-
PriCE: Privacy-Preserving and Cost-Effective Scheduling for Parallelizing the Large Medical Image Processing Workflow over Hybrid Clouds
Authors:
Yuandou Wang,
Neel Kanwal,
Kjersti Engan,
Chunming Rong,
Paola Grosso,
Zhiming Zhao
Abstract:
Running deep neural networks for large medical images is a resource-hungry and time-consuming task with centralized computing. Outsourcing such medical image processing tasks to hybrid clouds has benefits, such as a significant reduction of execution time and monetary cost. However, due to privacy concerns, it is still challenging to process sensitive medical images over clouds, which would hinder…
▽ More
Running deep neural networks for large medical images is a resource-hungry and time-consuming task with centralized computing. Outsourcing such medical image processing tasks to hybrid clouds has benefits, such as a significant reduction of execution time and monetary cost. However, due to privacy concerns, it is still challenging to process sensitive medical images over clouds, which would hinder their deployment in many real-world applications. To overcome this, we first formulate the overall optimization objectives of the privacy-preserving distributed system model, i.e., minimizing the amount of information about the private data learned by the adversaries throughout the process, reducing the maximum execution time and cost under the user budget constraint. We propose a novel privacy-preserving and cost-effective method called PriCE to solve this multi-objective optimization problem. We performed extensive simulation experiments for artifact detection tasks on medical images using an ensemble of five deep convolutional neural network inferences as the workflow task. Experimental results show that PriCE successfully splits a wide range of input gigapixel medical images with graph-coloring-based strategies, yielding desired output utility and lowering the privacy risk, makespan, and monetary cost under user's budget.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Equip** Computational Pathology Systems with Artifact Processing Pipelines: A Showcase for Computation and Performance Trade-offs
Authors:
Neel Kanwal,
Farbod Khoraminia,
Umay Kiraz,
Andres Mosquera-Zamudio,
Carlos Monteagudo,
Emiel A. M. Janssen,
Tahlita C. M. Zuiverloon,
Chunmig Rong,
Kjersti Engan
Abstract:
Histopathology is a gold standard for cancer diagnosis under a microscopic examination. However, histological tissue processing procedures result in artifacts, which are ultimately transferred to the digitized version of glass slides, known as whole slide images (WSIs). Artifacts are diagnostically irrelevant areas and may result in wrong deep learning (DL) algorithms predictions. Therefore, detec…
▽ More
Histopathology is a gold standard for cancer diagnosis under a microscopic examination. However, histological tissue processing procedures result in artifacts, which are ultimately transferred to the digitized version of glass slides, known as whole slide images (WSIs). Artifacts are diagnostically irrelevant areas and may result in wrong deep learning (DL) algorithms predictions. Therefore, detecting and excluding artifacts in the computational pathology (CPATH) system is essential for reliable automated diagnosis. In this paper, we propose a mixture of experts (MoE) scheme for detecting five notable artifacts, including damaged tissue, blur, folded tissue, air bubbles, and histologically irrelevant blood from WSIs. First, we train independent binary DL models as experts to capture particular artifact morphology. Then, we ensemble their predictions using a fusion mechanism. We apply probabilistic thresholding over the final probability distribution to improve the sensitivity of the MoE. We developed DL pipelines using two MoEs and two multiclass models of state-of-the-art deep convolutional neural networks (DCNNs) and vision transformers (ViTs). DCNNs-based MoE and ViTs-based MoE schemes outperformed simpler multiclass models and were tested on datasets from different hospitals and cancer types, where MoE using DCNNs yielded the best results. The proposed MoE yields 86.15% F1 and 97.93% sensitivity scores on unseen data, retaining less computational cost for inference than MoE using ViTs. This best performance of MoEs comes with relatively higher computational trade-offs than multiclass models. The proposed artifact detection pipeline will not only ensure reliable CPATH predictions but may also provide quality control.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2024; v1 submitted 12 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Towards Privacy-, Budget-, and Deadline-Aware Service Optimization for Large Medical Image Processing across Hybrid Clouds
Authors:
Yuandou Wang,
Neel Kanwal,
Kjersti Engan,
Chunming Rong,
Paola Grosso,
Zhiming Zhao
Abstract:
Efficiently processing medical images, such as whole slide images in digital pathology, is essential for timely diagnosing high-risk diseases. However, this demands advanced computing infrastructure, e.g., GPU servers for deep learning inferencing, and local processing is time-consuming and costly. Besides, privacy concerns further complicate the employment of remote cloud infrastructures. While p…
