-
Topology optimization of fluidic pressure-driven multi-material compliant mechanisms
Authors:
Prabhat Kumar,
Josh Pinskier,
David Howard,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
Compliant mechanisms actuated by pneumatic loads are receiving increasing attention due to their direct applicability as soft robots that perform tasks using their flexible bodies. Using multiple materials to build them can further improve their performance and efficiency. Due to developments in additive manufacturing, the fabrication of multi-material soft robots is becoming a real possibility. T…
▽ More
Compliant mechanisms actuated by pneumatic loads are receiving increasing attention due to their direct applicability as soft robots that perform tasks using their flexible bodies. Using multiple materials to build them can further improve their performance and efficiency. Due to developments in additive manufacturing, the fabrication of multi-material soft robots is becoming a real possibility. To exploit this opportunity, there is a need for a dedicated design approach. This paper offers a systematic approach to develo** such mechanisms using topology optimization. The extended SIMP scheme is employed for multi-material modeling. The design-dependent nature of the pressure load is modeled using the Darcy law with a volumetric drainage term. Flow coefficient of each element is interpolated using a smoothed Heaviside function. The obtained pressure field is converted to consistent nodal loads. The adjoint-variable approach is employed to determine the sensitivities. A robust formulation is employed, wherein a min-max optimization problem is formulated using the output displacements of the eroded and blueprint designs. Volume constraints are applied to the blueprint design, whereas the strain energy constraint is formulated with respect to the eroded design. The efficacy and success of the approach are demonstrated by designing pneumatically actuated multi-material gripper and contractor mechanisms. A numerical study confirms that multiple-material mechanisms perform relatively better than their single-material counterparts.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Automated design of pneumatic soft grippers through design-dependent multi-material topology optimization
Authors:
Josh Pinskier,
Prabhat Kumar,
Matthijs Langelaar,
David Howard
Abstract:
Soft robotic gras** has rapidly spread through the academic robotics community in recent years and pushed into industrial applications. At the same time, multimaterial 3D printing has become widely available, enabling the monolithic manufacture of devices containing rigid and elastic sections. We propose a novel design technique that leverages both technologies and can automatically design bespo…
▽ More
Soft robotic gras** has rapidly spread through the academic robotics community in recent years and pushed into industrial applications. At the same time, multimaterial 3D printing has become widely available, enabling the monolithic manufacture of devices containing rigid and elastic sections. We propose a novel design technique that leverages both technologies and can automatically design bespoke soft robotic grippers for fruit-picking and similar applications. We demonstrate the novel topology optimisation formulation that generates multi-material soft grippers, can solve internal and external pressure boundaries, and investigate methods to produce air-tight designs. Compared to existing methods, it vastly expands the searchable design space while increasing simulation accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2023; v1 submitted 24 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Efficient computation of states and sensitivities for compound structural optimisation problems using a Linear Dependency Aware Solver (LDAS)
Authors:
Stijn Koppen,
Max van der Kolk,
Sanne van den Boom,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
Real-world structural optimisation problems involve multiple loading conditions and design constraints, with responses typically depending on states of discretised governing equations. Generally, one uses gradient-based nested analysis and design approaches to solve these problems. Herein, solving both physical and adjoint problems dominates the overall computational effort. Although not commonly…
▽ More
Real-world structural optimisation problems involve multiple loading conditions and design constraints, with responses typically depending on states of discretised governing equations. Generally, one uses gradient-based nested analysis and design approaches to solve these problems. Herein, solving both physical and adjoint problems dominates the overall computational effort. Although not commonly detected, real-world problems can contain linear dependencies between encountered physical and adjoint loads. Manually kee** track of such dependencies becomes tedious as design problems become increasingly involved. To detect and exploit such dependencies, this work proposes the use of a Linear Dependency Aware Solver (LDAS), which is able to efficiently detect linear dependencies between all loads to avoid unnecessary solves entirely and automatically. Illustrative examples are provided that demonstrate the need and benefits of using an LDAS, including a run-time experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
A simple and versatile topology optimization formulation for flexure synthesis
Authors:
Stijn Koppen,
Matthijs Langelaar,
Fred van Keulen
Abstract:
High-tech equipment critically relies on flexures for precise manipulation and measurement. Through elastic deformation, flexures offer extreme position repeatability within a limited range of motion in their degrees of freedom, while constraining motion in the degrees of constraint. Topology optimization proves a prospective tool for the design of short-stroke flexures, providing maximum design f…
