-
Promise of Graph Sparsification and Decomposition for Noise Reduction in QAOA: Analysis for Trapped-Ion Compilations
Authors:
Jai Moondra,
Philip C. Lotshaw,
Greg Mohler,
Swati Gupta
Abstract:
We develop new approximate compilation schemes that significantly reduce the expense of compiling the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) for solving the Max-Cut problem. Our main focus is on compilation with trapped-ion simulators using Pauli-$X$ operations and all-to-all Ising Hamiltonian $H_\text{Ising}$ evolution generated by Molmer-Sorensen or optical dipole force interactions,…
▽ More
We develop new approximate compilation schemes that significantly reduce the expense of compiling the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) for solving the Max-Cut problem. Our main focus is on compilation with trapped-ion simulators using Pauli-$X$ operations and all-to-all Ising Hamiltonian $H_\text{Ising}$ evolution generated by Molmer-Sorensen or optical dipole force interactions, though some of our results also apply to standard gate-based compilations. Our results are based on principles of graph sparsification and decomposition; the former reduces the number of edges in a graph while maintaining its cut structure, while the latter breaks a weighted graph into a small number of unweighted graphs. Though these techniques have been used as heuristics in various hybrid quantum algorithms, there have been no guarantees on their performance, to the best of our knowledge. This work provides the first provable guarantees using sparsification and decomposition to improve quantum noise resilience and reduce quantum circuit complexity.
For quantum hardware that uses edge-by-edge QAOA compilations, sparsification leads to a direct reduction in circuit complexity. For trapped-ion quantum simulators implementing all-to-all $H_\text{Ising}$ pulses, we show that for a $(1-ε)$ factor loss in the Max-Cut approximation ($ε>0)$, our compilations improve the (worst-case) number of $H_\text{Ising}$ pulses from $O(n^2)$ to $O(n\log(n/ε))$ and the (worst-case) number of Pauli-$X$ bit flips from $O(n^2)$ to $O\left(\frac{n\log(n/ε)}{ε^2}\right)$ for $n$-node graphs. We demonstrate significant reductions in noise are obtained in our new compilation approaches using theory and numerical calculations for trapped-ion hardware. We anticipate these approximate compilation techniques will be useful tools in a variety of future quantum computing experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Balancing Notions of Equity: Approximation Algorithms for Fair Portfolio of Solutions in Combinatorial Optimization
Authors:
Swati Gupta,
Jai Moondra,
Mohit Singh
Abstract:
Inspired by equity considerations, we consider top-$k$ norm, ordered norm, and symmetric monotonic norm objectives for various combinatorial optimization problems. Top-$k$ norms and ordered norms have natural interpretations in terms of minimizing the impact on individuals bearing largest costs. To model decision-making with multiple equity criteria, we study the notion of portfolios of solutions…
▽ More
Inspired by equity considerations, we consider top-$k$ norm, ordered norm, and symmetric monotonic norm objectives for various combinatorial optimization problems. Top-$k$ norms and ordered norms have natural interpretations in terms of minimizing the impact on individuals bearing largest costs. To model decision-making with multiple equity criteria, we study the notion of portfolios of solutions with the property that each norm or equity criteria has an approximately optimal solution in this portfolio. We attempt to characterize portfolios by their sizes and approximation factor guarantees for various combinatorial problems. For a given problem, we investigate whether (1) there exists a single solution that is approximately optimal for all norms, (2) there exists a small approximately optimal portfolio of size larger than 1, (3) there exist polynomial time algorithms to find these small portfolios. We study an algorithmic framework to obtain single solutions that are approximately optimal for all norms. We show the existence of such a solution for problems such as $k$-clustering, ordered set cover, scheduling for job completion time minimization, and scheduling for machine load minimization on identical machines. We also give efficient algorithms to find these solutions in most cases, except set cover where we show there is a gap in terms of computational complexity. Our work improves upon the best-known approximation factor across all norms for a single solution in $k$-clustering. For uncapacitated facility location and scheduling for machine load minimization with identical jobs, we obtain logarithmic sized portfolios, also providing a matching lower bound in the latter case. Our work results in new open combinatorial questions, which might be of independent interest.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Which $L_p$ norm is the fairest? Approximations for fair facility location across all "$p$"
Authors:
Swati Gupta,
Jai Moondra,
Mohit Singh
Abstract:
Fair facility location problems try to balance access costs to open facilities borne by different groups of people by minimizing the $L_p$ norm of these group distances. However, there is no clear choice of "$p$" in the current literature. We present a novel approach to address the challenge of choosing the right notion of fairness. We introduce the concept of portfolios, a set of solutions that c…
▽ More
