-
High-level Stream Processing: A Complementary Analysis of Fault Recovery
Authors:
Adriano Vogel,
Sören Henning,
Esteban Perez-Wohlfeil,
Otmar Ertl,
Rick Rabiser
Abstract:
Parallel computing is very important to accelerate the performance of software systems. Additionally, considering that a recurring challenge is to process high data volumes continuously, stream processing emerged as a paradigm and software architectural style. Several software systems rely on stream processing to deliver scalable performance, whereas open-source frameworks provide coding abstracti…
▽ More
Parallel computing is very important to accelerate the performance of software systems. Additionally, considering that a recurring challenge is to process high data volumes continuously, stream processing emerged as a paradigm and software architectural style. Several software systems rely on stream processing to deliver scalable performance, whereas open-source frameworks provide coding abstraction and high-level parallel computing. Although stream processing's performance is being extensively studied, the measurement of fault tolerance--a key abstraction offered by stream processing frameworks--has still not been adequately measured with comprehensive testbeds. In this work, we extend the previous fault recovery measurements with an exploratory analysis of the configuration space, additional experimental measurements, and analysis of improvement opportunities. We focus on robust deployment setups inspired by requirements for near real-time analytics of a large cloud observability platform. The results indicate significant potential for improving fault recovery and performance. However, these improvements entail grappling with configuration complexities, particularly in identifying and selecting the configurations to be fine-tuned and determining the appropriate values for them. Therefore, new abstractions for transparent configuration tuning are also needed for large-scale industry setups. We believe that more software engineering efforts are needed to provide insights into potential abstractions and how to achieve them. The stream processing community and industry practitioners could also benefit from more interactions with the high-level parallel programming community, whose expertise and insights on making parallel programming more productive and efficient could be extended.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
A Comprehensive Benchmarking Analysis of Fault Recovery in Stream Processing Frameworks
Authors:
Adriano Vogel,
Sören Henning,
Esteban Perez-Wohlfeil,
Otmar Ertl,
Rick Rabiser
Abstract:
Nowadays, several software systems rely on stream processing architectures to deliver scalable performance and handle large volumes of data in near real-time. Stream processing frameworks facilitate scalable computing by distributing the application's execution across multiple machines. Despite performance being extensively studied, the measurement of fault tolerance-a key feature offered by strea…
▽ More
Nowadays, several software systems rely on stream processing architectures to deliver scalable performance and handle large volumes of data in near real-time. Stream processing frameworks facilitate scalable computing by distributing the application's execution across multiple machines. Despite performance being extensively studied, the measurement of fault tolerance-a key feature offered by stream processing frameworks-has still not been measured properly with updated and comprehensive testbeds. Moreover, the impact that fault recovery can have on performance is mostly ignored. This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of fault recovery performance, stability, and recovery time in a cloud-native environment with modern open-source frameworks, namely Flink, Kafka Streams, and Spark Structured Streaming. Our benchmarking analysis is inspired by chaos engineering to inject failures. Generally, our results indicate that much has changed compared to previous studies on fault recovery in distributed stream processing. In particular, the results indicate that Flink is the most stable and has one of the best fault recovery. Moreover, Kafka Streams shows performance instabilities after failures, which is due to its current rebalancing strategy that can be suboptimal in terms of load balancing. Spark Structured Streaming shows suitable fault recovery performance and stability, but with higher event latency. Our study intends to (i) help industry practitioners in choosing the most suitable stream processing framework for efficient and reliable executions of data-intensive applications; (ii) support researchers in applying and extending our research method as well as our benchmark; (iii) identify, prevent, and assist in solving potential issues in production deployments.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2024; v1 submitted 9 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
ShuffleBench: A Benchmark for Large-Scale Data Shuffling Operations with Distributed Stream Processing Frameworks
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Adriano Vogel,
Michael Leichtfried,
Otmar Ertl,
Rick Rabiser
Abstract:
