-
Counteracting Concept Drift by Learning with Future Malware Predictions
Authors:
Branislav Bosansky,
Lada Hospodkova,
Michal Najman,
Maria Rigaki,
Elnaz Babayeva,
Viliam Lisy
Abstract:
The accuracy of deployed malware-detection classifiers degrades over time due to changes in data distributions and increasing discrepancies between training and testing data. This phenomenon is known as the concept drift. While the concept drift can be caused by various reasons in general, new malicious files are created by malware authors with a clear intention of avoiding detection. The existenc…
▽ More
The accuracy of deployed malware-detection classifiers degrades over time due to changes in data distributions and increasing discrepancies between training and testing data. This phenomenon is known as the concept drift. While the concept drift can be caused by various reasons in general, new malicious files are created by malware authors with a clear intention of avoiding detection. The existence of the intention opens a possibility for predicting such future samples. Including predicted samples in training data should consequently increase the accuracy of the classifiers on new testing data.
We compare two methods for predicting future samples: (1) adversarial training and (2) generative adversarial networks (GANs). The first method explicitly seeks for adversarial examples against the classifier that are then used as a part of training data. Similarly, GANs also generate synthetic training data. We use GANs to learn changes in data distributions within different time periods of training data and then apply these changes to generate samples that could be in testing data. We compare these prediction methods on two different datasets: (1) Ember public dataset and (2) the internal dataset of files incoming to Avast. We show that while adversarial training yields more robust classifiers, this method is not a good predictor of future malware in general. This is in contrast with previously reported positive results in different domains (including natural language processing and spam detection). On the other hand, we show that GANs can be successfully used as predictors of future malware. We specifically examine malware families that exhibit significant changes in their data distributions over time and the experimental results confirm that GAN-based predictions can significantly improve the accuracy of the classifier on new, previously unseen data.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Look-ahead Search on Top of Policy Networks in Imperfect Information Games
Authors:
Ondrej Kubicek,
Neil Burch,
Viliam Lisy
Abstract:
Search in test time is often used to improve the performance of reinforcement learning algorithms. Performing theoretically sound search in fully adversarial two-player games with imperfect information is notoriously difficult and requires a complicated training process. We present a method for adding test-time search to an arbitrary policy-gradient algorithm that learns from sampled trajectories.…
▽ More
Search in test time is often used to improve the performance of reinforcement learning algorithms. Performing theoretically sound search in fully adversarial two-player games with imperfect information is notoriously difficult and requires a complicated training process. We present a method for adding test-time search to an arbitrary policy-gradient algorithm that learns from sampled trajectories. Besides the policy network, the algorithm trains an additional critic network, which estimates the expected values of players following various transformations of the policies given by the policy network. These values are then used for depth-limited search. We show how the values from this critic can create a value function for imperfect information games. Moreover, they can be used to compute the summary statistics necessary to start the search from an arbitrary decision point in the game. The presented algorithm is scalable to very large games since it does not require any search during train time. We evaluate the algorithm's performance when trained along Regularized Nash Dynamics, and we evaluate the benefit of using the search in the standard benchmark game of Leduc hold'em, multiple variants of imperfect information Goofspiel, and Battleships.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2024; v1 submitted 23 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Generation of Games for Opponent Model Differentiation
Authors:
David Milec,
Viliam Lisý,
Christopher Kiekintveld
Abstract:
Protecting against adversarial attacks is a common multiagent problem. Attackers in the real world are predominantly human actors, and the protection methods often incorporate opponent models to improve the performance when facing humans. Previous results show that modeling human behavior can significantly improve the performance of the algorithms. However, modeling humans correctly is a complex p…
▽ More
Protecting against adversarial attacks is a common multiagent problem. Attackers in the real world are predominantly human actors, and the protection methods often incorporate opponent models to improve the performance when facing humans. Previous results show that modeling human behavior can significantly improve the performance of the algorithms. However, modeling humans correctly is a complex problem, and the models are often simplified and assume humans make mistakes according to some distribution or train parameters for the whole population from which they sample. In this work, we use data gathered by psychologists who identified personality types that increase the likelihood of performing malicious acts. However, in the previous work, the tests on a handmade game could not show strategic differences between the models. We created a novel model that links its parameters to psychological traits. We optimized over parametrized games and created games in which the differences are profound. Our work can help with automatic game generation when we need a game in which some models will behave differently and to identify situations in which the models do not align.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
