Showing 1–16 of 16 results for author: Korzekwa, D

AE-Flow: AutoEncoder Normalizing Flow

Authors: Jakub Mosiński, Piotr Biliński, Thomas Merritt, Abdelhamid Ezzerg, Daniel Korzekwa

Abstract: Recently normalizing flows have been gaining traction in text-to-speech (TTS) and voice conversion (VC) due to their state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. Normalizing flows are unsupervised generative models. In this paper, we introduce supervision to the training process of normalizing flows, without the need for parallel data. We call this training paradigm AutoEncoder Normalizing Flow (AE-Flow).… ▽ More Recently normalizing flows have been gaining traction in text-to-speech (TTS) and voice conversion (VC) due to their state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. Normalizing flows are unsupervised generative models. In this paper, we introduce supervision to the training process of normalizing flows, without the need for parallel data. We call this training paradigm AutoEncoder Normalizing Flow (AE-Flow). It adds a reconstruction loss forcing the model to use information from the conditioning to reconstruct an audio sample. Our goal is to understand the impact of each component and find the right combination of the negative log-likelihood (NLL) and the reconstruction loss in training normalizing flows with coupling blocks. For that reason we will compare flow-based map** model trained with: (i) NLL loss, (ii) NLL and reconstruction losses, as well as (iii) reconstruction loss only. Additionally, we compare our model with SOTA VC baseline. The models are evaluated in terms of naturalness, speaker similarity, intelligibility in many-to-many and many-to-any VC settings. The results show that the proposed training paradigm systematically improves speaker similarity and naturalness when compared to regular training methods of normalizing flows. Furthermore, we show that our method improves speaker similarity and intelligibility over the state-of-the-art. △ Less

Submitted 27 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: ICASSP 2023

Creating New Voices using Normalizing Flows

Authors: Piotr Bilinski, Thomas Merritt, Abdelhamid Ezzerg, Kamil Pokora, Sebastian Cygert, Kayoko Yanagisawa, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Daniel Korzekwa

Abstract: Creating realistic and natural-sounding synthetic speech remains a big challenge for voice identities unseen during training. As there is growing interest in synthesizing voices of new speakers, here we investigate the ability of normalizing flows in text-to-speech (TTS) and voice conversion (VC) modes to extrapolate from speakers observed during training to create unseen speaker identities. First… ▽ More Creating realistic and natural-sounding synthetic speech remains a big challenge for voice identities unseen during training. As there is growing interest in synthesizing voices of new speakers, here we investigate the ability of normalizing flows in text-to-speech (TTS) and voice conversion (VC) modes to extrapolate from speakers observed during training to create unseen speaker identities. Firstly, we create an approach for TTS and VC, and then we comprehensively evaluate our methods and baselines in terms of intelligibility, naturalness, speaker similarity, and ability to create new voices. We use both objective and subjective metrics to benchmark our techniques on 2 evaluation tasks: zero-shot and new voice speech synthesis. The goal of the former task is to measure the precision of the conversion to an unseen voice. The goal of the latter is to measure the ability to create new voices. Extensive evaluations demonstrate that the proposed approach systematically allows to obtain state-of-the-art performance in zero-shot speech synthesis and creates various new voices, unobserved in the training set. We consider this work to be the first attempt to synthesize new voices based on mel-spectrograms and normalizing flows, along with a comprehensive analysis and comparison of the TTS and VC modes. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2023; originally announced December 2023.

Comments: Interspeech 2022

Journal ref: Interspeech 2022, 2958-2962

Comparing normalizing flows and diffusion models for prosody and acoustic modelling in text-to-speech

Authors: Guangyan Zhang, Thomas Merritt, Manuel Sam Ribeiro, Biel Tura-Vecino, Kayoko Yanagisawa, Kamil Pokora, Abdelhamid Ezzerg, Sebastian Cygert, Ammar Abbas, Piotr Bilinski, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Daniel Korzekwa, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba

Abstract: Neural text-to-speech systems are often optimized on L1/L2 losses, which make strong assumptions about the distributions of the target data space. Aiming to improve those assumptions, Normalizing Flows and Diffusion Probabilistic Models were recently proposed as alternatives. In this paper, we compare traditional L1/L2-based approaches to diffusion and flow-based approaches for the tasks of prosod… ▽ More Neural text-to-speech systems are often optimized on L1/L2 losses, which make strong assumptions about the distributions of the target data space. Aiming to improve those assumptions, Normalizing Flows and Diffusion Probabilistic Models were recently proposed as alternatives. In this paper, we compare traditional L1/L2-based approaches to diffusion and flow-based approaches for the tasks of prosody and mel-spectrogram prediction for text-to-speech synthesis. We use a prosody model to generate log-f0 and duration features, which are used to condition an acoustic model that generates mel-spectrograms. Experimental results demonstrate that the flow-based model achieves the best performance for spectrogram prediction, improving over equivalent diffusion and L1 models. Meanwhile, both diffusion and flow-based prosody predictors result in significant improvements over a typical L2-trained prosody models. △ Less

Submitted 31 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures, 5 tables. Interspeech 2023

On granularity of prosodic representations in expressive text-to-speech

Authors: Mikolaj Babianski, Kamil Pokora, Raahil Shah, Rafal Sienkiewicz, Daniel Korzekwa, Viacheslav Klimkov

Abstract: In expressive speech synthesis it is widely adopted to use latent prosody representations to deal with variability of the data during training. Same text may correspond to various acoustic realizations, which is known as a one-to-many map** problem in text-to-speech. Utterance, word, or phoneme-level representations are extracted from target signal in an auto-encoding setup, to complement phonet… ▽ More In expressive speech synthesis it is widely adopted to use latent prosody representations to deal with variability of the data during training. Same text may correspond to various acoustic realizations, which is known as a one-to-many map** problem in text-to-speech. Utterance, word, or phoneme-level representations are extracted from target signal in an auto-encoding setup, to complement phonetic input and simplify that map**. This paper compares prosodic embeddings at different levels of granularity and examines their prediction from text. We show that utterance-level embeddings have insufficient capacity and phoneme-level tend to introduce instabilities when predicted from text. Word-level representations impose balance between capacity and predictability. As a result, we close the gap in naturalness by 90% between synthetic speech and recordings on LibriTTS dataset, without sacrificing intelligibility. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: Accepted to IEEE SLT 2022

Journal ref: 2022 IEEE Spoken Language Technology Workshop (SLT), pp. 892-899

Automated detection of pronunciation errors in non-native English speech employing deep learning

Authors: Daniel Korzekwa

Abstract: Despite significant advances in recent years, the existing Computer-Assisted Pronunciation Training (CAPT) methods detect pronunciation errors with a relatively low accuracy (precision of 60% at 40%-80% recall). This Ph.D. work proposes novel deep learning methods for detecting pronunciation errors in non-native (L2) English speech, outperforming the state-of-the-art method in AUC metric (Area und… ▽ More Despite significant advances in recent years, the existing Computer-Assisted Pronunciation Training (CAPT) methods detect pronunciation errors with a relatively low accuracy (precision of 60% at 40%-80% recall). This Ph.D. work proposes novel deep learning methods for detecting pronunciation errors in non-native (L2) English speech, outperforming the state-of-the-art method in AUC metric (Area under the Curve) by 41%, i.e., from 0.528 to 0.749. One of the problems with existing CAPT methods is the low availability of annotated mispronounced speech needed for reliable training of pronunciation error detection models. Therefore, the detection of pronunciation errors is reformulated to the task of generating synthetic mispronounced speech. Intuitively, if we could mimic mispronounced speech and produce any amount of training data, detecting pronunciation errors would be more effective. Furthermore, to eliminate the need to align canonical and recognized phonemes, a novel end-to-end multi-task technique to directly detect pronunciation errors was proposed. The pronunciation error detection models have been used at Amazon to automatically detect pronunciation errors in synthetic speech to accelerate the research into new speech synthesis methods. It was demonstrated that the proposed deep learning methods are applicable in the tasks of detecting and reconstructing dysarthric speech. △ Less

Submitted 13 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: PhD Thesis, in English + extended summary in Polish

Computer-assisted Pronunciation Training -- Speech synthesis is almost all you need

Authors: Daniel Korzekwa, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba, Thomas Drugman, Bozena Kostek