Fair facility location problems try to balance access costs to open facilities borne by different groups of people by minimizing the $L_p$ norm of these group distances. However, there is no clear choice of "$p$" in the current literature. We present a novel approach to address the challenge of choosing the right notion of fairness. We introduce the concept of portfolios, a set of solutions that contains an approximately optimal solution for each objective in a given class of objectives, such as $L_p$ norms. This concept opens up new possibilities for getting around the "right" notion of fairness for many problems. For $r$ client groups, we demonstrate portfolios of size $Θ(\log r)$ for the facility location and $k$-clustering problems, with an $O(1)$-approximate solution for each $L_p$ norm. Further, motivated by the Justice40 Initiative that provides rolling budget investments, we impose a refinement-like structure on the portfolio. We develop novel approximation algorithms for these structured portfolios and show experimental evidence of their performance in two US counties. We also present a planning tool that provides potential ways to expand access to US healthcare facilities, which might be of independent interest to policymakers.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2024; v1 submitted 27 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Multi Purpose Routing: New Perspectives and Approximation Algorithms
Authors:
Majid Farhadi,
Jai Moondra,
Prasad Tetali,
Alejandro Toriello
Abstract:
The cost due to delay in services may be intrinsically different for various applications of vehicle routing such as medical emergencies, logistical operations, and ride-sharing. We study a fundamental generalization of the Traveling Salesman Problem, namely $L_p$ TSP, where the objective is to minimize an aggregated measure of the delay in services, quantified by the Minkowski $p$-norm of the del…
▽ More
The cost due to delay in services may be intrinsically different for various applications of vehicle routing such as medical emergencies, logistical operations, and ride-sharing. We study a fundamental generalization of the Traveling Salesman Problem, namely $L_p$ TSP, where the objective is to minimize an aggregated measure of the delay in services, quantified by the Minkowski $p$-norm of the delay vector. We present efficient combinatorial and Linear Programming algorithms for approximating $L_p$ TSP on general metrics. We provide several approximation algorithms for the $L_p$ TSP problem, including $4.27$ & $10.92$-approximation algorithms for single & multi vehicle $L_2$ TSP, called the Traveling Firefighter Problem. Among other contributions, we provide an $8$-approximation and a $1.78$ inapproximability for All-Norm TSP problem, addressing scenarios where one does not know the ideal cost function, or is seeking simultaneous approximation with respect to any cost function.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Reusing Combinatorial Structure: Faster Iterative Projections over Submodular Base Polytopes
Authors:
Jai Moondra,
Hassan Mortagy,
Swati Gupta
Abstract:
Optimization algorithms such as projected Newton's method, FISTA, mirror descent, and its variants enjoy near-optimal regret bounds and convergence rates, but suffer from a computational bottleneck of computing ``projections'' in potentially each iteration (e.g., $O(T^{1/2})$ regret of online mirror descent). On the other hand, conditional gradient variants solve a linear optimization in each iter…
▽ More
Optimization algorithms such as projected Newton's method, FISTA, mirror descent, and its variants enjoy near-optimal regret bounds and convergence rates, but suffer from a computational bottleneck of computing ``projections'' in potentially each iteration (e.g., $O(T^{1/2})$ regret of online mirror descent). On the other hand, conditional gradient variants solve a linear optimization in each iteration, but result in suboptimal rates (e.g., $O(T^{3/4})$ regret of online Frank-Wolfe). Motivated by this trade-off in runtime v/s convergence rates, we consider iterative projections of close-by points over widely-prevalent submodular base polytopes $B(f)$. We first give necessary and sufficient conditions for when two close points project to the same face of a polytope, and then show that points far away from the polytope project onto its vertices with high probability. We next use this theory and develop a toolkit to speed up the computation of iterative projections over submodular polytopes using both discrete and continuous perspectives. We subsequently adapt the away-step Frank-Wolfe algorithm to use this information and enable early termination. For the special case of cardinality-based submodular polytopes, we improve the runtime of computing certain Bregman projections by a factor of $Ω(n/\log(n))$. Our theoretical results show orders of magnitude reduction in runtime in preliminary computational experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023; v1 submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Generating Target Graph Couplings for QAOA from Native Quantum Hardware Couplings
Authors:
Joel Rajakumar,
Jai Moondra,
Bryan Gard,
Swati Gupta,
Creston D. Herold
Abstract:
We present methods for constructing any target coupling graph using limited global controls in an Ising-like quantum spin system. Our approach is motivated by implementing the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) on trapped ion quantum hardware to find approximate solutions to Max-Cut. We present a mathematical description of the problem and provide approximately optimal algorithmic c…
▽ More
We present methods for constructing any target coupling graph using limited global controls in an Ising-like quantum spin system. Our approach is motivated by implementing the quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) on trapped ion quantum hardware to find approximate solutions to Max-Cut. We present a mathematical description of the problem and provide approximately optimal algorithmic constructions that generate arbitrary unweighted coupling graphs with $n$ nodes in $O(n)$ global entangling operations and weighted graphs with $m$ edges in $O(m)$ operations. These upper bounds are not tight in general, and we formulate a mixed-integer program to solve the graph coupling problem to optimality. We perform numeric experiments on small graphs with $n\le8$ and show that optimal sequences, which use fewer operations, can be found using mixed-integer programs. Noisy simulations of Max-Cut QAOA show that our implementation is less susceptible to noise than the standard gate-based compilation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2022; v1 submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
