-
T3: Transparent Tracking & Triggering for Fine-grained Overlap of Compute & Collectives
Authors:
Suchita Pati,
Shaizeen Aga,
Mahzabeen Islam,
Nuwan Jayasena,
Matthew D. Sinclair
Abstract:
Large Language Models increasingly rely on distributed techniques for their training and inference. These techniques require communication across devices which can reduce scaling efficiency as the number of devices increases. While some distributed techniques can overlap, and thus, hide this communication with independent computations, techniques such as Tensor Parallelism (TP) inherently serializ…
▽ More
Large Language Models increasingly rely on distributed techniques for their training and inference. These techniques require communication across devices which can reduce scaling efficiency as the number of devices increases. While some distributed techniques can overlap, and thus, hide this communication with independent computations, techniques such as Tensor Parallelism (TP) inherently serialize communication with model execution. One approach to hide this serialized communication is to interleave it with the producer operation (of the communicated data) in a fine-grained manner. However, this fine-grained interleaving of communication and computation in software can be difficult. Furthermore, as with any concurrent execution, it requires compute and memory resources to be shared between computation and communication, causing resource contention that reduces overlap** efficacy.
To overcome these challenges, we propose T3 which applies hardware-software co-design to transparently overlap serialized communication while minimizing resource contention with compute. T3 transparently fuses producer operations with the subsequent communication via a simple configuration of the producer's output address space and requires minor software changes. At the hardware level, T3 adds a lightweight track and trigger mechanism to orchestrate the producer's compute, and communication. It further uses compute-enhanced memories for communication's attendant compute. As a result, T3 reduces resource contention, and efficiently overlaps serialized communication with computation. For important Transformer models like T-NLG, T3 speeds up communication-heavy sublayers by 30% geomean (max 47%) and reduces data movement by 22% geomean (max 36%). Furthermore, T3's benefits persist as models scale: geomean 29% for sublayers in $\sim$500-billion parameter models, PALM and MT-NLG.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Inclusive-PIM: Hardware-Software Co-design for Broad Acceleration on Commercial PIM Architectures
Authors:
Johnathan Alsop,
Shaizeen Aga,
Mohamed Ibrahim,
Mahzabeen Islam,
Andrew Mccrabb,
Nuwan Jayasena
Abstract:
Continual demand for memory bandwidth has made it worthwhile for memory vendors to reassess processing in memory (PIM), which enables higher bandwidth by placing compute units in/near-memory. As such, memory vendors have recently proposed commercially viable PIM designs. However, these proposals are largely driven by the needs of (a narrow set of) machine learning (ML) primitives. While such propo…
▽ More
Continual demand for memory bandwidth has made it worthwhile for memory vendors to reassess processing in memory (PIM), which enables higher bandwidth by placing compute units in/near-memory. As such, memory vendors have recently proposed commercially viable PIM designs. However, these proposals are largely driven by the needs of (a narrow set of) machine learning (ML) primitives. While such proposals are reasonable given the the growing importance of ML, as memory is a pervasive component, %in this work, we make there is a case for a more inclusive PIM design that can accelerate primitives across domains.
In this work, we ascertain the capabilities of commercial PIM proposals to accelerate various primitives across domains. We first begin with outlining a set of characteristics, termed PIM-amenability-test, which aid in assessing if a given primitive is likely to be accelerated by PIM. Next, we apply this test to primitives under study to ascertain efficient data-placement and orchestration to map the primitives to underlying PIM architecture. We observe here that, even though primitives under study are largely PIM-amenable, existing commercial PIM proposals do not realize their performance potential for these primitives. To address this, we identify bottlenecks that arise in PIM execution and propose hardware and software optimizations which stand to broaden the acceleration reach of commercial PIM designs (improving average PIM speedups from 1.12x to 2.49x relative to a GPU baseline). Overall, while we believe emerging commercial PIM proposals add a necessary and complementary design point in the application acceleration space, hardware-software co-design is necessary to deliver their benefits broadly.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2024; v1 submitted 14 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Computation vs. Communication Scaling for Future Transformers on Future Hardware
Authors:
Suchita Pati,
Shaizeen Aga,
Mahzabeen Islam,
Nuwan Jayasena,
Matthew D. Sinclair
Abstract:
Scaling neural network models has delivered dramatic quality gains across ML problems. However, this scaling has increased the reliance on efficient distributed training techniques. Accordingly, as with other distributed computing scenarios, it is important to understand how will compute and communication scale relative to one another as models scale and hardware evolves? A careful study which ans…
▽ More
Scaling neural network models has delivered dramatic quality gains across ML problems. However, this scaling has increased the reliance on efficient distributed training techniques. Accordingly, as with other distributed computing scenarios, it is important to understand how will compute and communication scale relative to one another as models scale and hardware evolves? A careful study which answers this question can better guide the design of future systems which can efficiently train future large models.
