Showing 1–10 of 10 results for author: Marron, A

On Augmenting Scenario-Based Modeling with Generative AI

Authors: David Harel, Guy Katz, Assaf Marron, Smadar Szekely

Abstract: The manual modeling of complex systems is a daunting task; and although a plethora of methods exist that mitigate this issue, the problem remains very difficult. Recent advances in generative AI have allowed the creation of general-purpose chatbots, capable of assisting software engineers in various modeling tasks. However, these chatbots are often inaccurate, and an unstructured use thereof could… ▽ More The manual modeling of complex systems is a daunting task; and although a plethora of methods exist that mitigate this issue, the problem remains very difficult. Recent advances in generative AI have allowed the creation of general-purpose chatbots, capable of assisting software engineers in various modeling tasks. However, these chatbots are often inaccurate, and an unstructured use thereof could result in erroneous system models. In this paper, we outline a method for the safer and more structured use of chatbots as part of the modeling process. To streamline this integration, we propose leveraging scenario-based modeling techniques, which are known to facilitate the automated analysis of models. We argue that through iterative invocations of the chatbot and the manual and automatic inspection of the resulting models, a more accurate system model can eventually be obtained. We describe favorable preliminary results, which highlight the potential of this approach. △ Less

Submitted 4 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: This is a preprint version of a paper that will appear at Modelsward 2024

MSC Class: 68N19

Toward Methodical Discovery and Handling of Hidden Assumptions in Complex Systems and Models

Authors: David Harel, Uwe Aßmann, Fabiana Fournier, Lior Limonad, Assaf Marron, Smadar Szekely

Abstract: Methodologies for development of complex systems and models include external reviews by domain and technology experts. Among others, such reviews can uncover undocumented built-in assumptions that may be critical for correct and safe operation or constrain applicability. Since such assumptions may still escape human-centered processes like reviews, agile development, and risk analyses, here, we co… ▽ More Methodologies for development of complex systems and models include external reviews by domain and technology experts. Among others, such reviews can uncover undocumented built-in assumptions that may be critical for correct and safe operation or constrain applicability. Since such assumptions may still escape human-centered processes like reviews, agile development, and risk analyses, here, we contribute toward making this process more methodical and automatable. We first present a blueprint for a taxonomy and formalization of the problem. We then show that a variety of digital artifacts of the system or model can be automatically checked against extensive reference knowledge. Since mimicking the breadth and depth of knowledge and skills of experts may appear unattainable, we illustrate the basic feasibility of automation with rudimentary experiments using OpenAI's ChatGPT. We believe that systematic handling of this aspect of system engineering can contribute significantly to the quality and safety of complex systems and models, and to the efficiency of development projects. We dedicate this work to Werner Damm, whose contributions to modeling and model-based development, in industry and academia, with a special focus on safety, helped establish a solid foundation to our discipline and to the work of many scientists and professionals, including, naturally, the approaches and techniques described here. △ Less

Submitted 27 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

The Human-or-Machine Matter: Turing-Inspired Reflections on an Everyday Issue

Authors: David Harel, Assaf Marron

Abstract: In his seminal paper ``Computing Machinery and Intelligence'', Alan Turing introduced the ``imitation game'' as part of exploring the concept of machine intelligence. The Turing Test has since been the subject of much analysis, debate, refinement and extension. Here we sidestep the question of whether a particular machine can be labeled intelligent, or can be said to match human capabilities in a… ▽ More In his seminal paper ``Computing Machinery and Intelligence'', Alan Turing introduced the ``imitation game'' as part of exploring the concept of machine intelligence. The Turing Test has since been the subject of much analysis, debate, refinement and extension. Here we sidestep the question of whether a particular machine can be labeled intelligent, or can be said to match human capabilities in a given context. Instead, we first draw attention to the seemingly simpler question a person may ask themselves in an everyday interaction: ``Am I interacting with a human or with a machine?''. We then shift the focus from seeking a method for eliciting the answer, and, rather, reflect upon the importance and significance of this Human-or-Machine question and the use one may make of a reliable answer thereto. Whereas Turing's original test is widely considered to be more of a thought experiment, the Human-or-Machine matter as discussed here has obvious practical relevance. While it is still unclear if and when machines will be able to mimic human behavior with high fidelity in everyday contexts, we argue that near-term exploration of the issues raised here can contribute to refinement of methods for develo** computerized systems, and may also lead to new insights into fundamental characteristics of human behavior. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2023; v1 submitted 7 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Evolution is Driven by Natural Autoencoding: Reframing Species, Interaction Codes, Cooperation, and Sexual Reproduction

