-
End-to-End Joint Target and Non-Target Speakers ASR
Authors:
Ryo Masumura,
Naoki Makishima,
Taiga Yamane,
Yoshihiko Yamazaki,
Saki Mizuno,
Mana Ihori,
Mihiro Uchida,
Keita Suzuki,
Hiroshi Sato,
Tomohiro Tanaka,
Akihiko Takashima,
Satoshi Suzuki,
Takafumi Moriya,
Nobukatsu Hojo,
Atsushi Ando
Abstract:
This paper proposes a novel automatic speech recognition (ASR) system that can transcribe individual speaker's speech while identifying whether they are target or non-target speakers from multi-talker overlapped speech. Target-speaker ASR systems are a promising way to only transcribe a target speaker's speech by enrolling the target speaker's information. However, in conversational ASR applicatio…
▽ More
This paper proposes a novel automatic speech recognition (ASR) system that can transcribe individual speaker's speech while identifying whether they are target or non-target speakers from multi-talker overlapped speech. Target-speaker ASR systems are a promising way to only transcribe a target speaker's speech by enrolling the target speaker's information. However, in conversational ASR applications, transcribing both the target speaker's speech and non-target speakers' ones is often required to understand interactive information. To naturally consider both target and non-target speakers in a single ASR model, our idea is to extend autoregressive modeling-based multi-talker ASR systems to utilize the enrollment speech of the target speaker. Our proposed ASR is performed by recursively generating both textual tokens and tokens that represent target or non-target speakers. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Downstream Task Agnostic Speech Enhancement with Self-Supervised Representation Loss
Authors:
Hiroshi Sato,
Ryo Masumura,
Tsubasa Ochiai,
Marc Delcroix,
Takafumi Moriya,
Takanori Ashihara,
Kentaro Shinayama,
Saki Mizuno,
Mana Ihori,
Tomohiro Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
Self-supervised learning (SSL) is the latest breakthrough in speech processing, especially for label-scarce downstream tasks by leveraging massive unlabeled audio data. The noise robustness of the SSL is one of the important challenges to expanding its application. We can use speech enhancement (SE) to tackle this issue. However, the mismatch between the SE model and SSL models potentially limits…
▽ More
Self-supervised learning (SSL) is the latest breakthrough in speech processing, especially for label-scarce downstream tasks by leveraging massive unlabeled audio data. The noise robustness of the SSL is one of the important challenges to expanding its application. We can use speech enhancement (SE) to tackle this issue. However, the mismatch between the SE model and SSL models potentially limits its effect. In this work, we propose a new SE training criterion that minimizes the distance between clean and enhanced signals in the feature representation of the SSL model to alleviate the mismatch. We expect that the loss in the SSL domain could guide SE training to preserve or enhance various levels of characteristics of the speech signals that may be required for high-level downstream tasks. Experiments show that our proposal improves the performance of an SE and SSL pipeline on five downstream tasks with noisy input while maintaining the SE performance.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
MaskCycleGAN-VC: Learning Non-parallel Voice Conversion with Filling in Frames
Authors:
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is a technique for training voice converters without a parallel corpus. Cycle-consistent adversarial network-based VCs (CycleGAN-VC and CycleGAN-VC2) are widely accepted as benchmark methods. However, owing to their insufficient ability to grasp time-frequency structures, their application is limited to mel-cepstrum conversion and not mel-spectrogram conversion d…
▽ More
Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is a technique for training voice converters without a parallel corpus. Cycle-consistent adversarial network-based VCs (CycleGAN-VC and CycleGAN-VC2) are widely accepted as benchmark methods. However, owing to their insufficient ability to grasp time-frequency structures, their application is limited to mel-cepstrum conversion and not mel-spectrogram conversion despite recent advances in mel-spectrogram vocoders. To overcome this, CycleGAN-VC3, an improved variant of CycleGAN-VC2 that incorporates an additional module called time-frequency adaptive normalization (TFAN), has been proposed. However, an increase in the number of learned parameters is imposed. As an alternative, we propose MaskCycleGAN-VC, which is another extension of CycleGAN-VC2 and is trained using a novel auxiliary task called filling in frames (FIF). With FIF, we apply a temporal mask to the input mel-spectrogram and encourage the converter to fill in missing frames based on surrounding frames. This task allows the converter to learn time-frequency structures in a self-supervised manner and eliminates the need for an additional module such as TFAN. A subjective evaluation of the naturalness and speaker similarity showed that MaskCycleGAN-VC outperformed both CycleGAN-VC2 and CycleGAN-VC3 with a model size similar to that of CycleGAN-VC2. Audio samples are available at http://www.kecl.ntt.co.jp/people/kaneko.takuhiro/projects/maskcyclegan-vc/index.html.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
CycleGAN-VC3: Examining and Improving CycleGAN-VCs for Mel-spectrogram Conversion
Authors:
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is a technique for learning map**s between source and target speeches without using a parallel corpus. Recently, cycle-consistent adversarial network (CycleGAN)-VC and CycleGAN-VC2 have shown promising results regarding this problem and have been widely used as benchmark methods. However, owing to the ambiguity of the effectiveness of CycleGAN-VC/VC2 for mel-sp…
