-
Fair Coordination of Distributed Energy Resources with Volt-Var Control and PV Curtailment
Authors:
Daniel Gebbran,
Sleiman Mhanna,
Yiju Ma,
Archie C. Chapman,
Gregor Verbic
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel distributed optimal power flow (DOPF) method for fair distributed energy resource (DER) coordination in the context of mandated rooftop PV inverter control modes. In practice, inverter reactive power control is increasingly required by grid connection codes, which often unfairly curtail PV generation of prosumers towards the end of low-voltage feeders. Similarly, optimi…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel distributed optimal power flow (DOPF) method for fair distributed energy resource (DER) coordination in the context of mandated rooftop PV inverter control modes. In practice, inverter reactive power control is increasingly required by grid connection codes, which often unfairly curtail PV generation of prosumers towards the end of low-voltage feeders. Similarly, optimization-based DER coordination methods that aim solely for technically-efficient DER coordination do not consider the distribution of PV curtailment across customers. To address these concerns, we develop a tractable multi-objective DOPF method for optimal DER coordination that (i) curtails PV generation fairly across prosumers, and (ii) incorporates a standard piecewise-linear volt-var control reactive power control function without using integer variables. Three equity principles representing different interpretations of fairness are implemented in our coordination method; namely, egalitarian, proportional and uniform dynamic PV curtailment redistribution. The performance of our approach is demonstrated on low-voltage distribution feeders of different sizes (5, 10, 25, 50 and 100 prosumers) using two network topologies: line topology without lateral spurs and tree topology with lateral spurs. Each network considers three levels of PV penetration, giving 30 test systems in total. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed DOPF method for fair DER coordination: PV curtailment is equitably distributed among prosumers with a computational burden on par with conventional DOPF approaches. Moreover, different fairness methods result in different patterns of curtailment, which a regulator may choose between.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Practical Considerations of DER Coordination with Distributed Optimal Power Flow
Authors:
Daniel Gebbran,
Sleiman Mhanna,
Archie C. Chapman,
Wibowo Hardjawana,
Branka Vucetic,
Gregor Verbic
Abstract:
The coordination of prosumer-owned, behind-the-meter distributed energy resources (DER) can be achieved using a multiperiod, distributed optimal power flow (DOPF), which satisfies network constraints and preserves the privacy of prosumers. To solve the problem in a distributed fashion, it is decomposed and solved using the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM), which may require many…
▽ More
The coordination of prosumer-owned, behind-the-meter distributed energy resources (DER) can be achieved using a multiperiod, distributed optimal power flow (DOPF), which satisfies network constraints and preserves the privacy of prosumers. To solve the problem in a distributed fashion, it is decomposed and solved using the alternating direction method of multipliers (ADMM), which may require many iterations between prosumers and the central entity (i.e., an aggregator). Furthermore, the computational burden is shared among the agents with different processing capacities. Therefore, computational constraints and communication requirements may make the DOPF infeasible or impractical. In this paper, part of the DOPF (some of the prosumer subproblems) is executed on a Raspberry Pi-based hardware prototype, which emulates a low processing power, edge computing device. Four important aspects are analyzed using test cases of different complexities. The first is the computation cost of executing the subproblems in the edge computing device. The second is the algorithm operation on congested electrical networks, which impacts the convergence speed of DOPF solutions. Third, the precision of the computed solution, including the trade-off between solution quality and the number of iterations, is examined. Fourth, the communication requirements for implementation across different communication networks are investigated. The above metrics are analyzed in four scenarios involving 26-bus and 51-bus networks.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Accelerated Methods for the SOCP-relaxed Component-based Distributed Optimal Power Flow
Authors:
Sleiman Mhanna,
Archie Chapman,
Gregor Verbic
Abstract:
In light of the increased focus on distributed methods, this paper proposes two accelerated subgradient methods and an adaptive penalty parameter scheme to speed-up the convergence of ADMM on the component-based dual decomposition of the second-order cone programming (SOCP) relaxation of the OPF. This work is the first to apply an adaptive penalty parameter method along with an accelerated subgrad…
▽ More
In light of the increased focus on distributed methods, this paper proposes two accelerated subgradient methods and an adaptive penalty parameter scheme to speed-up the convergence of ADMM on the component-based dual decomposition of the second-order cone programming (SOCP) relaxation of the OPF. This work is the first to apply an adaptive penalty parameter method along with an accelerated subgradient method together in one scheme for distributed OPF. This accelerated scheme is demonstrated to reach substantial speed-ups, as high as 87%, on real-world test systems with more than 9000 buses, as well as on other difficult test cases.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2018; v1 submitted 10 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