Authors: Irun R. Cohen, Assaf Marron

Abstract: The continuity of life and its evolution, we proposed, emerge from an interactive group process manifested in networks of interaction. We term this process \textit{survival-of-the-fitted}. Here, we reason that survival of the fitted results from a natural computational process we term \textit{natural autoencoding}. Natural autoencoding works by retaining repeating biological interactions while non… ▽ More The continuity of life and its evolution, we proposed, emerge from an interactive group process manifested in networks of interaction. We term this process \textit{survival-of-the-fitted}. Here, we reason that survival of the fitted results from a natural computational process we term \textit{natural autoencoding}. Natural autoencoding works by retaining repeating biological interactions while non-repeatable interactions disappear. (1) We define a species by its \textit{species interaction code}, which consists of a compact description of the repeating interactions of species organisms with their external and internal environments. Species interaction codes are descriptions recorded in the biological infrastructure that enables repeating interactions. Encoding and decoding are interwoven. (2) Evolution proceeds by natural autoencoding of sustained changes in species interaction codes. DNA is only one element in natural autoencoding. (3) Natural autoencoding accounts for the paradox of genome randomization in sexual reproduction -- recombined genomes are analogous to the diversified inputs required for artificial autoencoding. The increase in entropy generated by genome randomization compensates for the decrease in entropy generated by organized life. (4) Natural autoencoding and artificial autoencoding algorithms manifest defined similarities and differences. Recognition of the importance of fittedness could well serve the future of a humanly livable biosphere. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 2023; v1 submitted 22 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: In version 7 we added various clarifications including to terminology, definitions, and to the reference to the second law of thermodynamics

Scenario-Assisted Deep Reinforcement Learning

Authors: Raz Yerushalmi, Guy Amir, Achiya Elyasaf, David Harel, Guy Katz, Assaf Marron

Abstract: Deep reinforcement learning has proven remarkably useful in training agents from unstructured data. However, the opacity of the produced agents makes it difficult to ensure that they adhere to various requirements posed by human engineers. In this work-in-progress report, we propose a technique for enhancing the reinforcement learning training process (specifically, its reward calculation), in a w… ▽ More Deep reinforcement learning has proven remarkably useful in training agents from unstructured data. However, the opacity of the produced agents makes it difficult to ensure that they adhere to various requirements posed by human engineers. In this work-in-progress report, we propose a technique for enhancing the reinforcement learning training process (specifically, its reward calculation), in a way that allows human engineers to directly contribute their expert knowledge, making the agent under training more likely to comply with various relevant constraints. Moreover, our proposed approach allows formulating these constraints using advanced model engineering techniques, such as scenario-based modeling. This mix of black-box learning-based tools with classical modeling approaches could produce systems that are effective and efficient, but are also more transparent and maintainable. We evaluated our technique using a case-study from the domain of internet congestion control, obtaining promising results. △ Less

Submitted 9 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Journal ref: In Proceedings of MODELSWARD 2022: the 10th International Conference on Model-Driven Engineering and Software Development, ISBN 978-989-758-550-0, ISSN 2184-4348, pages 310-319

Expecting the Unexpected: Develo** Autonomous-System Design Principles for Reacting to Unpredicted Events and Conditions

Authors: Assaf Marron, Lior Limonad, Sarah Pollack, David Harel

Abstract: When develo** autonomous systems, engineers and other stakeholders make great effort to prepare the system for all foreseeable events and conditions. However, these systems are still bound to encounter events and conditions that were not considered at design time. For reasons like safety, cost, or ethics, it is often highly desired that these new situations be handled correctly upon first encoun… ▽ More When develo** autonomous systems, engineers and other stakeholders make great effort to prepare the system for all foreseeable events and conditions. However, these systems are still bound to encounter events and conditions that were not considered at design time. For reasons like safety, cost, or ethics, it is often highly desired that these new situations be handled correctly upon first encounter. In this paper we first justify our position that there will always exist unpredicted events and conditions, driven among others by: new inventions in the real world; the diversity of world-wide system deployments and uses; and, the non-negligible probability that multiple seemingly unlikely events, which may be neglected at design time, will not only occur, but occur together. We then argue that despite this unpredictability property, handling these events and conditions is indeed possible. Hence, we offer and exemplify design principles that when applied in advance, can enable systems to deal, in the future, with unpredicted circumstances. We conclude with a discussion of how this work and a broader theoretical study of the unexpected can contribute toward a foundation of engineering principles for develo** trustworthy next-generation autonomous systems. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2020; v1 submitted 16 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Comments: 6 pages; 1 figure

Integrating Inter-Object Scenarios with Intra-object Statecharts for Develo** Reactive Systems

