-
Understanding and mitigating difficulties in posterior predictive evaluation
Authors:
Abhinav Agrawal,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Predictive posterior densities (PPDs) are of interest in approximate Bayesian inference. Typically, these are estimated by simple Monte Carlo (MC) averages using samples from the approximate posterior. We observe that the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of such estimators can be extremely low. An analysis for exact inference reveals SNR decays exponentially as there is an increase in (a) the mismatch…
▽ More
Predictive posterior densities (PPDs) are of interest in approximate Bayesian inference. Typically, these are estimated by simple Monte Carlo (MC) averages using samples from the approximate posterior. We observe that the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of such estimators can be extremely low. An analysis for exact inference reveals SNR decays exponentially as there is an increase in (a) the mismatch between training and test data, (b) the dimensionality of the latent space, or (c) the size of the test data relative to the training data. Further analysis extends these results to approximate inference. To remedy the low SNR problem, we propose replacing simple MC sampling with importance sampling using a proposal distribution optimized at test time on a variational proxy for the SNR and demonstrate that this yields greatly improved estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Simulation-based stacking
Authors:
Yuling Yao,
Bruno Régaldo-Saint Blancard,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Simulation-based inference has been popular for amortized Bayesian computation. It is typical to have more than one posterior approximation, from different inference algorithms, different architectures, or simply the randomness of initialization and stochastic gradients. With a consistency guarantee, we present a general posterior stacking framework to make use of all available approximations. Our…
▽ More
Simulation-based inference has been popular for amortized Bayesian computation. It is typical to have more than one posterior approximation, from different inference algorithms, different architectures, or simply the randomness of initialization and stochastic gradients. With a consistency guarantee, we present a general posterior stacking framework to make use of all available approximations. Our stacking method is able to combine densities, simulation draws, confidence intervals, and moments, and address the overall precision, calibration, coverage, and bias of the posterior approximation at the same time. We illustrate our method on several benchmark simulations and a challenging cosmological inference task.
△ Less
Submitted 29 February, 2024; v1 submitted 25 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
A High-Performance Design, Implementation, Deployment, and Evaluation of The Slim Fly Network
Authors:
Nils Blach,
Maciej Besta,
Daniele De Sensi,
Jens Domke,
Hussein Harake,
Shigang Li,
Patrick Iff,
Marek Konieczny,
Kartik Lakhotia,
Ales Kubicek,
Marcel Ferrari,
Fabrizio Petrini,
Torsten Hoefler
Abstract:
Novel low-diameter network topologies such as Slim Fly (SF) offer significant cost and power advantages over the established Fat Tree, Clos, or Dragonfly. To spearhead the adoption of low-diameter networks, we design, implement, deploy, and evaluate the first real-world SF installation. We focus on deployment, management, and operational aspects of our test cluster with 200 servers and carefully a…
▽ More
Novel low-diameter network topologies such as Slim Fly (SF) offer significant cost and power advantages over the established Fat Tree, Clos, or Dragonfly. To spearhead the adoption of low-diameter networks, we design, implement, deploy, and evaluate the first real-world SF installation. We focus on deployment, management, and operational aspects of our test cluster with 200 servers and carefully analyze performance. We demonstrate techniques for simple cabling and cabling validation as well as a novel high-performance routing architecture for InfiniBand-based low-diameter topologies. Our real-world benchmarks show SF's strong performance for many modern workloads such as deep neural network training, graph analytics, or linear algebra kernels. SF outperforms non-blocking Fat Trees in scalability while offering comparable or better performance and lower cost for large network sizes. Our work can facilitate deploying SF while the associated (open-source) routing architecture is fully portable and applicable to accelerate any low-diameter interconnect.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2024; v1 submitted 5 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Provable convergence guarantees for black-box variational inference
Authors:
Justin Domke,
Guillaume Garrigos,
Robert Gower
Abstract:
Black-box variational inference is widely used in situations where there is no proof that its stochastic optimization succeeds. We suggest this is due to a theoretical gap in existing stochastic optimization proofs: namely the challenge of gradient estimators with unusual noise bounds, and a composite non-smooth objective. For dense Gaussian variational families, we observe that existing gradient…
▽ More
Black-box variational inference is widely used in situations where there is no proof that its stochastic optimization succeeds. We suggest this is due to a theoretical gap in existing stochastic optimization proofs: namely the challenge of gradient estimators with unusual noise bounds, and a composite non-smooth objective. For dense Gaussian variational families, we observe that existing gradient estimators based on reparameterization satisfy a quadratic noise bound and give novel convergence guarantees for proximal and projected stochastic gradient descent using this bound. This provides rigorous guarantees that methods similar to those used in practice converge on realistic inference problems.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2023; v1 submitted 4 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Discriminative calibration: Check Bayesian computation from simulations and flexible classifier
Authors:
Yuling Yao,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
To check the accuracy of Bayesian computations, it is common to use rank-based simulation-based calibration (SBC). However, SBC has drawbacks: The test statistic is somewhat ad-hoc, interactions are difficult to examine, multiple testing is a challenge, and the resulting p-value is not a divergence metric. We propose to replace the marginal rank test with a flexible classification approach that le…
▽ More
To check the accuracy of Bayesian computations, it is common to use rank-based simulation-based calibration (SBC). However, SBC has drawbacks: The test statistic is somewhat ad-hoc, interactions are difficult to examine, multiple testing is a challenge, and the resulting p-value is not a divergence metric. We propose to replace the marginal rank test with a flexible classification approach that learns test statistics from data. This measure typically has a higher statistical power than the SBC rank test and returns an interpretable divergence measure of miscalibration, computed from classification accuracy. This approach can be used with different data generating processes to address likelihood-free inference or traditional inference methods like Markov chain Monte Carlo or variational inference. We illustrate an automated implementation using neural networks and statistically-inspired features, and validate the method with numerical and real data experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2023; v1 submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Sample Average Approximation for Black-Box VI