Accordingly, this work provides a comprehensive multi-axial (algorithmic, empirical, hardware evolution) analysis of compute vs. communication (Comp-vs.-Comm) scaling for future Transformer models on future hardware. First, our algorithmic analysis shows that compute generally enjoys an edge over communication as models scale. However, since memory capacity scales slower than compute, these trends are being stressed. Next, we quantify this edge by empirically studying how Comp-vs.-Comm scales for future models on future hardware. To avoid profiling numerous Transformer models across many setups, we extract execution regions and project costs using operator models. This allows a spectrum (hundreds) of future model/hardware scenarios to be accurately studied ($<$15% error), and reduces profiling costs by 2100$\times$. Our experiments show that communication will be a significant portion (40-75%) of runtime as models and hardware evolve. Moreover, communication which is hidden by overlapped computation in today's models often cannot be hidden in future, larger models. Overall, this work highlights the increasingly large role communication will play as models scale and discusses techniques and upcoming technologies that can help address it.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2023; v1 submitted 6 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Demystifying BERT: Implications for Accelerator Design
Authors:
Suchita Pati,
Shaizeen Aga,
Nuwan Jayasena,
Matthew D. Sinclair
Abstract:
Transfer learning in natural language processing (NLP), as realized using models like BERT (Bi-directional Encoder Representation from Transformer), has significantly improved language representation with models that can tackle challenging language problems. Consequently, these applications are driving the requirements of future systems. Thus, we focus on BERT, one of the most popular NLP transfer…
▽ More
Transfer learning in natural language processing (NLP), as realized using models like BERT (Bi-directional Encoder Representation from Transformer), has significantly improved language representation with models that can tackle challenging language problems. Consequently, these applications are driving the requirements of future systems. Thus, we focus on BERT, one of the most popular NLP transfer learning algorithms, to identify how its algorithmic behavior can guide future accelerator design. To this end, we carefully profile BERT training and identify key algorithmic behaviors which are worthy of attention in accelerator design.
We observe that while computations which manifest as matrix multiplication dominate BERT's overall runtime, as in many convolutional neural networks, memory-intensive computations also feature prominently. We characterize these computations, which have received little attention so far. Further, we also identify heterogeneity in compute-intensive BERT computations and discuss software and possible hardware mechanisms to further optimize these computations. Finally, we discuss implications of these behaviors as networks get larger and use distributed training environments, and how techniques such as micro-batching and mixed-precision training scale. Overall, our analysis identifies holistic solutions to optimize systems for BERT-like models.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
SeqPoint: Identifying Representative Iterations of Sequence-based Neural Networks
Authors:
Suchita Pati,
Shaizeen Aga,
Matthew D. Sinclair,
Nuwan Jayasena
Abstract:
The ubiquity of deep neural networks (DNNs) continues to rise, making them a crucial application class for hardware optimizations. However, detailed profiling and characterization of DNN training remains difficult as these applications often run for hours to days on real hardware. Prior works exploit the iterative nature of DNNs to profile a few training iterations. While such a strategy is sound…
▽ More
The ubiquity of deep neural networks (DNNs) continues to rise, making them a crucial application class for hardware optimizations. However, detailed profiling and characterization of DNN training remains difficult as these applications often run for hours to days on real hardware. Prior works exploit the iterative nature of DNNs to profile a few training iterations. While such a strategy is sound for networks like convolutional neural networks (CNNs), where the nature of the computation is largely input independent, we observe in this work that this approach is sub-optimal for sequence-based neural networks (SQNNs) such as recurrent neural networks (RNNs). The amount and nature of computations in SQNNs can vary for each input, resulting in heterogeneity across iterations. Thus, arbitrarily selecting a few iterations is insufficient to accurately summarize the behavior of the entire training run. To tackle this challenge, we carefully study the factors that impact SQNN training iterations and identify input sequence length as the key determining factor for variations across iterations. We then use this observation to characterize all iterations of an SQNN training run (requiring no profiling or simulation of the application) and select representative iterations, which we term SeqPoints. We analyze two state-of-the-art SQNNs, DeepSpeech2 and Google's Neural Machine Translation (GNMT), and show that SeqPoints can represent their entire training runs accurately, resulting in geomean errors of only 0.11% and 0.53%, respectively, when projecting overall runtime and 0.13% and 1.50% when projecting speedups due to architectural changes. This high accuracy is achieved while reducing the time needed for profiling by 345x and 214x for the two networks compared to full training runs. As a result, SeqPoint can enable analysis of SQNN training runs in mere minutes instead of hours or days.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
CODA: Enabling Co-location of Computation and Data for Near-Data Processing
Authors:
Hyojong Kim,
Ramyad Hadidi,
Lifeng Nai,
Hyesoon Kim,
Nuwan Jayasena,
Yasuko Eckert,
Onur Kayiran,
Gabriel H. Loh
Abstract:
Recent studies have demonstrated that near-data processing (NDP) is an effective technique for improving performance and energy efficiency of data-intensive workloads. However, leveraging NDP in realistic systems with multiple memory modules introduces a new challenge. In today's systems, where no computation occurs in memory modules, the physical address space is interleaved at a fine granularity…
▽ More
Recent studies have demonstrated that near-data processing (NDP) is an effective technique for improving performance and energy efficiency of data-intensive workloads. However, leveraging NDP in realistic systems with multiple memory modules introduces a new challenge. In today's systems, where no computation occurs in memory modules, the physical address space is interleaved at a fine granularity among all memory modules to help improve the utilization of processor-memory interfaces by distributing the memory traffic. However, this is at odds with efficient use of NDP, which requires careful placement of data in memory modules such that near-data computations and their exclusively used data can be localized in individual memory modules, while distributing shared data among memory modules to reduce hotspots. In order to address this new challenge, we propose a set of techniques that (1) enable collections of OS pages to either be fine-grain interleaved among memory modules (as is done today) or to be placed contiguously on individual memory modules (as is desirable for NDP private data), and (2) decide whether to localize or distribute each memory object based on its anticipated access pattern and steer computations to the memory where the data they access is located. Our evaluations across a wide range of workloads show that the proposed mechanism improves performance by 31% and reduces 38% remote data accesses over a baseline system that cannot exploit computate-data affinity characteristics.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
