Showing 1–14 of 14 results for author: Gutfraind, A

Risk-reducing design and operations toolkit: 90 strategies for managing risk and uncertainty in decision problems

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind

Abstract: Uncertainty is a pervasive challenge in decision analysis, and decision theory recognizes two classes of solutions: probabilistic models and cognitive heuristics. However, engineers, public planners and other decision-makers instead use a third class of strategies that could be called RDOT (Risk-reducing Design and Operations Toolkit). These include incorporating robustness into designs, contingen… ▽ More Uncertainty is a pervasive challenge in decision analysis, and decision theory recognizes two classes of solutions: probabilistic models and cognitive heuristics. However, engineers, public planners and other decision-makers instead use a third class of strategies that could be called RDOT (Risk-reducing Design and Operations Toolkit). These include incorporating robustness into designs, contingency planning, and others that do not fall into the categories of probabilistic models or cognitive heuristics. Moreover, identical strategies appear in several domains and disciplines, pointing to an important shared toolkit. The focus of this paper is to develop a catalog of such strategies and develop a framework for them. The paper finds more than 90 examples of such strategies falling into six broad categories and argues that they provide an efficient response to decision problems that are seemingly intractable due to high uncertainty. It then proposes a framework to incorporate them into decision theory using multi-objective optimization. Overall, RDOT represents an overlooked class of responses to uncertainty. Because RDOT strategies do not depend on accurate forecasting or estimation, they could be applied fruitfully to certain decision problems affected by high uncertainty and make them much more tractable. △ Less

Submitted 6 September, 2023; originally announced September 2023.

MSC Class: 60A05; 91B05; 62C05 ACM Class: F.1.3

On solving decision and risk management problems subject to uncertainty

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind

Abstract: Uncertainty is a pervasive challenge in decision and risk management and it is usually studied by quantification and modeling. Interestingly, engineers and other decision makers usually manage uncertainty with strategies such as incorporating robustness, or by employing decision heuristics. The focus of this paper is then to develop a systematic understanding of such strategies, determine their ra… ▽ More Uncertainty is a pervasive challenge in decision and risk management and it is usually studied by quantification and modeling. Interestingly, engineers and other decision makers usually manage uncertainty with strategies such as incorporating robustness, or by employing decision heuristics. The focus of this paper is then to develop a systematic understanding of such strategies, determine their range of application, and develop a framework to better employ them. Based on a review of a dataset of 100 decision problems, this paper found that many decision problems have pivotal properties, i.e. properties that enable solution strategies, and finds 14 such properties. Therefore, an analyst can first find these properties in a given problem, and then utilize the strategies they enable. Multi-objective optimization methods could be used to make investment decisions quantitatively. The analytical complexity of decision problems can also be scored by evaluating how many of the pivotal properties are available. Overall, we find that in the light of pivotal properties, complex problems under uncertainty frequently appear surprisingly tractable. △ Less

Submitted 18 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 12 pages

MSC Class: 60A05; 91B05; 62C05 ACM Class: F.1.3

Using massive health insurance claims data to predict very high-cost claimants: a machine learning approach

Authors: José M. Maisog, Wenhong Li, Yanchun Xu, Brian Hurley, Hetal Shah, Ryan Lemberg, Tina Borden, Stephen Bandeian, Melissa Schline, Roxanna Cross, Alan Spiro, Russ Michael, Alexander Gutfraind

Abstract: Due to escalating healthcare costs, accurately predicting which patients will incur high costs is an important task for payers and providers of healthcare. High-cost claimants (HiCCs) are patients who have annual costs above $\$250,000… ▽ More Due to escalating healthcare costs, accurately predicting which patients will incur high costs is an important task for payers and providers of healthcare. High-cost claimants (HiCCs) are patients who have annual costs above $\$250,000$ and who represent just 0.16% of the insured population but currently account for 9% of all healthcare costs. In this study, we aimed to develop a high-performance algorithm to predict HiCCs to inform a novel care management system. Using health insurance claims from 48 million people and augmented with census data, we applied machine learning to train binary classification models to calculate the personal risk of HiCC. To train the models, we developed a platform starting with 6,006 variables across all clinical and demographic dimensions and constructed over one hundred candidate models. The best model achieved an area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 91.2%. The model exceeds the highest published performance (84%) and remains high for patients with no prior history of high-cost status (89%), who have less than a full year of enrollment (87%), or lack pharmacy claims data (88%). It attains an area under the precision-recall curve of 23.1%, and precision of 74% at a threshold of 0.99. A care management program enrolling 500 people with the highest HiCC risk is expected to treat 199 true HiCCs and generate a net savings of $\$7.3$ million per year. Our results demonstrate that high-performing predictive models can be constructed using claims data and publicly available data alone, even for rare high-cost claimants exceeding $\$250,000$. Our model demonstrates the transformational power of machine learning and artificial intelligence in care management, which would allow healthcare payers and providers to introduce the next generation of care management programs. △ Less