NASimEmu: Network Attack Simulator & Emulator for Training Agents Generalizing to Novel Scenarios
Authors:
Jaromír Janisch,
Tomáš Pevný,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
Current frameworks for training offensive penetration testing agents with deep reinforcement learning struggle to produce agents that perform well in real-world scenarios, due to the reality gap in simulation-based frameworks and the lack of scalability in emulation-based frameworks. Additionally, existing frameworks often use an unrealistic metric that measures the agents' performance on the trai…
▽ More
Current frameworks for training offensive penetration testing agents with deep reinforcement learning struggle to produce agents that perform well in real-world scenarios, due to the reality gap in simulation-based frameworks and the lack of scalability in emulation-based frameworks. Additionally, existing frameworks often use an unrealistic metric that measures the agents' performance on the training data. NASimEmu, a new framework introduced in this paper, addresses these issues by providing both a simulator and an emulator with a shared interface. This approach allows agents to be trained in simulation and deployed in the emulator, thus verifying the realism of the used abstraction. Our framework promotes the development of general agents that can transfer to novel scenarios unseen during their training. For the simulation part, we adopt an existing simulator NASim and enhance its realism. The emulator is implemented with industry-level tools, such as Vagrant, VirtualBox, and Metasploit. Experiments demonstrate that a simulation-trained agent can be deployed in emulation, and we show how to use the framework to train a general agent that transfers into novel, structurally different scenarios. NASimEmu is available as open-source.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2023; v1 submitted 26 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Avast-CTU Public CAPE Dataset
Authors:
Branislav Bosansky,
Dominik Kouba,
Ondrej Manhal,
Thorsten Sick,
Viliam Lisy,
Jakub Kroustek,
Petr Somol
Abstract:
There is a limited amount of publicly available data to support research in malware analysis technology. Particularly, there are virtually no publicly available datasets generated from rich sandboxes such as Cuckoo/CAPE. The benefit of using dynamic sandboxes is the realistic simulation of file execution in the target machine and obtaining a log of such execution. The machine can be infected by ma…
▽ More
There is a limited amount of publicly available data to support research in malware analysis technology. Particularly, there are virtually no publicly available datasets generated from rich sandboxes such as Cuckoo/CAPE. The benefit of using dynamic sandboxes is the realistic simulation of file execution in the target machine and obtaining a log of such execution. The machine can be infected by malware hence there is a good chance of capturing the malicious behavior in the execution logs, thus allowing researchers to study such behavior in detail. Although the subsequent analysis of log information is extensively covered in industrial cybersecurity backends, to our knowledge there has been only limited effort invested in academia to advance such log analysis capabilities using cutting edge techniques. We make this sample dataset available to support designing new machine learning methods for malware detection, especially for automatic detection of generic malicious behavior. The dataset has been collected in cooperation between Avast Software and Czech Technical University - AI Center (AIC).
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Explaining Classifiers Trained on Raw Hierarchical Multiple-Instance Data
Authors:
Tomáš Pevný,
Viliam Lisý,
Branislav Bošanský,
Petr Somol,
Michal Pěchouček
Abstract:
Learning from raw data input, thus limiting the need for feature engineering, is a component of many successful applications of machine learning methods in various domains. While many problems naturally translate into a vector representation directly usable in standard classifiers, a number of data sources have the natural form of structured data interchange formats (e.g., security logs in JSON/XM…
▽ More
Learning from raw data input, thus limiting the need for feature engineering, is a component of many successful applications of machine learning methods in various domains. While many problems naturally translate into a vector representation directly usable in standard classifiers, a number of data sources have the natural form of structured data interchange formats (e.g., security logs in JSON/XML format). Existing methods, such as in Hierarchical Multiple Instance Learning (HMIL), allow learning from such data in their raw form. However, the explanation of the classifiers trained on raw structured data remains largely unexplored. By treating these models as sub-set selections problems, we demonstrate how interpretable explanations, with favourable properties, can be generated using computationally efficient algorithms. We compare to an explanation technique adopted from graph neural networks showing an order of magnitude speed-up and higher-quality explanations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Continual Depth-limited Responses for Computing Counter-strategies in Sequential Games
Authors:
David Milec,
Ondřej Kubíček,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
In zero-sum games, the optimal strategy is well-defined by the Nash equilibrium. However, it is overly conservative when playing against suboptimal opponents and it can not exploit their weaknesses. Limited look-ahead game solving in imperfect-information games allows defeating human experts in massive real-world games such as Poker, Liar's Dice, and Scotland Yard. However, since they approximate…
▽ More