▽ More
Efficiently processing medical images, such as whole slide images in digital pathology, is essential for timely diagnosing high-risk diseases. However, this demands advanced computing infrastructure, e.g., GPU servers for deep learning inferencing, and local processing is time-consuming and costly. Besides, privacy concerns further complicate the employment of remote cloud infrastructures. While previous research has explored privacy and security-aware workflow scheduling in hybrid clouds for distributed processing, privacy-preserving data splitting, optimizing the service allocation of outsourcing computation on split data to the cloud, and privacy evaluation for large medical images still need to be addressed. This study focuses on tailoring a virtual infrastructure within a hybrid cloud environment and scheduling the image processing services while preserving privacy. We aim to minimize the use of untrusted nodes, lower monetary costs, and reduce execution time under privacy, budget, and deadline requirements. We consider a two-phase solution and develop 1) a privacy-preserving data splitting algorithm and 2) a greedy Pareto front-based algorithm for optimizing the service allocation. We conducted experiments with real and simulated data to validate and compare our method with a baseline. The results show that our privacy mechanism design outperforms the baseline regarding the average lower band on individual privacy and information gain for privacy evaluation. In addition, our approach can obtain various Pareto optimal-based allocations with users' preferences on the maximum number of untrusted nodes, budget, and time threshold. Our solutions often dominate the baseline's solution and are superior on a tight budget. Specifically, our approach has been ahead of baseline, up to 85.2% and 6.8% in terms of the total financial and time costs, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
A Dual Convolutional Neural Network Pipeline for Melanoma Diagnostics and Prognostics
Authors:
Marie Bø-Sande,
Edvin Benjaminsen,
Neel Kanwal,
Saul Fuster,
Helga Hardardottir,
Ingrid Lundal,
Emiel A. M. Janssen,
Kjersti Engan
Abstract:
Melanoma is a type of cancer that begins in the cells controlling the pigment of the skin, and it is often referred to as the most dangerous skin cancer. Diagnosing melanoma can be time-consuming, and a recent increase in melanoma incidents indicates a growing demand for a more efficient diagnostic process. This paper presents a pipeline for melanoma diagnostics, leveraging two convolutional neura…
▽ More
Melanoma is a type of cancer that begins in the cells controlling the pigment of the skin, and it is often referred to as the most dangerous skin cancer. Diagnosing melanoma can be time-consuming, and a recent increase in melanoma incidents indicates a growing demand for a more efficient diagnostic process. This paper presents a pipeline for melanoma diagnostics, leveraging two convolutional neural networks, a diagnosis, and a prognosis model. The diagnostic model is responsible for localizing malignant patches across whole slide images and delivering a patient-level diagnosis as malignant or benign. Further, the prognosis model utilizes the diagnostic model's output to provide a patient-level prognosis as good or bad. The full pipeline has an F1 score of 0.79 when tested on data from the same distribution as it was trained on.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Enhancing Prostate Cancer Diagnosis with Deep Learning: A Study using mpMRI Segmentation and Classification
Authors:
Anil B. Gavade,
Neel Kanwal,
Priyanka A. Gavade,
Rajendra Nerli
Abstract:
Prostate cancer (PCa) is a severe disease among men globally. It is important to identify PCa early and make a precise diagnosis for effective treatment. For PCa diagnosis, Multi-parametric magnetic resonance imaging (mpMRI) emerged as an invaluable imaging modality that offers a precise anatomical view of the prostate gland and its tissue structure. Deep learning (DL) models can enhance existing…
▽ More
Prostate cancer (PCa) is a severe disease among men globally. It is important to identify PCa early and make a precise diagnosis for effective treatment. For PCa diagnosis, Multi-parametric magnetic resonance imaging (mpMRI) emerged as an invaluable imaging modality that offers a precise anatomical view of the prostate gland and its tissue structure. Deep learning (DL) models can enhance existing clinical systems and improve patient care by locating regions of interest for physicians. Recently, DL techniques have been employed to develop a pipeline for segmenting and classifying different cancer types. These studies show that DL can be used to increase diagnostic precision and give objective results without variability. This work uses well-known DL models for the classification and segmentation of mpMRI images to detect PCa. Our implementation involves four pipelines; Semantic DeepSegNet with ResNet50, DeepSegNet with recurrent neural network (RNN), U-Net with RNN, and U-Net with a long short-term memory (LSTM). Each segmentation model is paired with a different classifier to evaluate the performance using different metrics. The results of our experiments show that the pipeline that uses the combination of U-Net and the LSTM model outperforms all other combinations, excelling in both segmentation and classification tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2023; v1 submitted 8 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Balancing Privacy and Progress in Artificial Intelligence: Anonymization in Histopathology for Biomedical Research and Education