Distributed stream processing frameworks help building scalable and reliable applications that perform transformations and aggregations on continuous data streams. This paper introduces ShuffleBench, a novel benchmark to evaluate the performance of modern stream processing frameworks. In contrast to other benchmarks, it focuses on use cases where stream processing frameworks are mainly employed fo…
▽ More
Distributed stream processing frameworks help building scalable and reliable applications that perform transformations and aggregations on continuous data streams. This paper introduces ShuffleBench, a novel benchmark to evaluate the performance of modern stream processing frameworks. In contrast to other benchmarks, it focuses on use cases where stream processing frameworks are mainly employed for shuffling (i.e., re-distributing) data records to perform state-local aggregations, while the actual aggregation logic is considered as black-box software components. ShuffleBench is inspired by requirements for near real-time analytics of a large cloud observability platform and takes up benchmarking metrics and methods for latency, throughput, and scalability established in the performance engineering research community. Although inspired by a real-world observability use case, it is highly configurable to allow domain-independent evaluations. ShuffleBench comes as a ready-to-use open-source software utilizing existing Kubernetes tooling and providing implementations for four state-of-the-art frameworks. Therefore, we expect ShuffleBench to be a valuable contribution to both industrial practitioners building stream processing applications and researchers working on new stream processing approaches. We complement this paper with an experimental performance evaluation that employs ShuffleBench with various configurations on Flink, Hazelcast, Kafka Streams, and Spark in a cloud-native environment. Our results show that Flink achieves the highest throughput while Hazelcast processes data streams with the lowest latency.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Benchmarking Function Hook Latency in Cloud-Native Environments
Authors:
Mario Kahlhofer,
Patrick Kern,
Sören Henning,
Stefan Rass
Abstract:
Researchers and engineers are increasingly adopting cloud-native technologies for application development and performance evaluation. While this has improved the reproducibility of benchmarks in the cloud, the complexity of cloud-native environments makes it difficult to run benchmarks reliably. Cloud-native applications are often instrumented or altered at runtime, by dynamically patching or hook…
▽ More
Researchers and engineers are increasingly adopting cloud-native technologies for application development and performance evaluation. While this has improved the reproducibility of benchmarks in the cloud, the complexity of cloud-native environments makes it difficult to run benchmarks reliably. Cloud-native applications are often instrumented or altered at runtime, by dynamically patching or hooking them, which introduces a significant performance overhead. Our work discusses the benchmarking-related pitfalls of the dominant cloud-native technology, Kubernetes, and how they affect performance measurements of dynamically patched or hooked applications. We present recommendations to mitigate these risks and demonstrate how an improper experimental setup can negatively impact latency measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
MuLMS-AZ: An Argumentative Zoning Dataset for the Materials Science Domain
Authors:
Timo Pierre Schrader,
Teresa Bürkle,
Sophie Henning,
Sherry Tan,
Matteo Finco,
Stefan Grünewald,
Maira Indrikova,
Felix Hildebrand,
Annemarie Friedrich
Abstract:
Scientific publications follow conventionalized rhetorical structures. Classifying the Argumentative Zone (AZ), e.g., identifying whether a sentence states a Motivation, a Result or Background information, has been proposed to improve processing of scholarly documents. In this work, we adapt and extend this idea to the domain of materials science research. We present and release a new dataset of 5…
▽ More
Scientific publications follow conventionalized rhetorical structures. Classifying the Argumentative Zone (AZ), e.g., identifying whether a sentence states a Motivation, a Result or Background information, has been proposed to improve processing of scholarly documents. In this work, we adapt and extend this idea to the domain of materials science research. We present and release a new dataset of 50 manually annotated research articles. The dataset spans seven sub-topics and is annotated with a materials-science focused multi-label annotation scheme for AZ. We detail corpus statistics and demonstrate high inter-annotator agreement. Our computational experiments show that using domain-specific pre-trained transformer-based text encoders is key to high classification performance. We also find that AZ categories from existing datasets in other domains are transferable to varying degrees.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Benchmarking scalability of stream processing frameworks deployed as microservices in the cloud
