-
Type-B analogue of Bell numbers using Rota's Umbral calculus approach
Authors:
Eli Bagno,
David Garber
Abstract:
Rota used the functional L to recover old properties and obtain some new formulas for the Bell numbers. Tanny used Rota's functional L and the celebrated Worpitzky identity to obtain some expression for the ordered Bell numbers, which can be seen as an evident to the fact that the ordered Bell numbers are gamma-positive. In this paper, we extend some of Rota's and Tanny's results to the framework…
▽ More
Rota used the functional L to recover old properties and obtain some new formulas for the Bell numbers. Tanny used Rota's functional L and the celebrated Worpitzky identity to obtain some expression for the ordered Bell numbers, which can be seen as an evident to the fact that the ordered Bell numbers are gamma-positive. In this paper, we extend some of Rota's and Tanny's results to the framework of the set partitions of Coxeter type B.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Projection-Free Online Convex Optimization with Time-Varying Constraints
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ben Kretzu
Abstract:
We consider the setting of online convex optimization with adversarial time-varying constraints in which actions must be feasible w.r.t. a fixed constraint set, and are also required on average to approximately satisfy additional time-varying constraints. Motivated by scenarios in which the fixed feasible set (hard constraint) is difficult to project on, we consider projection-free algorithms that…
▽ More
We consider the setting of online convex optimization with adversarial time-varying constraints in which actions must be feasible w.r.t. a fixed constraint set, and are also required on average to approximately satisfy additional time-varying constraints. Motivated by scenarios in which the fixed feasible set (hard constraint) is difficult to project on, we consider projection-free algorithms that access this set only through a linear optimization oracle (LOO). We present an algorithm that, on a sequence of length $T$ and using overall $T$ calls to the LOO, guarantees $\tilde{O}(T^{3/4})$ regret w.r.t. the losses and $O(T^{7/8})$ constraints violation (ignoring all quantities except for $T$) . In particular, these bounds hold w.r.t. any interval of the sequence. We also present a more efficient algorithm that requires only first-order oracle access to the soft constraints and achieves similar bounds w.r.t. the entire sequence. We extend the latter to the setting of bandit feedback and obtain similar bounds (as a function of $T$) in expectation.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
From Oja's Algorithm to the Multiplicative Weights Update Method with Applications
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
Oja's algorithm is a well known online algorithm studied mainly in the context of stochastic principal component analysis. We make a simple observation, yet to the best of our knowledge a novel one, that when applied to a any (not necessarily stochastic) sequence of symmetric matrices which share common eigenvectors, the regret of Oja's algorithm could be directly bounded in terms of the regret of…
▽ More
Oja's algorithm is a well known online algorithm studied mainly in the context of stochastic principal component analysis. We make a simple observation, yet to the best of our knowledge a novel one, that when applied to a any (not necessarily stochastic) sequence of symmetric matrices which share common eigenvectors, the regret of Oja's algorithm could be directly bounded in terms of the regret of the well known multiplicative weights update method for the problem of prediction with expert advice. Several applications to optimization with quadratic forms over the unit sphere in $\reals^n$ are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Efficiency of First-Order Methods for Low-Rank Tensor Recovery with the Tensor Nuclear Norm Under Strict Complementarity
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Atara Kaplan
Abstract:
We consider convex relaxations for recovering low-rank tensors based on constrained minimization over a ball induced by the tensor nuclear norm, recently introduced in \cite{tensor_tSVD}. We build on a recent line of results that considered convex relaxations for the recovery of low-rank matrices and established that under a strict complementarity condition (SC), both the convergence rate and per-…
▽ More
We consider convex relaxations for recovering low-rank tensors based on constrained minimization over a ball induced by the tensor nuclear norm, recently introduced in \cite{tensor_tSVD}. We build on a recent line of results that considered convex relaxations for the recovery of low-rank matrices and established that under a strict complementarity condition (SC), both the convergence rate and per-iteration runtime of standard gradient methods may improve dramatically. We develop the appropriate strict complementarity condition for the tensor nuclear norm ball and obtain the following main results under this condition: 1. When the objective to minimize is of the form $f(\mX)=g(\mA\mX)+\langle{\mC,\mX}\rangle$ , where $g$ is strongly convex and $\mA$ is a linear map (e.g., least squares), a quadratic growth bound holds, which implies linear convergence rates for standard projected gradient methods, despite the fact that $f$ need not be strongly convex. 2. For a smooth objective function, when initialized in certain proximity of an optimal solution which satisfies SC, standard projected gradient methods only require SVD computations (for projecting onto the tensor nuclear norm ball) of rank that matches the tubal rank of the optimal solution. In particular, when the tubal rank is constant, this implies nearly linear (in the size of the tensor) runtime per iteration, as opposed to super linear without further assumptions. 3. For a nonsmooth objective function which admits a popular smooth saddle-point formulation, we derive similar results to the latter for the well known extragradient method. An additional contribution which may be of independent interest, is the rigorous extension of many basic results regarding tensors of arbitrary order, which were previously obtained only for third-order tensors.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Projection-free Online Exp-concave Optimization
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ben Kretzu
Abstract:
We consider the setting of online convex optimization (OCO) with \textit{exp-concave} losses. The best regret bound known for this setting is $O(n\log{}T)$, where $n$ is the dimension and $T$ is the number of prediction rounds (treating all other quantities as constants and assuming $T$ is sufficiently large), and is attainable via the well-known Online Newton Step algorithm (ONS). However, ONS re…
▽ More
We consider the setting of online convex optimization (OCO) with \textit{exp-concave} losses. The best regret bound known for this setting is $O(n\log{}T)$, where $n$ is the dimension and $T$ is the number of prediction rounds (treating all other quantities as constants and assuming $T$ is sufficiently large), and is attainable via the well-known Online Newton Step algorithm (ONS). However, ONS requires on each iteration to compute a projection (according to some matrix-induced norm) onto the feasible convex set, which is often computationally prohibitive in high-dimensional settings and when the feasible set admits a non-trivial structure. In this work we consider projection-free online algorithms for exp-concave and smooth losses, where by projection-free we refer to algorithms that rely only on the availability of a linear optimization oracle (LOO) for the feasible set, which in many applications of interest admits much more efficient implementations than a projection oracle. We present an LOO-based ONS-style algorithm, which using overall $O(T)$ calls to a LOO, guarantees in worst case regret bounded by $\widetilde{O}(n^{2/3}T^{2/3})$ (ignoring all quantities except for $n,T$). However, our algorithm is most interesting in an important and plausible low-dimensional data scenario: if the gradients (approximately) span a subspace of dimension at most $ρ$, $ρ<< n$, the regret bound improves to $\widetilde{O}(ρ^{2/3}T^{2/3})$, and by applying standard deterministic sketching techniques, both the space and average additional per-iteration runtime requirements are only $O(ρn)$ (instead of $O(n^2)$). This improves upon recently proposed LOO-based algorithms for OCO which, while having the same state-of-the-art dependence on the horizon $T$, suffer from regret/oracle complexity that scales with $\sqrt{n}$ or worse.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Faster Projection-Free Augmented Lagrangian Methods via Weak Proximal Oracle
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Tsur Livney,
Shoham Sabach
Abstract:
This paper considers a convex composite optimization problem with affine constraints, which includes problems that take the form of minimizing a smooth convex objective function over the intersection of (simple) convex sets, or regularized with multiple (simple) functions. Motivated by high-dimensional applications in which exact projection/proximal computations are not tractable, we propose a \te…
