-
Citation inequity and gendered citation practices in contemporary physics
Authors:
Erin G. Teich,
Jason Z. Kim,
Christopher W. Lynn,
Samantha C. Simon,
Andrei A. Klishin,
Karol P. Szymula,
Pragya Srivastava,
Lee C. Bassett,
Perry Zurn,
Jordan D. Dworkin,
Dani S. Bassett
Abstract:
The historical and contemporary under-attribution of women's contributions to scientific scholarship is well-known and well-studied, with effects that are felt today in myriad ways by women scientists. One measure of this under-attribution is the so-called citation gap between men and women: the under-citation of papers authored by women relative to expected rates coupled with a corresponding over…
▽ More
The historical and contemporary under-attribution of women's contributions to scientific scholarship is well-known and well-studied, with effects that are felt today in myriad ways by women scientists. One measure of this under-attribution is the so-called citation gap between men and women: the under-citation of papers authored by women relative to expected rates coupled with a corresponding over-citation of papers authored by men relative to expected rates. We explore the citation gap in contemporary physics, analyzing over one million articles published over the last 25 years in 35 physics journals that span a wide range of subfields. Using a model that predicts papers' expected citation rates according to a set of characteristics separate from author gender, we find a global bias wherein papers authored by women are significantly under-cited, and papers authored by men are significantly over-cited. Moreover, we find that citation behavior varies along several dimensions, such that imbalances differ according to who is citing, where they are citing, and how they are citing. Specifically, citation imbalance in favor of man-authored papers is highest for papers authored by men, papers published in general physics journals, and papers likely to be less familiar to citing authors. Our results suggest that, although deciding which papers to cite is an individual choice, the cumulative effects of these choices needlessly harm a subset of scholars. We discuss several strategies for the mitigation of these effects, including conscious behavioral changes at the individual, journal, and community levels.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Surges of collective human activity emerge from simple pairwise correlations
Authors:
Christopher W. Lynn,
Lia Papadopoulos,
Daniel D. Lee,
Danielle S. Bassett
Abstract:
Human populations exhibit complex behaviors---characterized by long-range correlations and surges in activity---across a range of social, political, and technological contexts. Yet it remains unclear where these collective behaviors come from, or if there even exists a set of unifying principles. Indeed, existing explanations typically rely on context-specific mechanisms, such as traffic jams driv…
▽ More
Human populations exhibit complex behaviors---characterized by long-range correlations and surges in activity---across a range of social, political, and technological contexts. Yet it remains unclear where these collective behaviors come from, or if there even exists a set of unifying principles. Indeed, existing explanations typically rely on context-specific mechanisms, such as traffic jams driven by work schedules or spikes in online traffic induced by significant events. However, analogies with statistical mechanics suggest a more general mechanism: that collective patterns can emerge organically from fine-scale interactions within a population. Here, across four different modes of human activity, we show that the simplest correlations in a population---those between pairs of individuals---can yield accurate quantitative predictions for the large-scale behavior of the entire population. To quantify the minimal consequences of pairwise correlations, we employ the principle of maximum entropy, making our description equivalent to an Ising model whose interactions and external fields are notably calculated from past observations of population activity. In addition to providing accurate quantitative predictions, we show that the topology of learned Ising interactions resembles the network of inter-human communication within a population. Together, these results demonstrate that fine-scale correlations can be used to predict large-scale social behaviors, a perspective that has critical implications for modeling and resource allocation in human populations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2019; v1 submitted 28 February, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Maximizing Activity in Ising Networks via the TAP Approximation
Authors:
Christopher W. Lynn,
Daniel D. Lee
Abstract:
A wide array of complex biological, social, and physical systems have recently been shown to be quantitatively described by Ising models, which lie at the intersection of statistical physics and machine learning. Here, we study the fundamental question of how to optimize the state of a networked Ising system given a budget of external influence. In the continuous setting where one can tune the inf…
▽ More
A wide array of complex biological, social, and physical systems have recently been shown to be quantitatively described by Ising models, which lie at the intersection of statistical physics and machine learning. Here, we study the fundamental question of how to optimize the state of a networked Ising system given a budget of external influence. In the continuous setting where one can tune the influence applied to each node, we propose a series of approximate gradient ascent algorithms based on the Plefka expansion, which generalizes the naïve mean field and TAP approximations. In the discrete setting where one chooses a small set of influential nodes, the problem is equivalent to the famous influence maximization problem in social networks with an additional stochastic noise term. In this case, we provide sufficient conditions for when the objective is submodular, allowing a greedy algorithm to achieve an approximation ratio of $1-1/e$. Additionally, we compare the Ising-based algorithms with traditional influence maximization algorithms, demonstrating the practical importance of accurately modeling stochastic fluctuations in the system.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2018; v1 submitted 28 February, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
