-
Variable binding and substitution for (nameless) dummies
Authors:
André Hirschowitz,
Tom Hirschowitz,
Ambroise Lafont,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
By abstracting over well-known properties of De Bruijn's representation with nameless dummies, we design a new theory of syntax with variable binding and capture-avoiding substitution. We propose it as a simpler alternative to Fiore, Plotkin, and Turi's approach, with which we establish a strong formal link. We also show that our theory easily incorporates simple types and equations between terms.
By abstracting over well-known properties of De Bruijn's representation with nameless dummies, we design a new theory of syntax with variable binding and capture-avoiding substitution. We propose it as a simpler alternative to Fiore, Plotkin, and Turi's approach, with which we establish a strong formal link. We also show that our theory easily incorporates simple types and equations between terms.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024; v1 submitted 6 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Modules over monads and operational semantics (expanded version)
Authors:
André Hirschowitz,
Tom Hirschowitz,
Ambroise Lafont
Abstract:
This paper is a contribution to the search for efficient and high-level mathematical tools to specify and reason about (abstract) programming languages or calculi. Generalising the reduction monads of Ahrens et al., we introduce transition monads, thus covering new applications such as lambda-bar-mu-calculus, pi-calculus, Positive GSOS specifications, differential lambda-calculus, and the big-step…
▽ More
This paper is a contribution to the search for efficient and high-level mathematical tools to specify and reason about (abstract) programming languages or calculi. Generalising the reduction monads of Ahrens et al., we introduce transition monads, thus covering new applications such as lambda-bar-mu-calculus, pi-calculus, Positive GSOS specifications, differential lambda-calculus, and the big-step, simply-typed, call-by-value lambda-calculus. Moreover, we design a suitable notion of signature for transition monads.
△ Less
Submitted 29 July, 2022; v1 submitted 11 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Reduction Monads and Their Signatures
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
André Hirschowitz,
Ambroise Lafont,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
In this work, we study 'reduction monads', which are essentially the same as monads relative to the free functor from sets into multigraphs. Reduction monads account for two aspects of the lambda calculus: on the one hand, in the monadic viewpoint, the lambda calculus is an object equipped with a well-behaved substitution; on the other hand, in the graphical viewpoint, it is an oriented multigraph…
▽ More
In this work, we study 'reduction monads', which are essentially the same as monads relative to the free functor from sets into multigraphs. Reduction monads account for two aspects of the lambda calculus: on the one hand, in the monadic viewpoint, the lambda calculus is an object equipped with a well-behaved substitution; on the other hand, in the graphical viewpoint, it is an oriented multigraph whose vertices are terms and whose edges witness the reductions between two terms.
We study presentations of reduction monads. To this end, we propose a notion of 'reduction signature'. As usual, such a signature plays the role of a virtual presentation, and specifies arities for generating operations---possibly subject to equations---together with arities for generating reduction rules. For each such signature, we define a category of models; any model is, in particular, a reduction monad. If the initial object of this category of models exists, we call it the 'reduction monad presented (or specified) by the given reduction signature'.
Our main result identifies a class of reduction signatures which specify a reduction monad in the above sense. We show in the examples that our approach covers several standard variants of the lambda calculus.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Modular specification of monads through higher-order presentations
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
André Hirschowitz,
Ambroise Lafont,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
In their work on second-order equational logic, Fiore and Hur have studied presentations of simply typed languages by generating binding constructions and equations among them. To each pair consisting of a binding signature and a set of equations, they associate a category of `models', and they give a monadicity result which implies that this category has an initial object, which is the language p…
▽ More
In their work on second-order equational logic, Fiore and Hur have studied presentations of simply typed languages by generating binding constructions and equations among them. To each pair consisting of a binding signature and a set of equations, they associate a category of `models', and they give a monadicity result which implies that this category has an initial object, which is the language presented by the pair.
In the present work, we propose, for the untyped setting, a variant of their approach where monads and modules over them are the central notions. More precisely, we study, for monads over sets, presentations by generating (`higher-order') operations and equations among them. We consider a notion of 2-signature which allows to specify a monad with a family of binding operations subject to a family of equations, as is the case for the paradigmatic example of the lambda calculus, specified by its two standard constructions (application and abstraction) subject to $β$- and $η$-equalities. Such a 2-signature is hence a pair $(Σ,E)$ of a binding signature $Σ$ and a family $E$ of equations for $Σ$. This notion of 2-signature has been introduced earlier by Ahrens in a slightly different context.
We associate, to each 2-signature $(Σ,E)$, a category of `models of $(Σ,E)$; and we say that a 2-signature is `effective' if this category has an initial object; the monad underlying this (essentially unique) object is the `monad specified by the 2-signature'. Not every 2-signature is effective; we identify a class of 2-signatures, which we call `algebraic', that are effective.
Importantly, our 2-signatures together with their models enjoy `modularity': when we glue (algebraic) 2-signatures together, their initial models are glued accordingly.
We provide a computer formalization for our main results.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Presentable signatures and initial semantics
Authors:
Benedikt Ahrens,
André Hirschowitz,
Ambroise Lafont,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
We present a device for specifying and reasoning about syntax for datatypes, programming languages, and logic calculi. More precisely, we study a notion of "signature" for specifying syntactic constructions.
In the spirit of Initial Semantics, we define the "syntax generated by a signature" to be the initial object -- if it exists -- in a suitable category of models. In our framework, the existe…
▽ More
We present a device for specifying and reasoning about syntax for datatypes, programming languages, and logic calculi. More precisely, we study a notion of "signature" for specifying syntactic constructions.
