-
Model Predictive Contouring Control for Vehicle Obstacle Avoidance at the Limit of Handling Using Torque Vectoring
Authors:
Alberto Bertipaglia,
Davide Tavernini,
Umberto Montanaro,
Mohsen Alirezaei,
Riender Happee,
Aldo Sorniotti,
Barys Shyrokau
Abstract:
This paper presents an original approach to vehicle obstacle avoidance. It involves the development of a nonlinear Model Predictive Contouring Control, which uses torque vectoring to stabilise and drive the vehicle in evasive manoeuvres at the limit of handling. The proposed algorithm combines motion planning, path tracking and vehicle stability objectives, prioritising collision avoidance in emer…
▽ More
This paper presents an original approach to vehicle obstacle avoidance. It involves the development of a nonlinear Model Predictive Contouring Control, which uses torque vectoring to stabilise and drive the vehicle in evasive manoeuvres at the limit of handling. The proposed algorithm combines motion planning, path tracking and vehicle stability objectives, prioritising collision avoidance in emergencies. The controller's prediction model is a nonlinear double-track vehicle model based on an extended Fiala tyre to capture the nonlinear coupled longitudinal and lateral dynamics. The controller computes the optimal steering angle and the longitudinal forces per each of the four wheels to minimise tracking error in safe situations and maximise the vehicle-to-obstacle distance in emergencies. Thanks to the optimisation of the longitudinal tyre forces, the proposed controller can produce an extra yaw moment, increasing the vehicle's lateral agility to avoid obstacles while kee** the vehicle stable. The optimal forces are constrained in the tyre friction circle not to exceed the tyres and vehicle capabilities. In a high-fidelity simulation environment, we demonstrate the benefits of torque vectoring, showing that our proposed approach is capable of successfully avoiding obstacles and kee** the vehicle stable while driving a double-lane change manoeuvre, in comparison to baselines lacking torque vectoring or collision avoidance prioritisation.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Motion Cueing Algorithm for Effective Motion Perception: A frequency-splitting MPC Approach
Authors:
Vishrut Jain,
Andrea Lazcano,
Riender Happee,
Barys Shyrokau
Abstract:
Model predictive control (MPC) is a promising technique for motion cueing in driving simulators, but its high computation time limits widespread real-time application. This paper proposes a hybrid algorithm that combines filter-based and MPC-based techniques to improve specific force tracking while reducing computation time. The proposed algorithm divides the reference acceleration into low-freque…
▽ More
Model predictive control (MPC) is a promising technique for motion cueing in driving simulators, but its high computation time limits widespread real-time application. This paper proposes a hybrid algorithm that combines filter-based and MPC-based techniques to improve specific force tracking while reducing computation time. The proposed algorithm divides the reference acceleration into low-frequency and high-frequency components. The high-frequency component serves as a reference for translational motion to avoid workspace limit violations, while the low-frequency component is for tilt coordination. The total acceleration serves as a reference for combined specific force with the highest priority to enable compensation of deviations from its reference values. The algorithm uses constraints in the MPC formulation to account for workspace limits and workspace management is applied. The investigated scenarios were a step signal, a multi-sine wave and a recorded real-drive slalom maneuver. Based on the conducted simulations, the algorithm produces approximately 15% smaller root means squared error (RMSE) for the step signal compared to the state-of-the-art. Around 16% improvement is observed when the real-drive scenario is used as the simulation scenario, and for the multi-sine wave, 90% improvement is observed. At higher prediction horizons the algorithm matches the performance of a state-of-the-art MPC-based motion cueing algorithm. Finally, for all prediction horizons, the frequency-splitting algorithm produced faster results. The pre-generated references reduce the required prediction horizon and computational complexity while improving tracking performance. Hence, the proposed frequency-splitting algorithm outperforms state-of-the-art MPC-based algorithm and offers promise for real-time application in driving simulators.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Model Predictive Contouring Control for Vehicle Obstacle Avoidance at the Limit of Handling
Authors:
Alberto Bertipaglia,
Mohsen Alirezaei,
Riender Happee,
Barys Shyrokau
Abstract:
This paper proposes a non-linear Model Predictive Contouring Control (MPCC) for obstacle avoidance in automated vehicles driven at the limit of handling. The proposed controller integrates motion planning, path tracking and vehicle stability objectives, prioritising obstacle avoidance in emergencies. The controller's prediction model is a non-linear single-track vehicle model with the Fiala tyre t…
▽ More