Abstract: The research community has long studied computer-assisted pronunciation training (CAPT) methods in non-native speech. Researchers focused on studying various model architectures, such as Bayesian networks and deep learning methods, as well as on the analysis of different representations of the speech signal. Despite significant progress in recent years, existing CAPT methods are not able to detect… ▽ More The research community has long studied computer-assisted pronunciation training (CAPT) methods in non-native speech. Researchers focused on studying various model architectures, such as Bayesian networks and deep learning methods, as well as on the analysis of different representations of the speech signal. Despite significant progress in recent years, existing CAPT methods are not able to detect pronunciation errors with high accuracy (only 60\% precision at 40\%-80\% recall). One of the key problems is the low availability of mispronounced speech that is needed for the reliable training of pronunciation error detection models. If we had a generative model that could mimic non-native speech and produce any amount of training data, then the task of detecting pronunciation errors would be much easier. We present three innovative techniques based on phoneme-to-phoneme (P2P), text-to-speech (T2S), and speech-to-speech (S2S) conversion to generate correctly pronounced and mispronounced synthetic speech. We show that these techniques not only improve the accuracy of three machine learning models for detecting pronunciation errors but also help establish a new state-of-the-art in the field. Earlier studies have used simple speech generation techniques such as P2P conversion, but only as an additional mechanism to improve the accuracy of pronunciation error detection. We, on the other hand, consider speech generation to be the first-class method of detecting pronunciation errors. The effectiveness of these techniques is assessed in the tasks of detecting pronunciation and lexical stress errors. Non-native English speech corpora of German, Italian, and Polish speakers are used in the evaluations. The best proposed S2S technique improves the accuracy of detecting pronunciation errors in AUC metric by 41\% from 0.528 to 0.749 compared to the state-of-the-art approach. △ Less

Submitted 2 July, 2022; originally announced July 2022.

Comments: Published in Speech Communication Journal

Text-free non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion using normalising flows

Authors: Thomas Merritt, Abdelhamid Ezzerg, Piotr Biliński, Magdalena Proszewska, Kamil Pokora, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Daniel Korzekwa

Abstract: Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is typically achieved using lossy representations of the source speech. However, ensuring only speaker identity information is dropped whilst all other information from the source speech is retained is a large challenge. This is particularly challenging in the scenario where at inference-time we have no knowledge of the text being read, i.e., text-free VC. To mit… ▽ More Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is typically achieved using lossy representations of the source speech. However, ensuring only speaker identity information is dropped whilst all other information from the source speech is retained is a large challenge. This is particularly challenging in the scenario where at inference-time we have no knowledge of the text being read, i.e., text-free VC. To mitigate this, we investigate information-preserving VC approaches. Normalising flows have gained attention for text-to-speech synthesis, however have been under-explored for VC. Flows utilize invertible functions to learn the likelihood of the data, thus provide a lossless encoding of speech. We investigate normalising flows for VC in both text-conditioned and text-free scenarios. Furthermore, for text-free VC we compare pre-trained and jointly-learnt priors. Flow-based VC evaluations show no degradation between text-free and text-conditioned VC, resulting in improvements over the state-of-the-art. Also, joint-training of the prior is found to negatively impact text-free VC quality. △ Less

Submitted 15 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Enhancing audio quality for expressive Neural Text-to-Speech

Authors: Abdelhamid Ezzerg, Adam Gabrys, Bartosz Putrycz, Daniel Korzekwa, Daniel Saez-Trigueros, David McHardy, Kamil Pokora, Jakub Lachowicz, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba, Viacheslav Klimkov

Abstract: Artificial speech synthesis has made a great leap in terms of naturalness as recent Text-to-Speech (TTS) systems are capable of producing speech with similar quality to human recordings. However, not all speaking styles are easy to model: highly expressive voices are still challenging even to recent TTS architectures since there seems to be a trade-off between expressiveness in a generated audio a… ▽ More Artificial speech synthesis has made a great leap in terms of naturalness as recent Text-to-Speech (TTS) systems are capable of producing speech with similar quality to human recordings. However, not all speaking styles are easy to model: highly expressive voices are still challenging even to recent TTS architectures since there seems to be a trade-off between expressiveness in a generated audio and its signal quality. In this paper, we present a set of techniques that can be leveraged to enhance the signal quality of a highly-expressive voice without the use of additional data. The proposed techniques include: tuning the autoregressive loop's granularity during training; using Generative Adversarial Networks in acoustic modelling; and the use of Variational Auto-Encoders in both the acoustic model and the neural vocoder. We show that, when combined, these techniques greatly closed the gap in perceived naturalness between the baseline system and recordings by 39% in terms of MUSHRA scores for an expressive celebrity voice. △ Less