▽ More
This paper considers a convex composite optimization problem with affine constraints, which includes problems that take the form of minimizing a smooth convex objective function over the intersection of (simple) convex sets, or regularized with multiple (simple) functions. Motivated by high-dimensional applications in which exact projection/proximal computations are not tractable, we propose a \textit{projection-free} augmented Lagrangian-based method, in which primal updates are carried out using a \textit{weak proximal oracle} (WPO). In an earlier work, WPO was shown to be more powerful than the standard \textit{linear minimization oracle} (LMO) that underlies conditional gradient-based methods (aka Frank-Wolfe methods). Moreover, WPO is computationally tractable for many high-dimensional problems of interest, including those motivated by recovery of low-rank matrices and tensors, and optimization over polytopes which admit efficient LMOs. The main result of this paper shows that under a certain curvature assumption (which is weaker than strong convexity), our WPO-based algorithm achieves an ergodic rate of convergence of $O(1/T)$ for both the objective residual and feasibility gap. This result, to the best of our knowledge, improves upon the $O(1/\sqrt{T})$ rate for existing LMO-based projection-free methods for this class of problems. Empirical experiments on a low-rank and sparse covariance matrix estimation task and the Max Cut semidefinite relaxation demonstrate that of our method can outperform state-of-the-art LMO-based Lagrangian-based methods.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2023; v1 submitted 25 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Low-Rank Mirror-Prox for Nonsmooth and Low-Rank Matrix Optimization Problems
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Atara Kaplan
Abstract:
Low-rank and nonsmooth matrix optimization problems capture many fundamental tasks in statistics and machine learning. While significant progress has been made in recent years in develo** efficient methods for \textit{smooth} low-rank optimization problems that avoid maintaining high-rank matrices and computing expensive high-rank SVDs, advances for nonsmooth problems have been slow paced. In th…
▽ More
Low-rank and nonsmooth matrix optimization problems capture many fundamental tasks in statistics and machine learning. While significant progress has been made in recent years in develo** efficient methods for \textit{smooth} low-rank optimization problems that avoid maintaining high-rank matrices and computing expensive high-rank SVDs, advances for nonsmooth problems have been slow paced. In this paper we consider standard convex relaxations for such problems. Mainly, we prove that under a \textit{strict complementarity} condition and under the relatively mild assumption that the nonsmooth objective can be written as a maximum of smooth functions, approximated variants of two popular \textit{mirror-prox} methods: the Euclidean \textit{extragradient method} and mirror-prox with \textit{matrix exponentiated gradient updates}, when initialized with a "warm-start", converge to an optimal solution with rate $O(1/t)$, while requiring only two \textit{low-rank} SVDs per iteration. Moreover, for the extragradient method we also consider relaxed versions of strict complementarity which yield a trade-off between the rank of the SVDs required and the radius of the ball in which we need to initialize the method. We support our theoretical results with empirical experiments on several nonsmooth low-rank matrix recovery tasks, demonstrating both the plausibility of the strict complementarity assumption, and the efficient convergence of our proposed low-rank mirror-prox variants.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Frank-Wolfe-based Algorithms for Approximating Tyler's M-estimator
Authors:
Lior Danon,
Dan Garber
Abstract:
Tyler's M-estimator is a well known procedure for robust and heavy-tailed covariance estimation. Tyler himself suggested an iterative fixed-point algorithm for computing his estimator however, it requires super-linear (in the size of the data) runtime per iteration, which maybe prohibitive in large scale. In this work we propose, to the best of our knowledge, the first Frank-Wolfe-based algorithms…
▽ More
Tyler's M-estimator is a well known procedure for robust and heavy-tailed covariance estimation. Tyler himself suggested an iterative fixed-point algorithm for computing his estimator however, it requires super-linear (in the size of the data) runtime per iteration, which maybe prohibitive in large scale. In this work we propose, to the best of our knowledge, the first Frank-Wolfe-based algorithms for computing Tyler's estimator. One variant uses standard Frank-Wolfe steps, the second also considers \textit{away-steps} (AFW), and the third is a \textit{geodesic} version of AFW (GAFW). AFW provably requires, up to a log factor, only linear time per iteration, while GAFW runs in linear time (up to a log factor) in a large $n$ (number of data-points) regime. All three variants are shown to provably converge to the optimal solution with sublinear rate, under standard assumptions, despite the fact that the underlying optimization problem is not convex nor smooth. Under an additional fairly mild assumption, that holds with probability 1 when the (normalized) data-points are i.i.d. samples from a continuous distribution supported on the entire unit sphere, AFW and GAFW are proved to converge with linear rates. Importantly, all three variants are parameter-free and use adaptive step-sizes.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2022; v1 submitted 19 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
New Projection-free Algorithms for Online Convex Optimization with Adaptive Regret Guarantees
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ben Kretzu
Abstract:
We present new efficient \textit{projection-free} algorithms for online convex optimization (OCO), where by projection-free we refer to algorithms that avoid computing orthogonal projections onto the feasible set, and instead relay on different and potentially much more efficient oracles. While most state-of-the-art projection-free algorithms are based on the \textit{follow-the-leader} framework,…
▽ More
We present new efficient \textit{projection-free} algorithms for online convex optimization (OCO), where by projection-free we refer to algorithms that avoid computing orthogonal projections onto the feasible set, and instead relay on different and potentially much more efficient oracles. While most state-of-the-art projection-free algorithms are based on the \textit{follow-the-leader} framework, our algorithms are fundamentally different and are based on the \textit{online gradient descent} algorithm with a novel and efficient approach to computing so-called \textit{infeasible projections}. As a consequence, we obtain the first projection-free algorithms which naturally yield \textit{adaptive regret} guarantees, i.e., regret bounds that hold w.r.t. any sub-interval of the sequence. Concretely, when assuming the availability of a linear optimization oracle (LOO) for the feasible set, on a sequence of length $T$, our algorithms guarantee $O(T^{3/4})$ adaptive regret and $O(T^{3/4})$ adaptive expected regret, for the full-information and bandit settings, respectively, using only $O(T)$ calls to the LOO. These bounds match the current state-of-the-art regret bounds for LOO-based projection-free OCO, which are \textit{not adaptive}. We also consider a new natural setting in which the feasible set is accessible through a separation oracle. We present algorithms which, using overall $O(T)$ calls to the separation oracle, guarantee $O(\sqrt{T})$ adaptive regret and $O(T^{3/4})$ adaptive expected regret for the full-information and bandit settings, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2023; v1 submitted 9 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Low-Rank Extragradient Method for Nonsmooth and Low-Rank Matrix Optimization Problems
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Atara Kaplan
Abstract:
Low-rank and nonsmooth matrix optimization problems capture many fundamental tasks in statistics and machine learning. While significant progress has been made in recent years in develo** efficient methods for \textit{smooth} low-rank optimization problems that avoid maintaining high-rank matrices and computing expensive high-rank SVDs, advances for nonsmooth problems have been slow paced.
In…
▽ More
Low-rank and nonsmooth matrix optimization problems capture many fundamental tasks in statistics and machine learning. While significant progress has been made in recent years in develo** efficient methods for \textit{smooth} low-rank optimization problems that avoid maintaining high-rank matrices and computing expensive high-rank SVDs, advances for nonsmooth problems have been slow paced.