▽ More
Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is a technique for learning map**s between source and target speeches without using a parallel corpus. Recently, cycle-consistent adversarial network (CycleGAN)-VC and CycleGAN-VC2 have shown promising results regarding this problem and have been widely used as benchmark methods. However, owing to the ambiguity of the effectiveness of CycleGAN-VC/VC2 for mel-spectrogram conversion, they are typically used for mel-cepstrum conversion even when comparative methods employ mel-spectrogram as a conversion target. To address this, we examined the applicability of CycleGAN-VC/VC2 to mel-spectrogram conversion. Through initial experiments, we discovered that their direct applications compromised the time-frequency structure that should be preserved during conversion. To remedy this, we propose CycleGAN-VC3, an improvement of CycleGAN-VC2 that incorporates time-frequency adaptive normalization (TFAN). Using TFAN, we can adjust the scale and bias of the converted features while reflecting the time-frequency structure of the source mel-spectrogram. We evaluated CycleGAN-VC3 on inter-gender and intra-gender non-parallel VC. A subjective evaluation of naturalness and similarity showed that for every VC pair, CycleGAN-VC3 outperforms or is competitive with the two types of CycleGAN-VC2, one of which was applied to mel-cepstrum and the other to mel-spectrogram. Audio samples are available at http://www.kecl.ntt.co.jp/people/kaneko.takuhiro/projects/cyclegan-vc3/index.html.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
VoiceGrad: Non-Parallel Any-to-Many Voice Conversion with Annealed Langevin Dynamics
Authors:
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo,
Shogo Seki
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a non-parallel any-to-many voice conversion (VC) method termed VoiceGrad. Inspired by WaveGrad, a recently introduced novel waveform generation method, VoiceGrad is based upon the concepts of score matching and Langevin dynamics. It uses weighted denoising score matching to train a score approximator, a fully convolutional network with a U-Net structure designed to predic…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a non-parallel any-to-many voice conversion (VC) method termed VoiceGrad. Inspired by WaveGrad, a recently introduced novel waveform generation method, VoiceGrad is based upon the concepts of score matching and Langevin dynamics. It uses weighted denoising score matching to train a score approximator, a fully convolutional network with a U-Net structure designed to predict the gradient of the log density of the speech feature sequences of multiple speakers, and performs VC by using annealed Langevin dynamics to iteratively update an input feature sequence towards the nearest stationary point of the target distribution based on the trained score approximator network. Thanks to the nature of this concept, VoiceGrad enables any-to-many VC, a VC scenario in which the speaker of input speech can be arbitrary, and allows for non-parallel training, which requires no parallel utterances or transcriptions.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2024; v1 submitted 6 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Many-to-Many Voice Transformer Network
Authors:
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Wen-Chin Huang,
Kou Tanaka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Nobukatsu Hojo,
Tomoki Toda
Abstract:
This paper proposes a voice conversion (VC) method based on a sequence-to-sequence (S2S) learning framework, which enables simultaneous conversion of the voice characteristics, pitch contour, and duration of input speech. We previously proposed an S2S-based VC method using a transformer network architecture called the voice transformer network (VTN). The original VTN was designed to learn only a m…
▽ More
This paper proposes a voice conversion (VC) method based on a sequence-to-sequence (S2S) learning framework, which enables simultaneous conversion of the voice characteristics, pitch contour, and duration of input speech. We previously proposed an S2S-based VC method using a transformer network architecture called the voice transformer network (VTN). The original VTN was designed to learn only a map** of speech feature sequences from one speaker to another. The main idea we propose is an extension of the original VTN that can simultaneously learn map**s among multiple speakers. This extension called the many-to-many VTN makes it able to fully use available training data collected from multiple speakers by capturing common latent features that can be shared across different speakers. It also allows us to introduce a training loss called the identity map** loss to ensure that the input feature sequence will remain unchanged when the source and target speaker indices are the same. Using this particular loss for model training has been found to be extremely effective in improving the performance of the model at test time. We conducted speaker identity conversion experiments and found that our model obtained higher sound quality and speaker similarity than baseline methods. We also found that our model, with a slight modification to its architecture, could handle any-to-many conversion tasks reasonably well.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2020; v1 submitted 18 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
StarGAN-VC2: Rethinking Conditional Methods for StarGAN-Based Voice Conversion
Authors:
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
Non-parallel multi-domain voice conversion (VC) is a technique for learning map**s among multiple domains without relying on parallel data. This is important but challenging owing to the requirement of learning multiple map**s and the non-availability of explicit supervision. Recently, StarGAN-VC has garnered attention owing to its ability to solve this problem only using a single generator. H…