In zero-sum games, the optimal strategy is well-defined by the Nash equilibrium. However, it is overly conservative when playing against suboptimal opponents and it can not exploit their weaknesses. Limited look-ahead game solving in imperfect-information games allows defeating human experts in massive real-world games such as Poker, Liar's Dice, and Scotland Yard. However, since they approximate Nash equilibrium, they tend to only win slightly against weak opponents. We propose methods combining limited look-ahead solving with an opponent model in order to 1) approximate a best response in large games or 2) compute a robust response with control over the robustness of the response. Both methods can compute the response in real time to previously unseen strategies. We present theoretical guarantees of our methods. We show that existing robust response methods do not work combined with limited look-ahead solving of the shelf, and we propose a novel solution for the issue. Our algorithm performs significantly better than multiple baselines in smaller games and outperforms state-of-the-art methods against SlumBot.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2024; v1 submitted 23 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Revisiting Game Representations: The Hidden Costs of Efficiency in Sequential Decision-making Algorithms
Authors:
Vojtěch Kovařík,
David Milec,
Michal Šustr,
Dominik Seitz,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
Recent advancements in algorithms for sequential decision-making under imperfect information have shown remarkable success in large games such as limit- and no-limit poker. These algorithms traditionally formalize the games using the extensive-form game formalism, which, as we show, while theoretically sound, is memory-inefficient and computationally intensive in practice. To mitigate these challe…
▽ More
Recent advancements in algorithms for sequential decision-making under imperfect information have shown remarkable success in large games such as limit- and no-limit poker. These algorithms traditionally formalize the games using the extensive-form game formalism, which, as we show, while theoretically sound, is memory-inefficient and computationally intensive in practice. To mitigate these challenges, a popular workaround involves using a specialized representation based on player specific information-state trees. However, as we show, this alternative significantly narrows the set of games that can be represented efficiently.
In this study, we identify the set of large games on which modern algorithms have been benchmarked as being naturally represented by Sequential Bayesian Games. We elucidate the critical differences between extensive-form game and sequential Bayesian game representations, both theoretically and empirically. We further argue that the impressive experimental results often cited in the literature may be skewed, as they frequently stem from testing these algorithms only on this restricted class of games. By understanding these nuances, we aim to guide future research in develo** more universally applicable and efficient algorithms for sequential decision-making under imperfect information.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023; v1 submitted 20 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Improving Robustness of Malware Classifiers using Adversarial Strings Generated from Perturbed Latent Representations
Authors:
Marek Galovic,
Branislav Bosansky,
Viliam Lisy
Abstract:
In malware behavioral analysis, the list of accessed and created files very often indicates whether the examined file is malicious or benign. However, malware authors are trying to avoid detection by generating random filenames and/or modifying used filenames with new versions of the malware. These changes represent real-world adversarial examples. The goal of this work is to generate realistic ad…
▽ More
In malware behavioral analysis, the list of accessed and created files very often indicates whether the examined file is malicious or benign. However, malware authors are trying to avoid detection by generating random filenames and/or modifying used filenames with new versions of the malware. These changes represent real-world adversarial examples. The goal of this work is to generate realistic adversarial examples and improve the classifier's robustness against these attacks. Our approach learns latent representations of input strings in an unsupervised fashion and uses gradient-based adversarial attack methods in the latent domain to generate adversarial examples in the input domain. We use these examples to improve the classifier's robustness by training on the generated adversarial set of strings. Compared to classifiers trained only on perturbed latent vectors, our approach produces classifiers that are significantly more robust without a large trade-off in standard accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Mill.jl and JsonGrinder.jl: automated differentiable feature extraction for learning from raw JSON data
Authors:
Simon Mandlik,
Matej Racinsky,
Viliam Lisy,
Tomas Pevny
Abstract:
Learning from raw data input, thus limiting the need for manual feature engineering, is one of the key components of many successful applications of machine learning methods. While machine learning problems are often formulated on data that naturally translate into a vector representation suitable for classifiers, there are data sources, for example in cybersecurity, that are naturally represented…
▽ More
Learning from raw data input, thus limiting the need for manual feature engineering, is one of the key components of many successful applications of machine learning methods. While machine learning problems are often formulated on data that naturally translate into a vector representation suitable for classifiers, there are data sources, for example in cybersecurity, that are naturally represented in diverse files with a unifying hierarchical structure, such as XML, JSON, and Protocol Buffers. Converting this data to vector (tensor) representation is generally done by manual feature engineering, which is laborious, lossy, and prone to human bias about the importance of particular features.