Submitted 13 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures, 2 tables, SSW 2021

Non-Autoregressive TTS with Explicit Duration Modelling for Low-Resource Highly Expressive Speech

Authors: Raahil Shah, Kamil Pokora, Abdelhamid Ezzerg, Viacheslav Klimkov, Goeric Huybrechts, Bartosz Putrycz, Daniel Korzekwa, Thomas Merritt

Abstract: Whilst recent neural text-to-speech (TTS) approaches produce high-quality speech, they typically require a large amount of recordings from the target speaker. In previous work, a 3-step method was proposed to generate high-quality TTS while greatly reducing the amount of data required for training. However, we have observed a ceiling effect in the level of naturalness achievable for highly express… ▽ More Whilst recent neural text-to-speech (TTS) approaches produce high-quality speech, they typically require a large amount of recordings from the target speaker. In previous work, a 3-step method was proposed to generate high-quality TTS while greatly reducing the amount of data required for training. However, we have observed a ceiling effect in the level of naturalness achievable for highly expressive voices when using this approach. In this paper, we present a method for building highly expressive TTS voices with as little as 15 minutes of speech data from the target speaker. Compared to the current state-of-the-art approach, our proposed improvements close the gap to recordings by 23.3% for naturalness of speech and by 16.3% for speaker similarity. Further, we match the naturalness and speaker similarity of a Tacotron2-based full-data (~10 hours) model using only 15 minutes of target speaker data, whereas with 30 minutes or more, we significantly outperform it. The following improvements are proposed: 1) changing from an autoregressive, attention-based TTS model to a non-autoregressive model replacing attention with an external duration model and 2) an additional Conditional Generative Adversarial Network (cGAN) based fine-tuning step. △ Less

Submitted 25 June, 2021; v1 submitted 24 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures. Accepted to Speech Synthesis Workshop (SSW) 2021

Improving the expressiveness of neural vocoding with non-affine Normalizing Flows

Authors: Adam Gabryś, Yunlong Jiao, Viacheslav Klimkov, Daniel Korzekwa, Roberto Barra-Chicote

Abstract: This paper proposes a general enhancement to the Normalizing Flows (NF) used in neural vocoding. As a case study, we improve expressive speech vocoding with a revamped Parallel Wavenet (PW). Specifically, we propose to extend the affine transformation of PW to the more expressive invertible non-affine function. The greater expressiveness of the improved PW leads to better-perceived signal quality… ▽ More This paper proposes a general enhancement to the Normalizing Flows (NF) used in neural vocoding. As a case study, we improve expressive speech vocoding with a revamped Parallel Wavenet (PW). Specifically, we propose to extend the affine transformation of PW to the more expressive invertible non-affine function. The greater expressiveness of the improved PW leads to better-perceived signal quality and naturalness in the waveform reconstruction and text-to-speech (TTS) tasks. We evaluate the model across different speaking styles on a multi-speaker, multi-lingual dataset. In the waveform reconstruction task, the proposed model closes the naturalness and signal quality gap from the original PW to recordings by $10\%$, and from other state-of-the-art neural vocoding systems by more than $60\%$. We also demonstrate improvements in objective metrics on the evaluation test set with L2 Spectral Distance and Cross-Entropy reduced by $3\%$ and $6\unicode{x2030}$ comparing to the affine PW. Furthermore, we extend the probability density distillation procedure proposed by the original PW paper, so that it works with any non-affine invertible and differentiable function. △ Less

Submitted 16 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: Accepted to Interspeech 2021, 5 pages,3 figures

Weakly-supervised word-level pronunciation error detection in non-native English speech

