-
Anomaly Detection in Offshore Wind Turbine Structures using Hierarchical Bayesian Modelling
Authors:
S. M. Smith,
A. J. Hughes,
T. A. Dardeno,
L. A. Bull,
N. Dervilis,
K. Worden
Abstract:
Population-based structural health monitoring (PBSHM), aims to share information between members of a population. An offshore wind (OW) farm could be considered as a population of nominally-identical wind-turbine structures. However, benign variations exist among members, such as geometry, sea-bed conditions and temperature differences. These factors could influence structural properties and there…
▽ More
Population-based structural health monitoring (PBSHM), aims to share information between members of a population. An offshore wind (OW) farm could be considered as a population of nominally-identical wind-turbine structures. However, benign variations exist among members, such as geometry, sea-bed conditions and temperature differences. These factors could influence structural properties and therefore the dynamic response, making it more difficult to detect structural problems via traditional SHM techniques. This paper explores the use of a hierarchical Bayesian model to infer expected soil stiffness distributions at both population and local levels, as a basis to perform anomaly detection, in the form of scour, for new and existing turbines. To do this, observations of natural frequency will be generated as though they are from a small population of wind turbines. Differences between individual observations will be introduced by postulating distributions over the soil stiffness and measurement noise, as well as reducing soil depth (to represent scour), in the case of anomaly detection.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Monitoring-Supported Value Generation for Managing Structures and Infrastructure Systems
Authors:
Antonios Kamariotis,
Eleni Chatzi,
Daniel Straub,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Kai Goebel,
Aidan J. Hughes,
Geert Lombaert,
Costas Papadimitriou,
Konstantinos G. Papakonstantinou,
Matteo Pozzi,
Michael Todd,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
To maximize its value, the design, development and implementation of Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) should focus on its role in facilitating decision support. In this position paper, we offer perspectives on the synergy between SHM and decision-making. We propose a classification of SHM use cases aligning with various dimensions that are closely linked to the respective decision contexts. The…
▽ More
To maximize its value, the design, development and implementation of Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) should focus on its role in facilitating decision support. In this position paper, we offer perspectives on the synergy between SHM and decision-making. We propose a classification of SHM use cases aligning with various dimensions that are closely linked to the respective decision contexts. The types of decisions that have to be supported by the SHM system within these settings are discussed along with the corresponding challenges. We provide an overview of different classes of models that are required for integrating SHM in the decision-making process to support management and operation and maintenance of structures and infrastructure systems. Fundamental decision-theoretic principles and state-of-the-art methods for optimizing maintenance and operational decision-making under uncertainty are briefly discussed. Finally, we offer a viewpoint on the appropriate course of action for quantifying, validating and maximizing the added value generated by SHM. This work aspires to synthesize the different perspectives of the SHM, Prognostic Health Management (PHM), and reliability communities, and deliver a roadmap towards monitoring-based decision support.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Quantifying the value of information transfer in population-based SHM
Authors:
Aidan J. Hughes,
Jack Poole,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Paul Gardner,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
Population-based structural health monitoring (PBSHM), seeks to address some of the limitations associated with data scarcity that arise in traditional SHM. A tenet of the population-based approach to SHM is that information can be shared between sufficiently-similar structures in order to improve predictive models. Transfer learning techniques, such as domain adaptation, have been shown to be a h…
▽ More
Population-based structural health monitoring (PBSHM), seeks to address some of the limitations associated with data scarcity that arise in traditional SHM. A tenet of the population-based approach to SHM is that information can be shared between sufficiently-similar structures in order to improve predictive models. Transfer learning techniques, such as domain adaptation, have been shown to be a highly-useful technology for sharing information between structures when develo** statistical classifiers for PBSHM. Nonetheless, transfer-learning techniques are not without their pitfalls. In some circumstances, for example if the data distributions associated with the structures within a population are dissimilar, applying transfer-learning methods can be detrimental to classification performance -- this phenomenon is known as negative transfer. Given the potentially-severe consequences of negative transfer, it is prudent for engineers to ask the question `when, what, and how should one transfer between structures?'.