Authors:
Javier Burroni,
Justin Domke,
Daniel Sheldon
Abstract:
We present a novel approach for black-box VI that bypasses the difficulties of stochastic gradient ascent, including the task of selecting step-sizes. Our approach involves using a sequence of sample average approximation (SAA) problems. SAA approximates the solution of stochastic optimization problems by transforming them into deterministic ones. We use quasi-Newton methods and line search to sol…
▽ More
We present a novel approach for black-box VI that bypasses the difficulties of stochastic gradient ascent, including the task of selecting step-sizes. Our approach involves using a sequence of sample average approximation (SAA) problems. SAA approximates the solution of stochastic optimization problems by transforming them into deterministic ones. We use quasi-Newton methods and line search to solve each deterministic optimization problem and present a heuristic policy to automate hyperparameter selection. Our experiments show that our method simplifies the VI problem and achieves faster performance than existing methods.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2023; v1 submitted 13 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
U-Statistics for Importance-Weighted Variational Inference
Authors:
Javier Burroni,
Kenta Takatsu,
Justin Domke,
Daniel Sheldon
Abstract:
We propose the use of U-statistics to reduce variance for gradient estimation in importance-weighted variational inference. The key observation is that, given a base gradient estimator that requires $m > 1$ samples and a total of $n > m$ samples to be used for estimation, lower variance is achieved by averaging the base estimator on overlap** batches of size $m$ than disjoint batches, as current…
▽ More
We propose the use of U-statistics to reduce variance for gradient estimation in importance-weighted variational inference. The key observation is that, given a base gradient estimator that requires $m > 1$ samples and a total of $n > m$ samples to be used for estimation, lower variance is achieved by averaging the base estimator on overlap** batches of size $m$ than disjoint batches, as currently done. We use classical U-statistic theory to analyze the variance reduction, and propose novel approximations with theoretical guarantees to ensure computational efficiency. We find empirically that U-statistic variance reduction can lead to modest to significant improvements in inference performance on a range of models, with little computational cost.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Myths and Legends in High-Performance Computing
Authors:
Satoshi Matsuoka,
Jens Domke,
Mohamed Wahib,
Aleksandr Drozd,
Torsten Hoefler
Abstract:
In this thought-provoking article, we discuss certain myths and legends that are folklore among members of the high-performance computing community. We gathered these myths from conversations at conferences and meetings, product advertisements, papers, and other communications such as tweets, blogs, and news articles within and beyond our community. We believe they represent the zeitgeist of the c…
▽ More
In this thought-provoking article, we discuss certain myths and legends that are folklore among members of the high-performance computing community. We gathered these myths from conversations at conferences and meetings, product advertisements, papers, and other communications such as tweets, blogs, and news articles within and beyond our community. We believe they represent the zeitgeist of the current era of massive change, driven by the end of many scaling laws such as Dennard scaling and Moore's law. While some laws end, new directions are emerging, such as algorithmic scaling or novel architecture research. Nevertheless, these myths are rarely based on scientific facts, but rather on some evidence or argumentation. In fact, we believe that this is the very reason for the existence of many myths and why they cannot be answered clearly. While it feels like there should be clear answers for each, some may remain endless philosophical debates, such as whether Beethoven was better than Mozart. We would like to see our collection of myths as a discussion of possible new directions for research and industry investment.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023; v1 submitted 6 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Joint control variate for faster black-box variational inference
Authors:
Xi Wang,
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Black-box variational inference performance is sometimes hindered by the use of gradient estimators with high variance. This variance comes from two sources of randomness: Data subsampling and Monte Carlo sampling. While existing control variates only address Monte Carlo noise, and incremental gradient methods typically only address data subsampling, we propose a new "joint" control variate that j…
▽ More
Black-box variational inference performance is sometimes hindered by the use of gradient estimators with high variance. This variance comes from two sources of randomness: Data subsampling and Monte Carlo sampling. While existing control variates only address Monte Carlo noise, and incremental gradient methods typically only address data subsampling, we propose a new "joint" control variate that jointly reduces variance from both sources of noise. This significantly reduces gradient variance, leading to faster optimization in several applications.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2024; v1 submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Langevin Diffusion Variational Inference
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Many methods that build powerful variational distributions based on unadjusted Langevin transitions exist. Most of these were developed using a wide range of different approaches and techniques. Unfortunately, the lack of a unified analysis and derivation makes develo** new methods and reasoning about existing ones a challenging task. We address this giving a single analysis that unifies and gen…
▽ More
Many methods that build powerful variational distributions based on unadjusted Langevin transitions exist. Most of these were developed using a wide range of different approaches and techniques. Unfortunately, the lack of a unified analysis and derivation makes develo** new methods and reasoning about existing ones a challenging task. We address this giving a single analysis that unifies and generalizes these existing techniques. The main idea is to augment the target and variational by numerically simulating the underdamped Langevin diffusion process and its time reversal. The benefits of this approach are twofold: it provides a unified formulation for many existing methods, and it simplifies the development of new ones. In fact, using our formulation we propose a new method that combines the strengths of previously existing algorithms; it uses underdamped Langevin transitions and powerful augmentations parameterized by a score network. Our empirical evaluation shows that our proposed method consistently outperforms relevant baselines in a wide range of tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2023; v1 submitted 16 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
High-Performance GPU-to-CPU Transpilation and Optimization via High-Level Parallel Constructs
Authors:
William S. Moses,
Ivan R. Ivanov,
Jens Domke,
Toshio Endo,
Johannes Doerfert,
Oleksandr Zinenko
Abstract:
While parallelism remains the main source of performance, architectural implementations and programming models change with each new hardware generation, often leading to costly application re-engineering. Most tools for performance portability require manual and costly application porting to yet another programming model.