A Component-Based Dual Decomposition Method for the OPF Problem
Authors:
Sleiman Mhanna,
Gregor Verbic,
Archie Chapman
Abstract:
This paper proposes a component-based dual decomposition of the nonconvex AC optimal power flow (OPF) problem, where the modified dual function is solved in a distributed fashion. The main contribution of this work is that is demonstrates that a distributed method with carefully tuned parameters can converge to globally optimal solutions despite the inherent nonconvexity of the problem and the abs…
▽ More
This paper proposes a component-based dual decomposition of the nonconvex AC optimal power flow (OPF) problem, where the modified dual function is solved in a distributed fashion. The main contribution of this work is that is demonstrates that a distributed method with carefully tuned parameters can converge to globally optimal solutions despite the inherent nonconvexity of the problem and the absence of theoretical guarantees of convergence. This paper is the first to conduct extensive numerical analysis resulting in the identification and tabulation of the algorithmic parameter settings that are crucial for the convergence of the method on 72 AC OPF test instances. Moreover, this work provides a deeper insight into the geometry of the modified Lagrange dual function of the OPF problem and highlights the conditions that make this function differentiable. This numerical demonstration of convergence coupled with the scalability and the privacy preserving nature of the proposed method makes it well suited for smart grid applications such as multi-period OPF with demand response (DR) and security constrained unit commitment (SCUC) with contingency constraints and multiple transmission system operators (TSOs).
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2017; v1 submitted 12 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Tight LP Approximations for the Optimal Power Flow Problem
Authors:
Sleiman Mhanna,
Gregor Verbic,
Archie Chapman
Abstract:
DC power flow approximations are ubiquitous in the electricity industry. However, these linear approximations fail to capture important physical aspects of power flow, such as the reactive power and voltage magnitude, which are crucial in many applications to ensure voltage stability and AC solution feasibility. This paper proposes two LP approximations of the AC optimal power flow problem, founde…
▽ More
DC power flow approximations are ubiquitous in the electricity industry. However, these linear approximations fail to capture important physical aspects of power flow, such as the reactive power and voltage magnitude, which are crucial in many applications to ensure voltage stability and AC solution feasibility. This paper proposes two LP approximations of the AC optimal power flow problem, founded on tight polyhedral approximations of the SOC constraints, in the aim of retaining the good lower bounds of the SOCP relaxation and relishing the computational efficiency of LP solvers. The high accuracy of the two LP approximations is corroborated by rigorous computational evaluations on systems with up to 9241 buses and different operating conditions. The computational efficiency of the two proposed LP models is shown to be comparable to, if not better than, that of the SOCP models in most instances. This performance is ideal for MILP extensions of these LP models since MILP is computationally more efficient than MIQCP.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2016; v1 submitted 1 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
A Fast Distributed Algorithm for Large-Scale Demand Response Aggregation
Authors:
Sleiman Mhanna,
Archie Chapman,
Gregor Verbic
Abstract:
A major challenge to implementing residential demand response is that of aligning the objectives of many households, each of which aims to minimize its payments and maximize its comfort level, while balancing this with the objectives of an aggregator that aims to minimize the cost of electricity purchased in a pooled wholesale market. This paper presents a fast distributed algorithm for aggregatin…
▽ More
A major challenge to implementing residential demand response is that of aligning the objectives of many households, each of which aims to minimize its payments and maximize its comfort level, while balancing this with the objectives of an aggregator that aims to minimize the cost of electricity purchased in a pooled wholesale market. This paper presents a fast distributed algorithm for aggregating a large number of households with a mixture of discrete and continuous energy levels. A distinctive feature of the method in this paper is that the nonconvex DR problem is decomposed in terms of households as opposed to devices, which allows incorporating more intricate couplings between energy storage devices, appliances and distributed energy resources. The proposed method is a fast distributed algorithm applied to the double smoothed dual function of the adopted DR model. The method is tested on systems with up to 2560 households, each with 10 devices on average. The proposed algorithm is designed to terminate in 60 iterations irrespective of system size, which can be ideal for an on-line version of this problem. Moreover, numerical results show that with minimal parameter tuning, the algorithm exhibits a very similar convergence behavior throughout the studied systems and converges to near-optimal solutions, which corroborates its scalability.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