Mill and JsonGrinder is a tandem of libraries, which fully automates the conversion. Starting with an arbitrary set of JSON samples, they create a differentiable machine learning model capable of infer from further JSON samples in their raw form.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning in OpenSpiel: A Reproduction Report
Authors:
Michael Walton,
Viliam Lisy
Abstract:
In this report, we present results reproductions for several core algorithms implemented in the OpenSpiel framework for learning in games. The primary contribution of this work is a validation of OpenSpiel's re-implemented search and Reinforcement Learning algorithms against the results reported in their respective originating works. Additionally, we provide complete documentation of hyperparamete…
▽ More
In this report, we present results reproductions for several core algorithms implemented in the OpenSpiel framework for learning in games. The primary contribution of this work is a validation of OpenSpiel's re-implemented search and Reinforcement Learning algorithms against the results reported in their respective originating works. Additionally, we provide complete documentation of hyperparameters and source code required to reproduce these experiments easily and exactly.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2021; v1 submitted 27 February, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Complexity and Algorithms for Exploiting Quantal Opponents in Large Two-Player Games
Authors:
David Milec,
Jakub Černý,
Viliam Lisý,
Bo An
Abstract:
Solution concepts of traditional game theory assume entirely rational players; therefore, their ability to exploit subrational opponents is limited. One type of subrationality that describes human behavior well is the quantal response. While there exist algorithms for computing solutions against quantal opponents, they either do not scale or may provide strategies that are even worse than the enti…
▽ More
Solution concepts of traditional game theory assume entirely rational players; therefore, their ability to exploit subrational opponents is limited. One type of subrationality that describes human behavior well is the quantal response. While there exist algorithms for computing solutions against quantal opponents, they either do not scale or may provide strategies that are even worse than the entirely-rational Nash strategies. This paper aims to analyze and propose scalable algorithms for computing effective and robust strategies against a quantal opponent in normal-form and extensive-form games. Our contributions are: (1) we define two different solution concepts related to exploiting quantal opponents and analyze their properties; (2) we prove that computing these solutions is computationally hard; (3) therefore, we evaluate several heuristic approximations based on scalable counterfactual regret minimization (CFR); and (4) we identify a CFR variant that exploits the bounded opponents better than the previously used variants while being less exploitable by the worst-case perfectly-rational opponent.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2020; v1 submitted 30 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Symbolic Relational Deep Reinforcement Learning based on Graph Neural Networks and Autoregressive Policy Decomposition
Authors:
Jaromír Janisch,
Tomáš Pevný,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
We focus on reinforcement learning (RL) in relational problems that are naturally defined in terms of objects, their relations, and object-centric actions. These problems are characterized by variable state and action spaces, and finding a fixed-length representation, required by most existing RL methods, is difficult, if not impossible. We present a deep RL framework based on graph neural network…
▽ More
We focus on reinforcement learning (RL) in relational problems that are naturally defined in terms of objects, their relations, and object-centric actions. These problems are characterized by variable state and action spaces, and finding a fixed-length representation, required by most existing RL methods, is difficult, if not impossible. We present a deep RL framework based on graph neural networks and auto-regressive policy decomposition that naturally works with these problems and is completely domain-independent. We demonstrate the framework's broad applicability in three distinct domains and show impressive zero-shot generalization over different problem sizes.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2023; v1 submitted 25 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Discovering Imperfectly Observable Adversarial Actions using Anomaly Detection
Authors:
Olga Petrova,
Karel Durkota,
Galina Alperovich,
Karel Horak,
Michal Najman,
Branislav Bosansky,
Viliam Lisy
Abstract:
Anomaly detection is a method for discovering unusual and suspicious behavior. In many real-world scenarios, the examined events can be directly linked to the actions of an adversary, such as attacks on computer networks or frauds in financial operations. While the defender wants to discover such malicious behavior, the attacker seeks to accomplish their goal (e.g., exfiltrating data) while avoidi…
▽ More
