-
Performance Evaluation of MLO for XR Streaming: Can Wi-Fi 7 Meet the Expectations?
Authors:
Marc Carrascosa-Zamacois,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Francesc Wilhelmi,
Gianluca Fontanesi,
Anders Jonsson,
Giovanni Geraci,
Boris Bellalta
Abstract:
Extended Reality (XR) has stringent throughput and delay requirements that are hard to meet with current wireless technologies. Missing these requirements can lead to worsened picture quality, perceived lag between user input and corresponding output, and even dizziness for the end user. In this paper, we study the capability of upcoming Wi-Fi 7, and its novel support for Multi-Link Operation (MLO…
▽ More
Extended Reality (XR) has stringent throughput and delay requirements that are hard to meet with current wireless technologies. Missing these requirements can lead to worsened picture quality, perceived lag between user input and corresponding output, and even dizziness for the end user. In this paper, we study the capability of upcoming Wi-Fi 7, and its novel support for Multi-Link Operation (MLO), to cope with these tight requirements. Our study is based on simulation results extracted from an MLO-compliant simulator that realistically reproduces VR traffic. Results show that MLO can sustain VR applications. By jointly using multiple links with independent channel access procedures, MLO can reduce the overall delay, which is especially useful in the uplink, as it has more stringent requirements than the downlink, and is instrumental in delivering the expected performance. We show that using MLO can allow more users per network than an equivalent number of links using SLO. We also show that while maintaining the same overall bandwidth, a higher number of MLO links with narrow channels leads to lower delays than a lower number of links with wider channels.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Distributed Learning for Wi-Fi AP Load Prediction
Authors:
Dariush Salami,
Francesc Wilhelmi,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Mika Kasslin
Abstract:
The increasing cloudification and softwarization of networks foster the interplay among multiple independently managed deployments. An appealing reason for such an interplay lies in distributed Machine Learning (ML), which allows the creation of robust ML models by leveraging collective intelligence and computational power. In this paper, we study the application of the two cornerstones of distrib…
▽ More
The increasing cloudification and softwarization of networks foster the interplay among multiple independently managed deployments. An appealing reason for such an interplay lies in distributed Machine Learning (ML), which allows the creation of robust ML models by leveraging collective intelligence and computational power. In this paper, we study the application of the two cornerstones of distributed learning, namely Federated Learning (FL) and Knowledge Distillation (KD), on the Wi-Fi Access Point (AP) load prediction use case. The analysis conducted in this paper is done on a dataset that contains real measurements from a large Wi-Fi campus network, which we use to train the ML model under study based on different strategies. Performance evaluation includes relevant aspects for the suitability of distributed learning operation in real use cases, including the predictive performance, the associated communication overheads, or the energy consumption. In particular, we prove that distributed learning can improve the predictive accuracy centralized ML solutions by up to 93% while reducing the communication overheads and the energy cost by 80%.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
ConPA: A Contention-free Mechanism with Power Adaptation for Beyond Listen-Before-Talk
Authors:
Francesc Wilhelmi,
Paolo Baracca,
Gianluca Fontanesi,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano
Abstract:
In view of the need to find novel means to utilize the unlicensed spectrum to meet the rising latency and reliability requirements of new applications, we propose a novel mechanism that allows devices to transmit anytime that a packet has to be delivered. The proposed mechanism, Contention-free with Power Adaptation (ConPA), aims to bypass the contention periods of current Listen-Before-Talk (LBT)…
▽ More
In view of the need to find novel means to utilize the unlicensed spectrum to meet the rising latency and reliability requirements of new applications, we propose a novel mechanism that allows devices to transmit anytime that a packet has to be delivered. The proposed mechanism, Contention-free with Power Adaptation (ConPA), aims to bypass the contention periods of current Listen-Before-Talk (LBT) approaches, which are the main source of unreliability in unlicensed technologies like Wi-Fi. To assess the feasibility of ConPA, we provide an analytical method based on Markov chains, which allows deriving relevant performance metrics, including throughput, airtime, and quality of transmissions. Using such a model, we study the performance of ConPA in various scenarios, and compare it to baseline channel access approaches like the Distributed Coordination Function (DCF) and the IEEE 802.11ax Overlap** Basic Service Set (OBSS) Packet Detect (PD)-based Spatial Reuse (SR). Our results prove the effectiveness of ConPA in reusing the space to offer substantial throughput gains with respect to the baselines (up to 76% improvement).