In the spirit of Initial Semantics, we define the "syntax generated by a signature" to be the initial object -- if it exists -- in a suitable category of models. In our framework, the existence of an associated syntax to a signature is not automatically guaranteed. We identify, via the notion of presentation of a signature, a large class of signatures that do generate a syntax.
Our (presentable) signatures subsume classical algebraic signatures (i.e., signatures for languages with variable binding, such as the pure lambda calculus) and extend them to include several other significant examples of syntactic constructions.
One key feature of our notions of signature, syntax, and presentation is that they are highly compositional, in the sense that complex examples can be obtained by gluing simpler ones. Moreover, through the Initial Semantics approach, our framework provides, beyond the desired algebra of terms, a well-behaved substitution and the induction and recursion principles associated to the syntax.
This paper builds upon ideas from a previous attempt by Hirschowitz-Maggesi, which, in turn, was directly inspired by some earlier work of Ghani-Uustalu-Hamana and Matthes-Uustalu.
The main results presented in the paper are computer-checked within the UniMath system.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2021; v1 submitted 9 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Initial Semantics for Strengthened Signatures
Authors:
André Hirschowitz,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
We give a new general definition of arity, yielding the companion notions of signature and associated syntax. This setting is modular in the sense requested by Ghani and Uustalu: merging two extensions of syntax corresponds to building an amalgamated sum. These signatures are too general in the sense that we are not able to prove the existence of an associated syntax in this general context. So we…
▽ More
We give a new general definition of arity, yielding the companion notions of signature and associated syntax. This setting is modular in the sense requested by Ghani and Uustalu: merging two extensions of syntax corresponds to building an amalgamated sum. These signatures are too general in the sense that we are not able to prove the existence of an associated syntax in this general context. So we have to select arities and signatures for which there exists the desired initial monad. For this, we follow a track opened by Matthes and Uustalu: we introduce a notion of strengthened arity and prove that the corresponding signatures have initial semantics (i.e. associated syntax). Our strengthened arities admit colimits, which allows the treatment of the λ-calculus with explicit substitution.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Contraction-free proofs and finitary games for Linear Logic
Authors:
André Hirschowitz,
Michel Hirschowitz,
Tom Hirschowitz
Abstract:
In the standard sequent presentations of Girard's Linear Logic (LL), there are two "non-decreasing" rules, where the premises are not smaller than the conclusion, namely the cut and the contraction rules. It is a universal concern to eliminate the cut rule. We show that, using an admissible modification of the tensor rule, contractions can be eliminated, and that cuts can be simultaneously limit…
▽ More
In the standard sequent presentations of Girard's Linear Logic (LL), there are two "non-decreasing" rules, where the premises are not smaller than the conclusion, namely the cut and the contraction rules. It is a universal concern to eliminate the cut rule. We show that, using an admissible modification of the tensor rule, contractions can be eliminated, and that cuts can be simultaneously limited to a single initial occurrence. This view leads to a consistent, but incomplete game model for LL with exponentials, which is finitary, in the sense that each play is finite. The game is based on a set of inference rules which does not enjoy cut elimination. Nevertheless, the cut rule is valid in the model.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2009;
originally announced May 2009.
-
Topological Observations on Multiplicative Additive Linear Logic
Authors:
André Hirschowitz,
Michel Hirschowitz,
Tom Hirschowitz
Abstract:
As an attempt to uncover the topological nature of composition of strategies in game semantics, we present a ``topological'' game for Multiplicative Additive Linear Logic without propositional variables, including cut moves. We recast the notion of (winning) strategy and the question of cut elimination in this context, and prove a cut elimination theorem. Finally, we prove soundness and complete…
▽ More
As an attempt to uncover the topological nature of composition of strategies in game semantics, we present a ``topological'' game for Multiplicative Additive Linear Logic without propositional variables, including cut moves. We recast the notion of (winning) strategy and the question of cut elimination in this context, and prove a cut elimination theorem. Finally, we prove soundness and completeness. The topology plays a crucial role, in particular through the fact that strategies form a sheaf.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
Higher-order theories
Authors:
Andre' Hirschowitz,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
We extend our approach to abstract syntax (with binding constructions) through modules and linearity. First we give a new general definition of arity, yielding the companion notion of signature. Then we obtain a modularity result as requested by Ghani and Uustalu (2003): in our setting, merging two extensions of syntax corresponds to building an amalgamated sum. Finally we define a natural notio…
▽ More
We extend our approach to abstract syntax (with binding constructions) through modules and linearity. First we give a new general definition of arity, yielding the companion notion of signature. Then we obtain a modularity result as requested by Ghani and Uustalu (2003): in our setting, merging two extensions of syntax corresponds to building an amalgamated sum. Finally we define a natural notion of equation concerning a signature and prove the existence of an initial semantics for a so-called representable signature equipped with a set of equations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2008; v1 submitted 22 April, 2007;
originally announced April 2007.
-
Modules over Monads and Linearity
Authors:
André Hirschowitz,
Marco Maggesi
Abstract:
Inspired by the classical theory of modules over a monoid, we give a first account of the natural notion of module over a monad. The associated notion of morphism of left modules ("Linear" natural transformations) captures an important property of compatibility with substitution, in the heterogeneous case where "terms" and variables therein could be of different types as well as in the homogeneo…
▽ More
Inspired by the classical theory of modules over a monoid, we give a first account of the natural notion of module over a monad. The associated notion of morphism of left modules ("Linear" natural transformations) captures an important property of compatibility with substitution, in the heterogeneous case where "terms" and variables therein could be of different types as well as in the homogeneous case. In this paper, we present basic constructions of modules and we show examples concerning in particular abstract syntax and lambda-calculus.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2007; v1 submitted 11 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
