-
Large Scale Deterministic Networking: A Simulation Evaluation
Authors:
Ahmed Nasrallah,
Venkatraman Balasubramanian,
Akhilesh Thyagaturu,
Martin Reisslein,
Hesham ElBakoury
Abstract:
The use of Ethernet switched networks usually involves best effort service. A recent effort by the IEEE 802.1/3 TSN group has sought to standardize the Ethernet data-link protocol such that it operates on a deterministic service in addition to the best effort service targeting Operational Technology applications, e.g., industrial control systems. This paper investigates the Cyclic Queueing and For…
▽ More
The use of Ethernet switched networks usually involves best effort service. A recent effort by the IEEE 802.1/3 TSN group has sought to standardize the Ethernet data-link protocol such that it operates on a deterministic service in addition to the best effort service targeting Operational Technology applications, e.g., industrial control systems. This paper investigates the Cyclic Queueing and Forwarding (CQF) and Paternoster scheduling protocols in a typical industrial control loop with varying propagation delays emulating large scale networks. Our main findings for CQF and Paternoster are that CQF has an advantage towards real-time streams with hard-deadlines whilst Paternoster is for streams with more relaxed deadlines but can operate without time synchronization.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2019; v1 submitted 30 September, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Reconfiguration Algorithms for High Precision Communications in Time Sensitive Networks: Time-Aware Shaper Configuration with IEEE 802.1Qcc (Extended Version)
Authors:
Ahmed Nasrallah,
Venkatraman Balasubramanian,
Akhilesh Thyagaturu,
Martin Reisslein,
Hesham ElBakoury
Abstract:
As new networking paradigms emerge for different networking applications, e.g., cyber-physical systems, and different services are handled under a converged data link technology, e.g., Ethernet, certain applications with mission critical traffic cannot coexist on the same physical networking infrastructure using traditional Ethernet packet-switched networking protocols. The IEEE 802.1Q Time Sensit…
▽ More
As new networking paradigms emerge for different networking applications, e.g., cyber-physical systems, and different services are handled under a converged data link technology, e.g., Ethernet, certain applications with mission critical traffic cannot coexist on the same physical networking infrastructure using traditional Ethernet packet-switched networking protocols. The IEEE 802.1Q Time Sensitive Networking (TSN) task group is develo** protocol standards to provide deterministic properties on Ethernet based packet-switched networks. In particular, the IEEE 802.1Qcc, centralized management and control, and the IEEE 802.1Qbv, Time-Aware Shaper, can be used to manage and control scheduled traffic streams with periodic properties along with best-effort traffic on the same network infrastructure. In this paper, we investigate the effects of using the IEEE 802.1Qcc management protocol to accurately and precisely configure TAS enabled switches (with transmission windows governed by gate control lists (GCLs) with gate control entries (GCEs)) ensuring ultra-low latency, zero packet loss, and minimal jitter for scheduled TSN traffic. We examine both a centralized network/distributed user model (hybrid model) and a fully-distributed (decentralized) 802.1Qcc model on a typical industrial control network with the goal of maximizing scheduled traffic streams.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
TSN Algorithms for Large Scale Networks: A Survey and Conceptual Comparison
Authors:
Ahmed Nasrallah,
Venkatraman Balasubramanian,
Akhilesh Thyagaturu,
Martin Reisslein,
Hesham ElBakoury
Abstract:
This paper provides a comprehensive survey of queueing and scheduling mechanisms for supporting large scale deterministic networks (LDNs). The survey finds that extensive mechanism design research and standards development for LDNs has been conducted over the past few years. However, these mechanism design studies have not been followed up with a comprehensive rigorous evaluation. The main outcome…
▽ More
This paper provides a comprehensive survey of queueing and scheduling mechanisms for supporting large scale deterministic networks (LDNs). The survey finds that extensive mechanism design research and standards development for LDNs has been conducted over the past few years. However, these mechanism design studies have not been followed up with a comprehensive rigorous evaluation. The main outcome of this survey is a clear organization of the various research and standardization efforts towards queueing and scheduling mechanisms for LDNs as well as the identification of the main strands of mechanism development and their interdependencies. Based on this survey, it appears urgent to conduct a comprehensive rigorous simulation study of the main strands of mechanisms.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2019; v1 submitted 21 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