Anomaly detection is a method for discovering unusual and suspicious behavior. In many real-world scenarios, the examined events can be directly linked to the actions of an adversary, such as attacks on computer networks or frauds in financial operations. While the defender wants to discover such malicious behavior, the attacker seeks to accomplish their goal (e.g., exfiltrating data) while avoiding the detection. To this end, anomaly detectors have been used in a game-theoretic framework that captures these goals of a two-player competition. We extend the existing models to more realistic settings by (1) allowing both players to have continuous action spaces and by assuming that (2) the defender cannot perfectly observe the action of the attacker. We propose two algorithms for solving such games -- a direct extension of existing algorithms based on discretizing the feature space and linear programming and the second algorithm based on constrained learning. Experiments show that both algorithms are applicable for cases with low feature space dimensions but the learning-based method produces less exploitable strategies and it is scalable to higher dimensions. Moreover, we use real-world data to compare our approaches with existing classifiers in a data-exfiltration scenario via the DNS channel. The results show that our models are significantly less exploitable by an informed attacker.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Classification with Costly Features in Hierarchical Deep Sets
Authors:
Jaromír Janisch,
Tomáš Pevný,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
Classification with Costly Features (CwCF) is a classification problem that includes the cost of features in the optimization criteria. Individually for each sample, its features are sequentially acquired to maximize accuracy while minimizing the acquired features' cost. However, existing approaches can only process data that can be expressed as vectors of fixed length. In real life, the data ofte…
▽ More
Classification with Costly Features (CwCF) is a classification problem that includes the cost of features in the optimization criteria. Individually for each sample, its features are sequentially acquired to maximize accuracy while minimizing the acquired features' cost. However, existing approaches can only process data that can be expressed as vectors of fixed length. In real life, the data often possesses rich and complex structure, which can be more precisely described with formats such as XML or JSON. The data is hierarchical and often contains nested lists of objects. In this work, we extend an existing deep reinforcement learning-based algorithm with hierarchical deep sets and hierarchical softmax, so that it can directly process this data. The extended method has greater control over which features it can acquire and, in experiments with seven datasets, we show that this leads to superior performance. To showcase the real usage of the new method, we apply it to a real-life problem of classifying malicious web domains, using an online service.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024; v1 submitted 20 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Classification with Costly Features as a Sequential Decision-Making Problem
Authors:
Jaromír Janisch,
Tomáš Pevný,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
This work focuses on a specific classification problem, where the information about a sample is not readily available, but has to be acquired for a cost, and there is a per-sample budget. Inspired by real-world use-cases, we analyze average and hard variations of a directly specified budget. We postulate the problem in its explicit formulation and then convert it into an equivalent MDP, that can b…
▽ More
This work focuses on a specific classification problem, where the information about a sample is not readily available, but has to be acquired for a cost, and there is a per-sample budget. Inspired by real-world use-cases, we analyze average and hard variations of a directly specified budget. We postulate the problem in its explicit formulation and then convert it into an equivalent MDP, that can be solved with deep reinforcement learning. Also, we evaluate a real-world inspired setting with sparse training dataset with missing features. The presented method performs robustly well in all settings across several distinct datasets, outperforming other prior-art algorithms. The method is flexible, as showcased with all mentioned modifications and can be improved with any domain independent advancement in RL.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Rethinking Formal Models of Partially Observable Multiagent Decision Making
Authors:
Vojtěch Kovařík,
Martin Schmid,
Neil Burch,
Michael Bowling,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
Multiagent decision-making in partially observable environments is usually modelled as either an extensive-form game (EFG) in game theory or a partially observable stochastic game (POSG) in multiagent reinforcement learning (MARL). One issue with the current situation is that while most practical problems can be modelled in both formalisms, the relationship of the two models is unclear, which hind…
▽ More
Multiagent decision-making in partially observable environments is usually modelled as either an extensive-form game (EFG) in game theory or a partially observable stochastic game (POSG) in multiagent reinforcement learning (MARL). One issue with the current situation is that while most practical problems can be modelled in both formalisms, the relationship of the two models is unclear, which hinders the transfer of ideas between the two communities. A second issue is that while EFGs have recently seen significant algorithmic progress, their classical formalization is unsuitable for efficient presentation of the underlying ideas, such as those around decomposition.
