An Analytics of Culture: Modeling Subjectivity, Scalability, Contextuality, and Temporality
Authors:
Nanne van Noord,
Melvin Wevers,
Tobias Blanke,
Julia Noordegraaf,
Marcel Worring
Abstract:
There is a bidirectional relationship between culture and AI; AI models are increasingly used to analyse culture, thereby sha** our understanding of culture. On the other hand, the models are trained on collections of cultural artifacts thereby implicitly, and not always correctly, encoding expressions of culture. This creates a tension that both limits the use of AI for analysing culture and le…
▽ More
There is a bidirectional relationship between culture and AI; AI models are increasingly used to analyse culture, thereby sha** our understanding of culture. On the other hand, the models are trained on collections of cultural artifacts thereby implicitly, and not always correctly, encoding expressions of culture. This creates a tension that both limits the use of AI for analysing culture and leads to problems in AI with respect to cultural complex issues such as bias.
One approach to overcome this tension is to more extensively take into account the intricacies and complexities of culture. We structure our discussion using four concepts that guide humanistic inquiry into culture: subjectivity, scalability, contextuality, and temporality. We focus on these concepts because they have not yet been sufficiently represented in AI research. We believe that possible implementations of these aspects into AI research leads to AI that better captures the complexities of culture. In what follows, we briefly describe these four concepts and their absence in AI research. For each concept, we define possible research challenges.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
Archives and AI: An Overview of Current Debates and Future Perspectives
Authors:
Giovanni Colavizza,
Tobias Blanke,
Charles Jeurgens,
Julia Noordegraaf
Abstract:
The digital transformation is turning archives, both old and new, into data. As a consequence, automation in the form of artificial intelligence techniques is increasingly applied both to scale traditional recordkee** activities, and to experiment with novel ways to capture, organise and access records. We survey recent developments at the intersection of Artificial Intelligence and archival thi…
▽ More
The digital transformation is turning archives, both old and new, into data. As a consequence, automation in the form of artificial intelligence techniques is increasingly applied both to scale traditional recordkee** activities, and to experiment with novel ways to capture, organise and access records. We survey recent developments at the intersection of Artificial Intelligence and archival thinking and practice. Our overview of this growing body of literature is organised through the lenses of the Records Continuum model. We find four broad themes in the literature on archives and artificial intelligence: theoretical and professional considerations, the automation of recordkee** processes, organising and accessing archives, and novel forms of digital archives. We conclude by underlining emerging trends and directions for future work, which include the application of recordkee** principles to the very data and processes which power modern artificial intelligence, and a more structural, yet critically-aware, integration of artificial intelligence into archival systems and practice.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