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
AI/ML-based Load Prediction in IEEE 802.11 Enterprise Networks
Authors:
Francesc Wilhelmi,
Dariush Salami,
Gianluca Fontanesi,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Mika Kasslin
Abstract:
Enterprise Wi-Fi networks can greatly benefit from Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning (AI/ML) thanks to their well-developed management and operation capabilities. At the same time, AI/ML-based traffic/load prediction is one of the most appealing data-driven solutions to improve the Wi-Fi experience, either through the enablement of autonomous operation or by boosting troubleshooting wit…
▽ More
Enterprise Wi-Fi networks can greatly benefit from Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning (AI/ML) thanks to their well-developed management and operation capabilities. At the same time, AI/ML-based traffic/load prediction is one of the most appealing data-driven solutions to improve the Wi-Fi experience, either through the enablement of autonomous operation or by boosting troubleshooting with forecasted network utilization. In this paper, we study the suitability and feasibility of adopting AI/ML-based load prediction in practical enterprise Wi-Fi networks. While leveraging AI/ML solutions can potentially contribute to optimizing Wi-Fi networks in terms of energy efficiency, performance, and reliability, their effective adoption is constrained to aspects like data availability and quality, computational capabilities, and energy consumption. Our results show that hardware-constrained AI/ML models can potentially predict network load with less than 20% average error and 3% 85th-percentile error, which constitutes a suitable input for proactively driving Wi-Fi network optimization.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Throughput Analysis of IEEE 802.11bn Coordinated Spatial Reuse
Authors:
Francesc Wilhelmi,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Giovanni Geraci,
Boris Bellalta,
Gianluca Fontanesi,
David Nuñez
Abstract:
Multi-Access Point Coordination (MAPC) is becoming the cornerstone of the IEEE 802.11bn amendment, alias Wi-Fi 8. Among the MAPC features, Coordinated Spatial Reuse (C-SR) stands as one of the most appealing due to its capability to orchestrate simultaneous access point transmissions at a low implementation complexity. In this paper, we contribute to the understanding of C-SR by introducing an ana…
▽ More
Multi-Access Point Coordination (MAPC) is becoming the cornerstone of the IEEE 802.11bn amendment, alias Wi-Fi 8. Among the MAPC features, Coordinated Spatial Reuse (C-SR) stands as one of the most appealing due to its capability to orchestrate simultaneous access point transmissions at a low implementation complexity. In this paper, we contribute to the understanding of C-SR by introducing an analytical model based on Continuous Time Markov Chains (CTMCs) to characterize its throughput and spatial efficiency. Applying the proposed model to several network topologies, we show that C-SR opportunistically enables parallel high-quality transmissions and yields an average throughput gain of up to 59% in comparison to the legacy 802.11 Distributed Coordination Function (DCF) and up to 42% when compared to the 802.11ax Overlap** Basic Service Set Packet Detect (OBSS/PD) mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2023; v1 submitted 17 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Delay Analysis of IEEE 802.11be Multi-link Operation under Finite Load
Authors:
Boris Bellalta,
Marc Carrascosa,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Giovanni Geraci
Abstract:
Multi-link Operation (MLO), arguably the most disruptive feature introduced in IEEE 802.11be, will cater for delay-sensitive applications by using multiple radio interfaces concurrently. In this paper, we analyze the delay distribution of MLO under non-saturated traffic. Our results show that upgrading from legacy single-link to MLO successfully contains the $95$th percentile delay as the traffic…
▽ More
Multi-link Operation (MLO), arguably the most disruptive feature introduced in IEEE 802.11be, will cater for delay-sensitive applications by using multiple radio interfaces concurrently. In this paper, we analyze the delay distribution of MLO under non-saturated traffic. Our results show that upgrading from legacy single-link to MLO successfully contains the $95$th percentile delay as the traffic load increases, but also that adding extra interfaces yields rapidly diminishing gains. Further experiments we conduct on Google Stadia traces, accounting for realistic traffic with batch arrivals, confirm the insights stemming from our theoretical analysis, vouching for MLO to support high-resolution real-time video with a controlled delay.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2023; v1 submitted 23 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Understanding Multi-link Operation in Wi-Fi 7: Performance, Anomalies, and Solutions
Authors:
Marc Carrascosa-Zamacois,
Giovanni Geraci,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Anders Jonsson,
Boris Bellalta
Abstract:
Will Wi-Fi 7, conceived to support extremely high throughput, also deliver consistently low delay? The best hope seems to lie in allowing next-generation devices to access multiple channels via multi-link operation (MLO). In this paper, we aim to advance the understanding of MLO, placing the spotlight on its packet delay performance. We show that MLO devices can take advantage of multiple contenti…
