hubbing allows for routings with a multiplicity of "hubs" which are connected to the terminals…
▽ More
Robust network design refers to a class of optimization problems that occur when designing networks to efficiently handle variable demands. The notion of "hierarchical hubbing" was introduced (in the narrow context of a specific robust network design question), by Olver and Shepherd [2010]. Hierarchical hubbing allows for routings with a multiplicity of "hubs" which are connected to the terminals and to each other in a treelike fashion. Recently, Fréchette et al. [2013] explored this notion much more generally, focusing on its applicability to an extension of the well-studied hose model that allows for upper bounds on individual point-to-point demands. In this paper, we consider hierarchical hubbing in the context of a previously studied (and extremely natural) generalization of the hose model, and prove that the optimal hierarchical hubbing solution can be found efficiently. This result is relevant to a recently proposed generalization of the "VPN Conjecture".
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Dynamic vs Oblivious Routing in Network Design
Authors:
Navin Goyal,
Neil Olver,
F. Bruce Shepherd
Abstract:
Consider the robust network design problem of finding a minimum cost network with enough capacity to route all traffic demand matrices in a given polytope. We investigate the impact of different routing models in this robust setting: in particular, we compare \emph{oblivious} routing, where the routing between each terminal pair must be fixed in advance, to \emph{dynamic} routing, where routings m…
▽ More
Consider the robust network design problem of finding a minimum cost network with enough capacity to route all traffic demand matrices in a given polytope. We investigate the impact of different routing models in this robust setting: in particular, we compare \emph{oblivious} routing, where the routing between each terminal pair must be fixed in advance, to \emph{dynamic} routing, where routings may depend arbitrarily on the current demand. Our main result is a construction that shows that the optimal cost of such a network based on oblivious routing (fractional or integral) may be a factor of $\BigOmega(\log{n})$ more than the cost required when using dynamic routing. This is true even in the important special case of the asymmetric hose model. This answers a question in \cite{chekurisurvey07}, and is tight up to constant factors. Our proof technique builds on a connection between expander graphs and robust design for single-sink traffic patterns \cite{ChekuriHardness07}.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Pipage Rounding, Pessimistic Estimators and Matrix Concentration
Authors:
Nicholas J. A. Harvey,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
Pipage rounding is a dependent random sampling technique that has several interesting properties and diverse applications. One property that has been particularly useful is negative correlation of the resulting vector. Unfortunately negative correlation has its limitations, and there are some further desirable properties that do not seem to follow from existing techniques. In particular, recent co…
▽ More
Pipage rounding is a dependent random sampling technique that has several interesting properties and diverse applications. One property that has been particularly useful is negative correlation of the resulting vector. Unfortunately negative correlation has its limitations, and there are some further desirable properties that do not seem to follow from existing techniques. In particular, recent concentration results for sums of independent random matrices are not known to extend to a negatively dependent setting.
We introduce a simple but useful technique called concavity of pessimistic estimators. This technique allows us to show concentration of submodular functions and concentration of matrix sums under pipage rounding. The former result answers a question of Chekuri et al. (2009). To prove the latter result, we derive a new variant of Lieb's celebrated concavity theorem in matrix analysis.
We provide numerous applications of these results. One is to spectrally-thin trees, a spectral analog of the thin trees that played a crucial role in the recent breakthrough on the asymmetric traveling salesman problem. We show a polynomial time algorithm that, given a graph where every edge has effective conductance at least $κ$, returns an $O(κ^{-1} \cdot \log n / \log \log n)$-spectrally-thin tree. There are further applications to rounding of semidefinite programs, to the column subset selection problem, and to a geometric question of extracting a nearly-orthonormal basis from an isotropic distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Matroids and Integrality Gaps for Hypergraphic Steiner Tree Relaxations
Authors:
Michel X. Goemans,
Neil Olver,
Thomas Rothvoss,
Rico Zenklusen
Abstract:
Until recently, LP relaxations have played a limited role in the design of approximation algorithms for the Steiner tree problem. In 2010, Byrka et al. presented a ln(4)+epsilon approximation based on a hypergraphic LP relaxation, but surprisingly, their analysis does not provide a matching bound on the integrality gap.