▽ More
High-tech equipment critically relies on flexures for precise manipulation and measurement. Through elastic deformation, flexures offer extreme position repeatability within a limited range of motion in their degrees of freedom, while constraining motion in the degrees of constraint. Topology optimization proves a prospective tool for the design of short-stroke flexures, providing maximum design freedom and allowing for application-specific requirements. State-of-the-art topology optimization formulations for flexure synthesis are subject to challenges like ease of use, versatility, implementation complexity, and computational cost, leaving a generally accepted formulation absent. This study proposes a novel topology optimization formulation for the synthesis of short-stroke flexures uniquely based on strain energy measures under prescribed displacement scenarios. The resulting self-adjoint optimization problem resembles great similarity to classic compliance minimization and inherits similar implementation simplicity, computational efficiency, and convergence properties. Numerical examples demonstrate the versatility in flexure types and the extendability of additional design requirements. The provided source code encourages the formulation to be explored and applied in academia and industry.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Efficient multi-partition topology optimization
Authors:
Stijn Koppen,
Matthijs Langelaar,
Fred van Keulen
Abstract:
In topology optimization, the state of structures is typically obtained by numerically evaluating a discretized PDE-based model. The degrees of freedom of such a model can be partitioned in free and prescribed sets to define the boundary conditions. A multi-partition problem involves multiple partitions of the same discretization, typically corresponding to different loading scenarios. As a result…
▽ More
In topology optimization, the state of structures is typically obtained by numerically evaluating a discretized PDE-based model. The degrees of freedom of such a model can be partitioned in free and prescribed sets to define the boundary conditions. A multi-partition problem involves multiple partitions of the same discretization, typically corresponding to different loading scenarios. As a result, solving multi-partition problems involves multiple factorization/preconditionings of the system matrix, requiring a high computational effort. In this paper, a novel method is proposed to efficiently calculate the responses and accompanying design sensitivities in such multi-partition problems using static condensation for use in gradient-based topology optimization. A main problem class that benefits from the proposed method is the topology optimization of small-displacement multi-input-multi-output compliant mechanisms. However, the method is applicable to any linear problem. We present its formulation and an algorithmic complexity analysis to estimate computational advantages for both direct and iterative solution methods to solve the system of equations, verified by numerical experiments. It is demonstrated that substantial gains are achievable for large-scale multi-partition problems. This is especially true for problems with both a small set of number of degrees of freedom that fully describes the performance of the structure and with large similarities between the different partitions. A major contribution to the gain is the lack of large adjoint analyses required to obtain the sensitivities of the performance measure.
△ Less
Submitted 8 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Topological synthesis of fluidic pressure-actuated robust compliant mechanisms
Authors:
Prabhat Kumar,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
This paper presents a robust density-based topology optimization approach for synthesizing pressure-actuated compliant mechanisms. To ensure functionality under manufacturing inaccuracies, the robust or three-field formulation is employed, involving dilated, intermediate and eroded realizations of the design. Darcy's law in conjunction with a conceptualized drainage term is used to model the press…
▽ More
This paper presents a robust density-based topology optimization approach for synthesizing pressure-actuated compliant mechanisms. To ensure functionality under manufacturing inaccuracies, the robust or three-field formulation is employed, involving dilated, intermediate and eroded realizations of the design. Darcy's law in conjunction with a conceptualized drainage term is used to model the pressure load as a function of the design vector. The consistent nodal loads are evaluated from the obtained pressure field using the standard finite element method. The objective and load sensitivities are obtained using the adjoint-variable approach. A multi-criteria objective involving both the stiffness and flexibility of the mechanism is employed in the robust formulation, and min-max optimization problems are solved to obtain pressure-actuated inverter, gripper, and contractor compliant mechanisms with different minimum feature sizes. Limitations of the linear elasticity assumptions while designing mechanisms are identified with high pressure loads. Challenges involved in designing finite deformable pressure-actuated compliant mechanisms are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2023; v1 submitted 8 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Topology Optimization for Large-Scale Additive Manufacturing: Generating designs tailored to the deposition nozzle size
Authors:
Eduardo Fernández,
Can Ayas,
Matthijs Langelaar,
Pierre Duysinx
Abstract:
Additive Manufacturing (AM) processes intended for large scale components deposit large volumes of material to shorten process duration. This reduces the resolution of the AM process, which is typically defined by the size of the deposition nozzle. If the resolution limitation is not considered when designing for Large-Scale Additive Manufacturing (LSAM), difficulties can arise in the manufacturin…
▽ More
Additive Manufacturing (AM) processes intended for large scale components deposit large volumes of material to shorten process duration. This reduces the resolution of the AM process, which is typically defined by the size of the deposition nozzle. If the resolution limitation is not considered when designing for Large-Scale Additive Manufacturing (LSAM), difficulties can arise in the manufacturing process, which may require the adaptation of the deposition parameters. This work incorporates the nozzle size constraint into Topology Optimization (TO) in order to generate optimized designs suitable to the process resolution. This article proposes and compares two methods, which are based on existing TO techniques that enable control of minimum and maximum member size, and of minimum cavity size. The first method requires the minimum and maximum member size to be equal to the deposition nozzle size, thus design features of uniform width are obtained in the optimized design. The second method defines the size of the solid members sufficiently small for the resulting structure to resemble a structural skeleton, which can be interpreted as the deposition path. Through filtering and projection techniques, the thin structures are thickened according to the chosen nozzle size. Thus, a topology tailored to the size of the deposition nozzle is obtained along with a deposition proposal. The methods are demonstrated and assessed using 2D and 3D benchmark problems.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
On topology optimization of design-dependent pressure-loaded three-dimensional structures and compliant mechanisms
Authors:
Prabhat Kumar,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
This paper presents a density-based topology optimization method for designing three-dimensional (3D) compliant mechanisms and loadbearing structures with design-dependent pressure loading. Instead of interface-tracking techniques, the Darcy law in conjunction with a drainage term is employed to obtain pressure field as a function of the design vector. To ensure continuous transition of pressure l…
▽ More
This paper presents a density-based topology optimization method for designing three-dimensional (3D) compliant mechanisms and loadbearing structures with design-dependent pressure loading. Instead of interface-tracking techniques, the Darcy law in conjunction with a drainage term is employed to obtain pressure field as a function of the design vector. To ensure continuous transition of pressure loads as the design evolves, the flow coefficient of a finite element is defined using a smooth Heaviside function. The obtained pressure field is converted into consistent nodal loads using a transformation matrix. The presented approach employs the standard finite element formulation and also, allows consistent and computationally inexpensive calculation of load sensitivities using the adjoint-variable method. For compliant mechanism design, a multi-criteria objective is minimized, whereas minimization of compliance is performed for designing loadbearing structures. Efficacy and robustness of the presented approach is demonstrated by designing various pressure-actuated 3D compliant mechanisms and structures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2021; v1 submitted 12 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Automated and Accurate Geometry Extraction and Shape Optimization of 3D Topology Optimization Results
Authors:
Marco K. Swierstra,
Deepak K. Gupta,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
Designs generated by density-based topology optimization (TO) exhibit jagged and/or smeared boundaries, which forms an obstacle to their integration with existing CAD tools. Addressing this problem by smoothing or manual design adjustments is time-consuming and affects the optimality of TO designs. This paper proposes a fully automated procedure to obtain unambiguous, accurate and optimized geomet…
▽ More
Designs generated by density-based topology optimization (TO) exhibit jagged and/or smeared boundaries, which forms an obstacle to their integration with existing CAD tools. Addressing this problem by smoothing or manual design adjustments is time-consuming and affects the optimality of TO designs. This paper proposes a fully automated procedure to obtain unambiguous, accurate and optimized geometries from arbitrary 3D TO results. It consists of a geometry extraction stage using a level-set-based design description involving radial basis functions, followed by a shape optimization stage involving local analysis refinements near the structural boundary using the Finite Cell Method. Well-defined bounds on basis function weights ensure that sufficient sensitivity information is available throughout the shape optimization process. Our approach results in highly smooth and accurate optimized geometries, and its effectiveness is illustrated by 2D and 3D examples.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Topology Optimization of Fluidic Pressure Loaded Structures and Compliant Mechanisms using the Darcy Method
Authors:
Prabhat Kumar,
Jan S. Frouws,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
In various applications, design problems involving structures and compliant mechanisms experience fluidic pressure loads. During topology optimization of such design problems, these loads adapt their direction and location with the evolution of the design, which poses various challenges. A new density-based topology optimization approach using Darcy's law in conjunction with a drainage term is pre…
