-
Negative Effects of Gamification in Education Software: Systematic Map** and Practitioner Perceptions
Authors:
Clauvin Almeida,
Marcos Kalinowski,
Anderson Uchoa,
Bruno Feijo
Abstract:
Context: While most research shows positive effects of gamification, the focus on its adverse effects is considerably smaller and further understanding is needed. Objective: To provide a comprehensive overview on research reporting negative effects of game design elements and to provide insights into the awareness of developers on these effects and into how they could be considered in practice. Me…
▽ More
Context: While most research shows positive effects of gamification, the focus on its adverse effects is considerably smaller and further understanding is needed. Objective: To provide a comprehensive overview on research reporting negative effects of game design elements and to provide insights into the awareness of developers on these effects and into how they could be considered in practice. Method: We conducted a systematic map** study of the negative effects of game design elements on education/learning systems. We also held a focus group discussion with developers of a gamified software, discussing the map** study results with regard to their awareness and perceptions on the reported negative effects in practice. Results: The map** study revealed 87 papers reporting undesired effects of game design elements. We found that badges, leaderboards, competitions, and points are the game design elements most often reported as causing negative effects. The most cited negative effects were lack of effect, worsened performance, motivational issues, lack of understanding, and irrelevance. The ethical issues of gaming the system and cheating were also often reported. As part of our results, we map the relations between game design elements and the negative effects that they may cause. The focus group revealed that developers were not aware of many of the possible negative effects and that they consider this type of information useful. The discussion revealed their agreement on some of those potential negative effects and also some positive counterparts. Conclusions: Gamification, when properly applied, can have positive effects on education/learning software. However, gamified software is also prone to generate harmful effects. Revealing and discussing potentially negative effects can help to make more informed decisions considering their trade-off with respect to the expected benefits.
△ Less
Submitted 15 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
An adaptive music generation architecture for games based on the deep learning Transformer mode
Authors:
Gustavo Amaral Costa dos Santos,
Augusto Baffa,
Jean-Pierre Briot,
Bruno Feijó,
Antonio Luz Furtado
Abstract:
This paper presents an architecture for generating music for video games based on the Transformer deep learning model. Our motivation is to be able to customize the generation according to the taste of the player, who can select a corpus of training examples, corresponding to his preferred musical style. The system generates various musical layers, following the standard layering strategy currentl…
▽ More
This paper presents an architecture for generating music for video games based on the Transformer deep learning model. Our motivation is to be able to customize the generation according to the taste of the player, who can select a corpus of training examples, corresponding to his preferred musical style. The system generates various musical layers, following the standard layering strategy currently used by composers designing video game music. To adapt the music generated to the game play and to the player(s) situation, we are using an arousal-valence model of emotions, in order to control the selection of musical layers. We discuss current limitations and prospects for the future, such as collaborative and interactive control of the musical components.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2022; v1 submitted 4 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
A Note on Process Modelling: Combining Situation Calculus and Petri Nets
Authors:
Edirlei Soares de Lima,
Antonio L. Furtado,
Bruno Feijó,
Marco A. Casanova
Abstract:
The situation calculus logic model is convenient for modelling the actions that can occur in an information system application. The interplay of pre-conditions and post-conditions determines a semantically justified partial order of the defined actions and serves to enforce integrity constraints. This form of specification allows the use of plan-generation algorithms to investigate, before the sys…
▽ More
The situation calculus logic model is convenient for modelling the actions that can occur in an information system application. The interplay of pre-conditions and post-conditions determines a semantically justified partial order of the defined actions and serves to enforce integrity constraints. This form of specification allows the use of plan-generation algorithms to investigate, before the system is adopted, whether the proposed specification allows all desirable use cases, and effectively disallows undesirable ones. Especially for legacy applications, implemented without a prior specification, Process Mining techniques were employed to derive an implicit Petri net model from the analysis of a large number of traces registered in an execution log. However, if the system just begins to be used, and has a still empty execution log, this sort of process mining discovery would not be feasible. This paper explains how the Petri net model can be directly derived from the situation calculus specification rules. The main gist is to provide evidence that the two models are complementary, not only because the Petri net model is derivable from the situation calculus model, but also in view of the distinct advantages of the two models. While the situation calculus model leads to planning and simulated execution prior to implementation, the Petri net model can be designed to run in a restrictive mode, allowing an intuitive visualization of the workable sequences. As proof of concept, the paper describes a prototype to demonstrate the methods and applies it to two examples: a published request processing application used to introduce process mining notions; and an analogously structured trial by combat application taken from a popular movie. The prototype includes an interactive dramatization component, which enacts the second application.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Notes on Pervasive Virtuality
Authors:
Luis Valente,
Bruno Feijo,
Alexandre Ribeiro Silva,
Esteban Clua
Abstract:
This paper summarizes current notes about a new mixed-reality paradigm that we named as "pervasive virtuality". This paradigm has emerged recently in industry and academia through different initiatives. In this paper we intend to explore this new area by proposing a set of features that we identified as important or helpful to realize pervasive virtuality in games and entertainment applications.
This paper summarizes current notes about a new mixed-reality paradigm that we named as "pervasive virtuality". This paradigm has emerged recently in industry and academia through different initiatives. In this paper we intend to explore this new area by proposing a set of features that we identified as important or helpful to realize pervasive virtuality in games and entertainment applications.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Live-action Virtual Reality Games
Authors:
Luis Valente,
Esteban Clua,
Alexandre Ribeiro Silva,
Bruno Feijó
Abstract:
This paper proposes the concept of "live-action virtual reality games" as a new genre of digital games based on an innovative combination of live-action, mixed-reality, context-awareness, and interaction paradigms that comprise tangible objects, context-aware input devices, and embedded/embodied interactions. Live-action virtual reality games are "live-action games" because a player physically act…
▽ More
This paper proposes the concept of "live-action virtual reality games" as a new genre of digital games based on an innovative combination of live-action, mixed-reality, context-awareness, and interaction paradigms that comprise tangible objects, context-aware input devices, and embedded/embodied interactions. Live-action virtual reality games are "live-action games" because a player physically acts out (using his/her real body and senses) his/her "avatar" (his/her virtual representation) in the game stage, which is the mixed-reality environment where the game happens. The game stage is a kind of "augmented virtuality"; a mixed-reality where the virtual world is augmented with real-world information. In live-action virtual reality games, players wear HMD devices and see a virtual world that is constructed using the physical world architecture as the basic geometry and context information. Physical objects that reside in the physical world are also mapped to virtual elements. Live-action virtual reality games keeps the virtual and real-worlds superimposed, requiring players to physically move in the environment and to use different interaction paradigms (such as tangible and embodied interaction) to complete game activities. This setup enables the players to touch physical architectural elements (such as walls) and other objects, "feeling" the game stage. Players have free movement and may interact with physical objects placed in the game stage, implicitly and explicitly. Live-action virtual reality games differ from similar game concepts because they sense and use contextual information to create unpredictable game experiences, giving rise to emergent gameplay.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
