A compositional game to fairly divide homogeneous cake
Authors:
Abel Jansma
Abstract:
The central question in the game theory of cake-cutting is how to fairly distribute a finite resource among multiple players. Most research has focused on how to do this for a heterogeneous cake in a situation where the players do not have access to each other's valuation function, but I argue that even sharing homogeneous cake can have interesting mechanism design. Here, I introduce a new game, b…
▽ More
The central question in the game theory of cake-cutting is how to fairly distribute a finite resource among multiple players. Most research has focused on how to do this for a heterogeneous cake in a situation where the players do not have access to each other's valuation function, but I argue that even sharing homogeneous cake can have interesting mechanism design. Here, I introduce a new game, based on the compositional structure of iterated cake-cutting, that in the case of a homogeneous cake has a Nash equilibrium where each of $n$ players gets $1/n$ of the cake. Furthermore, the equilibrium distribution is the result of just $n-1$ cuts, so each player gets a contiguous piece of cake. Naive composition of the `I cut you choose' rule leads to an exponentially unfair cake distribution with a Gini-coefficient that approaches 1, and suffers from a high Price of Anarchy. This cost is completely eliminated by the proposed \textit{Biggest Player} rule for composition which achieves decentralised and asynchronous fairness at linear Robertson-Webb complexity. After introducing the game, proving the fairness of the equilibrium, and analysing the incentive structure, the game is implemented in Haskell and the Open Game engine to make the compositional structure explicit.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2023; v1 submitted 5 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
Higher-Order Interactions and Their Duals Reveal Synergy and Logical Dependence beyond Shannon-Information
Authors:
Abel Jansma
Abstract:
Information-theoretic quantities reveal dependencies among variables in the structure of joint, marginal, and conditional entropies, but leave some fundamentally different systems indistinguishable. Furthermore, there is no consensus on how to construct and interpret a higher-order generalisation of mutual information (MI). In this manuscript, we show that a recently proposed model-free definition…
▽ More
Information-theoretic quantities reveal dependencies among variables in the structure of joint, marginal, and conditional entropies, but leave some fundamentally different systems indistinguishable. Furthermore, there is no consensus on how to construct and interpret a higher-order generalisation of mutual information (MI). In this manuscript, we show that a recently proposed model-free definition of higher-order interactions amongst binary variables (MFIs), like mutual information, is a Möbius inversion on a Boolean algebra, but of surprisal instead of entropy. This gives an information-theoretic interpretation to the MFIs, and by extension to Ising interactions. We study the dual objects to MI and MFIs on the order-reversed lattice, and find that dual MI is related to the previously studied differential mutual information, while dual interactions (outeractions) are interactions with respect to a different background state. Unlike mutual information, in- and outeractions uniquely identify all six 2-input logic gates, the dy- and triadic distributions, and different causal dynamics that are identical in terms of their Shannon-information content.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2023; v1 submitted 9 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