We propose an alternative approach that automatically translates programs…
▽ More
While parallelism remains the main source of performance, architectural implementations and programming models change with each new hardware generation, often leading to costly application re-engineering. Most tools for performance portability require manual and costly application porting to yet another programming model.
We propose an alternative approach that automatically translates programs written in one programming model (CUDA), into another (CPU threads) based on Polygeist/MLIR. Our approach includes a representation of parallel constructs that allows conventional compiler transformations to apply transparently and without modification and enables parallelism-specific optimizations. We evaluate our framework by transpiling and optimizing the CUDA Rodinia benchmark suite for a multi-core CPU and achieve a 76% geomean speedup over handwritten OpenMP code. Further, we show how CUDA kernels from PyTorch can efficiently run and scale on the CPU-only Supercomputer Fugaku without user intervention. Our PyTorch compatibility layer making use of transpiled CUDA PyTorch kernels outperforms the PyTorch CPU native backend by 2.7$\times$.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Preparing for the Future -- Rethinking Proxy Apps
Authors:
Satoshi Matsuoka,
Jens Domke,
Mohamed Wahib,
Aleksandr Drozd,
Ray Bair,
Andrew A. Chien,
Jeffrey S. Vetter,
John Shalf
Abstract:
A considerable amount of research and engineering went into designing proxy applications, which represent common high-performance computing workloads, to co-design and evaluate the current generation of supercomputers, e.g., RIKEN's Supercomputer Fugaku, ANL's Aurora, or ORNL's Frontier. This process was necessary to standardize the procurement while avoiding duplicated effort at each HPC center t…
▽ More
A considerable amount of research and engineering went into designing proxy applications, which represent common high-performance computing workloads, to co-design and evaluate the current generation of supercomputers, e.g., RIKEN's Supercomputer Fugaku, ANL's Aurora, or ORNL's Frontier. This process was necessary to standardize the procurement while avoiding duplicated effort at each HPC center to develop their own benchmarks. Unfortunately, proxy applications force HPC centers and providers (vendors) into a an undesirable state of rigidity, in contrast to the fast-moving trends of current technology and future heterogeneity. To accommodate an extremely-heterogeneous future, we have to reconsider how to co-design supercomputers during the next decade, and avoid repeating the past mistakes. This position paper outlines the current state-of-the-art in system co-design, challenges encountered over the past years, and a proposed plan to move forward.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
At the Locus of Performance: Quantifying the Effects of Copious 3D-Stacked Cache on HPC Workloads
Authors:
Jens Domke,
Emil Vatai,
Balazs Gerofi,
Yuetsu Kodama,
Mohamed Wahib,
Artur Podobas,
Sparsh Mittal,
Miquel Pericàs,
Lingqi Zhang,
Peng Chen,
Aleksandr Drozd,
Satoshi Matsuoka
Abstract:
Over the last three decades, innovations in the memory subsystem were primarily targeted at overcoming the data movement bottleneck. In this paper, we focus on a specific market trend in memory technology: 3D-stacked memory and caches. We investigate the impact of extending the on-chip memory capabilities in future HPC-focused processors, particularly by 3D-stacked SRAM. First, we propose a method…
▽ More
Over the last three decades, innovations in the memory subsystem were primarily targeted at overcoming the data movement bottleneck. In this paper, we focus on a specific market trend in memory technology: 3D-stacked memory and caches. We investigate the impact of extending the on-chip memory capabilities in future HPC-focused processors, particularly by 3D-stacked SRAM. First, we propose a method oblivious to the memory subsystem to gauge the upper-bound in performance improvements when data movement costs are eliminated. Then, using the gem5 simulator, we model two variants of a hypothetical LARge Cache processor (LARC), fabricated in 1.5 nm and enriched with high-capacity 3D-stacked cache. With a volume of experiments involving a broad set of proxy-applications and benchmarks, we aim to reveal how HPC CPU performance will evolve, and conclude an average boost of 9.56x for cache-sensitive HPC applications, on a per-chip basis. Additionally, we exhaustively document our methodological exploration to motivate HPC centers to drive their own technological agenda through enhanced co-design.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023; v1 submitted 5 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Variational Inference with Locally Enhanced Bounds for Hierarchical Models
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Hierarchical models represent a challenging setting for inference algorithms. MCMC methods struggle to scale to large models with many local variables and observations, and variational inference (VI) may fail to provide accurate approximations due to the use of simple variational families. Some variational methods (e.g. importance weighted VI) integrate Monte Carlo methods to give better accuracy,…
▽ More
Hierarchical models represent a challenging setting for inference algorithms. MCMC methods struggle to scale to large models with many local variables and observations, and variational inference (VI) may fail to provide accurate approximations due to the use of simple variational families. Some variational methods (e.g. importance weighted VI) integrate Monte Carlo methods to give better accuracy, but these tend to be unsuitable for hierarchical models, as they do not allow for subsampling and their performance tends to degrade for high dimensional models. We propose a new family of variational bounds for hierarchical models, based on the application of tightening methods (e.g. importance weighting) separately for each group of local random variables. We show that our approach naturally allows the use of subsampling to get unbiased gradients, and that it fully leverages the power of methods that build tighter lower bounds by applying them independently in lower dimensional spaces, leading to better results and more accurate posterior approximations than relevant baselines.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2022; v1 submitted 8 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Amortized Variational Inference for Simple Hierarchical Models