This paper proposes a non-linear Model Predictive Contouring Control (MPCC) for obstacle avoidance in automated vehicles driven at the limit of handling. The proposed controller integrates motion planning, path tracking and vehicle stability objectives, prioritising obstacle avoidance in emergencies. The controller's prediction model is a non-linear single-track vehicle model with the Fiala tyre to capture the vehicle's non-linear behaviour. The MPCC computes the optimal steering angle and brake torques to minimise tracking error in safe situations and maximise the vehicle-to-obstacle distance in emergencies. Furthermore, the MPCC is extended with the tyre friction circle to fully exploit the vehicle's manoeuvrability and stability. The MPCC controller is tested using real-time rapid prototy** hardware to prove its real-time capability. The performance is compared with a state-of-the-art Model Predictive Control (MPC) in a high-fidelity simulation environment. The double lane change scenario results demonstrate a significant improvement in successfully avoiding obstacles and maintaining vehicle stability.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Modelling human seat contact interaction for vibration comfort
Authors:
Raj Desai,
Marko Cvetković,
Georgios Papaioannou,
Riender Happee
Abstract:
The seat to head vibration transmissibility depends on various characteristics of the seat and the human body. One of these, is the contact interaction, which transmits vibrational energy from the seat to the body. To enhance ride comfort, seat designers should be able to accurately simulate seat contact without the need for extensive experiments. Here, the contact area, pressure, friction and sea…
▽ More
The seat to head vibration transmissibility depends on various characteristics of the seat and the human body. One of these, is the contact interaction, which transmits vibrational energy from the seat to the body. To enhance ride comfort, seat designers should be able to accurately simulate seat contact without the need for extensive experiments. Here, the contact area, pressure, friction and seat and body deformation in compression and shear play a significant role. To address these challenges, the aim of this paper is to define appropriate contact models to improve the prediction capabilities of a seated human body model with regards to experimental data. A computationally efficient multibody (MB) model is evaluated interacting with finite element (FE) and MB backrest models, using several contact models. Outcomes are evaluated in the frequency domain for 3D vibration transmission from seat to pelvis, trunk, head and knees. Results illustrate that both FE and MB backrest models allowing compression and shear provide realistic results.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The impact of body and head dynamics on motion comfort assessment
Authors:
Georgios Papaioannou,
Raj Desai,
Riender Happee
Abstract:
Head motion is a key determinant of motion comfort and differs substantially from seat motion due to seat and body compliance and dynamic postural stabilization. This paper compares different human body model fidelities to transmit seat accelerations to the head for the assessment of motion comfort through simulations. Six-degree of freedom dynamics were analyzed using frequency response functions…
▽ More
Head motion is a key determinant of motion comfort and differs substantially from seat motion due to seat and body compliance and dynamic postural stabilization. This paper compares different human body model fidelities to transmit seat accelerations to the head for the assessment of motion comfort through simulations. Six-degree of freedom dynamics were analyzed using frequency response functions derived from an advanced human model (AHM), a computationally efficient human model (EHM) and experimental studies. Simulations of dynamic driving show that human models strongly affected the predicted ride comfort (increased up to a factor 3). Furthermore, they modestly affected sickness using the available filters from the literature and ISO-2631 (increased up to 30%), but more strongly affected sickness predicted by the subjective vertical conflict (SVC) model (increased up to 70%).
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Simulating vibration transmission and comfort in automated driving integrating models of seat, body, postural stabilization and motion perception
Authors:
Riender Happee,
Raj Desai,
Georgios Papaioannou
Abstract:
To enhance motion comfort in (automated) driving we present biomechanical models and demonstrate their ability to capture vibration transmission from seat to trunk and head. A computationally efficient full body model is presented, able to operate in real time while capturing translational and rotational motion of trunk and head with fore-aft, lateral and vertical seat motion. Sensory integration…
▽ More
To enhance motion comfort in (automated) driving we present biomechanical models and demonstrate their ability to capture vibration transmission from seat to trunk and head. A computationally efficient full body model is presented, able to operate in real time while capturing translational and rotational motion of trunk and head with fore-aft, lateral and vertical seat motion. Sensory integration models are presented predicting motion perception and motion sickness accumulation using the head motion as predicted by biomechanical models.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Computationally efficient human body modelling for real time motion comfort assessment
Authors:
Raj Desai,
Marko Cvetković,
Junda Wu,
Georgios Papaioannou,
Riender Happee
Abstract:
Due to the complexity of the human body and its neuromuscular stabilization, it has been challenging to efficiently and accurately predict human motion and capture posture while being driven. Existing simple models of the seated human body are mostly two-dimensional and developed in the mid-sagittal plane ex-posed to in-plane excitation. Such models capture fore-aft and vertical motion but not the…
▽ More
