-
Evaluating Tree Explanation Methods for Anomaly Reasoning: A Case Study of SHAP TreeExplainer and TreeInterpreter
Authors:
Pulkit Sharma,
Shezan Rohinton Mirzan,
Apurva Bhandari,
Anish Pimpley,
Abhiram Eswaran,
Soundar Srinivasan,
Liqun Shao
Abstract:
Understanding predictions made by Machine Learning models is critical in many applications. In this work, we investigate the performance of two methods for explaining tree-based models- Tree Interpreter (TI) and SHapley Additive exPlanations TreeExplainer (SHAP-TE). Using a case study on detecting anomalies in job runtimes of applications that utilize cloud-computing platforms, we compare these ap…
▽ More
Understanding predictions made by Machine Learning models is critical in many applications. In this work, we investigate the performance of two methods for explaining tree-based models- Tree Interpreter (TI) and SHapley Additive exPlanations TreeExplainer (SHAP-TE). Using a case study on detecting anomalies in job runtimes of applications that utilize cloud-computing platforms, we compare these approaches using a variety of metrics, including computation time, significance of attribution value, and explanation accuracy. We find that, although the SHAP-TE offers consistency guarantees over TI, at the cost of increased computation, consistency does not necessarily improve the explanation performance in our case study.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Griffon: Reasoning about Job Anomalies with Unlabeled Data in Cloud-based Platforms
Authors:
Liqun Shao,
Yiwen Zhu,
Abhiram Eswaran,
Kristin Lieber,
Janhavi Mahajan,
Minsoo Thigpen,
Sudhir Darbha,
Siqi Liu,
Subru Krishnan,
Soundar Srinivasan,
Carlo Curino,
Konstantinos Karanasos
Abstract:
Microsoft's internal big data analytics platform is comprised of hundreds of thousands of machines, serving over half a million jobs daily, from thousands of users. The majority of these jobs are recurring and are crucial for the company's operation. Although administrators spend significant effort tuning system performance, some jobs inevitably experience slowdowns, i.e., their execution time deg…
▽ More
Microsoft's internal big data analytics platform is comprised of hundreds of thousands of machines, serving over half a million jobs daily, from thousands of users. The majority of these jobs are recurring and are crucial for the company's operation. Although administrators spend significant effort tuning system performance, some jobs inevitably experience slowdowns, i.e., their execution time degrades over previous runs. Currently, the investigation of such slowdowns is a labor-intensive and error-prone process, which costs Microsoft significant human and machine resources, and negatively impacts several lines of businesses. In this work, we present Griffin, a system we built and have deployed in production last year to automatically discover the root cause of job slowdowns. Existing solutions either rely on labeled data (i.e., resolved incidents with labeled reasons for job slowdowns), which is in most cases non-existent or non-trivial to acquire, or on time-series analysis of individual metrics that do not target specific jobs holistically. In contrast, in Griffin we cast the problem to a corresponding regression one that predicts the runtime of a job, and show how the relative contributions of the features used to train our interpretable model can be exploited to rank the potential causes of job slowdowns. Evaluated over historical incidents, we show that Griffin discovers slowdown causes that are consistent with the ones validated by domain-expert engineers, in a fraction of the time required by them.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
MMLSpark: Unifying Machine Learning Ecosystems at Massive Scales
Authors:
Mark Hamilton,
Sudarshan Raghunathan,
Ilya Matiach,
Andrew Schonhoffer,
Anand Raman,
Eli Barzilay,
Karthik Rajendran,
Dalitso Banda,
Casey Jisoo Hong,
Manon Knoertzer,
Ben Brodsky,
Minsoo Thigpen,
Janhavi Suresh Mahajan,
Courtney Cochrane,
Abhiram Eswaran,
Ari Green
Abstract:
We introduce Microsoft Machine Learning for Apache Spark (MMLSpark), an ecosystem of enhancements that expand the Apache Spark distributed computing library to tackle problems in Deep Learning, Micro-Service Orchestration, Gradient Boosting, Model Interpretability, and other areas of modern computation. Furthermore, we present a novel system called Spark Serving that allows users to run any Apache…
▽ More
We introduce Microsoft Machine Learning for Apache Spark (MMLSpark), an ecosystem of enhancements that expand the Apache Spark distributed computing library to tackle problems in Deep Learning, Micro-Service Orchestration, Gradient Boosting, Model Interpretability, and other areas of modern computation. Furthermore, we present a novel system called Spark Serving that allows users to run any Apache Spark program as a distributed, sub-millisecond latency web service backed by their existing Spark Cluster. All MMLSpark contributions have the same API to enable simple composition across frameworks and usage across batch, streaming, and RESTful web serving scenarios on static, elastic, or serverless clusters. We showcase MMLSpark by creating a method for deep object detection capable of learning without human labeled data and demonstrate its effectiveness for Snow Leopard conservation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2019; v1 submitted 19 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