Authors:
Abhinav Agrawal,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
It is difficult to use subsampling with variational inference in hierarchical models since the number of local latent variables scales with the dataset. Thus, inference in hierarchical models remains a challenge at large scale. It is helpful to use a variational family with structure matching the posterior, but optimization is still slow due to the huge number of local distributions. Instead, this…
▽ More
It is difficult to use subsampling with variational inference in hierarchical models since the number of local latent variables scales with the dataset. Thus, inference in hierarchical models remains a challenge at large scale. It is helpful to use a variational family with structure matching the posterior, but optimization is still slow due to the huge number of local distributions. Instead, this paper suggests an amortized approach where shared parameters simultaneously represent all local distributions. This approach is similarly accurate as using a given joint distribution (e.g., a full-rank Gaussian) but is feasible on datasets that are several orders of magnitude larger. It is also dramatically faster than using a structured variational distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
MLPerf HPC: A Holistic Benchmark Suite for Scientific Machine Learning on HPC Systems
Authors:
Steven Farrell,
Murali Emani,
Jacob Balma,
Lukas Drescher,
Aleksandr Drozd,
Andreas Fink,
Geoffrey Fox,
David Kanter,
Thorsten Kurth,
Peter Mattson,
Dawei Mu,
Amit Ruhela,
Kento Sato,
Koichi Shirahata,
Tsuguchika Tabaru,
Aristeidis Tsaris,
Jan Balewski,
Ben Cumming,
Takumi Danjo,
Jens Domke,
Takaaki Fukai,
Naoto Fukumoto,
Tatsuya Fukushi,
Balazs Gerofi,
Takumi Honda
, et al. (18 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Scientific communities are increasingly adopting machine learning and deep learning models in their applications to accelerate scientific insights. High performance computing systems are pushing the frontiers of performance with a rich diversity of hardware resources and massive scale-out capabilities. There is a critical need to understand fair and effective benchmarking of machine learning appli…
▽ More
Scientific communities are increasingly adopting machine learning and deep learning models in their applications to accelerate scientific insights. High performance computing systems are pushing the frontiers of performance with a rich diversity of hardware resources and massive scale-out capabilities. There is a critical need to understand fair and effective benchmarking of machine learning applications that are representative of real-world scientific use cases. MLPerf is a community-driven standard to benchmark machine learning workloads, focusing on end-to-end performance metrics. In this paper, we introduce MLPerf HPC, a benchmark suite of large-scale scientific machine learning training applications driven by the MLCommons Association. We present the results from the first submission round, including a diverse set of some of the world's largest HPC systems. We develop a systematic framework for their joint analysis and compare them in terms of data staging, algorithmic convergence, and compute performance. As a result, we gain a quantitative understanding of optimizations on different subsystems such as staging and on-node loading of data, compute-unit utilization, and communication scheduling, enabling overall $>10 \times$ (end-to-end) performance improvements through system scaling. Notably, our analysis shows a scale-dependent interplay between the dataset size, a system's memory hierarchy, and training convergence that underlines the importance of near-compute storage. To overcome the data-parallel scalability challenge at large batch sizes, we discuss specific learning techniques and hybrid data-and-model parallelism that are effective on large systems. We conclude by characterizing each benchmark with respect to low-level memory, I/O, and network behavior to parameterize extended roofline performance models in future rounds.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2021; v1 submitted 21 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Variational Marginal Particle Filters
Authors:
**lin Lai,
Justin Domke,
Daniel Sheldon
Abstract:
Variational inference for state space models (SSMs) is known to be hard in general. Recent works focus on deriving variational objectives for SSMs from unbiased sequential Monte Carlo estimators. We reveal that the marginal particle filter is obtained from sequential Monte Carlo by applying Rao-Blackwellization operations, which sacrifices the trajectory information for reduced variance and differ…
▽ More
Variational inference for state space models (SSMs) is known to be hard in general. Recent works focus on deriving variational objectives for SSMs from unbiased sequential Monte Carlo estimators. We reveal that the marginal particle filter is obtained from sequential Monte Carlo by applying Rao-Blackwellization operations, which sacrifices the trajectory information for reduced variance and differentiability. We propose the variational marginal particle filter (VMPF), which is a differentiable and reparameterizable variational filtering objective for SSMs based on an unbiased estimator. We find that VMPF with biased gradients gives tighter bounds than previous objectives, and the unbiased reparameterization gradients are sometimes beneficial.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2022; v1 submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
A64FX -- Your Compiler You Must Decide!