Submitted 30 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 34 pages, 2 figures, In review in PLoS ONE

MSC Class: J.3; I.2.6 ACM Class: J.3; I.2.6

Risk analysis beyond vulnerability and resilience - characterizing the defensibility of critical systems

Authors: Vicki Bier, Alexander Gutfraind

Abstract: A common problem in risk analysis is to characterize the overall security of a system of valuable assets (e.g., government buildings or communication hubs), and to suggest measures to mitigate any hazards or security threats. Currently, analysts typically rely on a combination of indices, such as resilience, robustness, redundancy, security, and vulnerability. However, these indices are not by the… ▽ More A common problem in risk analysis is to characterize the overall security of a system of valuable assets (e.g., government buildings or communication hubs), and to suggest measures to mitigate any hazards or security threats. Currently, analysts typically rely on a combination of indices, such as resilience, robustness, redundancy, security, and vulnerability. However, these indices are not by themselves sufficient as a guide to action; for example, while it is possible to develop policies to decrease vulnerability, such policies may not always be cost-effective. Motivated by this gap, we propose a new index, defensibility. A system is considered defensible to the extent that a modest investment can significantly reduce the damage from an attack or disruption. To compare systems whose performance is not readily commensurable (e.g., the electrical grid vs. the water-distribution network, both of which are critical, but which provide distinct types of services), we defined defensibility as a dimensionless index. After defining defensibility quantitatively, we illustrate how the defensibility of a system depends on factors such as the defender and attacker asset valuations, the nature of the threat (whether intelligent and adaptive, or random), and the levels of attack and defense strengths and provide analytical results that support the observations arising from the above illustrations. Overall, we argue that the defensibility of a system is an important dimension to consider when evaluating potential defensive investments, and that it can be applied in a variety of different contexts. △ Less

Submitted 8 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: 36 pages; Keywords: Risk Analysis, Defensibility, Vulnerability, Resilience, Counter-terrorism

Journal ref: European Journal of Operational Research 2019

Multiscale Planar Graph Generation

Authors: Varsha Chauhan, Alexander Gutfraind, Ilya Safro

Abstract: The study of network representations of physical, biological, and social phenomena can help us better understand the structural and functional dynamics of their networks and formulate predictive models of these phenomena. However, due to the scarcity of real-world network data owing to factors such as cost and effort required in collection of network data and the sensitivity of this data towards t… ▽ More The study of network representations of physical, biological, and social phenomena can help us better understand the structural and functional dynamics of their networks and formulate predictive models of these phenomena. However, due to the scarcity of real-world network data owing to factors such as cost and effort required in collection of network data and the sensitivity of this data towards theft and misuse, engineers and researchers often rely on synthetic data for simulations, hypothesis testing, decision making, and algorithm engineering. An important characteristic of infrastructure networks such as roads, water distribution and other utility systems is that they can be embedded in a plane, therefore to simulate these system we need realistic networks which are also planar. While the currently-available synthetic network generators can model networks that exhibit realism, they do not guarantee or achieve planarity. Therefore, in this paper we present a flexible algorithm that can synthesize realistic networks that are planar. The method follows a multi-scale randomized editing approach generating a hierarchy of coarsened networks of a given planar graph and introducing edits at various levels in the hierarchy. The method preserves the structural properties with minimal bias including the planarity of the network, while introducing realistic variability at multiple scales. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2019; v1 submitted 26 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Generating realistic scaled complex networks

Authors: Christian L. Staudt, Michael Hamann, Alexander Gutfraind, Ilya Safro, Henning Meyerhenke