Authors:
Neel Kanwal,
Emiel A. M. Janssen,
Kjersti Engan
Abstract:
The advancement of biomedical research heavily relies on access to large amounts of medical data. In the case of histopathology, Whole Slide Images (WSI) and clinicopathological information are valuable for develo** Artificial Intelligence (AI) algorithms for Digital Pathology (DP). Transferring medical data "as open as possible" enhances the usability of the data for secondary purposes but pose…
▽ More
The advancement of biomedical research heavily relies on access to large amounts of medical data. In the case of histopathology, Whole Slide Images (WSI) and clinicopathological information are valuable for develo** Artificial Intelligence (AI) algorithms for Digital Pathology (DP). Transferring medical data "as open as possible" enhances the usability of the data for secondary purposes but poses a risk to patient privacy. At the same time, existing regulations push towards kee** medical data "as closed as necessary" to avoid re-identification risks. Generally, these legal regulations require the removal of sensitive data but do not consider the possibility of data linkage attacks due to modern image-matching algorithms. In addition, the lack of standardization in DP makes it harder to establish a single solution for all formats of WSIs. These challenges raise problems for bio-informatics researchers in balancing privacy and progress while develo** AI algorithms. This paper explores the legal regulations and terminologies for medical data-sharing. We review existing approaches and highlight challenges from the histopathological perspective. We also present a data-sharing guideline for histological data to foster multidisciplinary research and education.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2023; v1 submitted 18 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Towards a privacy-preserving distributed cloud service for preprocessing very large medical images
Authors:
Yuandou Wang,
Neel Kanwal,
Kjersti Engan,
Chunming Rong,
Zhiming Zhao
Abstract:
Digitized histopathology glass slides, known as Whole Slide Images (WSIs), are often several gigapixels large and contain sensitive metadata information, which makes distributed processing unfeasible. Moreover, artifacts in WSIs may result in unreliable predictions when directly applied by Deep Learning (DL) algorithms. Therefore, preprocessing WSIs is beneficial, e.g., eliminating privacy-sensiti…
▽ More
Digitized histopathology glass slides, known as Whole Slide Images (WSIs), are often several gigapixels large and contain sensitive metadata information, which makes distributed processing unfeasible. Moreover, artifacts in WSIs may result in unreliable predictions when directly applied by Deep Learning (DL) algorithms. Therefore, preprocessing WSIs is beneficial, e.g., eliminating privacy-sensitive information, splitting a gigapixel medical image into tiles, and removing the diagnostically irrelevant areas. This work proposes a cloud service to parallelize the preprocessing pipeline for large medical images. The data and model parallelization will not only boost the end-to-end processing efficiency for histological tasks but also secure the reconstruction of WSI by randomly distributing tiles across processing nodes. Furthermore, the initial steps of the pipeline will be integrated into the Jupyter-based Virtual Research Environment (VRE) to enable image owners to configure and automate the execution process based on resource allocation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023; v1 submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Vision Transformers for Small Histological Datasets Learned through Knowledge Distillation
Authors:
Neel Kanwal,
Trygve Eftestol,
Farbod Khoraminia,
Tahlita CM Zuiverloon,
Kjersti Engan
Abstract:
Computational Pathology (CPATH) systems have the potential to automate diagnostic tasks. However, the artifacts on the digitized histological glass slides, known as Whole Slide Images (WSIs), may hamper the overall performance of CPATH systems. Deep Learning (DL) models such as Vision Transformers (ViTs) may detect and exclude artifacts before running the diagnostic algorithm. A simple way to deve…
▽ More