We take a fresh look at hypergraphic LP relaxations for the Steiner tree pro…
▽ More
Until recently, LP relaxations have played a limited role in the design of approximation algorithms for the Steiner tree problem. In 2010, Byrka et al. presented a ln(4)+epsilon approximation based on a hypergraphic LP relaxation, but surprisingly, their analysis does not provide a matching bound on the integrality gap.
We take a fresh look at hypergraphic LP relaxations for the Steiner tree problem - one that heavily exploits methods and results from the theory of matroids and submodular functions - which leads to stronger integrality gaps, faster algorithms, and a variety of structural insights of independent interest. More precisely, we present a deterministic ln(4)+epsilon approximation that compares against the LP value and therefore proves a matching ln(4) upper bound on the integrality gap.
Similarly to Byrka et al., we iteratively fix one component and update the LP solution. However, whereas they solve an LP at every iteration after contracting a component, we show how feasibility can be maintained by a greedy procedure on a well-chosen matroid. Apart from avoiding the expensive step of solving a hypergraphic LP at each iteration, our algorithm can be analyzed using a simple potential function. This gives an easy means to determine stronger approximation guarantees and integrality gaps when considering restricted graph topologies. In particular, this readily leads to a 73/60 bound on the integrality gap for quasi-bipartite graphs.
For the case of quasi-bipartite graphs, we present a simple algorithm to transform an optimal solution to the bidirected cut relaxation to an optimal solution of the hypergraphic relaxation, leading to a fast 73/60 approximation for quasi-bipartite graphs. Furthermore, we show how the separation problem of the hypergraphic relaxation can be solved by computing maximum flows, providing a fast independence oracle for our matroids.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2011; v1 submitted 30 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Inner Product Spaces for MinSum Coordination Mechanisms
Authors:
Richard Cole,
José R. Correa,
Vasilis Gkatzelis,
Vahab Mirrokni,
Neil Olver
Abstract:
We study policies aiming to minimize the weighted sum of completion times of jobs in the context of coordination mechanisms for selfish scheduling problems. Our goal is to design local policies that achieve a good price of anarchy in the resulting equilibria for unrelated machine scheduling. To obtain the approximation bounds, we introduce a new technique that while conceptually simple, seems to b…
▽ More
We study policies aiming to minimize the weighted sum of completion times of jobs in the context of coordination mechanisms for selfish scheduling problems. Our goal is to design local policies that achieve a good price of anarchy in the resulting equilibria for unrelated machine scheduling. To obtain the approximation bounds, we introduce a new technique that while conceptually simple, seems to be quite powerful. With this method we are able to prove the following results.
First, we consider Smith's Rule, which orders the jobs on a machine in ascending processing time to weight ratio, and show that it achieves an approximation ratio of 4. We also demonstrate that this is the best possible for deterministic non-preemptive strongly local policies. Since Smith's Rule is always optimal for a given assignment, this may seem unsurprising, but we then show that better approximation ratios can be obtained if either preemption or randomization is allowed.
We prove that ProportionalSharing, a preemptive strongly local policy, achieves an approximation ratio of 2.618 for the weighted sum of completion times, and an approximation ratio of 2.5 in the unweighted case. Again, we observe that these bounds are tight. Next, we consider Rand, a natural non-preemptive but randomized policy. We show that it achieves an approximation ratio of at most 2.13; moreover, if the sum of the weighted completion times is negligible compared to the cost of the optimal solution, this improves to π/2.
Finally, we show that both ProportionalSharing and Rand induce potential games, and thus always have a pure Nash equilibrium (unlike Smith's Rule). This also allows us to design the first \emph{combinatorial} constant-factor approximation algorithm minimizing weighted completion time for unrelated machine scheduling that achieves a factor of 2+ εfor any ε> 0.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2010; v1 submitted 9 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