To solve the first issue, we introduce factored-observation stochastic games (FOSGs), a minor modification of the POSG formalism which distinguishes between private and public observation and thereby greatly simplifies decomposition. To remedy the second issue, we show that FOSGs and POSGs are naturally connected to EFGs: by "unrolling" a FOSG into its tree form, we obtain an EFG. Conversely, any perfect-recall timeable EFG corresponds to some underlying FOSG in this manner. Moreover, this relationship justifies several minor modifications to the classical EFG formalization that recently appeared as an implicit response to the model's issues with decomposition. Finally, we illustrate the transfer of ideas between EFGs and MARL by presenting three key EFG techniques -- counterfactual regret minimization, sequence form, and decomposition -- in the FOSG framework.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2021; v1 submitted 26 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Value Functions for Depth-Limited Solving in Zero-Sum Imperfect-Information Games
Authors:
Vojtěch Kovařík,
Dominik Seitz,
Viliam Lisý,
Jan Rudolf,
Shuo Sun,
Karel Ha
Abstract:
We provide a formal definition of depth-limited games together with an accessible and rigorous explanation of the underlying concepts, both of which were previously missing in imperfect-information games. The definition works for an arbitrary extensive-form game and is not tied to any specific game-solving algorithm. Moreover, this framework unifies and significantly extends three approaches to de…
▽ More
We provide a formal definition of depth-limited games together with an accessible and rigorous explanation of the underlying concepts, both of which were previously missing in imperfect-information games. The definition works for an arbitrary extensive-form game and is not tied to any specific game-solving algorithm. Moreover, this framework unifies and significantly extends three approaches to depth-limited solving that previously existed in extensive-form games and multiagent reinforcement learning but were not known to be compatible. A key ingredient of these depth-limited games are value functions. Focusing on two-player zero-sum imperfect-information games, we show how to obtain optimal value functions and prove that public information provides both necessary and sufficient context for computing them. We provide a domain-independent encoding of the domains that allows for approximating value functions even by simple feed-forward neural networks, which are then able to generalize to unseen parts of the game. We use the resulting value network to implement a depth-limited version of counterfactual regret minimization. In three distinct domains, we show that the algorithm's exploitability is roughly linearly dependent on the value network's quality and that it is not difficult to train a value network with which depth-limited CFR's performance is as good as that of CFR with access to the full game.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2022; v1 submitted 31 May, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Problems with the EFG formalism: a solution attempt using observations
Authors:
Vojtěch Kovařík,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
We argue that the extensive-form game (EFG) model isn't powerful enough to express all important aspects of imperfect information games, such as those related to decomposition and online game solving. We present a principled attempt to fix the formalism by considering information partitions that correspond to observations. We show that EFGs cannot be "fixed" without additional knowledge about the…
▽ More
We argue that the extensive-form game (EFG) model isn't powerful enough to express all important aspects of imperfect information games, such as those related to decomposition and online game solving. We present a principled attempt to fix the formalism by considering information partitions that correspond to observations. We show that EFGs cannot be "fixed" without additional knowledge about the original task, and show how to extend the EFG model under this assumption. However, during our investigation, we ultimately concluded that a better solution is to abandon EFGs entirely and instead adopt a model based on partially observable stochastic games. The primary contribution of the text thus lies in exposing the problems with EFGs and presenting a detailed study on introducing imperfect information by adding observations into an underlying perfect-information model.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Monte Carlo Continual Resolving for Online Strategy Computation in Imperfect Information Games
Authors:
Michal Sustr,
Vojtech Kovarik,
Viliam Lisy
Abstract:
Online game playing algorithms produce high-quality strategies with a fraction of memory and computation required by their offline alternatives. Continual Resolving (CR) is a recent theoretically sound approach to online game playing that has been used to outperform human professionals in poker. However, parts of the algorithm were specific to poker, which enjoys many properties not shared by othe…
▽ More
Online game playing algorithms produce high-quality strategies with a fraction of memory and computation required by their offline alternatives. Continual Resolving (CR) is a recent theoretically sound approach to online game playing that has been used to outperform human professionals in poker. However, parts of the algorithm were specific to poker, which enjoys many properties not shared by other imperfect information games. We present a domain-independent formulation of CR applicable to any two-player zero-sum extensive-form games that works with an abstract resolving algorithm. We further describe and implement its Monte Carlo variant (MCCR) which uses Monte Carlo Counterfactual Regret Minimization (MCCFR) as a resolver. We prove the correctness of CR and show an $O(T^{-1/2})$-dependence of MCCR's exploitability on the computation time. Furthermore, we present an empirical comparison of MCCR with incremental tree building to Online Outcome Sampling and Information-set MCTS on several domains.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2019; v1 submitted 18 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Analysis of Hannan Consistent Selection for Monte Carlo Tree Search in Simultaneous Move Games