The current paper aims to demonstrate a transfer-strategy decision process for a classification task for a population of simulated structures in the context of a representative SHM maintenance problem, supported by domain adaptation. The transfer decision framework is based upon the concept of expected value of information transfer. In order to compute the expected value of information transfer, predictions must be made regarding the classification (and decision performance) in the target domain following information transfer. In order to forecast the outcome of transfers, a probabilistic regression is used here to predict classification performance from a proxy for structural similarity based on the modal assurance criterion.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Sharing Information Between Machine Tools to Improve Surface Finish Forecasting
Authors:
Daniel R. Clarkson,
Lawrence A. Bull,
Tina A. Dardeno,
Chandula T. Wickramarachchi,
Elizabeth J. Cross,
Timothy J. Rogers,
Keith Worden,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Aidan J. Hughes
Abstract:
At present, most surface-quality prediction methods can only perform single-task prediction which results in under-utilised datasets, repetitive work and increased experimental costs. To counter this, the authors propose a Bayesian hierarchical model to predict surface-roughness measurements for a turning machining process. The hierarchical model is compared to multiple independent Bayesian linear…
▽ More
At present, most surface-quality prediction methods can only perform single-task prediction which results in under-utilised datasets, repetitive work and increased experimental costs. To counter this, the authors propose a Bayesian hierarchical model to predict surface-roughness measurements for a turning machining process. The hierarchical model is compared to multiple independent Bayesian linear regression models to showcase the benefits of partial pooling in a machining setting with respect to prediction accuracy and uncertainty quantification.
△ Less
Submitted 9 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A decision framework for selecting information-transfer strategies in population-based SHM
Authors:
Aidan J. Hughes,
Jack Poole,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Paul Gardner,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
Decision-support for the operation and maintenance of structures provides significant motivation for the development and implementation of structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. Unfortunately, the limited availability of labelled training data hinders the development of the statistical models on which these decision-support systems rely. Population-based SHM seeks to mitigate the impact of da…
▽ More
Decision-support for the operation and maintenance of structures provides significant motivation for the development and implementation of structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. Unfortunately, the limited availability of labelled training data hinders the development of the statistical models on which these decision-support systems rely. Population-based SHM seeks to mitigate the impact of data scarcity by using transfer learning techniques to share information between individual structures within a population. The current paper proposes a decision framework for selecting transfer strategies based upon a novel concept -- the expected value of information transfer -- such that negative transfer is avoided. By avoiding negative transfer, and by optimising information transfer strategies using the transfer-decision framework, one can reduce the costs associated with operating and maintaining structures, and improve safety.
△ Less
Submitted 13 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Towards risk-informed PBSHM: Populations as hierarchical systems
Authors:
Aidan J. Hughes,
Paul Gardner,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
The prospect of informed and optimal decision-making regarding the operation and maintenance (O&M) of structures provides impetus to the development of structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. A probabilistic risk-based framework for decision-making has already been proposed. However, in order to learn the statistical models necessary for decision-making, measured data from the structure of int…
▽ More
The prospect of informed and optimal decision-making regarding the operation and maintenance (O&M) of structures provides impetus to the development of structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. A probabilistic risk-based framework for decision-making has already been proposed. However, in order to learn the statistical models necessary for decision-making, measured data from the structure of interest are required. Unfortunately, these data are seldom available across the range of environmental and operational conditions necessary to ensure good generalisation of the model.
Recently, technologies have been developed that overcome this challenge, by extending SHM to populations of structures, such that valuable knowledge may be transferred between instances of structures that are sufficiently similar. This new approach is termed population-based structural heath monitoring (PBSHM).
The current paper presents a formal representation of populations of structures, such that risk-based decision processes may be specified within them. The population-based representation is an extension to the hierarchical representation of a structure used within the probabilistic risk-based decision framework to define fault trees. The result is a series, consisting of systems of systems ranging from the individual component level up to an inventory of heterogeneous populations. The current paper considers an inventory of wind farms as a motivating example and highlights the inferences and decisions that can be made within the hierarchical representation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Mitigating sampling bias in risk-based active learning via an EM algorithm
Authors:
Aidan J. Hughes,
Lawrence A. Bull,
Paul Gardner,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
Risk-based active learning is an approach to develo** statistical classifiers for online decision-support. In this approach, data-label querying is guided according to the expected value of perfect information for incipient data points. For SHM applications, the value of information is evaluated with respect to a maintenance decision process, and the data-label querying corresponds to the inspec…
▽ More
Risk-based active learning is an approach to develo** statistical classifiers for online decision-support. In this approach, data-label querying is guided according to the expected value of perfect information for incipient data points. For SHM applications, the value of information is evaluated with respect to a maintenance decision process, and the data-label querying corresponds to the inspection of a structure to determine its health state. Sampling bias is a known issue within active-learning paradigms; this occurs when an active learning process over- or undersamples specific regions of a feature-space, thereby resulting in a training set that is not representative of the underlying distribution. This bias ultimately degrades decision-making performance, and as a consequence, results in unnecessary costs incurred. The current paper outlines a risk-based approach to active learning that utilises a semi-supervised Gaussian mixture model. The semi-supervised approach counteracts sampling bias by incorporating pseudo-labels for unlabelled data via an EM algorithm. The approach is demonstrated on a numerical example representative of the decision processes found in SHM.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Improving decision-making via risk-based active learning: Probabilistic discriminative classifiers
Authors:
Aidan J. Hughes,
Paul Gardner,
Lawrence A. Bull,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
Gaining the ability to make informed decisions on operation and maintenance of structures provides motivation for the implementation of structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. However, descriptive labels for measured data corresponding to health-states of the monitored system are often unavailable. This issue limits the applicability of fully-supervised machine learning paradigms for the devel…
▽ More
Gaining the ability to make informed decisions on operation and maintenance of structures provides motivation for the implementation of structural health monitoring (SHM) systems. However, descriptive labels for measured data corresponding to health-states of the monitored system are often unavailable. This issue limits the applicability of fully-supervised machine learning paradigms for the development of statistical classifiers to be used in decision-support in SHM systems. One approach to dealing with this problem is risk-based active learning. In such an approach, data-label querying is guided according to the expected value of perfect information for incipient data points. For risk-based active learning in SHM, the value of information is evaluated with respect to a maintenance decision process, and the data-label querying corresponds to the inspection of a structure to determine its health state.