Abstract: Research on generative models is a central project in the emerging field of network science, and it studies how statistical patterns found in real networks could be generated by formal rules. Output from these generative models is then the basis for designing and evaluating computational methods on networks, and for verification and simulation studies. During the last two decades, a variety of mod… ▽ More Research on generative models is a central project in the emerging field of network science, and it studies how statistical patterns found in real networks could be generated by formal rules. Output from these generative models is then the basis for designing and evaluating computational methods on networks, and for verification and simulation studies. During the last two decades, a variety of models has been proposed with an ultimate goal of achieving comprehensive realism for the generated networks. In this study, we (a) introduce a new generator, termed ReCoN; (b) explore how ReCoN and some existing models can be fitted to an original network to produce a structurally similar replica, (c) use ReCoN to produce networks much larger than the original exemplar, and finally (d) discuss open problems and promising research directions. In a comparative experimental study, we find that ReCoN is often superior to many other state-of-the-art network generation methods. We argue that ReCoN is a scalable and effective tool for modeling a given network while preserving important properties at both micro- and macroscopic scales, and for scaling the exemplar data by orders of magnitude in size. △ Less

Submitted 23 March, 2017; v1 submitted 7 September, 2016; originally announced September 2016.

Comments: 26 pages, 13 figures, extended version, a preliminary version of the paper was presented at the 5th International Workshop on Complex Networks and their Applications

Network installation and recovery: approximation lower bounds and faster exact formulations

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind, Jeremy Kun, Ádám D. Lelkes, Lev Reyzin

Abstract: We study the Neighbor Aided Network Installation Problem (NANIP) introduced previously which asks for a minimal cost ordering of the vertices of a graph, where the cost of visiting a node is a function of the number of neighbors that have already been visited. This problem has applications in resource management and disaster recovery. In this paper we analyze the computational hardness of NANIP. I… ▽ More We study the Neighbor Aided Network Installation Problem (NANIP) introduced previously which asks for a minimal cost ordering of the vertices of a graph, where the cost of visiting a node is a function of the number of neighbors that have already been visited. This problem has applications in resource management and disaster recovery. In this paper we analyze the computational hardness of NANIP. In particular we show that this problem is NP-hard even when restricted to convex decreasing cost functions, give a linear approximation lower bound for the greedy algorithm, and prove a general sub-constant approximation lower bound. Then we give a new integer programming formulation of NANIP and empirically observe its speedup over the original integer program. △ Less

Submitted 13 November, 2014; originally announced November 2014.

Multiscale Network Generation

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind, Lauren Ancel Meyers, Ilya Safro

Abstract: Networks are widely used in science and technology to represent relationships between entities, such as social or ecological links between organisms, enzymatic interactions in metabolic systems, or computer infrastructure. Statistical analyses of networks can provide critical insights into the structure, function, dynamics, and evolution of those systems. However, the structures of real-world netw… ▽ More Networks are widely used in science and technology to represent relationships between entities, such as social or ecological links between organisms, enzymatic interactions in metabolic systems, or computer infrastructure. Statistical analyses of networks can provide critical insights into the structure, function, dynamics, and evolution of those systems. However, the structures of real-world networks are often not known completely, and they may exhibit considerable variation so that no single network is sufficiently representative of a system. In such situations, researchers may turn to proxy data from related systems, sophisticated methods for network inference, or synthetic networks. Here, we introduce a flexible method for synthesizing realistic ensembles of networks starting from a known network, through a series of map**s that coarsen and later refine the network structure by randomized editing. The method, MUSKETEER, preserves structural properties with minimal bias, including unknown or unspecified features, while introducing realistic variability at multiple scales. Using examples from several domains, we show that MUSKETEER produces the intended stochasticity while achieving greater fidelity across a suite of network properties than do other commonly used network generation algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: 28 pages

Optimal recovery of damaged infrastructure network

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind, Milan Bradonjić, Tim Novikoff

