-
Half-checking propagators
Authors:
Mikael Zayenz Lagerkvist,
Magnus Rattfeldt
Abstract:
Propagators are central to the success of constraint programming, that is contracting functions removing values proven not to be in any solution of a given constraint. The literature contains numerous propagation algorithms, for many different constraints, and common to all these propagation algorithms is the notion of correctness: only values that appear in no solution to the respective constrain…
▽ More
Propagators are central to the success of constraint programming, that is contracting functions removing values proven not to be in any solution of a given constraint. The literature contains numerous propagation algorithms, for many different constraints, and common to all these propagation algorithms is the notion of correctness: only values that appear in no solution to the respective constraint may be removed. In this paper half-checking propagators are introduced, for which the only requirements are that identified solutions (by the propagators) are actual solutions (to the corresponding constraints), and that the propagators are contracting. In particular, a half-checking propagator may remove solutions resulting in an incomplete solving process, but with the upside that (good) solutions may be found faster. Overall completeness can be obtained by running half-checking propagators as one component in a portfolio solving process. Half-checking propagators opens up a wider variety of techniques to be used when designing propagation algorithms, compared to what is currently available.
A formal model for half-checking propagators is introduced, together with a detailed description of how to support such propagators in a constraint programming system. Three general directions for creating half-checking propagation algorithms are introduced, and used for designing new half-checking propagators for the cost-circuit constraint as examples. The new propagators are implemented in the Gecode system.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Nmbr9 as a Constraint Programming Challenge
Authors:
Mikael Zayenz Lagerkvist
Abstract:
Modern board games are a rich source of interesting and new challenges for combinatorial problems. The game Nmbr9 is a solitaire style puzzle game using polyominoes. The rules of the game are simple to explain, but modelling the game effectively using constraint programming is hard. This abstract presents the game, contributes new generalized variants of the game suitable for benchmarking and test…
▽ More
Modern board games are a rich source of interesting and new challenges for combinatorial problems. The game Nmbr9 is a solitaire style puzzle game using polyominoes. The rules of the game are simple to explain, but modelling the game effectively using constraint programming is hard. This abstract presents the game, contributes new generalized variants of the game suitable for benchmarking and testing, and describes a model for the presented variants. The question of the top possible score in the standard game is an open challenge.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
State Representation and Polyomino Placement for the Game Patchwork
Authors:
Mikael Zayenz Lagerkvist
Abstract:
Modern board games are a rich source of entertainment for many people, but also contain interesting and challenging structures for game playing research and implementing game playing agents. This paper studies the game Patchwork, a two player strategy game using polyomino tile drafting and placement. The core polyomino placement mechanic is implemented in a constraint model using regular constrain…
▽ More
Modern board games are a rich source of entertainment for many people, but also contain interesting and challenging structures for game playing research and implementing game playing agents. This paper studies the game Patchwork, a two player strategy game using polyomino tile drafting and placement. The core polyomino placement mechanic is implemented in a constraint model using regular constraints, extending and improving the model in (Lagerkvist, Pesant, 2008) with: explicit rotation handling; optional placements; and new constraints for resource usage. Crucial for implementing good game playing agents is to have great heuristics for guiding the search when faced with large branching factors. This paper divides placing tiles into two parts: a policy used for placing parts and an evaluation used to select among different placements. Policies are designed based on classical packing literature as well as common standard constraint programming heuristics. For evaluation, global propagation guided regret is introduced, choosing placements based on not ruling out later placements. Extensive evaluations are performed, showing the importance of using a good evaluation and that the proposed global propagation guided regret is a very effective guide.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Monte Carlo Methods for the Game Kingdomino
Authors:
Magnus Gedda,
Mikael Z. Lagerkvist,
Martin Butler
Abstract:
Kingdomino is introduced as an interesting game for studying game playing: the game is multiplayer (4 independent players per game); it has a limited game depth (13 moves per player); and it has limited but not insignificant interaction among players.
Several strategies based on locally greedy players, Monte Carlo Evaluation (MCE), and Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) are presented with variants.…
▽ More
Kingdomino is introduced as an interesting game for studying game playing: the game is multiplayer (4 independent players per game); it has a limited game depth (13 moves per player); and it has limited but not insignificant interaction among players.
Several strategies based on locally greedy players, Monte Carlo Evaluation (MCE), and Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) are presented with variants. We examine a variation of UCT called progressive win bias and a playout policy (Player-greedy) focused on selecting good moves for the player. A thorough evaluation is done showing how the strategies perform and how to choose parameters given specific time constraints. The evaluation shows that surprisingly MCE is stronger than MCTS for a game like Kingdomino.
All experiments use a cloud-native design, with a game server in a Docker container, and agents communicating using a REST-style JSON protocol. This enables a multi-language approach to separating the game state, the strategy implementations, and the coordination layer.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2018; v1 submitted 12 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
