-
New Classes of Distributed Time Complexity
Authors:
Alkida Balliu,
Juho Hirvonen,
Janne H. Korhonen,
Tuomo Lempiäinen,
Dennis Olivetti,
Jukka Suomela
Abstract:
A number of recent papers -- e.g. Brandt et al. (STOC 2016), Chang et al. (FOCS 2016), Ghaffari & Su (SODA 2017), Brandt et al. (PODC 2017), and Chang & Pettie (FOCS 2017) -- have advanced our understanding of one of the most fundamental questions in theory of distributed computing: what are the possible time complexity classes of LCL problems in the LOCAL model? In essence, we have a graph proble…
▽ More
A number of recent papers -- e.g. Brandt et al. (STOC 2016), Chang et al. (FOCS 2016), Ghaffari & Su (SODA 2017), Brandt et al. (PODC 2017), and Chang & Pettie (FOCS 2017) -- have advanced our understanding of one of the most fundamental questions in theory of distributed computing: what are the possible time complexity classes of LCL problems in the LOCAL model? In essence, we have a graph problem $Π$ in which a solution can be verified by checking all radius-$O(1)$ neighbourhoods, and the question is what is the smallest $T$ such that a solution can be computed so that each node chooses its own output based on its radius-$T$ neighbourhood. Here $T$ is the distributed time complexity of $Π$.
The time complexity classes for deterministic algorithms in bounded-degree graphs that are known to exist by prior work are $Θ(1)$, $Θ(\log^* n)$, $Θ(\log n)$, $Θ(n^{1/k})$, and $Θ(n)$. It is also known that there are two gaps: one between $ω(1)$ and $o(\log \log^* n)$, and another between $ω(\log^* n)$ and $o(\log n)$. It has been conjectured that many more gaps exist, and that the overall time hierarchy is relatively simple -- indeed, this is known to be the case in restricted graph families such as cycles and grids.
We show that the picture is much more diverse than previously expected. We present a general technique for engineering LCL problems with numerous different deterministic time complexities, including $Θ(\log^αn)$ for any $α\ge1$, $2^{Θ(\log^αn)}$ for any $α\le 1$, and $Θ(n^α)$ for any $α<1/2$ in the high end of the complexity spectrum, and $Θ(\log^α\log^* n)$ for any $α\ge 1$, $\smash{2^{Θ(\log^α\log^* n)}}$ for any $α\le 1$, and $Θ((\log^* n)^α)$ for any $α\le 1$ in the low end; here $α$ is a positive rational number.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2018; v1 submitted 6 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Constant Space and Non-Constant Time in Distributed Computing
Authors:
Tuomo Lempiäinen,
Jukka Suomela
Abstract:
While the relationship of time and space is an established topic in traditional centralised complexity theory, this is not the case in distributed computing. We aim to remedy this by studying the time and space complexity of algorithms in a weak message-passing model of distributed computing. While a constant number of communication rounds implies a constant number of states visited during the exe…
▽ More
While the relationship of time and space is an established topic in traditional centralised complexity theory, this is not the case in distributed computing. We aim to remedy this by studying the time and space complexity of algorithms in a weak message-passing model of distributed computing. While a constant number of communication rounds implies a constant number of states visited during the execution, the other direction is not clear at all. We consider several graph families and show that indeed, there exist non-trivial graph problems that are solvable by constant-space algorithms but that require a non-constant running time. This provides us with a new complexity class for distributed computing and raises interesting questions about the existence of further combinations of time and space complexity.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
LCL problems on grids
Authors:
Sebastian Brandt,
Juho Hirvonen,
Janne H. Korhonen,
Tuomo Lempiäinen,
Patric R. J. Östergård,
Christopher Purcell,
Joel Rybicki,
Jukka Suomela,
Przemysław Uznański
Abstract:
LCLs or locally checkable labelling problems (e.g. maximal independent set, maximal matching, and vertex colouring) in the LOCAL model of computation are very well-understood in cycles (toroidal 1-dimensional grids): every problem has a complexity of $O(1)$, $Θ(\log^* n)$, or $Θ(n)$, and the design of optimal algorithms can be fully automated.
This work develops the complexity theory of LCL prob…
▽ More
LCLs or locally checkable labelling problems (e.g. maximal independent set, maximal matching, and vertex colouring) in the LOCAL model of computation are very well-understood in cycles (toroidal 1-dimensional grids): every problem has a complexity of $O(1)$, $Θ(\log^* n)$, or $Θ(n)$, and the design of optimal algorithms can be fully automated.
This work develops the complexity theory of LCL problems for toroidal 2-dimensional grids. The complexity classes are the same as in the 1-dimensional case: $O(1)$, $Θ(\log^* n)$, and $Θ(n)$. However, given an LCL problem it is undecidable whether its complexity is $Θ(\log^* n)$ or $Θ(n)$ in 2-dimensional grids.
Nevertheless, if we correctly guess that the complexity of a problem is $Θ(\log^* n)$, we can completely automate the design of optimal algorithms. For any problem we can find an algorithm that is of a normal form $A' \circ S_k$, where $A'$ is a finite function, $S_k$ is an algorithm for finding a maximal independent set in $k$th power of the grid, and $k$ is a constant.
