-
Reliability of CKA as a Similarity Measure in Deep Learning
Authors:
MohammadReza Davari,
Stefan Horoi,
Amine Natik,
Guillaume Lajoie,
Guy Wolf,
Eugene Belilovsky
Abstract:
Comparing learned neural representations in neural networks is a challenging but important problem, which has been approached in different ways. The Centered Kernel Alignment (CKA) similarity metric, particularly its linear variant, has recently become a popular approach and has been widely used to compare representations of a network's different layers, of architecturally similar networks trained…
▽ More
Comparing learned neural representations in neural networks is a challenging but important problem, which has been approached in different ways. The Centered Kernel Alignment (CKA) similarity metric, particularly its linear variant, has recently become a popular approach and has been widely used to compare representations of a network's different layers, of architecturally similar networks trained differently, or of models with different architectures trained on the same data. A wide variety of conclusions about similarity and dissimilarity of these various representations have been made using CKA. In this work we present analysis that formally characterizes CKA sensitivity to a large class of simple transformations, which can naturally occur in the context of modern machine learning. This provides a concrete explanation of CKA sensitivity to outliers, which has been observed in past works, and to transformations that preserve the linear separability of the data, an important generalization attribute. We empirically investigate several weaknesses of the CKA similarity metric, demonstrating situations in which it gives unexpected or counter-intuitive results. Finally we study approaches for modifying representations to maintain functional behaviour while changing the CKA value. Our results illustrate that, in many cases, the CKA value can be easily manipulated without substantial changes to the functional behaviour of the models, and call for caution when leveraging activation alignment metrics.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2022; v1 submitted 28 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Exploring the Geometry and Topology of Neural Network Loss Landscapes
Authors:
Stefan Horoi,
Jessie Huang,
Bastian Rieck,
Guillaume Lajoie,
Guy Wolf,
Smita Krishnaswamy
Abstract:
Recent work has established clear links between the generalization performance of trained neural networks and the geometry of their loss landscape near the local minima to which they converge. This suggests that qualitative and quantitative examination of the loss landscape geometry could yield insights about neural network generalization performance during training. To this end, researchers have…
▽ More
Recent work has established clear links between the generalization performance of trained neural networks and the geometry of their loss landscape near the local minima to which they converge. This suggests that qualitative and quantitative examination of the loss landscape geometry could yield insights about neural network generalization performance during training. To this end, researchers have proposed visualizing the loss landscape through the use of simple dimensionality reduction techniques. However, such visualization methods have been limited by their linear nature and only capture features in one or two dimensions, thus restricting sampling of the loss landscape to lines or planes. Here, we expand and improve upon these in three ways. First, we present a novel "jump and retrain" procedure for sampling relevant portions of the loss landscape. We show that the resulting sampled data holds more meaningful information about the network's ability to generalize. Next, we show that non-linear dimensionality reduction of the jump and retrain trajectories via PHATE, a trajectory and manifold-preserving method, allows us to visualize differences between networks that are generalizing well vs poorly. Finally, we combine PHATE trajectories with a computational homology characterization to quantify trajectory differences.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2022; v1 submitted 31 January, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Advantages of biologically-inspired adaptive neural activation in RNNs during learning
Authors:
Victor Geadah,
Giancarlo Kerg,
Stefan Horoi,
Guy Wolf,
Guillaume Lajoie
Abstract:
Dynamic adaptation in single-neuron response plays a fundamental role in neural coding in biological neural networks. Yet, most neural activation functions used in artificial networks are fixed and mostly considered as an inconsequential architecture choice. In this paper, we investigate nonlinear activation function adaptation over the large time scale of learning, and outline its impact on seque…
▽ More
Dynamic adaptation in single-neuron response plays a fundamental role in neural coding in biological neural networks. Yet, most neural activation functions used in artificial networks are fixed and mostly considered as an inconsequential architecture choice. In this paper, we investigate nonlinear activation function adaptation over the large time scale of learning, and outline its impact on sequential processing in recurrent neural networks. We introduce a novel parametric family of nonlinear activation functions, inspired by input-frequency response curves of biological neurons, which allows interpolation between well-known activation functions such as ReLU and sigmoid. Using simple numerical experiments and tools from dynamical systems and information theory, we study the role of neural activation features in learning dynamics. We find that activation adaptation provides distinct task-specific solutions and in some cases, improves both learning speed and performance. Importantly, we find that optimal activation features emerging from our parametric family are considerably different from typical functions used in the literature, suggesting that exploiting the gap between these usual configurations can help learning. Finally, we outline situations where neural activation adaptation alone may help mitigate changes in input statistics in a given task, suggesting mechanisms for transfer learning optimization.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Internal representation dynamics and geometry in recurrent neural networks
Authors:
Stefan Horoi,
Guillaume Lajoie,
Guy Wolf
Abstract:
The efficiency of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) in dealing with sequential data has long been established. However, unlike deep, and convolution networks where we can attribute the recognition of a certain feature to every layer, it is unclear what "sub-task" a single recurrent step or layer accomplishes. Our work seeks to shed light onto how a vanilla RNN implements a simple classification tas…
▽ More
The efficiency of recurrent neural networks (RNNs) in dealing with sequential data has long been established. However, unlike deep, and convolution networks where we can attribute the recognition of a certain feature to every layer, it is unclear what "sub-task" a single recurrent step or layer accomplishes. Our work seeks to shed light onto how a vanilla RNN implements a simple classification task by analysing the dynamics of the network and the geometric properties of its hidden states. We find that early internal representations are evocative of the real labels of the data but this information is not directly accessible to the output layer. Furthermore the network's dynamics and the sequence length are both critical to correct classifications even when there is no additional task relevant information provided.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2020; v1 submitted 9 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