Due to the complexity of the human body and its neuromuscular stabilization, it has been challenging to efficiently and accurately predict human motion and capture posture while being driven. Existing simple models of the seated human body are mostly two-dimensional and developed in the mid-sagittal plane ex-posed to in-plane excitation. Such models capture fore-aft and vertical motion but not the more complex 3D motions due to lateral loading. Advanced 3D full-body active human models (AHMs), such as in MADYMO, can be used for comfort analysis and to investigate how vibrations influence the human body while being driven. However, such AHMs are very time-consuming due to their complexity. To effectively analyze motion comfort, a computationally efficient and accurate three dimensional (3D) human model, which runs faster than real-time, is presented. The model's postural stabilization parameters are tuned using available 3D vibration data for head, trunk and pelvis translation and rotation. A comparison between AHM and EHM is conducted regarding human body kinematics. According to the results, the EHM model configuration with two neck joints, two torso bending joints, and a spinal compression joint accurately predicts body kinematics.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Explaining human body responses in random vibration: Effect of motion direction, sitting posture, and anthropometry
Authors:
M. M. Cvetković,
R. Desai,
K. N. de Winkel,
G. Papaioannou,
R. Happee
Abstract:
This study investigates the effects of anthropometric attributes, biological sex, and posture on translational body kinematic responses in translational vibrations. In total, 35 participants were recruited. Perturbations were applied on a standard car seat using a motion-based platform with 0.1 to 12.0 Hz random noise signals, with 0.3 m/s2 rms acceleration, for 60 seconds. Multiple linear regress…
▽ More
This study investigates the effects of anthropometric attributes, biological sex, and posture on translational body kinematic responses in translational vibrations. In total, 35 participants were recruited. Perturbations were applied on a standard car seat using a motion-based platform with 0.1 to 12.0 Hz random noise signals, with 0.3 m/s2 rms acceleration, for 60 seconds. Multiple linear regression models (three basic models and one advanced model, including interactions between predictors) were created to determine the most influential predictors of peak translational gains in the frequency domain per body segment (pelvis, trunk, and head). The models introduced experimentally manipulated factors (motion direction, posture, measured anthropometric attributes, and biological sex) as predictors. Effects of included predictors on the model fit were estimated. Basic linear regression models could explain over 70% of peak body segments' kinematic body response (where the R2 adjusted was 0.728). The inclusion of additional predictors (posture, body height and weight, and biological sex) did enhance the model fit, but not significantly (R2 adjusted was 0.730). The multiple stepwise linear regression, including interactions between predictors, accounted for the data well with an adjusted R2 of 0.907. The present study shows that perturbation direction and body segment kinematics are crucial factors influencing peak translational gains. Besides the body segments' response, perturbation direction was the strongest predictor. Adopted postures and biological sex do not significantly affect kinematic responses.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Evaluation of motion comfort using advanced active human body models and efficient simplified models
Authors:
Raj Desai,
Marko Cvetković,
Georgios Papaioannou,
Riender Happee
Abstract:
Active muscles are crucial for maintaining postural stability when seated in a moving vehicle. Advanced active 3D non-linear full body models have been developed for impact and comfort simulation, including large numbers of individual muscle elements, and detailed non-linear models of the joint structures. While such models have an apparent potential to provide insight into postural stabilization,…
▽ More
Active muscles are crucial for maintaining postural stability when seated in a moving vehicle. Advanced active 3D non-linear full body models have been developed for impact and comfort simulation, including large numbers of individual muscle elements, and detailed non-linear models of the joint structures. While such models have an apparent potential to provide insight into postural stabilization, they are computationally demanding, making them less practical in particular for driving comfort where long time periods are to be studied. In vibrational comfort and in general biomechanical research, linearized models are effectively used. This paper evaluates the effectiveness of simplified 3D full-body human models to capture comfort provoked by whole-body vibrations. An efficient seated human body model is developed and validated using experimental data. We evaluate the required complexity in terms of joints and degrees of freedom for the spine, and explore how well linear spring-damper models can approximate reflexive postural stabilization. Results indicate that linear stiffness and dam** models can well capture the human response. The results are improved by adding proportional integral derivative (PID) and head-in-space (HIS) controllers to maintain the defined initial body posture. The integrator is shown to be essential to prevent drift from the defined posture. The joint angular relative displacement is used as the input reference to each PID controller. With this model, a faster than real-time solution is obtained when used with a simple seat model. The paper also discusses the advantages and disadvantages of various models and provides insight into which models are more appropriate for motion comfort analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023; v1 submitted 20 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
A new computational perceived risk model for automated vehicles based on potential collision avoidance difficulty (PCAD)
Authors:
Xiaolin He,
Riender Happee,
Meng Wang