Computational Pathology (CPATH) systems have the potential to automate diagnostic tasks. However, the artifacts on the digitized histological glass slides, known as Whole Slide Images (WSIs), may hamper the overall performance of CPATH systems. Deep Learning (DL) models such as Vision Transformers (ViTs) may detect and exclude artifacts before running the diagnostic algorithm. A simple way to develop robust and generalized ViTs is to train them on massive datasets. Unfortunately, acquiring large medical datasets is expensive and inconvenient, prompting the need for a generalized artifact detection method for WSIs. In this paper, we present a student-teacher recipe to improve the classification performance of ViT for the air bubbles detection task. ViT, trained under the student-teacher framework, boosts its performance by distilling existing knowledge from the high-capacity teacher model. Our best-performing ViT yields 0.961 and 0.911 F1-score and MCC, respectively, observing a 7% gain in MCC against stand-alone training. The proposed method presents a new perspective of leveraging knowledge distillation over transfer learning to encourage the use of customized transformers for efficient preprocessing pipelines in the CPATH systems.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Detection and Localization of Melanoma Skin Cancer in Histopathological Whole Slide Images
Authors:
Neel Kanwal,
Roger Amundsen,
Helga Hardardottir,
Luca Tomasetti,
Erling Sandoy Undersrud,
Emiel A. M. Janssen,
Kjersti Engan
Abstract:
Melanoma diagnosed and treated in its early stages can increase the survival rate. A projected increase in skin cancer incidents and a dearth of dermatopathologists have emphasized the need for computational pathology (CPATH) systems. CPATH systems with deep learning (DL) models have the potential to identify the presence of melanoma by exploiting underlying morphological and cellular features. Th…
▽ More
Melanoma diagnosed and treated in its early stages can increase the survival rate. A projected increase in skin cancer incidents and a dearth of dermatopathologists have emphasized the need for computational pathology (CPATH) systems. CPATH systems with deep learning (DL) models have the potential to identify the presence of melanoma by exploiting underlying morphological and cellular features. This paper proposes a DL method to detect melanoma and distinguish between normal skin and benign/malignant melanocytic lesions in Whole Slide Images (WSI). Our method detects lesions with high accuracy and localizes them on a WSI to identify potential regions of interest for pathologists. Interestingly, our DL method relies on using a single CNN network to create localization maps first and use them to perform slide-level predictions to determine patients who have melanoma. Our best model provides favorable patch-wise classification results with a 0.992 F1 score and 0.99 sensitivity on unseen data. The source code is https://github.com/RogerAmundsen/Melanoma-Diagnosis-and-Localization-from-Whole-Slide-Images-using-Convolutional-Neural-Networks.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2023; v1 submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
DID-eFed: Facilitating Federated Learning as a Service with Decentralized Identities
Authors:
Jiahui Geng,
Neel Kanwal,
Martin Gilje Jaatun,
Chunming Rong
Abstract:
We have entered the era of big data, and it is considered to be the "fuel" for the flourishing of artificial intelligence applications. The enactment of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) raises concerns about individuals' privacy in big data. Federated learning (FL) emerges as a functional solution that can help build high-performance models shared among multiple parties while still…
▽ More
We have entered the era of big data, and it is considered to be the "fuel" for the flourishing of artificial intelligence applications. The enactment of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) raises concerns about individuals' privacy in big data. Federated learning (FL) emerges as a functional solution that can help build high-performance models shared among multiple parties while still complying with user privacy and data confidentiality requirements. Although FL has been intensively studied and used in real applications, there is still limited research related to its prospects and applications as a FLaaS (Federated Learning as a Service) to interested 3rd parties. In this paper, we present a FLaaS system: DID-eFed, where FL is facilitated by decentralized identities (DID) and a smart contract. DID enables a more flexible and credible decentralized access management in our system, while the smart contract offers a frictionless and less error-prone process. We describe particularly the scenario where our DID-eFed enables the FLaaS among hospitals and research institutions.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2021; v1 submitted 18 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
A Survey of Modern Deep Learning based Object Detection Models
Authors:
Syed Sahil Abbas Zaidi,
Mohammad Samar Ansari,
Asra Aslam,
Nadia Kanwal,
Mamoona Asghar,
Brian Lee
Abstract:
Object Detection is the task of classification and localization of objects in an image or video. It has gained prominence in recent years due to its widespread applications. This article surveys recent developments in deep learning based object detectors. Concise overview of benchmark datasets and evaluation metrics used in detection is also provided along with some of the prominent backbone archi…