In this paper we consider standard convex relaxations for such problems. Mainly, we prove that under a natural \textit{generalized strict complementarity} condition and under the relatively mild assumption that the nonsmooth objective can be written as a maximum of smooth functions, the \textit{extragradient method}, when initialized with a "warm-start" point, converges to an optimal solution with rate $O(1/t)$ while requiring only two \textit{low-rank} SVDs per iteration. We give a precise trade-off between the rank of the SVDs required and the radius of the ball in which we need to initialize the method. We support our theoretical results with empirical experiments on several nonsmooth low-rank matrix recovery tasks, demonstrating that using simple initializations, the extragradient method produces exactly the same iterates when full-rank SVDs are replaced with SVDs of rank that matches the rank of the (low-rank) ground-truth matrix to be recovered.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Local Linear Convergence of Gradient Methods for Subspace Optimization via Strict Complementarity
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ron Fisher
Abstract:
We consider optimization problems in which the goal is find a $k$-dimensional subspace of $\mathbb{R}^n$, $k<<n$, which minimizes a convex and smooth loss. Such problems generalize the fundamental task of principal component analysis (PCA) to include robust and sparse counterparts, and logistic PCA for binary data, among others. This problem could be approached either via nonconvex gradient method…
▽ More
We consider optimization problems in which the goal is find a $k$-dimensional subspace of $\mathbb{R}^n$, $k<<n$, which minimizes a convex and smooth loss. Such problems generalize the fundamental task of principal component analysis (PCA) to include robust and sparse counterparts, and logistic PCA for binary data, among others. This problem could be approached either via nonconvex gradient methods with highly-efficient iterations, but for which arguing about fast convergence to a global minimizer is difficult or, via a convex relaxation for which arguing about convergence to a global minimizer is straightforward, but the corresponding methods are often inefficient in high dimensions. In this work we bridge these two approaches under a strict complementarity assumption, which in particular implies that the optimal solution to the convex relaxation is unique and is also the optimal solution to the original nonconvex problem. Our main result is a proof that a natural nonconvex gradient method which is \textit{SVD-free} and requires only a single QR-factorization of an $n\times k$ matrix per iteration, converges locally with a linear rate. We also establish linear convergence results for the nonconvex projected gradient method, and the Frank-Wolfe method when applied to the convex relaxation.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2022; v1 submitted 8 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Frank-Wolfe with a Nearest Extreme Point Oracle
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Noam Wolf
Abstract:
We consider variants of the classical Frank-Wolfe algorithm for constrained smooth convex minimization, that instead of access to the standard oracle for minimizing a linear function over the feasible set, have access to an oracle that can find an extreme point of the feasible set that is closest in Euclidean distance to a given vector. We first show that for many feasible sets of interest, such a…
▽ More
We consider variants of the classical Frank-Wolfe algorithm for constrained smooth convex minimization, that instead of access to the standard oracle for minimizing a linear function over the feasible set, have access to an oracle that can find an extreme point of the feasible set that is closest in Euclidean distance to a given vector. We first show that for many feasible sets of interest, such an oracle can be implemented with the same complexity as the standard linear optimization oracle. We then show that with such an oracle we can design new Frank-Wolfe variants which enjoy significantly improved complexity bounds in case the set of optimal solutions lies in the convex hull of a subset of extreme points with small diameter (e.g., a low-dimensional face of a polytope). In particular, for many $0\text{--}1$ polytopes, under quadratic growth and strict complementarity conditions, we obtain the first linearly convergent variant with rate that depends only on the dimension of the optimal face and not on the ambient dimension.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2022; v1 submitted 3 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
On the Efficient Implementation of the Matrix Exponentiated Gradient Algorithm for Low-Rank Matrix Optimization
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Atara Kaplan
Abstract:
Convex optimization over the spectrahedron, i.e., the set of all real $n\times n$ positive semidefinite matrices with unit trace, has important applications in machine learning, signal processing and statistics, mainly as a convex relaxation for optimization problems with low-rank matrices. It is also one of the most prominent examples in the theory of first-order methods for convex optimization i…
▽ More
Convex optimization over the spectrahedron, i.e., the set of all real $n\times n$ positive semidefinite matrices with unit trace, has important applications in machine learning, signal processing and statistics, mainly as a convex relaxation for optimization problems with low-rank matrices. It is also one of the most prominent examples in the theory of first-order methods for convex optimization in which non-Euclidean methods can be significantly preferable to their Euclidean counterparts. In particular, the desirable choice is the Matrix Exponentiated Gradient (MEG) method which is based on the Bregman distance induced by the (negative) von Neumann entropy. Unfortunately, implementing MEG requires a full SVD computation on each iteration, which is not scalable to high-dimensional problems. In this work we propose an efficient implementations of MEG, both with deterministic and stochastic gradients, which are tailored for optimization with low-rank matrices, and only use a single low-rank SVD computation on each iteration. We also provide efficiently-computable certificates for the correct convergence of our methods. Mainly, we prove that under a strict complementarity condition, the suggested methods converge from a ``warm-start" initialization with similar rates to their full-SVD-based counterparts. Finally, we bring empirical experiments which both support our theoretical findings and demonstrate the practical appeal of our methods.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2022; v1 submitted 18 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Revisiting Projection-free Online Learning: the Strongly Convex Case
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ben Kretzu
Abstract:
Projection-free optimization algorithms, which are mostly based on the classical Frank-Wolfe method, have gained significant interest in the machine learning community in recent years due to their ability to handle convex constraints that are popular in many applications, but for which computing projections is often computationally impractical in high-dimensional settings, and hence prohibit the u…
▽ More
Projection-free optimization algorithms, which are mostly based on the classical Frank-Wolfe method, have gained significant interest in the machine learning community in recent years due to their ability to handle convex constraints that are popular in many applications, but for which computing projections is often computationally impractical in high-dimensional settings, and hence prohibit the use of most standard projection-based methods. In particular, a significant research effort was put on projection-free methods for online learning. In this paper we revisit the Online Frank-Wolfe (OFW) method suggested by Hazan and Kale \cite{Hazan12} and fill a gap that has been left unnoticed for several years: OFW achieves a faster rate of $O(T^{2/3})$ on strongly convex functions (as opposed to the standard $O(T^{3/4})$ for convex but not strongly convex functions), where $T$ is the sequence length. This is somewhat surprising since it is known that for offline optimization, in general, strong convexity does not lead to faster rates for Frank-Wolfe. We also revisit the bandit setting under strong convexity and prove a similar bound of $\tilde O(T^{2/3})$ (instead of $O(T^{3/4})$ without strong convexity). Hence, in the current state-of-affairs, the best projection-free upper-bounds for the full-information and bandit settings with strongly convex and nonsmooth functions match up to logarithmic factors in $T$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021; v1 submitted 15 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Revisiting Frank-Wolfe for Polytopes: Strict Complementarity and Sparsity
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
In recent years it was proved that simple modifications of the classical Frank-Wolfe algorithm (aka conditional gradient algorithm) for smooth convex minimization over convex and compact polytopes, converge with linear rate, assuming the objective function has the quadratic growth property. However, the rate of these methods depends explicitly on the dimension of the problem which cannot explain t…
▽ More