Authors:
Jens Domke
Abstract:
The current number one of the TOP500 list, Supercomputer Fugaku, has demonstrated that CPU-only HPC systems aren't dead and CPUs can be used for more than just being the host controller for a discrete accelerators. While the specifications of the chip and overall system architecture, and benchmarks submitted to various lists, like TOP500 and Green500, etc., are clearly highlighting the potential,…
▽ More
The current number one of the TOP500 list, Supercomputer Fugaku, has demonstrated that CPU-only HPC systems aren't dead and CPUs can be used for more than just being the host controller for a discrete accelerators. While the specifications of the chip and overall system architecture, and benchmarks submitted to various lists, like TOP500 and Green500, etc., are clearly highlighting the potential, the proliferation of Arm into the HPC business is rather recent and hence the software stack might not be fully matured and tuned, yet. We test three state-of-the-art compiler suite against a broad set of benchmarks. Our measurements show that orders of magnitudes in performance can be gained by deviating from the recommended usage model of the A64FX compute nodes.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2021; v1 submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
MCMC Variational Inference via Uncorrected Hamiltonian Annealing
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Given an unnormalized target distribution we want to obtain approximate samples from it and a tight lower bound on its (log) normalization constant log Z. Annealed Importance Sampling (AIS) with Hamiltonian MCMC is a powerful method that can be used to do this. Its main drawback is that it uses non-differentiable transition kernels, which makes tuning its many parameters hard. We propose a framewo…
▽ More
Given an unnormalized target distribution we want to obtain approximate samples from it and a tight lower bound on its (log) normalization constant log Z. Annealed Importance Sampling (AIS) with Hamiltonian MCMC is a powerful method that can be used to do this. Its main drawback is that it uses non-differentiable transition kernels, which makes tuning its many parameters hard. We propose a framework to use an AIS-like procedure with Uncorrected Hamiltonian MCMC, called Uncorrected Hamiltonian Annealing. Our method leads to tight and differentiable lower bounds on log Z. We show empirically that our method yields better performances than other competing approaches, and that the ability to tune its parameters using reparameterization gradients may lead to large performance improvements.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2021; v1 submitted 8 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Empirical Evaluation of Biased Methods for Alpha Divergence Minimization
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
In this paper we empirically evaluate biased methods for alpha-divergence minimization. In particular, we focus on how the bias affects the final solutions found, and how this depends on the dimensionality of the problem. We find that (i) solutions returned by these methods appear to be strongly biased towards minimizers of the traditional "exclusive" KL-divergence, KL(q||p), and (ii) in high dime…
▽ More
In this paper we empirically evaluate biased methods for alpha-divergence minimization. In particular, we focus on how the bias affects the final solutions found, and how this depends on the dimensionality of the problem. We find that (i) solutions returned by these methods appear to be strongly biased towards minimizers of the traditional "exclusive" KL-divergence, KL(q||p), and (ii) in high dimensions, an impractically large amount of computation is needed to mitigate this bias and obtain solutions that actually minimize the alpha-divergence of interest.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
An Easy to Interpret Diagnostic for Approximate Inference: Symmetric Divergence Over Simulations
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
It is important to estimate the errors of probabilistic inference algorithms. Existing diagnostics for Markov chain Monte Carlo methods assume inference is asymptotically exact, and are not appropriate for approximate methods like variational inference or Laplace's method. This paper introduces a diagnostic based on repeatedly simulating datasets from the prior and performing inference on each. Th…
▽ More
It is important to estimate the errors of probabilistic inference algorithms. Existing diagnostics for Markov chain Monte Carlo methods assume inference is asymptotically exact, and are not appropriate for approximate methods like variational inference or Laplace's method. This paper introduces a diagnostic based on repeatedly simulating datasets from the prior and performing inference on each. The central observation is that it is possible to estimate a symmetric KL-divergence defined over these simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Matrix Engines for High Performance Computing:A Paragon of Performance or Gras** at Straws?
Authors:
Jens Domke,
Emil Vatai,
Aleksandr Drozd,
Peng Chen,
Yosuke Oyama,
Lingqi Zhang,
Shweta Salaria,
Daichi Mukunoki,
Artur Podobas,
Mohamed Wahib,
Satoshi Matsuoka
Abstract:
Matrix engines or units, in different forms and affinities, are becoming a reality in modern processors; CPUs and otherwise. The current and dominant algorithmic approach to Deep Learning merits the commercial investments in these units, and deduced from the No.1 benchmark in supercomputing, namely High Performance Linpack, one would expect an awakened enthusiasm by the HPC community, too.
Hence…
▽ More
Matrix engines or units, in different forms and affinities, are becoming a reality in modern processors; CPUs and otherwise. The current and dominant algorithmic approach to Deep Learning merits the commercial investments in these units, and deduced from the No.1 benchmark in supercomputing, namely High Performance Linpack, one would expect an awakened enthusiasm by the HPC community, too.
Hence, our goal is to identify the practical added benefits for HPC and machine learning applications by having access to matrix engines. For this purpose, we perform an in-depth survey of software stacks, proxy applications and benchmarks, and historical batch job records. We provide a cost-benefit analysis of matrix engines, both asymptotically and in conjunction with state-of-the-art processors. While our empirical data will temper the enthusiasm, we also outline opportunities to misuse these dense matrix-multiplication engines if they come for free.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2021; v1 submitted 27 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
On the Difficulty of Unbiased Alpha Divergence Minimization
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Several approximate inference algorithms have been proposed to minimize an alpha-divergence between an approximating distribution and a target distribution. Many of these algorithms introduce bias, the magnitude of which becomes problematic in high dimensions. Other algorithms are unbiased. These often seem to suffer from high variance, but little is rigorously known. In this work we study unbiase…
▽ More
Several approximate inference algorithms have been proposed to minimize an alpha-divergence between an approximating distribution and a target distribution. Many of these algorithms introduce bias, the magnitude of which becomes problematic in high dimensions. Other algorithms are unbiased. These often seem to suffer from high variance, but little is rigorously known. In this work we study unbiased methods for alpha-divergence minimization through the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) of the gradient estimator. We study several representative scenarios where strong analytical results are possible, such as fully-factorized or Gaussian distributions. We find that when alpha is not zero, the SNR worsens exponentially in the dimensionality of the problem. This casts doubt on the practicality of these methods. We empirically confirm these theoretical results.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2021; v1 submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Scaling Distributed Deep Learning Workloads beyond the Memory Capacity with KARMA
Authors:
Mohamed Wahib,
Haoyu Zhang,
Truong Thao Nguyen,
Aleksandr Drozd,
Jens Domke,
Lingqi Zhang,
Ryousei Takano,
Satoshi Matsuoka
Abstract:
The dedicated memory of hardware accelerators can be insufficient to store all weights and/or intermediate states of large deep learning models. Although model parallelism is a viable approach to reduce the memory pressure issue, significant modification of the source code and considerations for algorithms are required. An alternative solution is to use out-of-core methods instead of, or in additi…
▽ More
The dedicated memory of hardware accelerators can be insufficient to store all weights and/or intermediate states of large deep learning models. Although model parallelism is a viable approach to reduce the memory pressure issue, significant modification of the source code and considerations for algorithms are required. An alternative solution is to use out-of-core methods instead of, or in addition to, data parallelism. We propose a performance model based on the concurrency analysis of out-of-core training behavior, and derive a strategy that combines layer swap** and redundant recomputing. We achieve an average of 1.52x speedup in six different models over the state-of-the-art out-of-core methods. We also introduce the first method to solve the challenging problem of out-of-core multi-node training by carefully pipelining gradient exchanges and performing the parameter updates on the host. Our data parallel out-of-core solution can outperform complex hybrid model parallelism in training large models, e.g. Megatron-LM and Turning-NLG.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Approximation Based Variance Reduction for Reparameterization Gradients
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Flexible variational distributions improve variational inference but are harder to optimize. In this work we present a control variate that is applicable for any reparameterizable distribution with known mean and covariance matrix, e.g. Gaussians with any covariance structure. The control variate is based on a quadratic approximation of the model, and its parameters are set using a double-descent…
▽ More
Flexible variational distributions improve variational inference but are harder to optimize. In this work we present a control variate that is applicable for any reparameterizable distribution with known mean and covariance matrix, e.g. Gaussians with any covariance structure. The control variate is based on a quadratic approximation of the model, and its parameters are set using a double-descent scheme by minimizing the gradient estimator's variance. We empirically show that this control variate leads to large improvements in gradient variance and optimization convergence for inference with non-factorized variational distributions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2020; v1 submitted 29 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
High-Performance Routing with Multipathing and Path Diversity in Ethernet and HPC Networks
Authors:
Maciej Besta,
Jens Domke,
Marcel Schneider,
Marek Konieczny,
Salvatore Di Girolamo,
Timo Schneider,
Ankit Singla,
Torsten Hoefler
Abstract:
The recent line of research into topology design focuses on lowering network diameter. Many low-diameter topologies such as Slim Fly or Jellyfish that substantially reduce cost, power consumption, and latency have been proposed. A key challenge in realizing the benefits of these topologies is routing. On one hand, these networks provide shorter path lengths than established topologies such as Clos…
▽ More
The recent line of research into topology design focuses on lowering network diameter. Many low-diameter topologies such as Slim Fly or Jellyfish that substantially reduce cost, power consumption, and latency have been proposed. A key challenge in realizing the benefits of these topologies is routing. On one hand, these networks provide shorter path lengths than established topologies such as Clos or torus, leading to performance improvements. On the other hand, the number of shortest paths between each pair of endpoints is much smaller than in Clos, but there is a large number of non-minimal paths between router pairs. This hampers or even makes it impossible to use established multipath routing schemes such as ECMP. In this work, to facilitate high-performance routing in modern networks, we analyze existing routing protocols and architectures, focusing on how well they exploit the diversity of minimal and non-minimal paths. We first develop a taxonomy of different forms of support for multipathing and overall path diversity. Then, we analyze how existing routing schemes support this diversity. Among others, we consider multipathing with both shortest and non-shortest paths, support for disjoint paths, or enabling adaptivity. To address the ongoing convergence of HPC and "Big Data" domains, we consider routing protocols developed for both HPC systems and for data centers as well as general clusters. Thus, we cover architectures and protocols based on Ethernet, InfiniBand, and other HPC networks such as Myrinet. Our review will foster develo** future high-performance multipathing routing protocols in supercomputers and data centers.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2020; v1 submitted 7 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Advances in Black-Box VI: Normalizing Flows, Importance Weighting, and Optimization
Authors:
Abhinav Agrawal,
Daniel Sheldon,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Recent research has seen several advances relevant to black-box VI, but the current state of automatic posterior inference is unclear. One such advance is the use of normalizing flows to define flexible posterior densities for deep latent variable models. Another direction is the integration of Monte-Carlo methods to serve two purposes; first, to obtain tighter variational objectives for optimizat…
▽ More
Recent research has seen several advances relevant to black-box VI, but the current state of automatic posterior inference is unclear. One such advance is the use of normalizing flows to define flexible posterior densities for deep latent variable models. Another direction is the integration of Monte-Carlo methods to serve two purposes; first, to obtain tighter variational objectives for optimization, and second, to define enriched variational families through sampling. However, both flows and variational Monte-Carlo methods remain relatively unexplored for black-box VI. Moreover, on a pragmatic front, there are several optimization considerations like step-size scheme, parameter initialization, and choice of gradient estimators, for which there are no clear guidance in the existing literature. In this paper, we postulate that black-box VI is best addressed through a careful combination of numerous algorithmic components. We evaluate components relating to optimization, flows, and Monte-Carlo methods on a benchmark of 30 models from the Stan model library. The combination of these algorithmic components significantly advances the state-of-the-art "out of the box" variational inference.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2020; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
White Paper from Workshop on Large-scale Parallel Numerical Computing Technology (LSPANC 2020): HPC and Computer Arithmetic toward Minimal-Precision Computing
Authors:
Roman Iakymchuk,
Daichi Mukunoki,
Artur Podobas,
Fabienne Jézéquel,
Toshiyuki Imamura,
Norihisa Fujita,
Jens Huthmann,
Shuhei Kudo,
Yiyu Tan,
Jens Domke,
Kai Torben Ohlhus,
Takeshi Fukaya,
Takeo Hoshi,
Yuki Murakami,
Maho Nakata,
Takeshi Ogita,
Kentaro Sano,
Taisuke Boku
Abstract:
In numerical computations, precision of floating-point computations is a key factor to determine the performance (speed and energy-efficiency) as well as the reliability (accuracy and reproducibility). However, precision generally plays a contrary role for both. Therefore, the ultimate concept for maximizing both at the same time is the minimal-precision computing through precision-tuning, which a…
▽ More
In numerical computations, precision of floating-point computations is a key factor to determine the performance (speed and energy-efficiency) as well as the reliability (accuracy and reproducibility). However, precision generally plays a contrary role for both. Therefore, the ultimate concept for maximizing both at the same time is the minimal-precision computing through precision-tuning, which adjusts the optimal precision for each operation and data. Several studies have been already conducted for it so far (e.g. Precimoniuos and Verrou), but the scope of those studies is limited to the precision-tuning alone. Hence, we aim to propose a broader concept of the minimal-precision computing system with precision-tuning, involving both hardware and software stack.