Authors:
Vojtěch Kovařík,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
Hannan consistency, or no external regret, is a~key concept for learning in games. An action selection algorithm is Hannan consistent (HC) if its performance is eventually as good as selecting the~best fixed action in hindsight. If both players in a~zero-sum normal form game use a~Hannan consistent algorithm, their average behavior converges to a~Nash equilibrium (NE) of the~game. A similar result…
▽ More
Hannan consistency, or no external regret, is a~key concept for learning in games. An action selection algorithm is Hannan consistent (HC) if its performance is eventually as good as selecting the~best fixed action in hindsight. If both players in a~zero-sum normal form game use a~Hannan consistent algorithm, their average behavior converges to a~Nash equilibrium (NE) of the~game. A similar result is known about extensive form games, but the~played strategies need to be Hannan consistent with respect to the~counterfactual values, which are often difficult to obtain. We study zero-sum extensive form games with simultaneous moves, but otherwise perfect information. These games generalize normal form games and they are a special case of extensive form games. We study whether applying HC algorithms in each decision point of these games directly to the~observed payoffs leads to convergence to a~Nash equilibrium. This learning process corresponds to a~class of Monte Carlo Tree Search algorithms, which are popular for playing simultaneous-move games but do not have any known performance guarantees. We show that using HC algorithms directly on the~observed payoffs is not sufficient to guarantee the~convergence. With an~additional averaging over joint actions, the~convergence is guaranteed, but empirically slower. We further define an~additional property of HC algorithms, which is sufficient to guarantee the~convergence without the~averaging and we empirically show that commonly used HC algorithms have this property.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2019; v1 submitted 23 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Automated Construction of Bounded-Loss Imperfect-Recall Abstractions in Extensive-Form Games
Authors:
Jiri Cermak,
Viliam Lisy,
Branislav Bosansky
Abstract:
Extensive-form games (EFGs) model finite sequential interactions between players. The amount of memory required to represent these games is the main bottleneck of algorithms for computing optimal strategies and the size of these strategies is often impractical for real-world applications. A common approach to tackle the memory bottleneck is to use information abstraction that removes parts of info…
▽ More
Extensive-form games (EFGs) model finite sequential interactions between players. The amount of memory required to represent these games is the main bottleneck of algorithms for computing optimal strategies and the size of these strategies is often impractical for real-world applications. A common approach to tackle the memory bottleneck is to use information abstraction that removes parts of information available to players thus reducing the number of decision points in the game. However, existing information-abstraction techniques are either specific for a particular domain, they do not provide any quality guarantees, or they are applicable to very small subclasses of EFGs. We present domain-independent abstraction methods for creating imperfect recall abstractions in extensive-form games that allow computing strategies that are (near) optimal in the original game. To this end, we introduce two novel algorithms, FPIRA and CFR+IRA, based on fictitious play and counterfactual regret minimization. These algorithms can start with an arbitrary domain specific, or the coarsest possible, abstraction of the original game. The algorithms iteratively detect the missing information they require for computing a strategy for the abstract game that is (near) optimal in the original game. This information is then included back into the abstract game. Moreover, our algorithms are able to exploit imperfect-recall abstractions that allow players to forget even history of their own actions. However, the algorithms require traversing the complete unabstracted game tree. We experimentally show that our algorithms can closely approximate Nash equilibrium of large games using abstraction with as little as 0.9% of information sets of the original game. Moreover, the results suggest that memory savings increase with the increasing size of the original games.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2020; v1 submitted 14 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Classification with Costly Features using Deep Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Jaromír Janisch,
Tomáš Pevný,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
We study a classification problem where each feature can be acquired for a cost and the goal is to optimize a trade-off between the expected classification error and the feature cost. We revisit a former approach that has framed the problem as a sequential decision-making problem and solved it by Q-learning with a linear approximation, where individual actions are either requests for feature value…
▽ More
We study a classification problem where each feature can be acquired for a cost and the goal is to optimize a trade-off between the expected classification error and the feature cost. We revisit a former approach that has framed the problem as a sequential decision-making problem and solved it by Q-learning with a linear approximation, where individual actions are either requests for feature values or terminate the episode by providing a classification decision. On a set of eight problems, we demonstrate that by replacing the linear approximation with neural networks the approach becomes comparable to the state-of-the-art algorithms developed specifically for this problem. The approach is flexible, as it can be improved with any new reinforcement learning enhancement, it allows inclusion of pre-trained high-performance classifier, and unlike prior art, its performance is robust across all evaluated datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2018; v1 submitted 20 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