In recent years it was proved that simple modifications of the classical Frank-Wolfe algorithm (aka conditional gradient algorithm) for smooth convex minimization over convex and compact polytopes, converge with linear rate, assuming the objective function has the quadratic growth property. However, the rate of these methods depends explicitly on the dimension of the problem which cannot explain their empirical success for large scale problems. In this paper we first demonstrate that already for very simple problems and even when the optimal solution lies on a low-dimensional face of the polytope, such dependence on the dimension cannot be avoided in worst case. We then revisit the addition of a strict complementarity assumption already considered in Wolfe's classical book \cite{Wolfe1970}, and prove that under this condition, the Frank-Wolfe method with away-steps and line-search converges linearly with rate that depends explicitly only on the dimension of the optimal face. We motivate strict complementarity by proving that it implies sparsity-robustness of optimal solutions to noise.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2021; v1 submitted 31 May, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
On the Convergence of Stochastic Gradient Descent with Low-Rank Projections for Convex Low-Rank Matrix Problems
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
We revisit the use of Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) for solving convex optimization problems that serve as highly popular convex relaxations for many important low-rank matrix recovery problems such as \textit{matrix completion}, \textit{phase retrieval}, and more. The computational limitation of applying SGD to solving these relaxations in large-scale is the need to compute a potentially high…
▽ More
We revisit the use of Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD) for solving convex optimization problems that serve as highly popular convex relaxations for many important low-rank matrix recovery problems such as \textit{matrix completion}, \textit{phase retrieval}, and more. The computational limitation of applying SGD to solving these relaxations in large-scale is the need to compute a potentially high-rank singular value decomposition (SVD) on each iteration in order to enforce the low-rank-promoting constraint. We begin by considering a simple and natural sufficient condition so that these relaxations indeed admit low-rank solutions. This condition is also necessary for a certain notion of low-rank-robustness to hold. Our main result shows that under this condition which involves the eigenvalues of the gradient vector at optimal points, SGD with mini-batches, when initialized with a "warm-start" point, produces iterates that are low-rank with high probability, and hence only a low-rank SVD computation is required on each iteration. This suggests that SGD may indeed be practically applicable to solving large-scale convex relaxations of low-rank matrix recovery problems. Our theoretical results are accompanied with supporting preliminary empirical evidence. As a side benefit, our analysis is quite simple and short.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2020; v1 submitted 31 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Linear Convergence of Frank-Wolfe for Rank-One Matrix Recovery Without Strong Convexity
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
We consider convex optimization problems which are widely used as convex relaxations for low-rank matrix recovery problems. In particular, in several important problems, such as phase retrieval and robust PCA, the underlying assumption in many cases is that the optimal solution is rank-one. In this paper we consider a simple and natural sufficient condition on the objective so that the optimal sol…
▽ More
We consider convex optimization problems which are widely used as convex relaxations for low-rank matrix recovery problems. In particular, in several important problems, such as phase retrieval and robust PCA, the underlying assumption in many cases is that the optimal solution is rank-one. In this paper we consider a simple and natural sufficient condition on the objective so that the optimal solution to these relaxations is indeed unique and rank-one. Mainly, we show that under this condition, the standard Frank-Wolfe method with line-search (i.e., without any tuning of parameters whatsoever), which only requires a single rank-one SVD computation per iteration, finds an $ε$-approximated solution in only $O(\log{1/ε})$ iterations (as opposed to the previous best known bound of $O(1/ε)$), despite the fact that the objective is not strongly convex. We consider several variants of the basic method with improved complexities, as well as an extension motivated by robust PCA, and finally, an extension to nonsmooth problems.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2022; v1 submitted 3 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Improved Regret Bounds for Projection-free Bandit Convex Optimization
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ben Kretzu
Abstract:
We revisit the challenge of designing online algorithms for the bandit convex optimization problem (BCO) which are also scalable to high dimensional problems. Hence, we consider algorithms that are \textit{projection-free}, i.e., based on the conditional gradient method whose only access to the feasible decision set, is through a linear optimization oracle (as opposed to other methods which requir…
▽ More
We revisit the challenge of designing online algorithms for the bandit convex optimization problem (BCO) which are also scalable to high dimensional problems. Hence, we consider algorithms that are \textit{projection-free}, i.e., based on the conditional gradient method whose only access to the feasible decision set, is through a linear optimization oracle (as opposed to other methods which require potentially much more computationally-expensive subprocedures, such as computing Euclidean projections). We present the first such algorithm that attains $O(T^{3/4})$ expected regret using only $O(T)$ overall calls to the linear optimization oracle, in expectation, where $T$ is the number of prediction rounds. This improves over the $O(T^{4/5})$ expected regret bound recently obtained by \cite{Karbasi19}, and actually matches the current best regret bound for projection-free online learning in the \textit{full information} setting.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
On the Convergence of Projected-Gradient Methods with Low-Rank Projections for Smooth Convex Minimization over Trace-Norm Balls and Related Problems
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
Smooth convex minimization over the unit trace-norm ball is an important optimization problem in machine learning, signal processing, statistics and other fields, that underlies many tasks in which one wishes to recover a low-rank matrix given certain measurements. While first-order methods for convex optimization enjoy optimal convergence rates, they require in worst-case to compute a full-rank S…
▽ More
Smooth convex minimization over the unit trace-norm ball is an important optimization problem in machine learning, signal processing, statistics and other fields, that underlies many tasks in which one wishes to recover a low-rank matrix given certain measurements. While first-order methods for convex optimization enjoy optimal convergence rates, they require in worst-case to compute a full-rank SVD on each iteration, in order to compute the projection onto the trace-norm ball. These full-rank SVD computations however prohibit the application of such methods to large problems. A simple and natural heuristic to reduce the computational cost is to approximate the projection using only a low-rank SVD. This raises the question if, and under what conditions, this simple heuristic can indeed result in provable convergence to the optimal solution. In this paper we show that any optimal solution is a center of a Euclid. ball inside-which the projected-gradient map** admits rank that is at most the multiplicity of the largest singular value of the gradient vector. Moreover, the radius of the ball scales with the spectral gap of this gradient vector. We show how this readily implies the local convergence (i.e., from a "warm-start" initialization) of standard first-order methods, using only low-rank SVD computations. We also quantify the effect of "over-parameterization", i.e., using SVD computations with higher rank, on the radius of this ball, showing it can increase dramatically with moderately larger rank. We extend our results also to the setting of optimization with trace-norm regularization and optimization over bounded-trace positive semidefinite matrices. Our theoretical investigation is supported by concrete empirical evidence that demonstrates the \textit{correct} convergence of first-order methods with low-rank projections on real-world datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2020; v1 submitted 5 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
On the Regret Minimization of Nonconvex Online Gradient Ascent for Online PCA
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
In this paper we focus on the problem of Online Principal Component Analysis in the regret minimization framework. For this problem, all existing regret minimization algorithms for the fully-adversarial setting are based on a positive semidefinite convex relaxation, and hence require quadratic memory and SVD computation (either thin of full) on each iteration, which amounts to at least quadratic r…
▽ More
In this paper we focus on the problem of Online Principal Component Analysis in the regret minimization framework. For this problem, all existing regret minimization algorithms for the fully-adversarial setting are based on a positive semidefinite convex relaxation, and hence require quadratic memory and SVD computation (either thin of full) on each iteration, which amounts to at least quadratic runtime per iteration. This is in stark contrast to a corresponding stochastic i.i.d. variant of the problem, which was studied extensively lately, and admits very efficient gradient ascent algorithms that work directly on the natural non-convex formulation of the problem, and hence require only linear memory and linear runtime per iteration. This raises the question: can non-convex online gradient ascent algorithms be shown to minimize regret in online adversarial settings? In this paper we take a step forward towards answering this question. We introduce an \textit{adversarially-perturbed spiked-covariance model} in which, each data point is assumed to follow a fixed stochastic distribution with a non-zero spectral gap in the covariance matrix, but is then perturbed with some adversarial vector. This model is a natural extension of a well studied standard stochastic setting that allows for non-stationary (adversarial) patterns to arise in the data and hence, might serve as a significantly better approximation for real-world data-streams. We show that in an interesting regime of parameters, when the non-convex online gradient ascent algorithm is initialized with a "warm-start" vector, it provably minimizes the regret with high probability. We further discuss the possibility of computing such a "warm-start" vector, and also the use of regularization to obtain fast regret rates. Our theoretical findings are supported by empirical experiments on both synthetic and real-world data.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2019; v1 submitted 27 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Fast Stochastic Algorithms for Low-rank and Nonsmooth Matrix Problems