Authors: Daniel Korzekwa, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba, Thomas Drugman, Shira Calamaro, Bozena Kostek

Abstract: We propose a weakly-supervised model for word-level mispronunciation detection in non-native (L2) English speech. To train this model, phonetically transcribed L2 speech is not required and we only need to mark mispronounced words. The lack of phonetic transcriptions for L2 speech means that the model has to learn only from a weak signal of word-level mispronunciations. Because of that and due to… ▽ More We propose a weakly-supervised model for word-level mispronunciation detection in non-native (L2) English speech. To train this model, phonetically transcribed L2 speech is not required and we only need to mark mispronounced words. The lack of phonetic transcriptions for L2 speech means that the model has to learn only from a weak signal of word-level mispronunciations. Because of that and due to the limited amount of mispronounced L2 speech, the model is more likely to overfit. To limit this risk, we train it in a multi-task setup. In the first task, we estimate the probabilities of word-level mispronunciation. For the second task, we use a phoneme recognizer trained on phonetically transcribed L1 speech that is easily accessible and can be automatically annotated. Compared to state-of-the-art approaches, we improve the accuracy of detecting word-level pronunciation errors in AUC metric by 30% on the GUT Isle Corpus of L2 Polish speakers, and by 21.5% on the Isle Corpus of L2 German and Italian speakers. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: Accepted to Interspeech 2021

Universal Neural Vocoding with Parallel WaveNet

Authors: Yunlong Jiao, Adam Gabrys, Georgi Tinchev, Bartosz Putrycz, Daniel Korzekwa, Viacheslav Klimkov

Abstract: We present a universal neural vocoder based on Parallel WaveNet, with an additional conditioning network called Audio Encoder. Our universal vocoder offers real-time high-quality speech synthesis on a wide range of use cases. We tested it on 43 internal speakers of diverse age and gender, speaking 20 languages in 17 unique styles, of which 7 voices and 5 styles were not exposed during training. We… ▽ More We present a universal neural vocoder based on Parallel WaveNet, with an additional conditioning network called Audio Encoder. Our universal vocoder offers real-time high-quality speech synthesis on a wide range of use cases. We tested it on 43 internal speakers of diverse age and gender, speaking 20 languages in 17 unique styles, of which 7 voices and 5 styles were not exposed during training. We show that the proposed universal vocoder significantly outperforms speaker-dependent vocoders overall. We also show that the proposed vocoder outperforms several existing neural vocoder architectures in terms of naturalness and universality. These findings are consistent when we further test on more than 300 open-source voices. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2021; v1 submitted 1 February, 2021; originally announced February 2021.

Comments: 5 pages, 2 figures. Accepted to ICASSP 2021

Mispronunciation Detection in Non-native (L2) English with Uncertainty Modeling

Authors: Daniel Korzekwa, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba, Szymon Zaporowski, Shira Calamaro, Thomas Drugman, Bozena Kostek

Abstract: A common approach to the automatic detection of mispronunciation in language learning is to recognize the phonemes produced by a student and compare it to the expected pronunciation of a native speaker. This approach makes two simplifying assumptions: a) phonemes can be recognized from speech with high accuracy, b) there is a single correct way for a sentence to be pronounced. These assumptions do… ▽ More A common approach to the automatic detection of mispronunciation in language learning is to recognize the phonemes produced by a student and compare it to the expected pronunciation of a native speaker. This approach makes two simplifying assumptions: a) phonemes can be recognized from speech with high accuracy, b) there is a single correct way for a sentence to be pronounced. These assumptions do not always hold, which can result in a significant amount of false mispronunciation alarms. We propose a novel approach to overcome this problem based on two principles: a) taking into account uncertainty in the automatic phoneme recognition step, b) accounting for the fact that there may be multiple valid pronunciations. We evaluate the model on non-native (L2) English speech of German, Italian and Polish speakers, where it is shown to increase the precision of detecting mispronunciations by up to 18% (relative) compared to the common approach. △ Less

Submitted 8 February, 2021; v1 submitted 16 January, 2021; originally announced January 2021.

