-
The Effect of Video Playback Speed on Perception of Technical Skill in Robotic Surgery
Authors:
Jason D Kelly,
Nicholas Heller,
Ashley Petersen,
Thomas S Lendvay,
Timothy M Kowalewski
Abstract:
Purpose: Previous research has shown that obtaining non-expert crowd evaluations of surgical performances concords with the gold standard of expert surgeon review, and that faster playback speed increases ratings for videos of higher-skilled surgeons in laparoscopic simulation. The aim of this research is to extend this investigation to real surgeries that use non-expert crowd evaluations. We addr…
▽ More
Purpose: Previous research has shown that obtaining non-expert crowd evaluations of surgical performances concords with the gold standard of expert surgeon review, and that faster playback speed increases ratings for videos of higher-skilled surgeons in laparoscopic simulation. The aim of this research is to extend this investigation to real surgeries that use non-expert crowd evaluations. We address two questions (1) whether crowds award more favorable ratings to videos shown at increased playback speeds, and (2) if crowd evaluations of the first minute of a surgical procedure differ from crowd evaluations of the entire performance. Methods: A set of 56 videos of practicing surgeons were used to evaluate the technical skill of the surgeons at each video playback speed used for the first minute of the previously rated performance, using the GEARS assessment criteria. Results: Crowds on average did rate videos higher as playback speed was increased. This effect was observed for both proficient and expert surgeons. Each increase in the playback speed by 0.8x was associated with, on average, a 0.16-point increase in the GEARS score for expert surgeons and a 0.27-point increase in GEARS score for proficient surgeons, with both groups being perceived as obtaining relatively equal skill at the fastest playback speed. It was also found that 22 out of the 56 surgeons were perceived to be significantly different in skill when just viewing the first minute of performance. Conclusion: The observed increase in skill ratings with video playback speed replicates findings for laparoscopy in [2], and extends to real robotic surgeries. Furthermore, the large differences in skill labels when comparing the first minute of surgery to the entire 15 minute video warrants further investigation into how much perceived skill ratings vary in time (sub-task level) vs. summative metrics (task level).
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
The Effect of Video Playback Speed on Surgeon Technical Skill Perception
Authors:
Jason D Kelly,
Ashley Petersen,
Thomas S Lendvay,
Timothy M Kowalewski
Abstract:
Purpose: Finding effective methods of discriminating surgeon technical skill is a complex problem to solve computationally. Previous research has shown non-expert crowd evaluations of surgical performances are as accurate as the gold standard, expert surgeon review. The aim of this research is to learn whether crowdsourced evaluators give higher ratings of technical skill to video of performances…
▽ More
Purpose: Finding effective methods of discriminating surgeon technical skill is a complex problem to solve computationally. Previous research has shown non-expert crowd evaluations of surgical performances are as accurate as the gold standard, expert surgeon review. The aim of this research is to learn whether crowdsourced evaluators give higher ratings of technical skill to video of performances with increased playback speed, the use in discriminating skill levels, and if this increase is related to the evaluator consciously being aware that the video is being manually edited. Methods: A set of ten peg transfer videos (5 novices, 5 experts), were used to evaluate the perceived skill of the performers at each video playback speed used (0.4x-3.6x). Objective metrics used for measuring technical skill were also computed for comparison by manipulating the corresponding kinematic data of each performance. Two videos of an expert and novice performing dry lab laparoscopic trials of peg transfer tasks were used to obtain evaluations at each playback speed (0.2x-3.0x) of perception of whether a video is played at real-time playback speed or not. Results: We found that while both novices and experts had increased perceived technical skill as the video playback was increased, the amount of increase was significantly greater for experts. Each increase in playback speed by 0.4x was associated with, on average, a 0.72-point increase in the GOALS score (95% CI: 0.60-0.84 point increase; p < 0.001) for expert videos and only a 0.24-point increase in the GOALS score (95% CI: 0.13-0.36 point increase; p < 0.001) for novice videos. Conclusion: Due to the differential increase in perceived technical skill due to increased playback speed for experts, the difference between novice and expert skill levels of surgical performances may be more easily discerned by manually increasing the video playback speed.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Towards Data-Driven Hierarchical Surgical Skill Analysis
Authors:
Bin Li,
Berenice Mettler,
Timonthy M. Kowalewski
Abstract:
This paper evaluates methods of hierarchical skill analysis developed in aerospace to the problem of surgical skill assessment and modeling. The analysis employs tool motion data of Fundamental of Laparoscopic Skills (FLS) tasks collected from clinicians of various skill levels at three different clinical teaching hospitals in the United States. Outcomes are evaluated based on their ability to pro…
▽ More
This paper evaluates methods of hierarchical skill analysis developed in aerospace to the problem of surgical skill assessment and modeling. The analysis employs tool motion data of Fundamental of Laparoscopic Skills (FLS) tasks collected from clinicians of various skill levels at three different clinical teaching hospitals in the United States. Outcomes are evaluated based on their ability to provide relevant information about the underlying processes across the entire system hierarchy including control, guidance and planning.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
