An Empirical Evaluation of Columnar Storage Formats
Authors:
Xinyu Zeng,
Yulong Hui,
Jiahong Shen,
Andrew Pavlo,
Wes McKinney,
Huanchen Zhang
Abstract:
Columnar storage is a core component of a modern data analytics system. Although many database management systems (DBMSs) have proprietary storage formats, most provide extensive support to open-source storage formats such as Parquet and ORC to facilitate cross-platform data sharing. But these formats were developed over a decade ago, in the early 2010s, for the Hadoop ecosystem. Since then, both…
▽ More
Columnar storage is a core component of a modern data analytics system. Although many database management systems (DBMSs) have proprietary storage formats, most provide extensive support to open-source storage formats such as Parquet and ORC to facilitate cross-platform data sharing. But these formats were developed over a decade ago, in the early 2010s, for the Hadoop ecosystem. Since then, both the hardware and workload landscapes have changed.
In this paper, we revisit the most widely adopted open-source columnar storage formats (Parquet and ORC) with a deep dive into their internals. We designed a benchmark to stress-test the formats' performance and space efficiency under different workload configurations. From our comprehensive evaluation of Parquet and ORC, we identify design decisions advantageous with modern hardware and real-world data distributions. These include using dictionary encoding by default, favoring decoding speed over compression ratio for integer encoding algorithms, making block compression optional, and embedding finer-grained auxiliary data structures. We also point out the inefficiencies in the format designs when handling common machine learning workloads and using GPUs for decoding. Our analysis identified important considerations that may guide future formats to better fit modern technology trends.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2023; v1 submitted 11 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
Mainlining Databases: Supporting Fast Transactional Workloads on Universal Columnar Data File Formats
Authors:
Tianyu Li,
Matthew Butrovich,
Amadou Ngom,
Wan Shen Lim,
Wes McKinney,
Andrew Pavlo
Abstract:
The proliferation of modern data processing tools has given rise to open-source columnar data formats. The advantage of these formats is that they help organizations avoid repeatedly converting data to a new format for each application. These formats, however, are read-only, and organizations must use a heavy-weight transformation process to load data from on-line transactional processing (OLTP) s…
▽ More
The proliferation of modern data processing tools has given rise to open-source columnar data formats. The advantage of these formats is that they help organizations avoid repeatedly converting data to a new format for each application. These formats, however, are read-only, and organizations must use a heavy-weight transformation process to load data from on-line transactional processing (OLTP) systems. We aim to reduce or even eliminate this process by develo** a storage architecture for in-memory database management systems (DBMSs) that is aware of the eventual usage of its data and emits columnar storage blocks in a universal open-source format. We introduce relaxations to common analytical data formats to efficiently update records and rely on a lightweight transformation process to convert blocks to a read-optimized layout when they are cold. We also describe how to access data from third-party analytical tools with minimal serialization overhead. To evaluate our work, we implemented our storage engine based on the Apache Arrow format and integrated it into the DB-X DBMS. Our experiments show that our approach achieves comparable performance with dedicated OLTP DBMSs while enabling orders-of-magnitude faster data exports to external data science and machine learning tools than existing methods.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