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Wilhelm Hasselbring
Abstract:
Context: The combination of distributed stream processing with microservice architectures is an emerging pattern for building data-intensive software systems. In such systems, stream processing frameworks such as Apache Flink, Apache Kafka Streams, Apache Samza, Hazelcast Jet, or the Apache Beam SDK are used inside microservices to continuously process massive amounts of data in a distributed fash…
▽ More
Context: The combination of distributed stream processing with microservice architectures is an emerging pattern for building data-intensive software systems. In such systems, stream processing frameworks such as Apache Flink, Apache Kafka Streams, Apache Samza, Hazelcast Jet, or the Apache Beam SDK are used inside microservices to continuously process massive amounts of data in a distributed fashion. While all of these frameworks promote scalability as a core feature, there is only little empirical research evaluating and comparing their scalability. Objective: The goal of this study to obtain evidence about the scalability of state-of-the-art stream processing framework in different execution environments and regarding different scalability dimensions. Method: We benchmark five modern stream processing frameworks regarding their scalability using a systematic method. We conduct over 740 hours of experiments on Kubernetes clusters in the Google cloud and in a private cloud, where we deploy up to 110 simultaneously running microservice instances, which process up to one million messages per second. Results: All benchmarked frameworks exhibit approximately linear scalability as long as sufficient cloud resources are provisioned. However, the frameworks show considerable differences in the rate at which resources have to be added to cope with increasing load. There is no clear superior framework, but the ranking of the frameworks depends on the use case. Using Apache Beam as an abstraction layer still comes at the cost of significantly higher resource requirements regardless of the use case. We observe our results regardless of scaling load on a microservice, scaling the computational work performed inside the microservice, and the selected cloud environment. Moreover, vertical scaling can be a complementary measure to achieve scalability of stream processing frameworks.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2023; v1 submitted 20 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
MIST: a Large-Scale Annotated Resource and Neural Models for Functions of Modal Verbs in English Scientific Text
Authors:
Sophie Henning,
Nicole Macher,
Stefan Grünewald,
Annemarie Friedrich
Abstract:
Modal verbs (e.g., "can", "should", or "must") occur highly frequently in scientific articles. Decoding their function is not straightforward: they are often used for hedging, but they may also denote abilities and restrictions. Understanding their meaning is important for various NLP tasks such as writing assistance or accurate information extraction from scientific text.
To foster research on…
▽ More
Modal verbs (e.g., "can", "should", or "must") occur highly frequently in scientific articles. Decoding their function is not straightforward: they are often used for hedging, but they may also denote abilities and restrictions. Understanding their meaning is important for various NLP tasks such as writing assistance or accurate information extraction from scientific text.
To foster research on the usage of modals in this genre, we introduce the MIST (Modals In Scientific Text) dataset, which contains 3737 modal instances in five scientific domains annotated for their semantic, pragmatic, or rhetorical function. We systematically evaluate a set of competitive neural architectures on MIST. Transfer experiments reveal that leveraging non-scientific data is of limited benefit for modeling the distinctions in MIST. Our corpus analysis provides evidence that scientific communities differ in their usage of modal verbs, yet, classifiers trained on scientific data generalize to some extent to unseen scientific domains.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
A Survey of Methods for Addressing Class Imbalance in Deep-Learning Based Natural Language Processing
Authors:
Sophie Henning,
William Beluch,
Alexander Fraser,
Annemarie Friedrich
Abstract:
Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks are naturally imbalanced, as some target categories occur much more frequently than others in the real world. In such scenarios, current NLP models still tend to perform poorly on less frequent classes. Addressing class imbalance in NLP is an active research topic, yet, finding a good approach for a particular task and imbalance scenario is difficult.…
▽ More
Many natural language processing (NLP) tasks are naturally imbalanced, as some target categories occur much more frequently than others in the real world. In such scenarios, current NLP models still tend to perform poorly on less frequent classes. Addressing class imbalance in NLP is an active research topic, yet, finding a good approach for a particular task and imbalance scenario is difficult.