Abstract:
Perceived risk is crucial in designing trustworthy and acceptable vehicle automation systems. However, our understanding of its dynamics is limited, and models for perceived risk dynamics are scarce in the literature. This study formulates a new computational perceived risk model based on potential collision avoidance difficulty (PCAD) for drivers of SAE level 2 driving automation. PCAD uses the 2…
▽ More
Perceived risk is crucial in designing trustworthy and acceptable vehicle automation systems. However, our understanding of its dynamics is limited, and models for perceived risk dynamics are scarce in the literature. This study formulates a new computational perceived risk model based on potential collision avoidance difficulty (PCAD) for drivers of SAE level 2 driving automation. PCAD uses the 2D safe velocity gap as the potential collision avoidance difficulty, and takes into account collision severity. The safe velocity gap is defined as the 2D gap between the current velocity and the safe velocity region, and represents the amount of braking and steering needed, considering behavioural uncertainty of neighbouring vehicles and imprecise control of the subject vehicle. The PCAD predicts perceived risk both in continuous time and per event. We compare the PCAD model with three state-of-the-art models and analyse the models both theoretically and empirically with two unique datasets: Dataset Merging and Dataset Obstacle Avoidance. The PCAD model generally outperforms the other models in terms of model error, detection rate, and the ability to accurately capture the tendencies of human drivers' perceived risk, albeit at a longer computation time. Additionally, the study shows that the perceived risk is not static and varies with the surrounding traffic conditions. This research advances our understanding of perceived risk in automated driving and paves the way for improved safety and acceptance of driving automation systems.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Motion comfort and driver feel: An explorative study about their relation in remote driving
Authors:
Georgios Papaioannou,
Lin Zhao,
Mikael Nybacka,
Jenny Jerrelind,
Riender Happee,
Lars Drugge
Abstract:
Teleoperation is considered as a viable option to control fully automated vehicles (AVs) of Level 4 and 5 in special conditions. However, by bringing the remote drivers in the loop, their driving experience should be realistic to secure safe and comfortable remote control.Therefore, the remote control tower should be designed such that remote drivers receive high quality cues regarding the vehicle…
▽ More
Teleoperation is considered as a viable option to control fully automated vehicles (AVs) of Level 4 and 5 in special conditions. However, by bringing the remote drivers in the loop, their driving experience should be realistic to secure safe and comfortable remote control.Therefore, the remote control tower should be designed such that remote drivers receive high quality cues regarding the vehicle state and the driving environment. In this direction, the steering feedback could be manipulated to provide feedback to the remote drivers regarding how the vehicle reacts to their commands. However, until now, it is unclear how the remote drivers' steering feel could impact occupant's motion comfort. This paper focuses on exploring how the driver feel in remote (RD) and normal driving (ND) are related with motion comfort. More specifically, different types of steering feedback controllers are applied in (a) the steering system of a Research Concept Vehicle-model E (RCV-E) and (b) the steering system of a remote control tower. An experiment was performed to assess driver feel when the RCV-E is normally and remotely driven. Subjective assessment and objective metrics are employed to assess drivers' feel and occupants' motion comfort in both remote and normal driving scenarios. The results illustrate that motion sickness and ride comfort are only affected by the steering velocity in remote driving, while throttle input variations affect them in normal driving. The results demonstrate that motion sickness and steering velocity increase both around 25$\%$ from normal to remote driving.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
A Two-Stage Bayesian Optimisation for Automatic Tuning of an Unscented Kalman Filter for Vehicle Sideslip Angle Estimation
Authors:
A. Bertipaglia,
B. Shyrokau,
M. Alirezaei,
R. Happee
Abstract:
This paper presents a novel methodology to auto-tune an Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF). It involves using a Two-Stage Bayesian Optimisation (TSBO), based on a t-Student Process to optimise the process noise parameters of a UKF for vehicle sideslip angle estimation. Our method minimises performance metrics, given by the average sum of the states' and measurement' estimation error for various vehicle…
▽ More
This paper presents a novel methodology to auto-tune an Unscented Kalman Filter (UKF). It involves using a Two-Stage Bayesian Optimisation (TSBO), based on a t-Student Process to optimise the process noise parameters of a UKF for vehicle sideslip angle estimation. Our method minimises performance metrics, given by the average sum of the states' and measurement' estimation error for various vehicle manoeuvres covering a wide range of vehicle behaviour. The predefined cost function is minimised through a TSBO which aims to find a location in the feasible region that maximises the probability of improving the current best solution. Results on an experimental dataset show the capability to tune the UKF in 79.9% less time than using a genetic algorithm (GA) and the overall capacity to improve the estimation performance in an experimental test dataset of 9.9% to the current state-of-the-art GA.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
