-
La ROUTOURNE va tourner
Authors:
Quentin Bramas,
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Pascal Mérindol
Abstract:
Segment routing (SR) offers precise control over the paths taken: it specifies a list of detours, called segments, in IP packets. However, the number of detours that can be specified is limited by the hardware. When calculating segment lists, it is therefore necessary to limit their size. Although solutions have been proposed for calculating these lists, they lack generality and are not always opt…
▽ More
Segment routing (SR) offers precise control over the paths taken: it specifies a list of detours, called segments, in IP packets. However, the number of detours that can be specified is limited by the hardware. When calculating segment lists, it is therefore necessary to limit their size. Although solutions have been proposed for calculating these lists, they lack generality and are not always optimal or efficient. We present ROUTOURNE, a method for diverting routing algorithms so that they calculate, not simply an optimal physical path to be translated into a list of segments a posteriori (with no guarantee of its size), but directly the optimal lists of segments deployable by the underlying hardware. ROUTOURNE thus facilitates the deployment of advanced traffic engineering strategies and policies, notably for load balancing from sources. Despite a route fraught with surprising challenges - in particular, the loss of isotonicity induced by SR - ROUTOURNE proves efficient, inducing at worst a linear overhead. Its accuracy and optimality have been proven, and its effectiveness evaluated by generalizing it to several more or less complex path calculation algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2024; v1 submitted 13 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
A Simple and General Operational Framework to Deploy Optimal Routes with Source Routing
Authors:
Quentin Bramas,
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Pascal Mérindol
Abstract:
Source Routing, currently facilitated by Segment Routing (SR), enables precise control of forwarding paths by specifying detours (or segments) to deviate IP packets along routes with advanced properties beyond typical shortest IGP paths. Computing the desired optimal segment lists, known as encoding, leads to interesting challenges as the number of detours is tightly constrained for hardware perfo…
▽ More
Source Routing, currently facilitated by Segment Routing (SR), enables precise control of forwarding paths by specifying detours (or segments) to deviate IP packets along routes with advanced properties beyond typical shortest IGP paths. Computing the desired optimal segment lists, known as encoding, leads to interesting challenges as the number of detours is tightly constrained for hardware performance. Existing solutions either lack generality, correctness, optimality, or practical computing efficiency-in particular for sparse realistic networks. In this paper, we address all such challenges with GOFOR-SR. Our framework extends usual path computation algorithms to inherently look at optimal and feasible segment lists, streamlining the deployment of TE-compliant paths. By integrating encoding within the path computation itself and modifying the distance comparison method, GOFOR allows algorithms with various optimization objectives to efficiently compute optimal segment lists. Despite the loss of substructure optimality induced by SR, GOFOR proves particularly efficient, inducing only a linear overhead at worst. It also offers different strategies and path diversity options for intricate TE-aware loadbalancing. We formally prove the correctness and optimality of GOFOR, implement our framework for various practical usecases, and demonstrate its performance and benefits on both real and challenging topologies.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Constrained Backward Time Travel Planning is in P
Authors:
Quentin Bramas,
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Sébastien Tixeuil
Abstract:
We consider transportation networks that are modeled by dynamic graphs, and introduce the possibility for traveling agents to use Backward Time-Travel (BTT) devices at any node to go back in time (to some extent, and with some appropriate fee) before resuming their trip. We focus on dynamic line graphs. In more detail, we propose exact algorithms to compute travel plans with constraints on the BTT…
▽ More
We consider transportation networks that are modeled by dynamic graphs, and introduce the possibility for traveling agents to use Backward Time-Travel (BTT) devices at any node to go back in time (to some extent, and with some appropriate fee) before resuming their trip. We focus on dynamic line graphs. In more detail, we propose exact algorithms to compute travel plans with constraints on the BTT cost or on how far back in time you can go, while minimizing travel delay (that is, the time difference between the arrival instant and the starting instant), in polynomial time. We study the impact of the BTT devices pricing policies on the computation process of those plans considering travel delay and cost, and provide necessary properties that pricing policies should satisfy to enable to compute such plans. Finally, we provide an optimal online algorithm for the unconstrained problem when the cost function is the identity.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2023; v1 submitted 4 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Deploying Near-Optimal Delay-Constrained Paths with Segment Routing in Massive-Scale Networks
Authors:
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Thomas Alfroy,
Pascal Mérindol,
Quentin Bramas,
François Clad,
Cristel Pelsser
Abstract:
With a growing demand for quasi-instantaneous communication services such as real-time video streaming, cloud gaming, and industry 4.0 applications, multi-constraint Traffic Engineering (TE) becomes increasingly important. While legacy TE management planes have proven laborious to deploy, Segment Routing (SR) drastically eases the deployment of TE paths and is thus increasingly adopted by Internet…
▽ More
With a growing demand for quasi-instantaneous communication services such as real-time video streaming, cloud gaming, and industry 4.0 applications, multi-constraint Traffic Engineering (TE) becomes increasingly important. While legacy TE management planes have proven laborious to deploy, Segment Routing (SR) drastically eases the deployment of TE paths and is thus increasingly adopted by Internet Service Providers (ISP). There is a clear need in computing and deploying Delay-Constrained Least-Cost paths (DCLC) with SR for real-time interactive services. However, most current DCLC solutions are not tailored for SR. They also often lack efficiency or guarantees. Similarly to approximation schemes, we argue that the challenge is to design an algorithm providing both performances and guarantees. However, conversely to most of these schemes, we also consider operational constraints to provide a practical, high-performance implementation.