▽ More
Will Wi-Fi 7, conceived to support extremely high throughput, also deliver consistently low delay? The best hope seems to lie in allowing next-generation devices to access multiple channels via multi-link operation (MLO). In this paper, we aim to advance the understanding of MLO, placing the spotlight on its packet delay performance. We show that MLO devices can take advantage of multiple contention-free links to significantly reduce their transmission time, but also that they can occasionally starve one another and surprisingly incur a higher delay than that of a well planned legacy single link operation. We next examine and explain this anomaly, also putting forth practical workarounds to circumvent it. We conclude by pointing to other disruptive features that, if successfully paired with MLO, can usher in exciting and unprecedented opportunities for Wi-Fi 8.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Performance and Coexistence Evaluation of IEEE 802.11be Multi-link Operation
Authors:
Marc Carrascosa-Zamacois,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Anders Jonsson,
Giovanni Geraci,
Boris Bellalta
Abstract:
Wi-Fi 7 is already in the making, and Multi-Link Operation (MLO) is one of the main features proposed in its correspondent IEEE 802.11be amendment. MLO will allow devices to coordinate multiple radio interfaces to access separate channels through a single association, aiming for improved throughput, network delay, and overall spectrum reuse efficiency. In this work, we study three reference scenar…
▽ More
Wi-Fi 7 is already in the making, and Multi-Link Operation (MLO) is one of the main features proposed in its correspondent IEEE 802.11be amendment. MLO will allow devices to coordinate multiple radio interfaces to access separate channels through a single association, aiming for improved throughput, network delay, and overall spectrum reuse efficiency. In this work, we study three reference scenarios to evaluate the performance of the two main MLO implementations -- Multi-Link Multi-Radio (MLMR) and Multi-Link Single-Radio (MLSR) -- , the interplay between multiple nodes employing them, and their coexistence with legacy Single-Link devices. Importantly, our results reveal that the potential of MLMR is mainly unleashed in isolated deployments or under unloaded network conditions. Instead, in medium- to high-load scenarios, MLSR may prove more effective in reducing the latency while guaranteeing fairness with contending Single-Link nodes.
△ Less
Submitted 5 August, 2022; v1 submitted 30 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
IEEE 802.11be: Wi-Fi 7 Strikes Back
Authors:
Adrian Garcia-Rodriguez,
David Lopez-Perez,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Giovanni Geraci
Abstract:
As hordes of data-hungry devices challenge its current capabilities, Wi-Fi strikes back with 802.11be, alias Wi-Fi 7. This brand-new amendment promises a (r)evolution of unlicensed wireless connectivity as we know it. With its standardisation process being consolidated, we provide an updated digest of 802.11be essential features, vouching for multi-AP coordination as a must-have for critical and l…
▽ More
As hordes of data-hungry devices challenge its current capabilities, Wi-Fi strikes back with 802.11be, alias Wi-Fi 7. This brand-new amendment promises a (r)evolution of unlicensed wireless connectivity as we know it. With its standardisation process being consolidated, we provide an updated digest of 802.11be essential features, vouching for multi-AP coordination as a must-have for critical and latency-sensitive applications. We then get down to the nitty-gritty of one of its most enticing implementations-coordinated beamforming-, for which our standard-compliant simulations confirm near-tenfold reductions in worst-case delays.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
IEEE 802.11be Extremely High Throughput: The Next Generation of Wi-Fi Technology Beyond 802.11ax
Authors:
David López-Pérez,
Adrian Garcia-Rodriguez,
Lorenzo Galati-Giordano,
Mika Kasslin,
Klaus Doppler
Abstract:
Wi-Fi technology is continuously innovating to cater to the growing customer demands, driven by the digitalisation of everything, both in the home as well as the enterprise and hotspot spaces. In this article, we introduce to the wireless community the next generation Wi-Fi$-$based on IEEE 802.11be Extremely High Throughput (EHT)$-$, present the main objectives and timelines of this new 802.11be a…
▽ More
Wi-Fi technology is continuously innovating to cater to the growing customer demands, driven by the digitalisation of everything, both in the home as well as the enterprise and hotspot spaces. In this article, we introduce to the wireless community the next generation Wi-Fi$-$based on IEEE 802.11be Extremely High Throughput (EHT)$-$, present the main objectives and timelines of this new 802.11be amendment, thoroughly describe its main candidate features and enhancements, and cover the important issue of coexistence with other wireless technologies. We also provide simulation results to assess the potential throughput gains brought by 802.11be with respect to 802.11ax.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2019; v1 submitted 12 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.