With this survey, the first overview on class imbalance in deep-learning based NLP, we provide guidance for NLP researchers and practitioners dealing with imbalanced data. We first discuss various types of controlled and real-world class imbalance. Our survey then covers approaches that have been explicitly proposed for class-imbalanced NLP tasks or, originating in the computer vision community, have been evaluated on them. We organize the methods by whether they are based on sampling, data augmentation, choice of loss function, staged learning, or model design. Finally, we discuss open problems such as dealing with multi-label scenarios, and propose systematic benchmarking and reporting in order to move forward on this problem as a community.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2023; v1 submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Streaming vs. Functions: A Cost Perspective on Cloud Event Processing
Authors:
Tobias Pfandzelter,
Sören Henning,
Trever Schirmer,
Wilhelm Hasselbring,
David Bermbach
Abstract:
In cloud event processing, data generated at the edge is processed in real-time by cloud resources. Both distributed stream processing (DSP) and Function-as-a-Service (FaaS) have been proposed to implement such event processing applications. FaaS emphasizes fast development and easy operation, while DSP emphasizes efficient handling of large data volumes. Despite their architectural differences, b…
▽ More
In cloud event processing, data generated at the edge is processed in real-time by cloud resources. Both distributed stream processing (DSP) and Function-as-a-Service (FaaS) have been proposed to implement such event processing applications. FaaS emphasizes fast development and easy operation, while DSP emphasizes efficient handling of large data volumes. Despite their architectural differences, both can be used to model and implement loosely-coupled job graphs.
In this paper, we consider the selection of FaaS and DSP from a cost perspective. We implement stateless and stateful workflows from the Theodolite benchmarking suite using cloud FaaS and DSP. In an extensive evaluation, we show how application type, cloud service provider, and runtime environment can influence the cost of application deployments and derive decision guidelines for cloud engineers.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2022; v1 submitted 25 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Goals and Measures for Analyzing Power Consumption Data in Manufacturing Enterprises
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Wilhelm Hasselbring,
Heinz Burmester,
Armin Möbius,
Maik Wojcieszak
Abstract:
The Internet of Things adoption in the manufacturing industry allows enterprises to monitor their electrical power consumption in real time and at machine level. In this paper, we follow up on such emerging opportunities for data acquisition and show that analyzing power consumption in manufacturing enterprises can serve a variety of purposes. Apart from the prevalent goal of reducing overall powe…
▽ More
The Internet of Things adoption in the manufacturing industry allows enterprises to monitor their electrical power consumption in real time and at machine level. In this paper, we follow up on such emerging opportunities for data acquisition and show that analyzing power consumption in manufacturing enterprises can serve a variety of purposes. Apart from the prevalent goal of reducing overall power consumption for economical and ecological reasons, such data can, for example, be used to improve production processes.
Based on a literature review and expert interviews, we discuss how analyzing power consumption data can serve the goals reporting, optimization, fault detection, and predictive maintenance. To tackle these goals, we propose to implement the measures real-time data processing, multi-level monitoring, temporal aggregation, correlation, anomaly detection, forecasting, visualization, and alerting in software.