We leverage the inherent limitations of delay measurements and account for the operational constraint added by SR to design a new algorithm, best2cop, providing guarantees and performance in all cases. Best2cop outperforms a state-of-the-art algorithm on both random and real networks of up to 1000 nodes. Relying on commodity hardware with a single thread, our algorithm retrieves all non-superfluous 3-dimensional routes in only 250ms and 100ms respectively. This execution time is further reduced using multiple threads, as the design of best2cop enables a speedup almost linear in the number of cores. Finally, we extend best2cop to deal with massive scale ISP by leveraging the multi-area partitioning of these deployments. Thanks to our new topology generator specifically designed to model the realistic patterns of such massive IP networks, we show that best2cop solves DCLC-SR in approximately 1 second even for ISP having more than 100000 routers.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2022; v1 submitted 18 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
A Fast-Convergence Routing of the Hot-Potato
Authors:
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Quentin Bramas,
Cristel Pelsser,
Pascal Mérindol
Abstract:
Interactions between the intra- and inter-domain routing protocols received little attention despite playing an important role in forwarding transit traffic. More precisely, by default, IGP distances are taken into account by BGP to select the closest exit gateway for the transit traffic (hot-potato routing). Upon an IGP update, the new best gateway may change and should be updated through the (fu…
▽ More
Interactions between the intra- and inter-domain routing protocols received little attention despite playing an important role in forwarding transit traffic. More precisely, by default, IGP distances are taken into account by BGP to select the closest exit gateway for the transit traffic (hot-potato routing). Upon an IGP update, the new best gateway may change and should be updated through the (full) re-convergence of BGP, causing superfluous BGP processing and updates in many cases. We propose OPTIC (Optimal Protection Technique for Inter-intra domain Convergence), an efficient way to assemble both protocols without losing the hot-potato property. OPTIC pre-computes sets of gateways (BGP next-hops) shared by groups of prefixes. Such sets are guaranteed to contain the post-convergence gateway after any single IGP event for the grouped prefixes. The new optimal exits can be found through a single walk-through of each set, allowing the transit traffic to benefit from optimal BGP routes almost as soon as the IGP converges. Compared to vanilla BGP, OPTIC's structures allow it to consider a reduced number of entries: this number can be reduced by 99\% for stub networks. The update of OPTIC's structures, which is not required as long as border routers remain at least bi-connected, scales linearly in time with its number of groups.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Computing Delay-Constrained Least-Cost Paths for Segment Routing is Easier Than You Think
Authors:
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Thomas Alfroy,
Pascal Mérindol,
Quentin Bramas,
François Clad,
Cristel Pelsser
Abstract:
With the growth of demands for quasi-instantaneous communication services such as real-time video streaming, cloud gaming, and industry 4.0 applications, multi-constraint Traffic Engineering (TE) becomes increasingly important. While legacy TE management planes have proven laborious to deploy, Segment Routing (SR) drastically eases the deployment of TE paths and thus became the most appropriate te…
▽ More
With the growth of demands for quasi-instantaneous communication services such as real-time video streaming, cloud gaming, and industry 4.0 applications, multi-constraint Traffic Engineering (TE) becomes increasingly important. While legacy TE management planes have proven laborious to deploy, Segment Routing (SR) drastically eases the deployment of TE paths and thus became the most appropriate technology for many operators. The flexibility of SR sparked demands in ways to compute more elaborate paths. In particular, there exists a clear need in computing and deploying Delay-Constrained Least-Cost paths (DCLC) for real-time applications requiring both low delay and high bandwidth routes. However, most current DCLC solutions are heuristics not specifically tailored for SR. In this work, we leverage both inherent limitations in the accuracy of delay measurements and an operational constraint added by SR. We include these characteristics in the design of BEST2COP, an exact but efficient ECMP-aware algorithm that natively solves DCLC in SR domains. Through an extensive performance evaluation, we first show that BEST2COP scales well even in large random networks. In real networks having up to thousands of destinations, our algorithm returns all DCLC solutions encoded as SR paths in way less than a second.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
TNT, Watch me Explode: A Light in the Dark for Revealing MPLS Tunnels
Authors:
Yves Vanaubel,
Jean-Romain Luttringer,
Pascal Mérindol,
Jean-Jacques Pansiot,
Benoit Donnet
Abstract:
Internet topology discovery has been a recurrent research topic for nearly 20 years now. Usually, it works by sending hop-limited probes (i.e., traceroute) towards a set of destinations to collect topological data in order to infer the Internet topology at a given scale (e.g., at the router or the AS level). However, traceroute comes with multiple limitations, in particular with layer-2 clouds suc…
▽ More
Internet topology discovery has been a recurrent research topic for nearly 20 years now. Usually, it works by sending hop-limited probes (i.e., traceroute) towards a set of destinations to collect topological data in order to infer the Internet topology at a given scale (e.g., at the router or the AS level). However, traceroute comes with multiple limitations, in particular with layer-2 clouds such as MPLS that might hide their content to traceroute exploration. Thus, the resulting Internet topology data and models are incomplete and inaccurate.
In this paper, we introduce TNT (Trace the Naughty Tunnels), an extension to Paris traceroute for revealing most (if not all) MPLS tunnels along a path. TNT works in two basic stages. First, along with traceroute probes, it looks for evidences of the potential presence of hidden tunnels. Those evidences are surprising patterns in the traceroute output, e.g., abrupt and significant TTL shifts. Second, if alarms are triggered due to the presence of such evidences, TNT launches additional and dedicated probing for possibly revealing the content of the hidden tunnel. We validate TNT through emulation with GNS3 and tune its parameters through a dedicated measurement campaign. We also largely deploy TNT on the Archipelago platform and provide a quantification of tunnels, updating so the state of the art vision of MPLS tunnels. Finally, TNT and its validation platform are fully and publicly available, as well as the collected data and scripts used for processing data.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2019; v1 submitted 29 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