Comments: Accepted to ICASSP 2021

Detection of Lexical Stress Errors in Non-Native (L2) English with Data Augmentation and Attention

Authors: Daniel Korzekwa, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Szymon Zaporowski, Grzegorz Beringer, Jaime Lorenzo-Trueba, Alicja Serafinowicz, Jasha Droppo, Thomas Drugman, Bozena Kostek

Abstract: This paper describes two novel complementary techniques that improve the detection of lexical stress errors in non-native (L2) English speech: attention-based feature extraction and data augmentation based on Neural Text-To-Speech (TTS). In a classical approach, audio features are usually extracted from fixed regions of speech such as the syllable nucleus. We propose an attention-based deep learni… ▽ More This paper describes two novel complementary techniques that improve the detection of lexical stress errors in non-native (L2) English speech: attention-based feature extraction and data augmentation based on Neural Text-To-Speech (TTS). In a classical approach, audio features are usually extracted from fixed regions of speech such as the syllable nucleus. We propose an attention-based deep learning model that automatically derives optimal syllable-level representation from frame-level and phoneme-level audio features. Training this model is challenging because of the limited amount of incorrect stress patterns. To solve this problem, we propose to augment the training set with incorrectly stressed words generated with Neural TTS. Combining both techniques achieves 94.8% precision and 49.2% recall for the detection of incorrectly stressed words in L2 English speech of Slavic and Baltic speakers. △ Less

Submitted 7 June, 2021; v1 submitted 29 December, 2020; originally announced December 2020.

Comments: Accepted to Interspeech 2021

Interpretable Deep Learning Model for the Detection and Reconstruction of Dysarthric Speech

Authors: Daniel Korzekwa, Roberto Barra-Chicote, Bozena Kostek, Thomas Drugman, Mateusz Lajszczak

Abstract: This paper proposed a novel approach for the detection and reconstruction of dysarthric speech. The encoder-decoder model factorizes speech into a low-dimensional latent space and encoding of the input text. We showed that the latent space conveys interpretable characteristics of dysarthria, such as intelligibility and fluency of speech. MUSHRA perceptual test demonstrated that the adaptation of t… ▽ More This paper proposed a novel approach for the detection and reconstruction of dysarthric speech. The encoder-decoder model factorizes speech into a low-dimensional latent space and encoding of the input text. We showed that the latent space conveys interpretable characteristics of dysarthria, such as intelligibility and fluency of speech. MUSHRA perceptual test demonstrated that the adaptation of the latent space let the model generate speech of improved fluency. The multi-task supervised approach for predicting both the probability of dysarthric speech and the mel-spectrogram helps improve the detection of dysarthria with higher accuracy. This is thanks to a low-dimensional latent space of the auto-encoder as opposed to directly predicting dysarthria from a highly dimensional mel-spectrogram. △ Less

Submitted 10 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 5 pages, 5 figures, Accepted for Interspeech 2019

Comprehensive evaluation of statistical speech waveform synthesis

Authors: Thomas Merritt, Bartosz Putrycz, Adam Nadolski, Tianjun Ye, Daniel Korzekwa, Wiktor Dolecki, Thomas Drugman, Viacheslav Klimkov, Alexis Moinet, Andrew Breen, Rafal Kuklinski, Nikko Strom, Roberto Barra-Chicote

Abstract: Statistical TTS systems that directly predict the speech waveform have recently reported improvements in synthesis quality. This investigation evaluates Amazon's statistical speech waveform synthesis (SSWS) system. An in-depth evaluation of SSWS is conducted across a number of domains to better understand the consistency in quality. The results of this evaluation are validated by repeating the pro… ▽ More Statistical TTS systems that directly predict the speech waveform have recently reported improvements in synthesis quality. This investigation evaluates Amazon's statistical speech waveform synthesis (SSWS) system. An in-depth evaluation of SSWS is conducted across a number of domains to better understand the consistency in quality. The results of this evaluation are validated by repeating the procedure on a separate group of testers. Finally, an analysis of the nature of speech errors of SSWS compared to hybrid unit selection synthesis is conducted to identify the strengths and weaknesses of SSWS. Having a deeper insight into SSWS allows us to better define the focus of future work to improve this new technology. △ Less

Submitted 11 December, 2018; v1 submitted 15 November, 2018; originally announced November 2018.