We transfer our findings to two manufacturing enterprises and show how the presented goals reflect in these enterprises. In a pilot implementation of a power consumption analytics platform, we show how our proposed measures can be implemented with a microservice-based architecture, stream processing techniques, and the fog computing paradigm. We provide the implementations as open source as well as a public demo allowing to reproduce and extend our research.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Theodolite: Scalability Benchmarking of Distributed Stream Processing Engines in Microservice Architectures
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Wilhelm Hasselbring
Abstract:
Distributed stream processing engines are designed with a focus on scalability to process big data volumes in a continuous manner. We present the Theodolite method for benchmarking the scalability of distributed stream processing engines. Core of this method is the definition of use cases that microservices implementing stream processing have to fulfill. For each use case, our method identifies re…
▽ More
Distributed stream processing engines are designed with a focus on scalability to process big data volumes in a continuous manner. We present the Theodolite method for benchmarking the scalability of distributed stream processing engines. Core of this method is the definition of use cases that microservices implementing stream processing have to fulfill. For each use case, our method identifies relevant workload dimensions that might affect the scalability of a use case. We propose to design one benchmark per use case and relevant workload dimension. We present a general benchmarking framework, which can be applied to execute the individual benchmarks for a given use case and workload dimension. Our framework executes an implementation of the use case's dataflow architecture for different workloads of the given dimension and various numbers of processing instances. This way, it identifies how resources demand evolves with increasing workloads. Within the scope of this paper, we present 4 identified use cases, derived from processing Industrial Internet of Things data, and 7 corresponding workload dimensions. We provide implementations of 4 benchmarks with Kafka Streams and Apache Flink as well as an implementation of our benchmarking framework to execute scalability benchmarks in cloud environments. We use both for evaluating the Theodolite method and for benchmarking Kafka Streams' and Flink's scalability for different deployment options.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2021; v1 submitted 1 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Scalable and Reliable Multi-Dimensional Aggregation of Sensor Data Streams
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Wilhelm Hasselbring
Abstract:
Ever-increasing amounts of data and requirements to process them in real time lead to more and more analytics platforms and software systems being designed according to the concept of stream processing. A common area of application is the processing of continuous data streams from sensors, for example, IoT devices or performance monitoring tools. In addition to analyzing pure sensor data, analyses…
▽ More
Ever-increasing amounts of data and requirements to process them in real time lead to more and more analytics platforms and software systems being designed according to the concept of stream processing. A common area of application is the processing of continuous data streams from sensors, for example, IoT devices or performance monitoring tools. In addition to analyzing pure sensor data, analyses of data for groups of sensors often need to be performed as well. Therefore, data streams of the individual sensors have to be continuously aggregated to a data stream for a group. Motivated by a real-world application scenario, we propose that such a stream aggregation approach has to allow for aggregating sensors in hierarchical groups, support multiple such hierarchies in parallel, provide reconfiguration at runtime, and preserve the scalability and reliability qualities induced by applying stream processing techniques. We propose a stream processing architecture fulfilling these requirements, which can be integrated into existing big data architectures. We present a pilot implementation of such an extended architecture and show how it is used in industry. Furthermore, in experimental evaluations we show that our solution scales linearly with the amount of sensors and provides adequate reliability in the case of faults.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Industrial DevOps
Authors:
Wilhelm Hasselbring,
Sören Henning,
Björn Latte,
Armin Möbius,
Thomas Richter,
Stefan Schalk,
Maik Wojcieszak
Abstract:
The visions and ideas of Industry 4.0 require a profound interconnection of machines, plants, and IT systems in industrial production environments. This significantly increases the importance of software, which is coincidentally one of the main obstacles to the introduction of Industry 4.0. Lack of experience and knowledge, high investment and maintenance costs, as well as uncertainty about future…
▽ More
The visions and ideas of Industry 4.0 require a profound interconnection of machines, plants, and IT systems in industrial production environments. This significantly increases the importance of software, which is coincidentally one of the main obstacles to the introduction of Industry 4.0. Lack of experience and knowledge, high investment and maintenance costs, as well as uncertainty about future developments cause many small and medium-sized enterprises hesitating to adopt Industry 4.0 solutions. We propose Industrial DevOps as an approach to introduce methods and culture of DevOps into industrial production environments. The fundamental concept of this approach is a continuous process of operation, observation, and development of the entire production environment. This way, all stakeholders, systems, and data can thus be integrated via incremental steps and adjustments can be made quickly. Furthermore, we present the Titan software platform accompanied by a role model for integrating production environments with Industrial DevOps. In two initial industrial application scenarios, we address the challenges of energy management and predictive maintenance with the methods, organizational structures, and tools of Industrial DevOps.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
A Scalable Architecture for Power Consumption Monitoring in Industrial Production Environments
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Wilhelm Hasselbring,
Armin Möbius
Abstract:
Detailed knowledge about the electrical power consumption in industrial production environments is a prerequisite to reduce and optimize their power consumption. Today's industrial production sites are equipped with a variety of sensors that, inter alia, monitor electrical power consumption in detail. However, these environments often lack an automated data collation and analysis.