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Atara Kaplan
Abstract:
Composite convex optimization problems which include both a nonsmooth term and a low-rank promoting term have important applications in machine learning and signal processing, such as when one wishes to recover an unknown matrix that is simultaneously low-rank and sparse. However, such problems are highly challenging to solve in large-scale: the low-rank promoting term prohibits efficient implemen…
▽ More
Composite convex optimization problems which include both a nonsmooth term and a low-rank promoting term have important applications in machine learning and signal processing, such as when one wishes to recover an unknown matrix that is simultaneously low-rank and sparse. However, such problems are highly challenging to solve in large-scale: the low-rank promoting term prohibits efficient implementations of proximal methods for composite optimization and even simple subgradient methods. On the other hand, methods which are tailored for low-rank optimization, such as conditional gradient-type methods, which are often applied to a smooth approximation of the nonsmooth objective, are slow since their runtime scales with both the large Lipshitz parameter of the smoothed gradient vector and with $1/ε$. In this paper we develop efficient algorithms for \textit{stochastic} optimization of a strongly-convex objective which includes both a nonsmooth term and a low-rank promoting term. In particular, to the best of our knowledge, we present the first algorithm that enjoys all following critical properties for large-scale problems: i) (nearly) optimal sample complexity, ii) each iteration requires only a single \textit{low-rank} SVD computation, and iii) overall number of thin-SVD computations scales only with $\log{1/ε}$ (as opposed to $\textrm{poly}(1/ε)$ in previous methods). We also give an algorithm for the closely-related finite-sum setting. At the heart of our results lie a novel combination of a variance-reduction technique and the use of a \textit{weak-proximal oracle} which is key to obtaining all above three properties simultaneously.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Learning of Optimal Forecast Aggregation in Partial Evidence Environments
Authors:
Yakov Babichenko,
Dan Garber
Abstract:
We consider the forecast aggregation problem in repeated settings, where the forecasts are done on a binary event. At each period multiple experts provide forecasts about an event. The goal of the aggregator is to aggregate those forecasts into a subjective accurate forecast. We assume that experts are Bayesian; namely they share a common prior, each expert is exposed to some evidence, and each ex…
▽ More
We consider the forecast aggregation problem in repeated settings, where the forecasts are done on a binary event. At each period multiple experts provide forecasts about an event. The goal of the aggregator is to aggregate those forecasts into a subjective accurate forecast. We assume that experts are Bayesian; namely they share a common prior, each expert is exposed to some evidence, and each expert applies Bayes rule to deduce his forecast. The aggregator is ignorant with respect to the information structure (i.e., distribution over evidence) according to which experts make their prediction. The aggregator observes the experts' forecasts only. At the end of each period the actual state is realized. We focus on the question whether the aggregator can learn to aggregate optimally the forecasts of the experts, where the optimal aggregation is the Bayesian aggregation that takes into account all the information (evidence) in the system.
We consider the class of partial evidence information structures, where each expert is exposed to a different subset of conditionally independent signals. Our main results are positive; We show that optimal aggregation can be learned in polynomial time in a quite wide range of instances of the partial evidence environments. We provide a tight characterization of the instances where learning is possible and impossible.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Improved Complexities of Conditional Gradient-Type Methods with Applications to Robust Matrix Recovery Problems
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Shoham Sabach,
Atara Kaplan
Abstract:
Motivated by robust matrix recovery problems such as Robust Principal Component Analysis, we consider a general optimization problem of minimizing a smooth and strongly convex loss function applied to the sum of two blocks of variables, where each block of variables is constrained or regularized individually. We study a Conditional Gradient-Type method which is able to leverage the special structu…
▽ More
Motivated by robust matrix recovery problems such as Robust Principal Component Analysis, we consider a general optimization problem of minimizing a smooth and strongly convex loss function applied to the sum of two blocks of variables, where each block of variables is constrained or regularized individually. We study a Conditional Gradient-Type method which is able to leverage the special structure of the problem to obtain faster convergence rates than those attainable via standard methods, under a variety of assumptions. In particular, our method is appealing for matrix problems in which one of the blocks corresponds to a low-rank matrix since it avoids prohibitive full-rank singular value decompositions required by most standard methods. While our initial motivation comes from problems which originated in statistics, our analysis does not impose any statistical assumptions on the data.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2019; v1 submitted 15 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Logarithmic Regret for Online Gradient Descent Beyond Strong Convexity
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
Hoffman's classical result gives a bound on the distance of a point from a convex and compact polytope in terms of the magnitude of violation of the constraints. Recently, several results showed that Hoffman's bound can be used to derive strongly-convex-like rates for first-order methods for \textit{offline} convex optimization of curved, though not strongly convex, functions, over polyhedral sets…
▽ More
Hoffman's classical result gives a bound on the distance of a point from a convex and compact polytope in terms of the magnitude of violation of the constraints. Recently, several results showed that Hoffman's bound can be used to derive strongly-convex-like rates for first-order methods for \textit{offline} convex optimization of curved, though not strongly convex, functions, over polyhedral sets. In this work, we use this classical result for the first time to obtain faster rates for \textit{online convex optimization} over polyhedral sets with curved convex, though not strongly convex, loss functions. We show that under several reasonable assumptions on the data, the standard \textit{Online Gradient Descent} algorithm guarantees logarithmic regret. To the best of our knowledge, the only previous algorithm to achieve logarithmic regret in the considered settings is the \textit{Online Newton Step} algorithm which requires quadratic (in the dimension) memory and at least quadratic runtime per iteration, which greatly limits its applicability to large-scale problems. In particular, our results hold for \textit{semi-adversarial} settings in which the data is a combination of an arbitrary (adversarial) sequence and a stochastic sequence, which might provide reasonable approximation for many real-world sequences, or under a natural assumption that the data is low-rank. We demonstrate via experiments that the regret of OGD is indeed comparable to that of ONS (and even far better) on curved though not strongly-convex losses.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2019; v1 submitted 13 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Efficient Online Linear Optimization with Approximation Algorithms
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
We revisit the problem of \textit{online linear optimization} in case the set of feasible actions is accessible through an approximated linear optimization oracle with a factor $α$ multiplicative approximation guarantee. This setting is in particular interesting since it captures natural online extensions of well-studied \textit{offline} linear optimization problems which are NP-hard, yet admit ef…
▽ More
We revisit the problem of \textit{online linear optimization} in case the set of feasible actions is accessible through an approximated linear optimization oracle with a factor $α$ multiplicative approximation guarantee. This setting is in particular interesting since it captures natural online extensions of well-studied \textit{offline} linear optimization problems which are NP-hard, yet admit efficient approximation algorithms. The goal here is to minimize the $α$\textit{-regret} which is the natural extension of the standard \textit{regret} in \textit{online learning} to this setting.