FlexNGIA: A Flexible Internet Architecture for the Next-Generation Tactile Internet
Authors:
Mohamed Faten Zhani,
Hesham ElBakoury
Abstract:
From virtual reality and telepresence, to augmented reality, holoportation, and remotely controlled robotics, these future network applications promise an unprecedented development for society, economics and culture by revolutionizing the way we live, learn, work and play. In order to deploy such futuristic applications and to cater to their performance requirements, recent trends stressed the nee…
▽ More
From virtual reality and telepresence, to augmented reality, holoportation, and remotely controlled robotics, these future network applications promise an unprecedented development for society, economics and culture by revolutionizing the way we live, learn, work and play. In order to deploy such futuristic applications and to cater to their performance requirements, recent trends stressed the need for the Tactile Internet, an Internet that, according to the International Telecommunication Union, combines ultra low latency with extremely high availability, reliability and security. Unfortunately, today's Internet falls short when it comes to providing such stringent requirements due to several fundamental limitations in the design of the current network architecture and communication protocols. This brings the need to rethink the network architecture and protocols, and efficiently harness recent technological advances in terms of virtualization and network softwarization to design the Tactile Internet of the future.
In this paper, we start by analyzing the characteristics and requirements of future networking applications. We then highlight the limitations of the traditional network architecture and protocols and their inability to cater to these requirements. Afterward, we put forward a novel network architecture adapted to the Tactile Internet called FlexNGIA, a Flexible Next-Generation Internet Architecture. We then describe some use-cases where we discuss the potential mechanisms and control loops that could be offered by FlexNGIA in order to ensure the required performance and reliability guarantees for future applications. Finally, we identify the key research challenges to further develop FlexNGIA towards a full-fledged architecture for the future Tactile Internet.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2020; v1 submitted 17 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Ultra-Low Latency (ULL) Networks: The IEEE TSN and IETF DetNet Standards and Related 5G ULL Research
Authors:
Ahmed Nasrallah,
Akhilesh Thyagaturu,
Ziyad Alharbi,
Cuixiang Wang,
Xing Shao,
Martin Reisslein,
Hesham ElBakoury
Abstract:
Many network applications, e.g., industrial control, demand Ultra-Low Latency (ULL). However, traditional packet networks can only reduce the end-to-end latencies to the order of tens of milliseconds. The IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Networking (TSN) standard and related research studies have sought to provide link layer support for ULL networking, while the emerging IETF Deterministic Networking (De…
▽ More
Many network applications, e.g., industrial control, demand Ultra-Low Latency (ULL). However, traditional packet networks can only reduce the end-to-end latencies to the order of tens of milliseconds. The IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Networking (TSN) standard and related research studies have sought to provide link layer support for ULL networking, while the emerging IETF Deterministic Networking (DetNet) standards seek to provide the complementary network layer ULL support. This article provides an up-to-date comprehensive survey of the IEEE TSN and IETF DetNet standards and the related research studies. The survey of these standards and research studies is organized according to the main categories of flow concept, flow synchronization, flow management, flow control, and flow integrity. ULL networking mechanisms play a critical role in the emerging fifth generation (5G) network access chain from wireless devices via access, backhaul, and core networks. We survey the studies that specifically target the support of ULL in 5G networks, with the main categories of fronthaul, backhaul, and network management. Throughout, we identify the pitfalls and limitations of the existing standards and research studies. This survey can thus serve as a basis for the development of standards enhancements and future ULL research studies that address the identified pitfalls and limitations.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2018; v1 submitted 20 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.