Finally, partially with the help of automated design tools, we classify the complexity of several concrete LCL problems related to colourings and orientations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2017; v1 submitted 17 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
A Lower Bound for the Distributed Lovász Local Lemma
Authors:
Sebastian Brandt,
Orr Fischer,
Juho Hirvonen,
Barbara Keller,
Tuomo Lempiäinen,
Joel Rybicki,
Jukka Suomela,
Jara Uitto
Abstract:
We show that any randomised Monte Carlo distributed algorithm for the Lovász local lemma requires $Ω(\log \log n)$ communication rounds, assuming that it finds a correct assignment with high probability. Our result holds even in the special case of $d = O(1)$, where $d$ is the maximum degree of the dependency graph. By prior work, there are distributed algorithms for the Lovász local lemma with a…
▽ More
We show that any randomised Monte Carlo distributed algorithm for the Lovász local lemma requires $Ω(\log \log n)$ communication rounds, assuming that it finds a correct assignment with high probability. Our result holds even in the special case of $d = O(1)$, where $d$ is the maximum degree of the dependency graph. By prior work, there are distributed algorithms for the Lovász local lemma with a running time of $O(\log n)$ rounds in bounded-degree graphs, and the best lower bound before our work was $Ω(\log^* n)$ rounds [Chung et al. 2014].
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Ability to Count Is Worth $Θ(Δ)$ Rounds
Authors:
Tuomo Lempiäinen
Abstract:
Hella et al. (PODC 2012, Distributed Computing 2015) identified seven different models of distributed computing - one of which is the port-numbering model - and provided a complete classification of their computational power relative to each other. However, one of their simulation results involves an additive overhead of $2Δ-2$ communication rounds, and it was not clear, if this is actually optima…
▽ More
Hella et al. (PODC 2012, Distributed Computing 2015) identified seven different models of distributed computing - one of which is the port-numbering model - and provided a complete classification of their computational power relative to each other. However, one of their simulation results involves an additive overhead of $2Δ-2$ communication rounds, and it was not clear, if this is actually optimal. In this paper we give a positive answer: there is a matching linear-in-$Δ$ lower bound. This closes the final gap in our understanding of the models, with respect to the number of communication rounds.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Search Methods for Tile Sets in Patterned DNA Self-Assembly
Authors:
Mika Göös,
Tuomo Lempiäinen,
Eugen Czeizler,
Pekka Orponen
Abstract:
The Pattern self-Assembly Tile set Synthesis (PATS) problem, which arises in the theory of structured DNA self-assembly, is to determine a set of coloured tiles that, starting from a bordering seed structure, self-assembles to a given rectangular colour pattern. The task of finding minimum-size tile sets is known to be NP-hard. We explore several complete and incomplete search techniques for findi…
▽ More
The Pattern self-Assembly Tile set Synthesis (PATS) problem, which arises in the theory of structured DNA self-assembly, is to determine a set of coloured tiles that, starting from a bordering seed structure, self-assembles to a given rectangular colour pattern. The task of finding minimum-size tile sets is known to be NP-hard. We explore several complete and incomplete search techniques for finding minimal, or at least small, tile sets and also assess the reliability of the solutions obtained according to the kinetic Tile Assembly Model.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Weak Models of Distributed Computing, with Connections to Modal Logic
Authors:
Lauri Hella,
Matti Järvisalo,
Antti Kuusisto,
Juhana Laurinharju,
Tuomo Lempiäinen,
Kerkko Luosto,
Jukka Suomela,
Jonni Virtema
Abstract:
This work presents a classification of weak models of distributed computing. We focus on deterministic distributed algorithms, and study models of computing that are weaker versions of the widely-studied port-numbering model. In the port-numbering model, a node of degree d receives messages through d input ports and sends messages through d output ports, both numbered with 1,2,...,d. In this work,…
▽ More
This work presents a classification of weak models of distributed computing. We focus on deterministic distributed algorithms, and study models of computing that are weaker versions of the widely-studied port-numbering model. In the port-numbering model, a node of degree d receives messages through d input ports and sends messages through d output ports, both numbered with 1,2,...,d. In this work, VVc is the class of all graph problems that can be solved in the standard port-numbering model. We study the following subclasses of VVc:
VV: Input port i and output port i are not necessarily connected to the same neighbour.
MV: Input ports are not numbered; algorithms receive a multiset of messages.
SV: Input ports are not numbered; algorithms receive a set of messages.
VB: Output ports are not numbered; algorithms send the same message to all output ports.
MB: Combination of MV and VB.
SB: Combination of SV and VB.
Now we have many trivial containment relations, such as SB \subseteq MB \subseteq VB \subseteq VV \subseteq VVc, but it is not obvious if, for example, either of VB \subseteq SV or SV \subseteq VB should hold. Nevertheless, it turns out that we can identify a linear order on these classes. We prove that SB \subsetneq MB = VB \subsetneq SV = MV = VV \subsetneq VVc. The same holds for the constant-time versions of these classes.
We also show that the constant-time variants of these classes can be characterised by a corresponding modal logic. Hence the linear order identified in this work has direct implications in the study of the expressibility of modal logic. Conversely, one can use tools from modal logic to study these classes.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2013; v1 submitted 9 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