We present new algorithms with significantly improved oracle complexity for both the full information and bandit variants of the problem. Mainly, for both variants, we present $α$-regret bounds of $O(T^{-1/3})$, were $T$ is the number of prediction rounds, using only $O(\log{T})$ calls to the approximation oracle per iteration, on average. These are the first results to obtain both average oracle complexity of $O(\log{T})$ (or even poly-logarithmic in $T$) and $α$-regret bound $O(T^{-c})$ for a constant $c>0$, for both variants.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Communication-efficient Algorithms for Distributed Stochastic Principal Component Analysis
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ohad Shamir,
Nathan Srebro
Abstract:
We study the fundamental problem of Principal Component Analysis in a statistical distributed setting in which each machine out of $m$ stores a sample of $n$ points sampled i.i.d. from a single unknown distribution. We study algorithms for estimating the leading principal component of the population covariance matrix that are both communication-efficient and achieve estimation error of the order o…
▽ More
We study the fundamental problem of Principal Component Analysis in a statistical distributed setting in which each machine out of $m$ stores a sample of $n$ points sampled i.i.d. from a single unknown distribution. We study algorithms for estimating the leading principal component of the population covariance matrix that are both communication-efficient and achieve estimation error of the order of the centralized ERM solution that uses all $mn$ samples. On the negative side, we show that in contrast to results obtained for distributed estimation under convexity assumptions, for the PCA objective, simply averaging the local ERM solutions cannot guarantee error that is consistent with the centralized ERM. We show that this unfortunate phenomena can be remedied by performing a simple correction step which correlates between the individual solutions, and provides an estimator that is consistent with the centralized ERM for sufficiently-large $n$. We also introduce an iterative distributed algorithm that is applicable in any regime of $n$, which is based on distributed matrix-vector products. The algorithm gives significant acceleration in terms of communication rounds over previous distributed algorithms, in a wide regime of parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Efficient coordinate-wise leading eigenvector computation
Authors:
Jialei Wang,
Weiran Wang,
Dan Garber,
Nathan Srebro
Abstract:
We develop and analyze efficient "coordinate-wise" methods for finding the leading eigenvector, where each step involves only a vector-vector product. We establish global convergence with overall runtime guarantees that are at least as good as Lanczos's method and dominate it for slowly decaying spectrum. Our methods are based on combining a shift-and-invert approach with coordinate-wise algorithm…
▽ More
We develop and analyze efficient "coordinate-wise" methods for finding the leading eigenvector, where each step involves only a vector-vector product. We establish global convergence with overall runtime guarantees that are at least as good as Lanczos's method and dominate it for slowly decaying spectrum. Our methods are based on combining a shift-and-invert approach with coordinate-wise algorithms for linear regression.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Stochastic Canonical Correlation Analysis
Authors:
Chao Gao,
Dan Garber,
Nathan Srebro,
Jialei Wang,
Weiran Wang
Abstract:
We study the sample complexity of canonical correlation analysis (CCA), \ie, the number of samples needed to estimate the population canonical correlation and directions up to arbitrarily small error. With mild assumptions on the data distribution, we show that in order to achieve $ε$-suboptimality in a properly defined measure of alignment between the estimated canonical directions and the popula…
▽ More
We study the sample complexity of canonical correlation analysis (CCA), \ie, the number of samples needed to estimate the population canonical correlation and directions up to arbitrarily small error. With mild assumptions on the data distribution, we show that in order to achieve $ε$-suboptimality in a properly defined measure of alignment between the estimated canonical directions and the population solution, we can solve the empirical objective exactly with $N(ε, Δ, γ)$ samples, where $Δ$ is the singular value gap of the whitened cross-covariance matrix and $1/γ$ is an upper bound of the condition number of auto-covariance matrices. Moreover, we can achieve the same learning accuracy by drawing the same level of samples and solving the empirical objective approximately with a stochastic optimization algorithm; this algorithm is based on the shift-and-invert power iterations and only needs to process the dataset for $\mathcal{O}\left(\log \frac{1}ε \right)$ passes. Finally, we show that, given an estimate of the canonical correlation, the streaming version of the shift-and-invert power iterations achieves the same learning accuracy with the same level of sample complexity, by processing the data only once.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019; v1 submitted 20 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Faster Eigenvector Computation via Shift-and-Invert Preconditioning
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Elad Hazan,
Chi **,
Sham M. Kakade,
Cameron Musco,
Praneeth Netrapalli,
Aaron Sidford
Abstract:
We give faster algorithms and improved sample complexities for estimating the top eigenvector of a matrix $Σ$ -- i.e. computing a unit vector $x$ such that $x^T Σx \ge (1-ε)λ_1(Σ)$:
Offline Eigenvector Estimation: Given an explicit $A \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times d}$ with $Σ= A^TA$, we show how to compute an $ε$ approximate top eigenvector in time…
▽ More
We give faster algorithms and improved sample complexities for estimating the top eigenvector of a matrix $Σ$ -- i.e. computing a unit vector $x$ such that $x^T Σx \ge (1-ε)λ_1(Σ)$:
Offline Eigenvector Estimation: Given an explicit $A \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times d}$ with $Σ= A^TA$, we show how to compute an $ε$ approximate top eigenvector in time $\tilde O([nnz(A) + \frac{d*sr(A)}{gap^2} ]* \log 1/ε)$ and $\tilde O([\frac{nnz(A)^{3/4} (d*sr(A))^{1/4}}{\sqrt{gap}} ] * \log 1/ε)$. Here $nnz(A)$ is the number of nonzeros in $A$, $sr(A)$ is the stable rank, $gap$ is the relative eigengap. By separating the $gap$ dependence from the $nnz(A)$ term, our first runtime improves upon the classical power and Lanczos methods. It also improves prior work using fast subspace embeddings [AC09, CW13] and stochastic optimization [Sha15c], giving significantly better dependencies on $sr(A)$ and $ε$. Our second running time improves these further when $nnz(A) \le \frac{d*sr(A)}{gap^2}$.
Online Eigenvector Estimation: Given a distribution $D$ with covariance matrix $Σ$ and a vector $x_0$ which is an $O(gap)$ approximate top eigenvector for $Σ$, we show how to refine to an $ε$ approximation using $ O(\frac{var(D)}{gap*ε})$ samples from $D$. Here $var(D)$ is a natural notion of variance. Combining our algorithm with previous work to initialize $x_0$, we obtain improved sample complexity and runtime results under a variety of assumptions on $D$.
We achieve our results using a general framework that we believe is of independent interest. We give a robust analysis of the classic method of shift-and-invert preconditioning to reduce eigenvector computation to approximately solving a sequence of linear systems. We then apply fast stochastic variance reduced gradient (SVRG) based system solvers to achieve our claims.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Linear-memory and Decomposition-invariant Linearly Convergent Conditional Gradient Algorithm for Structured Polytopes
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Ofer Meshi
Abstract:
Recently, several works have shown that natural modifications of the classical conditional gradient method (aka Frank-Wolfe algorithm) for constrained convex optimization, provably converge with a linear rate when: i) the feasible set is a polytope, and ii) the objective is smooth and strongly-convex. However, all of these results suffer from two significant shortcomings: large memory requirement…
▽ More
Recently, several works have shown that natural modifications of the classical conditional gradient method (aka Frank-Wolfe algorithm) for constrained convex optimization, provably converge with a linear rate when: i) the feasible set is a polytope, and ii) the objective is smooth and strongly-convex. However, all of these results suffer from two significant shortcomings: large memory requirement due to the need to store an explicit convex decomposition of the current iterate, and as a consequence, large running-time overhead per iteration, and worst case convergence rate that depends unfavorably on the dimension.
In this work we present a new conditional gradient variant and a corresponding analysis that improves on both of the above shortcomings. In particular: both memory and computation overheads are only linear in the dimension. Moreover, in case the optimal solution is sparse, the new convergence rate replaces a factor which is at least linear in the dimension in previous works, with a linear dependence on the number of non-zeros in the optimal solution.