▽ More
Non-parallel multi-domain voice conversion (VC) is a technique for learning map**s among multiple domains without relying on parallel data. This is important but challenging owing to the requirement of learning multiple map**s and the non-availability of explicit supervision. Recently, StarGAN-VC has garnered attention owing to its ability to solve this problem only using a single generator. However, there is still a gap between real and converted speech. To bridge this gap, we rethink conditional methods of StarGAN-VC, which are key components for achieving non-parallel multi-domain VC in a single model, and propose an improved variant called StarGAN-VC2. Particularly, we rethink conditional methods in two aspects: training objectives and network architectures. For the former, we propose a source-and-target conditional adversarial loss that allows all source domain data to be convertible to the target domain data. For the latter, we introduce a modulation-based conditional method that can transform the modulation of the acoustic feature in a domain-specific manner. We evaluated our methods on non-parallel multi-speaker VC. An objective evaluation demonstrates that our proposed methods improve speech quality in terms of both global and local structure measures. Furthermore, a subjective evaluation shows that StarGAN-VC2 outperforms StarGAN-VC in terms of naturalness and speaker similarity. The converted speech samples are provided at http://www.kecl.ntt.co.jp/people/kaneko.takuhiro/projects/stargan-vc2/index.html.
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2019; v1 submitted 29 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
CycleGAN-VC2: Improved CycleGAN-based Non-parallel Voice Conversion
Authors:
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is a technique for learning the map** from source to target speech without relying on parallel data. This is an important task, but it has been challenging due to the disadvantages of the training conditions. Recently, CycleGAN-VC has provided a breakthrough and performed comparably to a parallel VC method without relying on any extra data, modules, or time ali…
▽ More
Non-parallel voice conversion (VC) is a technique for learning the map** from source to target speech without relying on parallel data. This is an important task, but it has been challenging due to the disadvantages of the training conditions. Recently, CycleGAN-VC has provided a breakthrough and performed comparably to a parallel VC method without relying on any extra data, modules, or time alignment procedures. However, there is still a large gap between the real target and converted speech, and bridging this gap remains a challenge. To reduce this gap, we propose CycleGAN-VC2, which is an improved version of CycleGAN-VC incorporating three new techniques: an improved objective (two-step adversarial losses), improved generator (2-1-2D CNN), and improved discriminator (PatchGAN). We evaluated our method on a non-parallel VC task and analyzed the effect of each technique in detail. An objective evaluation showed that these techniques help bring the converted feature sequence closer to the target in terms of both global and local structures, which we assess by using Mel-cepstral distortion and modulation spectra distance, respectively. A subjective evaluation showed that CycleGAN-VC2 outperforms CycleGAN-VC in terms of naturalness and similarity for every speaker pair, including intra-gender and inter-gender pairs.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
WaveCycleGAN2: Time-domain Neural Post-filter for Speech Waveform Generation
Authors:
Kou Tanaka,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
WaveCycleGAN has recently been proposed to bridge the gap between natural and synthesized speech waveforms in statistical parametric speech synthesis and provides fast inference with a moving average model rather than an autoregressive model and high-quality speech synthesis with the adversarial training. However, the human ear can still distinguish the processed speech waveforms from natural ones…
▽ More
WaveCycleGAN has recently been proposed to bridge the gap between natural and synthesized speech waveforms in statistical parametric speech synthesis and provides fast inference with a moving average model rather than an autoregressive model and high-quality speech synthesis with the adversarial training. However, the human ear can still distinguish the processed speech waveforms from natural ones. One possible cause of this distinguishability is the aliasing observed in the processed speech waveform via down/up-sampling modules. To solve the aliasing and provide higher quality speech synthesis, we propose WaveCycleGAN2, which 1) uses generators without down/up-sampling modules and 2) combines discriminators of the waveform domain and acoustic parameter domain. The results show that the proposed method 1) alleviates the aliasing well, 2) is useful for both speech waveforms generated by analysis-and-synthesis and statistical parametric speech synthesis, and 3) achieves a mean opinion score comparable to those of natural speech and speech synthesized by WaveNet (open WaveNet) and WaveGlow while processing speech samples at a rate of more than 150 kHz on an NVIDIA Tesla P100.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2019; v1 submitted 5 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
AttS2S-VC: Sequence-to-Sequence Voice Conversion with Attention and Context Preservation Mechanisms
Authors:
Kou Tanaka,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