Authors: David Harel, Rami Marelly, Assaf Marron, Smadar Szekely

Abstract: In all software development projects, engineers face the challenge of translating the requirements layer into a design layer, then into an implementation-code layer, and then validating the correctness of the result. Many methodologies, languages and tools exist for facilitating the process, including multiple back-and-forth `refinement trips' across the requirements, design and implementation lay… ▽ More In all software development projects, engineers face the challenge of translating the requirements layer into a design layer, then into an implementation-code layer, and then validating the correctness of the result. Many methodologies, languages and tools exist for facilitating the process, including multiple back-and-forth `refinement trips' across the requirements, design and implementation layers, by focusing on formalizing the artifacts involved and on automating a variety of tasks throughout. In this paper, we introduce a novel and unique development environment, which integrates scenario-based programming (SBP) via the LSC language and the object-oriented, visual Statecharts formalism, for the development of reactive systems. LSC targets creation of models and systems directly from requirement specifications, and Statecharts is used mainly for specifying final component behavior. Our integration enables semantically-rich joint execution, with the sharing and interfacing of objects and events, and can be used for creating and then gradually enhancing testable models from early in requirements elicitation through detailed design. In some cases, it can be used for generating final system code. We describe the technical details of the integration and its semantics and discuss its significance for future development methodologies. △ Less

Submitted 7 October, 2020; v1 submitted 24 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Autonomics: In Search of a Foundation for Next Generation Autonomous Systems

Authors: David Harel, Assaf Marron, Joseph Sifakis

Abstract: The potential benefits of autonomous systems have been driving intensive development of such systems, and of supporting tools and methodologies. However, there are still major issues to be dealt with before such development becomes commonplace engineering practice, with accepted and trustworthy deliverables. We argue that a solid, evolving, publicly available, community-controlled foundation for d… ▽ More The potential benefits of autonomous systems have been driving intensive development of such systems, and of supporting tools and methodologies. However, there are still major issues to be dealt with before such development becomes commonplace engineering practice, with accepted and trustworthy deliverables. We argue that a solid, evolving, publicly available, community-controlled foundation for develo** next generation autonomous systems is a must. We discuss what is needed for such a foundation, identify a central aspect thereof, namely, decision-making, and focus on three main challenges: (i) how to specify autonomous system behavior and the associated decisions in the face of unpredictability of future events and conditions and the inadequacy of current languages for describing these; (ii) how to carry out faithful simulation and analysis of system behavior with respect to rich environments that include humans, physical artifacts, and other systems,; and (iii) how to engineer systems that combine executable model-driven techniques and data-driven machine learning techniques. We argue that autonomics, i.e., the study of unique challenges presented by next generation autonomous systems, and research towards resolving them, can introduce substantial contributions and innovations in system engineering and computer science. △ Less

Submitted 16 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

On-the-Fly Construction of Composite Events in Scenario-Based Modeling using Constraint Solvers

Authors: Guy Katz, Assaf Marron, Aviran Sadon, Gera Weiss

Abstract: Scenario-Based Programming is a methodology for modeling and constructing complex reactive systems from simple, stand-alone building blocks, called scenarios. These scenarios are designed to model different traits of the system, and can be interwoven together and executed to produce cohesive system behavior. Existing execution frameworks for scenario-based programs allow scenarios to specify their… ▽ More Scenario-Based Programming is a methodology for modeling and constructing complex reactive systems from simple, stand-alone building blocks, called scenarios. These scenarios are designed to model different traits of the system, and can be interwoven together and executed to produce cohesive system behavior. Existing execution frameworks for scenario-based programs allow scenarios to specify their view of what the system must, may, or must not do only through very strict interfaces. This limits the methodology's expressive power and often prevents users from modeling certain complex requirements. Here, we propose to extend Scenario-Based Programming's execution mechanism to allow scenarios to specify how the system should behave using rich logical constraints. We then leverage modern constraint solvers (such as SAT or SMT solvers) to resolve these constraints at every step of running the system, towards yielding the desired overall system behavior. We provide an implementation of our approach and demonstrate its applicability to various systems that could not be easily modeled in an executable manner by existing Scenario-Based approaches. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2020; v1 submitted 1 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: This is a preprint version of the paper that appeared at Modelsward 2019

Wise Computing: Towards Endowing System Development with True Wisdom

Authors: David Harel, Guy Katz, Rami Marelly, Assaf Marron

Abstract: Encouraged by significant advances in algorithms and tools for verification and analysis, high level modeling and programming techniques, natural language programming, etc., we feel it is time for a major change in the way complex software and systems are developed. We present a vision that will shift the power balance between human engineers and the development and runtime environments. The idea… ▽ More Encouraged by significant advances in algorithms and tools for verification and analysis, high level modeling and programming techniques, natural language programming, etc., we feel it is time for a major change in the way complex software and systems are developed. We present a vision that will shift the power balance between human engineers and the development and runtime environments. The idea is to endow the computer with human-like wisdom - not general wisdom, and not AI in the standard sense of the term - but wisdom geared towards classical system-building, which will be manifested, throughout development, in creativity and proactivity, and deep insights into the system's own structure and behavior, its overarching goals and rationale. Ideally, the computer will join the development team as an equal partner - knowledgeable, concerned, and responsibly active. We present a running demo of our initial efforts on the topic, illustrating on a small example what we feel is the feasibility of the ideas. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 2015; v1 submitted 23 January, 2015; originally announced January 2015.

ACM Class: D.2