At the heart of our method, and corresponding analysis, is a novel way to compute decomposition-invariant away-steps. While our theoretical guarantees do not apply to any polytope, they apply to several important structured polytopes that capture central concepts such as paths in graphs, perfect matchings in bipartite graphs, marginal distributions that arise in structured prediction tasks, and more. Our theoretical findings are complemented by empirical evidence which shows that our method delivers state-of-the-art performance.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Faster Projection-free Convex Optimization over the Spectrahedron
Authors:
Dan Garber
Abstract:
Minimizing a convex function over the spectrahedron, i.e., the set of all positive semidefinite matrices with unit trace, is an important optimization task with many applications in optimization, machine learning, and signal processing. It is also notoriously difficult to solve in large-scale since standard techniques require expensive matrix decompositions. An alternative, is the conditional grad…
▽ More
Minimizing a convex function over the spectrahedron, i.e., the set of all positive semidefinite matrices with unit trace, is an important optimization task with many applications in optimization, machine learning, and signal processing. It is also notoriously difficult to solve in large-scale since standard techniques require expensive matrix decompositions. An alternative, is the conditional gradient method (aka Frank-Wolfe algorithm) that regained much interest in recent years, mostly due to its application to this specific setting. The key benefit of the CG method is that it avoids expensive matrix decompositions all together, and simply requires a single eigenvector computation per iteration, which is much more efficient. On the downside, the CG method, in general, converges with an inferior rate. The error for minimizing a $β$-smooth function after $t$ iterations scales like $β/t$. This convergence rate does not improve even if the function is also strongly convex.
In this work we present a modification of the CG method tailored for convex optimization over the spectrahedron. The per-iteration complexity of the method is essentially identical to that of the standard CG method: only a single eigenvecor computation is required. For minimizing an $α$-strongly convex and $β$-smooth function, the expected approximation error of the method after $t$ iterations is: $$O\left({\min\{\frac{β}{t} ,\left({\frac{β\sqrt{\textrm{rank}(\textbf{X}^*)}}{α^{1/4}t}}\right)^{4/3}, \left({\fracβ{\sqrtαλ_{\min}(\textbf{X}^*)t}}\right)^{2}\}}\right) ,$$ where $\textbf{X}^*$ is the optimal solution. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first result that attains provably faster convergence rates for a CG variant for optimization over the spectrahedron. We also present encouraging preliminary empirical results.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Efficient Globally Convergent Stochastic Optimization for Canonical Correlation Analysis
Authors:
Weiran Wang,
Jialei Wang,
Dan Garber,
Nathan Srebro
Abstract:
We study the stochastic optimization of canonical correlation analysis (CCA), whose objective is nonconvex and does not decouple over training samples. Although several stochastic gradient based optimization algorithms have been recently proposed to solve this problem, no global convergence guarantee was provided by any of them. Inspired by the alternating least squares/power iterations formulatio…
▽ More
We study the stochastic optimization of canonical correlation analysis (CCA), whose objective is nonconvex and does not decouple over training samples. Although several stochastic gradient based optimization algorithms have been recently proposed to solve this problem, no global convergence guarantee was provided by any of them. Inspired by the alternating least squares/power iterations formulation of CCA, and the shift-and-invert preconditioning method for PCA, we propose two globally convergent meta-algorithms for CCA, both of which transform the original problem into sequences of least squares problems that need only be solved approximately. We instantiate the meta-algorithms with state-of-the-art SGD methods and obtain time complexities that significantly improve upon that of previous work. Experimental results demonstrate their superior performance.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2016; v1 submitted 7 April, 2016;
originally announced April 2016.
-
Fast and Simple PCA via Convex Optimization
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Elad Hazan
Abstract:
The problem of principle component analysis (PCA) is traditionally solved by spectral or algebraic methods. We show how computing the leading principal component could be reduced to solving a \textit{small} number of well-conditioned {\it convex} optimization problems. This gives rise to a new efficient method for PCA based on recent advances in stochastic methods for convex optimization.
In par…
▽ More
The problem of principle component analysis (PCA) is traditionally solved by spectral or algebraic methods. We show how computing the leading principal component could be reduced to solving a \textit{small} number of well-conditioned {\it convex} optimization problems. This gives rise to a new efficient method for PCA based on recent advances in stochastic methods for convex optimization.
In particular we show that given a $d\times d$ matrix $\X = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^n\x_i\x_i^{\top}$ with top eigenvector $\u$ and top eigenvalue $λ_1$ it is possible to: \begin{itemize} \item compute a unit vector $\w$ such that $(\w^{\top}\u)^2 \geq 1-ε$ in $\tilde{O}\left({\frac{d}{δ^2}+N}\right)$ time, where $δ= λ_1 - λ_2$ and $N$ is the total number of non-zero entries in $\x_1,...,\x_n$,
\item compute a unit vector $\w$ such that $\w^{\top}\X\w \geq λ_1-ε$ in $\tilde{O}(d/ε^2)$ time. \end{itemize} To the best of our knowledge, these bounds are the fastest to date for a wide regime of parameters. These results could be further accelerated when $δ$ (in the first case) and $ε$ (in the second case) are smaller than $\sqrt{d/N}$.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2015; v1 submitted 18 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Faster Rates for the Frank-Wolfe Method over Strongly-Convex Sets
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Elad Hazan
Abstract:
The Frank-Wolfe method (a.k.a. conditional gradient algorithm) for smooth optimization has regained much interest in recent years in the context of large scale optimization and machine learning. A key advantage of the method is that it avoids projections - the computational bottleneck in many applications - replacing it by a linear optimization step. Despite this advantage, the known convergence r…
▽ More
The Frank-Wolfe method (a.k.a. conditional gradient algorithm) for smooth optimization has regained much interest in recent years in the context of large scale optimization and machine learning. A key advantage of the method is that it avoids projections - the computational bottleneck in many applications - replacing it by a linear optimization step. Despite this advantage, the known convergence rates of the FW method fall behind standard first order methods for most settings of interest. It is an active line of research to derive faster linear optimization-based algorithms for various settings of convex optimization.
In this paper we consider the special case of optimization over strongly convex sets, for which we prove that the vanila FW method converges at a rate of $\frac{1}{t^2}$. This gives a quadratic improvement in convergence rate compared to the general case, in which convergence is of the order $\frac{1}{t}$, and known to be tight. We show that various balls induced by $\ell_p$ norms, Schatten norms and group norms are strongly convex on one hand and on the other hand, linear optimization over these sets is straightforward and admits a closed-form solution. We further show how several previous fast-rate results for the FW method follow easily from our analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2015; v1 submitted 5 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
Length-based attacks in polycyclic groups
Authors:
David Garber,
Delaram Kahrobaei,
Ha T. Lam
Abstract:
After the Anshel-Anshel-Goldfeld (AAG) key-exchange protocol was introduced in 1999, it was implemented and studied with braid groups and with the Thompson group as its underlying platforms. The length-based attack, introduced by Hughes and Tannenbaum, has been used to extensively study AAG with the braid group as the underlying platform. Meanwhile, a new platform, using polycyclic groups, was pro…
▽ More
After the Anshel-Anshel-Goldfeld (AAG) key-exchange protocol was introduced in 1999, it was implemented and studied with braid groups and with the Thompson group as its underlying platforms. The length-based attack, introduced by Hughes and Tannenbaum, has been used to extensively study AAG with the braid group as the underlying platform. Meanwhile, a new platform, using polycyclic groups, was proposed by Eick and Kahrobaei.