This paper describes a method based on a sequence-to-sequence learning (Seq2Seq) with attention and context preservation mechanism for voice conversion (VC) tasks. Seq2Seq has been outstanding at numerous tasks involving sequence modeling such as speech synthesis and recognition, machine translation, and image captioning. In contrast to current VC techniques, our method 1) stabilizes and accelerat…
▽ More
This paper describes a method based on a sequence-to-sequence learning (Seq2Seq) with attention and context preservation mechanism for voice conversion (VC) tasks. Seq2Seq has been outstanding at numerous tasks involving sequence modeling such as speech synthesis and recognition, machine translation, and image captioning. In contrast to current VC techniques, our method 1) stabilizes and accelerates the training procedure by considering guided attention and proposed context preservation losses, 2) allows not only spectral envelopes but also fundamental frequency contours and durations of speech to be converted, 3) requires no context information such as phoneme labels, and 4) requires no time-aligned source and target speech data in advance. In our experiment, the proposed VC framework can be trained in only one day, using only one GPU of an NVIDIA Tesla K80, while the quality of the synthesized speech is higher than that of speech converted by Gaussian mixture model-based VC and is comparable to that of speech generated by recurrent neural network-based text-to-speech synthesis, which can be regarded as an upper limit on VC performance.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
ConvS2S-VC: Fully convolutional sequence-to-sequence voice conversion
Authors:
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Kou Tanaka,
Damian Kwasny,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
This paper proposes a voice conversion (VC) method using sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq or S2S) learning, which flexibly converts not only the voice characteristics but also the pitch contour and duration of input speech. The proposed method, called ConvS2S-VC, has three key features. First, it uses a model with a fully convolutional architecture. This is particularly advantageous in that it is sui…
▽ More
This paper proposes a voice conversion (VC) method using sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq or S2S) learning, which flexibly converts not only the voice characteristics but also the pitch contour and duration of input speech. The proposed method, called ConvS2S-VC, has three key features. First, it uses a model with a fully convolutional architecture. This is particularly advantageous in that it is suitable for parallel computations using GPUs. It is also beneficial since it enables effective normalization techniques such as batch normalization to be used for all the hidden layers in the networks. Second, it achieves many-to-many conversion by simultaneously learning map**s among multiple speakers using only a single model instead of separately learning map**s between each speaker pair using a different model. This enables the model to fully utilize available training data collected from multiple speakers by capturing common latent features that can be shared across different speakers. Owing to this structure, our model works reasonably well even without source speaker information, thus making it able to handle any-to-many conversion tasks. Third, we introduce a mechanism, called the conditional batch normalization that switches batch normalization layers in accordance with the target speaker. This particular mechanism has been found to be extremely effective for our many-to-many conversion model. We conducted speaker identity conversion experiments and found that ConvS2S-VC obtained higher sound quality and speaker similarity than baseline methods. We also found from audio examples that it could perform well in various tasks including emotional expression conversion, electrolaryngeal speech enhancement, and English accent conversion.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2020; v1 submitted 5 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
WaveCycleGAN: Synthetic-to-natural speech waveform conversion using cycle-consistent adversarial networks
Authors:
Kou Tanaka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Nobukatsu Hojo,
Hirokazu Kameoka
Abstract:
We propose a learning-based filter that allows us to directly modify a synthetic speech waveform into a natural speech waveform. Speech-processing systems using a vocoder framework such as statistical parametric speech synthesis and voice conversion are convenient especially for a limited number of data because it is possible to represent and process interpretable acoustic features over a compact…
▽ More
We propose a learning-based filter that allows us to directly modify a synthetic speech waveform into a natural speech waveform. Speech-processing systems using a vocoder framework such as statistical parametric speech synthesis and voice conversion are convenient especially for a limited number of data because it is possible to represent and process interpretable acoustic features over a compact space, such as the fundamental frequency (F0) and mel-cepstrum. However, a well-known problem that leads to the quality degradation of generated speech is an over-smoothing effect that eliminates some detailed structure of generated/converted acoustic features. To address this issue, we propose a synthetic-to-natural speech waveform conversion technique that uses cycle-consistent adversarial networks and which does not require any explicit assumption about speech waveform in adversarial learning. In contrast to current techniques, since our modification is performed at the waveform level, we expect that the proposed method will also make it possible to generate `vocoder-less' sounding speech even if the input speech is synthesized using a vocoder framework. The experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method can 1) alleviate the over-smoothing effect of the acoustic features despite the direct modification method used for the waveform and 2) greatly improve the naturalness of the generated speech sounds.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2018; v1 submitted 25 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