▽ More
Object Detection is the task of classification and localization of objects in an image or video. It has gained prominence in recent years due to its widespread applications. This article surveys recent developments in deep learning based object detectors. Concise overview of benchmark datasets and evaluation metrics used in detection is also provided along with some of the prominent backbone architectures used in recognition tasks. It also covers contemporary lightweight classification models used on edge devices. Lastly, we compare the performances of these architectures on multiple metrics.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2021; v1 submitted 24 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Attention-based Clinical Note Summarization
Authors:
Neel Kanwal,
Giuseppe Rizzo
Abstract:
In recent years, the trend of deploying digital systems in numerous industries has hiked. The health sector has observed an extensive adoption of digital systems and services that generate significant medical records. Electronic health records contain valuable information for prospective and retrospective analysis that is often not entirely exploited because of the complicated dense information st…
▽ More
In recent years, the trend of deploying digital systems in numerous industries has hiked. The health sector has observed an extensive adoption of digital systems and services that generate significant medical records. Electronic health records contain valuable information for prospective and retrospective analysis that is often not entirely exploited because of the complicated dense information storage. The crude purpose of condensing health records is to select the information that holds most characteristics of the original documents based on a reported disease. These summaries may boost diagnosis and save a doctor's time during a saturated workload situation like the COVID-19 pandemic. In this paper, we are applying a multi-head attention-based mechanism to perform extractive summarization of meaningful phrases on clinical notes. Our method finds major sentences for a summary by correlating tokens, segments, and positional embeddings of sentences in a clinical note. The model outputs attention scores that are statistically transformed to extract critical phrases for visualization on the heat-map** tool and for human use.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2022; v1 submitted 18 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
A Fuzzy Brute Force Matching Method for Binary Image Features
Authors:
Erkan Bostanci,
Nadia Kanwal,
Betul Bostanci,
Mehmet Serdar Guzel
Abstract:
Matching of binary image features is an important step in many different computer vision applications. Conventionally, an arbitrary threshold is used to identify a correct match from incorrect matches using Hamming distance which may improve or degrade the matching results for different input images. This is mainly due to the image content which is affected by the scene, lighting and imaging condi…
▽ More
Matching of binary image features is an important step in many different computer vision applications. Conventionally, an arbitrary threshold is used to identify a correct match from incorrect matches using Hamming distance which may improve or degrade the matching results for different input images. This is mainly due to the image content which is affected by the scene, lighting and imaging conditions. This paper presents a fuzzy logic based approach for brute force matching of image features to overcome this situation. The method was tested using a well-known image database with known ground truth. The approach is shown to produce a higher number of correct matches when compared against constant distance thresholds. The nature of fuzzy logic which allows the vagueness of information and tolerance to errors has been successfully exploited in an image processing context. The uncertainty arising from the imaging conditions has been overcome with the use of compact fuzzy matching membership functions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Comparative Study of Instance Based Learning and Back Propagation for Classification Problems
Authors:
Nadia Kanwal,
Erkan Bostanci
Abstract:
The paper presents a comparative study of the performance of Back Propagation and Instance Based Learning Algorithm for classification tasks. The study is carried out by a series of experiments will all possible combinations of parameter values for the algorithms under evaluation. The algorithm's classification accuracy is compared over a range of datasets and measurements like Cross Validation, K…
▽ More