▽ More
In various applications, design problems involving structures and compliant mechanisms experience fluidic pressure loads. During topology optimization of such design problems, these loads adapt their direction and location with the evolution of the design, which poses various challenges. A new density-based topology optimization approach using Darcy's law in conjunction with a drainage term is presented to provide a continuous and consistent treatment of design-dependent fluidic pressure loads. The porosity of each finite element and its drainage term are related to its density variable using a Heaviside function, yielding a smooth transition between the solid and void phases. A design-dependent pressure field is established using Darcy's law and the associated PDE is solved using the finite element method. Further, the obtained pressure field is used to determine the consistent nodal loads. The approach provides a computationally inexpensive evaluation of load sensitivities using the adjoint-variable method. To show the efficacy and robustness of the proposed method, numerical examples related to fluidic pressure loaded stiff structures and small-deformation compliant mechanisms are solved. For the structures, compliance is minimized, whereas for the mechanisms a multi-criteria objective is minimized with given resource constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2020; v1 submitted 7 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Compliant Fluidic Control Structures: Concept and Synthesis Approach
Authors:
Prabhat Kumar,
Paola Fanzio,
Luigi Sasso,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
The concept and synthesis approach for planar Compliant Fluidic Control Structures (CFCSs), monolithic flexible continua with embedded functional pores, is presented in this manuscript. Such structures are envisioned to find application in biomedicine as tunable microuidic devices for drug/nutrient delivery. The functional pores enlarge and/or contract upondeformation of the compliant structure in…
▽ More
The concept and synthesis approach for planar Compliant Fluidic Control Structures (CFCSs), monolithic flexible continua with embedded functional pores, is presented in this manuscript. Such structures are envisioned to find application in biomedicine as tunable microuidic devices for drug/nutrient delivery. The functional pores enlarge and/or contract upondeformation of the compliant structure in response to external stimuli, facilitating the regulated control of fluid/nutrient/drug transport. A thickness design variable based topology optimization problem is formulated to generate effective designs of these structures. An objective based on hydraulic diameter(s) is conceptualized, and it is extremized using a gradient based optimizer. Both geometrical and material nonlinearities are considered. The nonlinear behaviour of employed hyperelastic material is modeled via the Arruda-Boyce constitutive material model. Large-displacement finite element analysis is performed using the updated Lagrangian formulation in plane-stress setting. The proposed synthesis approach is applied to various CFCSs for a variety of fluidic control functionalities. The optimized designs of various CFCSs with single and/or multiple functional pores are fabricated via a Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) soft lithography process, using a high precision 3D printed mold and their performances are compared. with the numerical predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2019; v1 submitted 28 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Design and analysis adaptivity in multi-resolution topology optimization
Authors:
Deepak K. Gupta,
Fred van Keulen,
Matthijs Langelaar
Abstract:
Multiresolution topology optimization (MTO) methods involve decoupling of the design and analysis discretizations, such that a high-resolution design can be obtained at relatively low analysis costs. Recent studies have shown that the MTO method can be approximately 3 and 30 times faster than the traditional topology optimization method for 2D and 3D problems, respectively. To further exploit the…
▽ More
Multiresolution topology optimization (MTO) methods involve decoupling of the design and analysis discretizations, such that a high-resolution design can be obtained at relatively low analysis costs. Recent studies have shown that the MTO method can be approximately 3 and 30 times faster than the traditional topology optimization method for 2D and 3D problems, respectively. To further exploit the potential of decoupling analysis and design, we propose a dp-adaptive MTO method, which involves locally increasing/decreasing the shape function orders (p) and design resolution (d). The adaptive refinement/coarsening is performed using a composite refinement indicator which includes criteria based on analysis error, presence of intermediate densities as well as the occurrence of design artefacts referred to as QR-patterns. While standard MTO must rely on filtering to suppress QR-patterns, the proposed adaptive method ensures efficiently that these artefacts are suppressed in the final design, without sacrificing the design resolution. The applicability of the dp-adaptive MTO method is demonstrated on several 2D mechanical design problems. For all the cases, significant speed-ups in computational time are obtained. In particular for design problems involving low material volume fractions, speed-ups of up to a factor of 10 can be obtained over the conventional MTO method.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
