The Good, the Bad, and the Hulk-like GPT: Analyzing Emotional Decisions of Large Language Models in Cooperation and Bargaining Games
Authors:
Mikhail Mozikov,
Nikita Severin,
Valeria Bodishtianu,
Maria Glushanina,
Mikhail Baklashkin,
Andrey V. Savchenko,
Ilya Makarov
Abstract:
Behavior study experiments are an important part of society modeling and understanding human interactions. In practice, many behavioral experiments encounter challenges related to internal and external validity, reproducibility, and social bias due to the complexity of social interactions and cooperation in human user studies. Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have provided researche…
▽ More
Behavior study experiments are an important part of society modeling and understanding human interactions. In practice, many behavioral experiments encounter challenges related to internal and external validity, reproducibility, and social bias due to the complexity of social interactions and cooperation in human user studies. Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have provided researchers with a new promising tool for the simulation of human behavior. However, existing LLM-based simulations operate under the unproven hypothesis that LLM agents behave similarly to humans as well as ignore a crucial factor in human decision-making: emotions.
In this paper, we introduce a novel methodology and the framework to study both, the decision-making of LLMs and their alignment with human behavior under emotional states. Experiments with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 on four games from two different classes of behavioral game theory showed that emotions profoundly impact the performance of LLMs, leading to the development of more optimal strategies. While there is a strong alignment between the behavioral responses of GPT-3.5 and human participants, particularly evident in bargaining games, GPT-4 exhibits consistent behavior, ignoring induced emotions for rationality decisions. Surprisingly, emotional prompting, particularly with `anger' emotion, can disrupt the "superhuman" alignment of GPT-4, resembling human emotional responses.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
Long-term hail risk assessment with deep neural networks
Authors:
Ivan Lukyanenko,
Mikhail Mozikov,
Yury Maximov,
Ilya Makarov
Abstract:
Hail risk assessment is necessary to estimate and reduce damage to crops, orchards, and infrastructure. Also, it helps to estimate and reduce consequent losses for businesses and, particularly, insurance companies. But hail forecasting is challenging. Data used for designing models for this purpose are tree-dimensional geospatial time series. Hail is a very local event with respect to the resoluti…
▽ More
Hail risk assessment is necessary to estimate and reduce damage to crops, orchards, and infrastructure. Also, it helps to estimate and reduce consequent losses for businesses and, particularly, insurance companies. But hail forecasting is challenging. Data used for designing models for this purpose are tree-dimensional geospatial time series. Hail is a very local event with respect to the resolution of available datasets. Also, hail events are rare - only 1% of targets in observations are marked as "hail". Models for nowcasting and short-term hail forecasts are improving. Introducing machine learning models to the meteorology field is not new. There are also various climate models reflecting possible scenarios of climate change in the future. But there are no machine learning models for data-driven forecasting of changes in hail frequency for a given area.
The first possible approach for the latter task is to ignore spatial and temporal structure and develop a model capable of classifying a given vertical profile of meteorological variables as favorable to hail formation or not. Although such an approach certainly neglects important information, it is very light weighted and easily scalable because it treats observations as independent from each other. The more advanced approach is to design a neural network capable to process geospatial data. Our idea here is to combine convolutional layers responsible for the processing of spatial data with recurrent neural network blocks capable to work with temporal structure.
This study compares two approaches and introduces a model suitable for the task of forecasting changes in hail frequency for ongoing decades.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.