Abstract: Natural disasters or attacks may disrupt infrastructure networks on a vast scale. Parts of the damaged network are interdependent, making it difficult to plan and optimally execute the recovery operations. To study how interdependencies affect the recovery schedule, we introduce a new discrete optimization problem where the goal is to minimize the total cost of installing (or recovering) a given n… ▽ More Natural disasters or attacks may disrupt infrastructure networks on a vast scale. Parts of the damaged network are interdependent, making it difficult to plan and optimally execute the recovery operations. To study how interdependencies affect the recovery schedule, we introduce a new discrete optimization problem where the goal is to minimize the total cost of installing (or recovering) a given network. This cost is determined by the structure of the network and the sequence in which the nodes are installed. Namely, the cost of installing a node is a function of the number of its neighbors that have been installed before it. We analyze the natural case where the cost function is decreasing and convex, and provide bounds on the cost of the optimal solution. We also show that all sequences have the same cost when the cost function is linear and provide an upper bound on the cost of a random solution for an Erdős-Rényi random graph. Examining the computational complexity, we show that the problem is NP-hard when the cost function is arbitrary. Finally, we provide a formulation as an integer program, an exact dynamic programming algorithm, and a greedy heuristic which gives high quality solutions. △ Less

Submitted 11 July, 2012; originally announced July 2012.

Comments: In review with Optimization Letters

Evader Interdiction and Collateral Damage

Authors: Matthew P. Johnson, Alexander Gutfraind

Abstract: In network interdiction problems, evaders (e.g., hostile agents or data packets) may be moving through a network towards targets and we wish to choose locations for sensors in order to intercept the evaders before they reach their destinations. The evaders might follow deterministic routes or Markov chains, or they may be reactive}, i.e., able to change their routes in order to avoid sensors place… ▽ More In network interdiction problems, evaders (e.g., hostile agents or data packets) may be moving through a network towards targets and we wish to choose locations for sensors in order to intercept the evaders before they reach their destinations. The evaders might follow deterministic routes or Markov chains, or they may be reactive}, i.e., able to change their routes in order to avoid sensors placed to detect them. The challenge in such problems is to choose sensor locations economically, balancing security gains with costs, including the inconvenience sensors inflict upon innocent travelers. We study the objectives of 1) maximizing the number of evaders captured when limited by a budget on sensing cost and 2) capturing all evaders as cheaply as possible. We give optimal sensor placement algorithms for several classes of special graphs and hardness and approximation results for general graphs, including for deterministic or Markov chain-based and reactive or oblivious evaders. In a similar-sounding but fundamentally different problem setting posed by Rubinstein and Glazer where both evaders and innocent travelers are reactive, we again give optimal algorithms for special cases and hardness and approximation results on general graphs. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2011; originally announced August 2011.

Comments: Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Algorithms for Sensor Systems, Wireless Ad Hoc Networks and Autonomous Mobile Entities (ALGOSENSORS) 2011

Report number: LA-UR-11-10123 ACM Class: E.1; F.2; G.1.2

Interdiction of a Markovian Evader

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind, Aric A. Hagberg, David Izraelevitz, Feng Pan

Abstract: Shortest path network interdiction is a combinatorial optimization problem on an activity network arising in a number of important security-related applications. It is classically formulated as a bilevel maximin problem representing an "interdictor" and an "evader". The evader tries to move from a source node to the target node along a path of the least cost while the interdictor attempts to frust… ▽ More Shortest path network interdiction is a combinatorial optimization problem on an activity network arising in a number of important security-related applications. It is classically formulated as a bilevel maximin problem representing an "interdictor" and an "evader". The evader tries to move from a source node to the target node along a path of the least cost while the interdictor attempts to frustrate this motion by cutting edges or nodes. The interdiction objective is to find the optimal set of edges to cut given that there is a finite interdiction budget and the interdictor must move first. We reformulate the interdiction problem for stochastic evaders by introducing a model in which the evader follows a Markovian random walk guided by the least-cost path to the target. This model can represent incomplete knowledge about the evader, and the resulting model is a nonlinear 0-1 optimization problem. We then introduce an optimization heuristic based on betweenness centrality that can rapidly find high-quality interdiction solutions by providing a global view of the network. △ Less

Submitted 2 September, 2010; originally announced September 2010.