ACVAE-VC: Non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion with auxiliary classifier variational autoencoder
Authors:
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
This paper proposes a non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion (VC) method using a variant of the conditional variational autoencoder (VAE) called an auxiliary classifier VAE (ACVAE). The proposed method has three key features. First, it adopts fully convolutional architectures to construct the encoder and decoder networks so that the networks can learn conversion rules that capture time depende…
▽ More
This paper proposes a non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion (VC) method using a variant of the conditional variational autoencoder (VAE) called an auxiliary classifier VAE (ACVAE). The proposed method has three key features. First, it adopts fully convolutional architectures to construct the encoder and decoder networks so that the networks can learn conversion rules that capture time dependencies in the acoustic feature sequences of source and target speech. Second, it uses an information-theoretic regularization for the model training to ensure that the information in the attribute class label will not be lost in the conversion process. With regular CVAEs, the encoder and decoder are free to ignore the attribute class label input. This can be problematic since in such a situation, the attribute class label will have little effect on controlling the voice characteristics of input speech at test time. Such situations can be avoided by introducing an auxiliary classifier and training the encoder and decoder so that the attribute classes of the decoder outputs are correctly predicted by the classifier. Third, it avoids producing buzzy-sounding speech at test time by simply transplanting the spectral details of the input speech into its converted version. Subjective evaluation experiments revealed that this simple method worked reasonably well in a non-parallel many-to-many speaker identity conversion task.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2020; v1 submitted 13 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
StarGAN-VC: Non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion with star generative adversarial networks
Authors:
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo
Abstract:
This paper proposes a method that allows non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion (VC) by using a variant of a generative adversarial network (GAN) called StarGAN. Our method, which we call StarGAN-VC, is noteworthy in that it (1) requires no parallel utterances, transcriptions, or time alignment procedures for speech generator training, (2) simultaneously learns many-to-many map**s across dif…
▽ More
This paper proposes a method that allows non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion (VC) by using a variant of a generative adversarial network (GAN) called StarGAN. Our method, which we call StarGAN-VC, is noteworthy in that it (1) requires no parallel utterances, transcriptions, or time alignment procedures for speech generator training, (2) simultaneously learns many-to-many map**s across different attribute domains using a single generator network, (3) is able to generate converted speech signals quickly enough to allow real-time implementations and (4) requires only several minutes of training examples to generate reasonably realistic-sounding speech. Subjective evaluation experiments on a non-parallel many-to-many speaker identity conversion task revealed that the proposed method obtained higher sound quality and speaker similarity than a state-of-the-art method based on variational autoencoding GANs.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2018; v1 submitted 6 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Generative adversarial network-based approach to signal reconstruction from magnitude spectrograms
Authors:
Keisuke Oyamada,
Hirokazu Kameoka,
Takuhiro Kaneko,
Kou Tanaka,
Nobukatsu Hojo,
Hiroyasu Ando
Abstract:
In this paper, we address the problem of reconstructing a time-domain signal (or a phase spectrogram) solely from a magnitude spectrogram. Since magnitude spectrograms do not contain phase information, we must restore or infer phase information to reconstruct a time-domain signal. One widely used approach for dealing with the signal reconstruction problem was proposed by Griffin and Lim. This meth…
▽ More
In this paper, we address the problem of reconstructing a time-domain signal (or a phase spectrogram) solely from a magnitude spectrogram. Since magnitude spectrograms do not contain phase information, we must restore or infer phase information to reconstruct a time-domain signal. One widely used approach for dealing with the signal reconstruction problem was proposed by Griffin and Lim. This method usually requires many iterations for the signal reconstruction process and depending on the inputs, it does not always produce high-quality audio signals. To overcome these shortcomings, we apply a learning-based approach to the signal reconstruction problem by modeling the signal reconstruction process using a deep neural network and training it using the idea of a generative adversarial network. Experimental evaluations revealed that our method was able to reconstruct signals faster with higher quality than the Griffin-Lim method.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