In 2019, we have started the Minimal-Precision Computing project to propose a more broad concept of the minimal-precision computing system with precision-tuning, involving both hardware and software stack. Specifically, our system combines (1) a precision-tuning method based on Discrete Stochastic Arithmetic (DSA), (2) arbitrary-precision arithmetic libraries, (3) fast and accurate numerical libraries, and (4) Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA) with High-Level Synthesis (HLS).
In this white paper, we aim to provide an overview of various technologies related to minimal- and mixed-precision, to outline the future direction of the project, as well as to discuss current challenges together with our project members and guest speakers at the LSPANC 2020 workshop; https://www.r-ccs.riken.jp/labs/lpnctrt/lspanc2020jan/.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2020; v1 submitted 9 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Moment-Matching Conditions for Exponential Families with Conditioning or Hidden Data
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Maximum likelihood learning with exponential families leads to moment-matching of the sufficient statistics, a classic result. This can be generalized to conditional exponential families and/or when there are hidden data. This document gives a first-principles explanation of these generalized moment-matching conditions, along with a self-contained derivation.
Maximum likelihood learning with exponential families leads to moment-matching of the sufficient statistics, a classic result. This can be generalized to conditional exponential families and/or when there are hidden data. This document gives a first-principles explanation of these generalized moment-matching conditions, along with a self-contained derivation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
A Rule for Gradient Estimator Selection, with an Application to Variational Inference
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Stochastic gradient descent (SGD) is the workhorse of modern machine learning. Sometimes, there are many different potential gradient estimators that can be used. When so, choosing the one with the best tradeoff between cost and variance is important. This paper analyzes the convergence rates of SGD as a function of time, rather than iterations. This results in a simple rule to select the estimato…
▽ More
Stochastic gradient descent (SGD) is the workhorse of modern machine learning. Sometimes, there are many different potential gradient estimators that can be used. When so, choosing the one with the best tradeoff between cost and variance is important. This paper analyzes the convergence rates of SGD as a function of time, rather than iterations. This results in a simple rule to select the estimator that leads to the best optimization convergence guarantee. This choice is the same for different variants of SGD, and with different assumptions about the objective (e.g. convexity or smoothness). Inspired by this principle, we propose a technique to automatically select an estimator when a finite pool of estimators is given. Then, we extend to infinite pools of estimators, where each one is indexed by control variate weights. This is enabled by a reduction to a mixed-integer quadratic program. Empirically, automatically choosing an estimator performs comparably to the best estimator chosen with hindsight.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Thompson Sampling with Approximate Inference
Authors:
My Phan,
Yasin Abbasi-Yadkori,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
We study the effects of approximate inference on the performance of Thompson sampling in the $k$-armed bandit problems. Thompson sampling is a successful algorithm for online decision-making but requires posterior inference, which often must be approximated in practice. We show that even small constant inference error (in $α$-divergence) can lead to poor performance (linear regret) due to under-ex…
▽ More
We study the effects of approximate inference on the performance of Thompson sampling in the $k$-armed bandit problems. Thompson sampling is a successful algorithm for online decision-making but requires posterior inference, which often must be approximated in practice. We show that even small constant inference error (in $α$-divergence) can lead to poor performance (linear regret) due to under-exploration (for $α<1$) or over-exploration (for $α>0$) by the approximation. While for $α> 0$ this is unavoidable, for $α\leq 0$ the regret can be improved by adding a small amount of forced exploration even when the inference error is a large constant.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2020; v1 submitted 14 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Divide and Couple: Using Monte Carlo Variational Objectives for Posterior Approximation
Authors:
Justin Domke,
Daniel Sheldon
Abstract:
Recent work in variational inference (VI) uses ideas from Monte Carlo estimation to tighten the lower bounds on the log-likelihood that are used as objectives. However, there is no systematic understanding of how optimizing different objectives relates to approximating the posterior distribution. Develo** such a connection is important if the ideas are to be applied to inference-i.e., applicatio…
▽ More
Recent work in variational inference (VI) uses ideas from Monte Carlo estimation to tighten the lower bounds on the log-likelihood that are used as objectives. However, there is no systematic understanding of how optimizing different objectives relates to approximating the posterior distribution. Develo** such a connection is important if the ideas are to be applied to inference-i.e., applications that require an approximate posterior and not just an approximation of the log-likelihood. Given a VI objective defined by a Monte Carlo estimator of the likelihood, we use a "divide and couple" procedure to identify augmented proposal and target distributions. The divergence between these is equal to the gap between the VI objective and the log-likelihood. Thus, after maximizing the VI objective, the augmented variational distribution may be used to approximate the posterior distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2020; v1 submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Provable Gradient Variance Guarantees for Black-Box Variational Inference
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Recent variational inference methods use stochastic gradient estimators whose variance is not well understood. Theoretical guarantees for these estimators are important to understand when these methods will or will not work. This paper gives bounds for the common "reparameterization" estimators when the target is smooth and the variational family is a location-scale distribution. These bounds are…
▽ More
Recent variational inference methods use stochastic gradient estimators whose variance is not well understood. Theoretical guarantees for these estimators are important to understand when these methods will or will not work. This paper gives bounds for the common "reparameterization" estimators when the target is smooth and the variational family is a location-scale distribution. These bounds are unimprovable and thus provide the best possible guarantees under the stated assumptions.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2019; v1 submitted 19 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Provable Smoothness Guarantees for Black-Box Variational Inference
