-
Reasoning About Group Polarization: From Semantic Games to Sequent Systems
Authors:
Robert Freiman,
Carlos Olarte,
Elaine Pimentel,
Christian G. Fermüller
Abstract:
Group polarization, the phenomenon where individuals become more extreme after interacting, has been gaining attention, especially with the rise of social media sha** people's opinions. Recent interest has emerged in formal reasoning about group polarization using logical systems. In this work we consider the modal logic PNL that captures the notion of agents agreeing or disagreeing on a given t…
▽ More
Group polarization, the phenomenon where individuals become more extreme after interacting, has been gaining attention, especially with the rise of social media sha** people's opinions. Recent interest has emerged in formal reasoning about group polarization using logical systems. In this work we consider the modal logic PNL that captures the notion of agents agreeing or disagreeing on a given topic. Our contribution involves enhancing PNL with advanced formal reasoning techniques, instead of relying on axiomatic systems for analyzing group polarization. To achieve this, we introduce a semantic game tailored for (hybrid) extensions of PNL. This game fosters dynamic reasoning about concrete network models, aligning with our goal of strengthening PNL's effectiveness in studying group polarization. We show how this semantic game leads to a provability game by systemically exploring the truth in all models. This leads to the first cut-free sequent systems for some variants of PNL. Using polarization of formulas, the proposed calculi can be modularly adapted to consider different frame properties of the underlying model.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Truth and Preferences -- A Game Approach for Qualitative Choice Logic
Authors:
Robert Freiman,
Michael Bernreiter
Abstract:
In this paper, we introduce game-theoretic semantics (GTS) for Qualitative Choice Logic (QCL), which, in order to express preferences, extends classical propositional logic with an additional connective called ordered disjunction. Firstly, we demonstrate that game semantics can capture existing degree-based semantics for QCL in a natural way. Secondly, we show that game semantics can be leveraged…
▽ More
In this paper, we introduce game-theoretic semantics (GTS) for Qualitative Choice Logic (QCL), which, in order to express preferences, extends classical propositional logic with an additional connective called ordered disjunction. Firstly, we demonstrate that game semantics can capture existing degree-based semantics for QCL in a natural way. Secondly, we show that game semantics can be leveraged to derive new semantics for the language of QCL. In particular, we present a new semantics that makes use of GTS negation and, by doing so, avoids problems with negation in existing QCL-semantics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2022; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Games for Hybrid Logic -- From Semantic Games to Analytic Calculi
Authors:
Robert Freiman
Abstract:
Game semantics and winning strategies offer a potential conceptual bridge between semantics and proof systems of logics. We illustrate this link for hybrid logic -- an extension of modal logic that allows for explicit reference to worlds within the language. The main result is that the systematic search of winning strategies over all models can be finitized and thus reformulated as a proof system.
Game semantics and winning strategies offer a potential conceptual bridge between semantics and proof systems of logics. We illustrate this link for hybrid logic -- an extension of modal logic that allows for explicit reference to worlds within the language. The main result is that the systematic search of winning strategies over all models can be finitized and thus reformulated as a proof system.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