In this paper, we show that with a high enough Hirsch length, the polycyclic group as an underlying platform for AAG is resistant to the length-based attack. In particular, polycyclic groups could provide a secure platform for any cryptosystem based on conjugacy search problem such as non-commutative Diffie-Hellman, ElGamal and Cramer-Shoup key exchange protocols.
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2014; v1 submitted 2 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
A Linearly Convergent Conditional Gradient Algorithm with Applications to Online and Stochastic Optimization
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Elad Hazan
Abstract:
Linear optimization is many times algorithmically simpler than non-linear convex optimization. Linear optimization over matroid polytopes, matching polytopes and path polytopes are example of problems for which we have simple and efficient combinatorial algorithms, but whose non-linear convex counterpart is harder and admits significantly less efficient algorithms. This motivates the computational…
▽ More
Linear optimization is many times algorithmically simpler than non-linear convex optimization. Linear optimization over matroid polytopes, matching polytopes and path polytopes are example of problems for which we have simple and efficient combinatorial algorithms, but whose non-linear convex counterpart is harder and admits significantly less efficient algorithms. This motivates the computational model of convex optimization, including the offline, online and stochastic settings, using a linear optimization oracle. In this computational model we give several new results that improve over the previous state-of-the-art. Our main result is a novel conditional gradient algorithm for smooth and strongly convex optimization over polyhedral sets that performs only a single linear optimization step over the domain on each iteration and enjoys a linear convergence rate. This gives an exponential improvement in convergence rate over previous results.
Based on this new conditional gradient algorithm we give the first algorithms for online convex optimization over polyhedral sets that perform only a single linear optimization step over the domain while having optimal regret guarantees, answering an open question of Kalai and Vempala, and Hazan and Kale. Our online algorithms also imply conditional gradient algorithms for non-smooth and stochastic convex optimization with the same convergence rates as projected (sub)gradient methods.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2015; v1 submitted 20 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Almost Optimal Sublinear Time Algorithm for Semidefinite Programming
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Elad Hazan
Abstract:
We present an algorithm for approximating semidefinite programs with running time that is sublinear in the number of entries in the semidefinite instance. We also present lower bounds that show our algorithm to have a nearly optimal running time.
We present an algorithm for approximating semidefinite programs with running time that is sublinear in the number of entries in the semidefinite instance. We also present lower bounds that show our algorithm to have a nearly optimal running time.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
On the Orchard crossing number of prisms, ladders and other related graphs
Authors:
Elie Feder,
David Garber
Abstract:
This paper deals with the Orchard crossing number of some families of graphs which are based on cycles. These include disjoint cycles, cycles which share a vertex and cycles which share an edge. Specifically, we focus on the prism and ladder graphs.
This paper deals with the Orchard crossing number of some families of graphs which are based on cycles. These include disjoint cycles, cycles which share a vertex and cycles which share an edge. Specifically, we focus on the prism and ladder graphs.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Universal MMSE Filtering With Logarithmic Adaptive Regret
Authors:
Dan Garber,
Elad Hazan
Abstract:
We consider the problem of online estimation of a real-valued signal corrupted by oblivious zero-mean noise using linear estimators. The estimator is required to iteratively predict the underlying signal based on the current and several last noisy observations, and its performance is measured by the mean-square-error. We describe and analyze an algorithm for this task which: 1. Achieves logarithmi…
▽ More
We consider the problem of online estimation of a real-valued signal corrupted by oblivious zero-mean noise using linear estimators. The estimator is required to iteratively predict the underlying signal based on the current and several last noisy observations, and its performance is measured by the mean-square-error. We describe and analyze an algorithm for this task which: 1. Achieves logarithmic adaptive regret against the best linear filter in hindsight. This bound is assyptotically tight, and resolves the question of Moon and Weissman [1]. 2. Runs in linear time in terms of the number of filter coefficients. Previous constructions required at least quadratic time.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2011; v1 submitted 4 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
On the Orchard crossing number of complete bipartite graphs
Authors:
Elie Feder,
David Garber
Abstract:
We compute the Orchard crossing number, which is defined in a similar way to the rectilinear crossing number, for the complete bipartite graphs K_{n,n}.
We compute the Orchard crossing number, which is defined in a similar way to the rectilinear crossing number, for the complete bipartite graphs K_{n,n}.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Braid Group Cryptography
Authors:
David Garber
Abstract:
In the last decade, a number of public key cryptosystems based on com- binatorial group theoretic problems in braid groups have been proposed. We survey these cryptosystems and some known attacks on them.
This survey includes: Basic facts on braid groups and on the Garside normal form of its elements, some known algorithms for solving the word problem in the braid group, the major public-key c…
▽ More
In the last decade, a number of public key cryptosystems based on com- binatorial group theoretic problems in braid groups have been proposed. We survey these cryptosystems and some known attacks on them.
This survey includes: Basic facts on braid groups and on the Garside normal form of its elements, some known algorithms for solving the word problem in the braid group, the major public-key cryptosystems based on the braid group, and some of the known attacks on these cryptosystems. We conclude with a discussion of future directions (which includes also a description of cryptosystems which are based on other non-commutative groups).
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2008; v1 submitted 26 November, 2007;
originally announced November 2007.
-
Probabilistic Solutions of Equations in the Braid Group
Authors:
D. Garber,
S. Kaplan,
M. Teicher,
B. Tsaban,
U. Vishne
Abstract:
Given a system of equations in a "random" finitely generated subgroup of the braid group, we show how to find a small ordered list of elements in the subgroup, which contains a solution to the equations with a significant probability. Moreover, with a significant probability, the solution will be the first in the list. This gives a probabilistic solution to: The conjugacy problem, the group memb…
▽ More
Given a system of equations in a "random" finitely generated subgroup of the braid group, we show how to find a small ordered list of elements in the subgroup, which contains a solution to the equations with a significant probability. Moreover, with a significant probability, the solution will be the first in the list. This gives a probabilistic solution to: The conjugacy problem, the group membership problem, the shortest representation of an element, and other combinatorial group-theoretic problems in random subgroups of the braid group.
We use a memory-based extension of the standard length-based approach, which in principle can be applied to any group admitting an efficient, reasonably behaving length function.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2007; v1 submitted 5 April, 2004;
originally announced April 2004.
-
Length-based conjugacy search in the Braid group
Authors:
D. Garber,
S. Kaplan,
M. Teicher,
B. Tsaban,
U. Vishne
Abstract:
Several key agreement protocols are based on the following "Generalized Conjugacy Search Problem": Find, given elements b_1,...,b_n and xb_1x^{-1},...,xb_nx^{-1} in a nonabelian group G, the conjugator x. In the case of subgroups of the braid group B_N, Hughes and Tannenbaum suggested a length-based approach to finding x. Since the introduction of this approach, its effectiveness and successfulnes…
▽ More
Several key agreement protocols are based on the following "Generalized Conjugacy Search Problem": Find, given elements b_1,...,b_n and xb_1x^{-1},...,xb_nx^{-1} in a nonabelian group G, the conjugator x. In the case of subgroups of the braid group B_N, Hughes and Tannenbaum suggested a length-based approach to finding x. Since the introduction of this approach, its effectiveness and successfulness were debated.
We introduce several effective realizations of this approach. In particular, a new length function is defined on B_N which possesses significantly better properties than the natural length associated to the Garside normal form. We give experimental results concerning the success probability of this approach, which suggest that very large computational power is required for this method to successfully solve the Generalized Conjugacy Search Problem when its parameters are as in existing protocols.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2010; v1 submitted 20 September, 2002;
originally announced September 2002.