DeepStack: Expert-Level Artificial Intelligence in No-Limit Poker
Authors:
Matej Moravčík,
Martin Schmid,
Neil Burch,
Viliam Lisý,
Dustin Morrill,
Nolan Bard,
Trevor Davis,
Kevin Waugh,
Michael Johanson,
Michael Bowling
Abstract:
Artificial intelligence has seen several breakthroughs in recent years, with games often serving as milestones. A common feature of these games is that players have perfect information. Poker is the quintessential game of imperfect information, and a longstanding challenge problem in artificial intelligence. We introduce DeepStack, an algorithm for imperfect information settings. It combines recur…
▽ More
Artificial intelligence has seen several breakthroughs in recent years, with games often serving as milestones. A common feature of these games is that players have perfect information. Poker is the quintessential game of imperfect information, and a longstanding challenge problem in artificial intelligence. We introduce DeepStack, an algorithm for imperfect information settings. It combines recursive reasoning to handle information asymmetry, decomposition to focus computation on the relevant decision, and a form of intuition that is automatically learned from self-play using deep learning. In a study involving 44,000 hands of poker, DeepStack defeated with statistical significance professional poker players in heads-up no-limit Texas hold'em. The approach is theoretically sound and is shown to produce more difficult to exploit strategies than prior approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2017; v1 submitted 6 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Equilibrium Approximation Quality of Current No-Limit Poker Bots
Authors:
Viliam Lisy,
Michael Bowling
Abstract:
Approximating a Nash equilibrium is currently the best performing approach for creating poker-playing programs. While for the simplest variants of the game, it is possible to evaluate the quality of the approximation by computing the value of the best response strategy, this is currently not computationally feasible for larger variants of the game, such as heads-up no-limit Texas hold'em. In this…
▽ More
Approximating a Nash equilibrium is currently the best performing approach for creating poker-playing programs. While for the simplest variants of the game, it is possible to evaluate the quality of the approximation by computing the value of the best response strategy, this is currently not computationally feasible for larger variants of the game, such as heads-up no-limit Texas hold'em. In this paper, we present a simple and computationally inexpensive Local Best Response method for computing an approximate lower bound on the value of the best response strategy. Using this method, we show that existing poker-playing programs, based on solving abstract games, are remarkably poor Nash equilibrium approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2017; v1 submitted 22 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Analysis of Hannan Consistent Selection for Monte Carlo Tree Search in Simultaneous Move Games
Authors:
Vojtěch Kovařík,
Viliam Lisý
Abstract:
Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) has recently been successfully used to create strategies for playing imperfect-information games. Despite its popularity, there are no theoretic results that guarantee its convergence to a well-defined solution, such as Nash equilibrium, in these games. We partially fill this gap by analysing MCTS in the class of zero-sum extensive-form games with simultaneous moves…
▽ More
Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) has recently been successfully used to create strategies for playing imperfect-information games. Despite its popularity, there are no theoretic results that guarantee its convergence to a well-defined solution, such as Nash equilibrium, in these games. We partially fill this gap by analysing MCTS in the class of zero-sum extensive-form games with simultaneous moves but otherwise perfect information. The lack of information about the opponent's concurrent moves already causes that optimal strategies may require randomization. We present theoretic as well as empirical investigation of the speed and quality of convergence of these algorithms to the Nash equilibria. Primarily, we show that after minor technical modifications, MCTS based on any (approximately) Hannan consistent selection function always converges to an (approximate) subgame perfect Nash equilibrium. Without these modifications, Hannan consistency is not sufficient to ensure such convergence and the selection function must satisfy additional properties, which empirically hold for the most common Hannan consistent algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Convergence of Monte Carlo Tree Search in Simultaneous Move Games
Authors:
Viliam Lisý,
Vojtěch Kovařík,
Marc Lanctot,
Branislav Bošanský
Abstract:
We study Monte Carlo tree search (MCTS) in zero-sum extensive-form games with perfect information and simultaneous moves. We present a general template of MCTS algorithms for these games, which can be instantiated by various selection methods. We formally prove that if a selection method is $ε$-Hannan consistent in a matrix game and satisfies additional requirements on exploration, then the MCTS a…
▽ More
We study Monte Carlo tree search (MCTS) in zero-sum extensive-form games with perfect information and simultaneous moves. We present a general template of MCTS algorithms for these games, which can be instantiated by various selection methods. We formally prove that if a selection method is $ε$-Hannan consistent in a matrix game and satisfies additional requirements on exploration, then the MCTS algorithm eventually converges to an approximate Nash equilibrium (NE) of the extensive-form game. We empirically evaluate this claim using regret matching and Exp3 as the selection methods on randomly generated games and empirically selected worst case games. We confirm the formal result and show that additional MCTS variants also converge to approximate NE on the evaluated games.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2013; v1 submitted 31 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