Comments: Submitted to INFORMS Computing Society Conference (ICS2011)

Report number: LA-UR-08-06551 ACM Class: I.2.8

Targeting by Transnational Terrorist Groups

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind

Abstract: Many successful terrorist groups operate across international borders where different countries host different stages of terrorist operations. Often the recruits for the group come from one country or countries, while the targets of the operations are in another. Stop** such attacks is difficult because intervention in any region or route might merely shift the terrorists elsewhere. Here we prop… ▽ More Many successful terrorist groups operate across international borders where different countries host different stages of terrorist operations. Often the recruits for the group come from one country or countries, while the targets of the operations are in another. Stop** such attacks is difficult because intervention in any region or route might merely shift the terrorists elsewhere. Here we propose a model of transnational terrorism based on the theory of activity networks. The model represents attacks on different countries as paths in a network. The group is assumed to prefer paths of lowest cost (or risk) and maximal yield from attacks. The parameters of the model are computed for the Islamist-Salafi terrorist movement based on open source data and then used for estimation of risks of future attacks. The central finding is that the USA has an enduring appeal as a target, due to lack of other nations of matching geopolitical weight or openness. It is also shown that countries in Africa and Asia that have been overlooked as terrorist bases may become highly significant threats in the future. The model quantifies the dilemmas facing countries in the effort to cut such networks, and points to a limitation of deterrence against transnational terrorists. △ Less

Submitted 27 August, 2010; originally announced August 2010.

Report number: LA-UR 10-05689

Markovian Network Interdiction and the Four Color Theorem

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind, Kiyan Ahmadizadeh

Abstract: The Unreactive Markovian Evader Interdiction Problem (UME) asks to optimally place sensors on a network to detect Markovian motion by one or more "evaders". It was previously proved that finding the optimal sensor placement is NP-hard if the number of evaders is unbounded. Here we show that the problem is NP-hard with just 2 evaders using a connection to coloring of planar graphs. The results su… ▽ More The Unreactive Markovian Evader Interdiction Problem (UME) asks to optimally place sensors on a network to detect Markovian motion by one or more "evaders". It was previously proved that finding the optimal sensor placement is NP-hard if the number of evaders is unbounded. Here we show that the problem is NP-hard with just 2 evaders using a connection to coloring of planar graphs. The results suggest that approximation algorithms are needed even in applications where the number of evaders is small. It remains an open problem to determine the complexity of the 1-evader case or to devise efficient algorithms. △ Less

Submitted 22 November, 2009; originally announced November 2009.

Comments: 7 pages, 2 figures

Report number: LA-UR-09-07611 ACM Class: E.1; F.2; G.1.2

Optimal Interdiction of Unreactive Markovian Evaders

Authors: Alexander Gutfraind, Aric Hagberg, Feng Pan

Abstract: The interdiction problem arises in a variety of areas including military logistics, infectious disease control, and counter-terrorism. In the typical formulation of network interdiction, the task of the interdictor is to find a set of edges in a weighted network such that the removal of those edges would maximally increase the cost to an evader of traveling on a path through the network. Our w… ▽ More The interdiction problem arises in a variety of areas including military logistics, infectious disease control, and counter-terrorism. In the typical formulation of network interdiction, the task of the interdictor is to find a set of edges in a weighted network such that the removal of those edges would maximally increase the cost to an evader of traveling on a path through the network. Our work is motivated by cases in which the evader has incomplete information about the network or lacks planning time or computational power, e.g. when authorities set up roadblocks to catch bank robbers, the criminals do not know all the roadblock locations or the best path to use for their escape. We introduce a model of network interdiction in which the motion of one or more evaders is described by Markov processes and the evaders are assumed not to react to interdiction decisions. The interdiction objective is to find an edge set of size B, that maximizes the probability of capturing the evaders. We prove that similar to the standard least-cost formulation for deterministic motion this interdiction problem is also NP-hard. But unlike that problem our interdiction problem is submodular and the optimal solution can be approximated within 1-1/e using a greedy algorithm. Additionally, we exploit submodularity through a priority evaluation strategy that eliminates the linear complexity scaling in the number of network edges and speeds up the solution by orders of magnitude. Taken together the results bring closer the goal of finding realistic solutions to the interdiction problem on global-scale networks. △ Less

Submitted 1 March, 2009; originally announced March 2009.

Comments: Accepted at the Sixth International Conference on integration of AI and OR Techniques in Constraint Programming for Combinatorial Optimization Problems (CPAIOR 2009)

Report number: LA-UR-09-00560 ACM Class: E.1; F.2; G.1.2

Journal ref: CPAIOR 2009