The paper presents a comparative study of the performance of Back Propagation and Instance Based Learning Algorithm for classification tasks. The study is carried out by a series of experiments will all possible combinations of parameter values for the algorithms under evaluation. The algorithm's classification accuracy is compared over a range of datasets and measurements like Cross Validation, Kappa Statistics, Root Mean Squared Value and True Positive vs False Positive rate have been used to evaluate their performance. Along with performance comparison, techniques of handling missing values have also been compared that include Mean or Mode replacement and Multiple Imputation. The results showed that parameter adjustment plays vital role in improving an algorithm's accuracy and therefore, Back Propagation has shown better results as compared to Instance Based Learning. Furthermore, the problem of missing values was better handled by Multiple imputation method, however, not suitable for less amount of data.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Sensor Fusion of Camera, GPS and IMU using Fuzzy Adaptive Multiple Motion Models
Authors:
Erkan Bostanci,
Betul Bostanci,
Nadia Kanwal,
Adrian F. Clark
Abstract:
A tracking system that will be used for Augmented Reality (AR) applications has two main requirements: accuracy and frame rate. The first requirement is related to the performance of the pose estimation algorithm and how accurately the tracking system can find the position and orientation of the user in the environment. Accuracy problems of current tracking devices, considering that they are low-c…
▽ More
A tracking system that will be used for Augmented Reality (AR) applications has two main requirements: accuracy and frame rate. The first requirement is related to the performance of the pose estimation algorithm and how accurately the tracking system can find the position and orientation of the user in the environment. Accuracy problems of current tracking devices, considering that they are low-cost devices, cause static errors during this motion estimation process. The second requirement is related to dynamic errors (the end-to-end system delay; occurring because of the delay in estimating the motion of the user and displaying images based on this estimate. This paper investigates combining the vision-based estimates with measurements from other sensors, GPS and IMU, in order to improve the tracking accuracy in outdoor environments. The idea of using Fuzzy Adaptive Multiple Models (FAMM) was investigated using a novel fuzzy rule-based approach to decide on the model that results in improved accuracy and faster convergence for the fusion filter. Results show that the developed tracking system is more accurate than a conventional GPS-IMU fusion approach due to additional estimates from a camera and fuzzy motion models. The paper also presents an application in cultural heritage context.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Memory-Efficient Design Strategy for a Parallel Embedded Integral Image Computation Engine
Authors:
Shoaib Ehsan,
Adrian F. Clark,
Wah M. Cheung,
Arjunsingh M. Bais,
Bayar I. Menzat,
Nadia Kanwal,
Klaus D. McDonald-Maier
Abstract:
In embedded vision systems, parallel computation of the integral image presents several design challenges in terms of hardware resources, speed and power consumption. Although recursive equations significantly reduce the number of operations for computing the integral image, the required internal memory becomes prohibitively large for an embedded integral image computation engine for increasing im…
▽ More
In embedded vision systems, parallel computation of the integral image presents several design challenges in terms of hardware resources, speed and power consumption. Although recursive equations significantly reduce the number of operations for computing the integral image, the required internal memory becomes prohibitively large for an embedded integral image computation engine for increasing image sizes. With the objective of achieving high-throughput with minimum hardware resources, this paper proposes a memory-efficient design strategy for a parallel embedded integral image computation engine. Results show that the design achieves nearly 35% reduction in memory for common HD video.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Improved repeatability measures for evaluating performance of feature detectors
Authors:
Shoaib Ehsan,
Nadia Kanwal,
Adrian F. Clark,
Klaus D. McDonald-Maier
Abstract:
The most frequently employed measure for performance characterisation of local feature detectors is repeatability, but it has been observed that this does not necessarily mirror actual performance. Presented are improved repeatability formulations which correlate much better with the true performance of feature detectors. Comparative results for several state-of-the-art feature detectors are prese…
▽ More
The most frequently employed measure for performance characterisation of local feature detectors is repeatability, but it has been observed that this does not necessarily mirror actual performance. Presented are improved repeatability formulations which correlate much better with the true performance of feature detectors. Comparative results for several state-of-the-art feature detectors are presented using these measures; it is found that Hessian-based detectors are generally superior at identifying features when images are subject to various geometric and photometric transformations.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