In the context of SHM, risk-based active learning has only been considered for generative classifiers. The current paper demonstrates several advantages of using an alternative type of classifier -- discriminative models. Using the Z24 Bridge dataset as a case study, it is shown that discriminative classifiers have benefits, in the context of SHM decision-support, including improved robustness to sampling bias, and reduced expenditure on structural inspections.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
On robust risk-based active-learning algorithms for enhanced decision support
Authors:
Aidan J. Hughes,
Lawrence A. Bull,
Paul Gardner,
Nikolaos Dervilis,
Keith Worden
Abstract:
Classification models are a fundamental component of physical-asset management technologies such as structural health monitoring (SHM) systems and digital twins. Previous work introduced risk-based active learning, an online approach for the development of statistical classifiers that takes into account the decision-support context in which they are applied. Decision-making is considered by prefer…
▽ More
Classification models are a fundamental component of physical-asset management technologies such as structural health monitoring (SHM) systems and digital twins. Previous work introduced risk-based active learning, an online approach for the development of statistical classifiers that takes into account the decision-support context in which they are applied. Decision-making is considered by preferentially querying data labels according to expected value of perfect information (EVPI). Although several benefits are gained by adopting a risk-based active learning approach, including improved decision-making performance, the algorithms suffer from issues relating to sampling bias as a result of the guided querying process. This sampling bias ultimately manifests as a decline in decision-making performance during the later stages of active learning, which in turn corresponds to lost resource/utility.
The current paper proposes two novel approaches to counteract the effects of sampling bias: semi-supervised learning, and discriminative classification models. These approaches are first visualised using a synthetic dataset, then subsequently applied to an experimental case study, specifically, the Z24 Bridge dataset. The semi-supervised learning approach is shown to have variable performance; with robustness to sampling bias dependent on the suitability of the generative distributions selected for the model with respect to each dataset. In contrast, the discriminative classifiers are shown to have excellent robustness to the effects of sampling bias. Moreover, it was found that the number of inspections made during a monitoring campaign, and therefore resource expenditure, could be reduced with the careful selection of the statistical classifiers used within a decision-supporting monitoring system.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2022; v1 submitted 7 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
On risk-based active learning for structural health monitoring
Authors:
A. J. Hughes,
L. A. Bull,
P. Gardner,
R. J. Barthorpe,
N. Dervilis,
K. Worden
Abstract:
A primary motivation for the development and implementation of structural health monitoring systems, is the prospect of gaining the ability to make informed decisions regarding the operation and maintenance of structures and infrastructure. Unfortunately, descriptive labels for measured data corresponding to health-state information for the structure of interest are seldom available prior to the i…
▽ More
A primary motivation for the development and implementation of structural health monitoring systems, is the prospect of gaining the ability to make informed decisions regarding the operation and maintenance of structures and infrastructure. Unfortunately, descriptive labels for measured data corresponding to health-state information for the structure of interest are seldom available prior to the implementation of a monitoring system. This issue limits the applicability of the traditional supervised and unsupervised approaches to machine learning in the development of statistical classifiers for decision-supporting SHM systems.
The current paper presents a risk-based formulation of active learning, in which the querying of class-label information is guided by the expected value of said information for each incipient data point. When applied to structural health monitoring, the querying of class labels can be mapped onto the inspection of a structure of interest in order to determine its health state. In the current paper, the risk-based active learning process is explained and visualised via a representative numerical example and subsequently applied to the Z24 Bridge benchmark. The results of the case studies indicate that a decision-maker's performance can be improved via the risk-based active learning of a statistical classifier, such that the decision process itself is taken into account.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2021; v1 submitted 12 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