We present a s…
▽ More
Detailed knowledge about the electrical power consumption in industrial production environments is a prerequisite to reduce and optimize their power consumption. Today's industrial production sites are equipped with a variety of sensors that, inter alia, monitor electrical power consumption in detail. However, these environments often lack an automated data collation and analysis.
We present a system architecture that integrates different sensors and analyzes and visualizes the power consumption of devices, machines, and production plants. It is designed with a focus on scalability to support production environments of various sizes and to handle varying loads. We argue that a scalable architecture in this context must meet requirements for fault tolerance, extensibility, real-time data processing, and resource efficiency. As a solution, we propose a microservice-based architecture augmented by big data and stream processing techniques. Applying the fog computing paradigm, parts of it are deployed in an elastic, central cloud while other parts run directly, decentralized in the production environment.
A prototype implementation of this architecture presents solutions how different kinds of sensors can be integrated and their measurements can be continuously aggregated. In order to make analyzed data comprehensible, it features a single-page web application that provides different forms of data visualization. We deploy this pilot implementation in the data center of a medium-sized enterprise, where we successfully monitor the power consumption of 16~servers. Furthermore, we show the scalability of our architecture with 20,000~simulated sensors.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Generalized chart constraints for efficient PCFG and TAG parsing
Authors:
Stefan Grünewald,
Sophie Henning,
Alexander Koller
Abstract:
Chart constraints, which specify at which string positions a constituent may begin or end, have been shown to speed up chart parsers for PCFGs. We generalize chart constraints to more expressive grammar formalisms and describe a neural tagger which predicts chart constraints at very high precision. Our constraints accelerate both PCFG and TAG parsing, and combine effectively with other pruning tec…
▽ More
Chart constraints, which specify at which string positions a constituent may begin or end, have been shown to speed up chart parsers for PCFGs. We generalize chart constraints to more expressive grammar formalisms and describe a neural tagger which predicts chart constraints at very high precision. Our constraints accelerate both PCFG and TAG parsing, and combine effectively with other pruning techniques (coarse-to-fine and supertagging) for an overall speedup of two orders of magnitude, while improving accuracy.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Complexity and Inapproximability Results for Parallel Task Scheduling and Strip Packing
Authors:
Sören Henning,
Klaus Jansen,
Malin Rau,
Lars Schmarje
Abstract:
We study the Parallel Task Scheduling problem $Pm|size_j|C_{\max}$ with a constant number of machines. This problem is known to be strongly NP-complete for each $m \geq 5$, while it is solvable in pseudo-polynomial time for each $m \leq 3$. We give a positive answer to the long-standing open question whether this problem is strongly $NP$-complete for $m=4$. As a second result, we improve the lower…
▽ More
We study the Parallel Task Scheduling problem $Pm|size_j|C_{\max}$ with a constant number of machines. This problem is known to be strongly NP-complete for each $m \geq 5$, while it is solvable in pseudo-polynomial time for each $m \leq 3$. We give a positive answer to the long-standing open question whether this problem is strongly $NP$-complete for $m=4$. As a second result, we improve the lower bound of $\frac{12}{11}$ for approximating pseudo-polynomial Strip Packing to $\frac{5}{4}$. Since the best known approximation algorithm for this problem has a ratio of $\frac{4}{3} + \varepsilon$, this result narrows the gap between approximation ratio and inapproximability result by a significant step. Both results are proven by a reduction from the strongly $NP$-complete problem 3-Partition.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