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Black-box variational inference tries to approximate a complex target distribution though a gradient-based optimization of the parameters of a simpler distribution. Provable convergence guarantees require structural properties of the objective. This paper shows that for location-scale family approximations, if the target is M-Lipschitz smooth, then so is the objective, if the entropy is excluded.…
▽ More
Black-box variational inference tries to approximate a complex target distribution though a gradient-based optimization of the parameters of a simpler distribution. Provable convergence guarantees require structural properties of the objective. This paper shows that for location-scale family approximations, if the target is M-Lipschitz smooth, then so is the objective, if the entropy is excluded. The key proof idea is to describe gradients in a certain inner-product space, thus permitting use of Bessel's inequality. This result gives insight into how to parameterize distributions, gives bounds the location of the optimal parameters, and is a key ingredient for convergence guarantees.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2020; v1 submitted 24 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Using Large Ensembles of Control Variates for Variational Inference
Authors:
Tomas Geffner,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Variational inference is increasingly being addressed with stochastic optimization. In this setting, the gradient's variance plays a crucial role in the optimization procedure, since high variance gradients lead to poor convergence. A popular approach used to reduce gradient's variance involves the use of control variates. Despite the good results obtained, control variates developed for variation…
▽ More
Variational inference is increasingly being addressed with stochastic optimization. In this setting, the gradient's variance plays a crucial role in the optimization procedure, since high variance gradients lead to poor convergence. A popular approach used to reduce gradient's variance involves the use of control variates. Despite the good results obtained, control variates developed for variational inference are typically looked at in isolation. In this paper we clarify the large number of control variates that are available by giving a systematic view of how they are derived. We also present a Bayesian risk minimization framework in which the quality of a procedure for combining control variates is quantified by its effect on optimization convergence rates, which leads to a very simple combination rule. Results show that combining a large number of control variates this way significantly improves the convergence of inference over using the typical gradient estimators or a reduced number of control variates.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2020; v1 submitted 29 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Double-precision FPUs in High-Performance Computing: an Embarrassment of Riches?
Authors:
Jens Domke,
Kazuaki Matsumura,
Mohamed Wahib,
Haoyu Zhang,
Keita Yashima,
Toshiki Tsuchikawa,
Yohei Tsuji,
Artur Podobas,
Satoshi Matsuoka
Abstract:
Among the (uncontended) common wisdom in High-Performance Computing (HPC) is the applications' need for large amount of double-precision support in hardware. Hardware manufacturers, the TOP500 list, and (rarely revisited) legacy software have without doubt followed and contributed to this view.
In this paper, we challenge that wisdom, and we do so by exhaustively comparing a large number of HPC…
▽ More
Among the (uncontended) common wisdom in High-Performance Computing (HPC) is the applications' need for large amount of double-precision support in hardware. Hardware manufacturers, the TOP500 list, and (rarely revisited) legacy software have without doubt followed and contributed to this view.
In this paper, we challenge that wisdom, and we do so by exhaustively comparing a large number of HPC proxy application on two processors: Intel's Knights Landing (KNL) and Knights Mill (KNM). Although similar, the KNM and KNL architecturally deviate at one important point: the silicon area devoted to double-precision arithmetic's. This fortunate discrepancy allows us to empirically quantify the performance impact in reducing the amount of hardware double-precision arithmetic.
Our analysis shows that this common wisdom might not always be right. We find that the investigated HPC proxy applications do allow for a (significant) reduction in double-precision with little-to-no performance implications. With the advent of a failing of Moore's law, our results partially reinforce the view taken by modern industry (e.g. upcoming Fujitsu ARM64FX) to integrate hybrid-precision hardware units.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2019; v1 submitted 22 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Importance Weighting and Variational Inference
Authors:
Justin Domke,
Daniel Sheldon
Abstract:
Recent work used importance sampling ideas for better variational bounds on likelihoods. We clarify the applicability of these ideas to pure probabilistic inference, by showing the resulting Importance Weighted Variational Inference (IWVI) technique is an instance of augmented variational inference, thus identifying the looseness in previous work. Experiments confirm IWVI's practicality for probab…
▽ More
Recent work used importance sampling ideas for better variational bounds on likelihoods. We clarify the applicability of these ideas to pure probabilistic inference, by showing the resulting Importance Weighted Variational Inference (IWVI) technique is an instance of augmented variational inference, thus identifying the looseness in previous work. Experiments confirm IWVI's practicality for probabilistic inference. As a second contribution, we investigate inference with elliptical distributions, which improves accuracy in low dimensions, and convergence in high dimensions.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2018; v1 submitted 27 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Conditional Inference in Pre-trained Variational Autoencoders via Cross-coding
Authors:
Ga Wu,
Justin Domke,
Scott Sanner
Abstract:
Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) are a popular generative model, but one in which conditional inference can be challenging. If the decomposition into query and evidence variables is fixed, conditional VAEs provide an attractive solution. To support arbitrary queries, one is generally reduced to Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling methods that can suffer from long mixing times. In this paper, we propo…
▽ More
Variational Autoencoders (VAEs) are a popular generative model, but one in which conditional inference can be challenging. If the decomposition into query and evidence variables is fixed, conditional VAEs provide an attractive solution. To support arbitrary queries, one is generally reduced to Markov Chain Monte Carlo sampling methods that can suffer from long mixing times. In this paper, we propose an idea we term cross-coding to approximate the distribution over the latent variables after conditioning on an evidence assignment to some subset of the variables. This allows generating query samples without retraining the full VAE. We experimentally evaluate three variations of cross-coding showing that (i) they can be quickly optimized for different decompositions of evidence and query and (ii) they quantitatively and qualitatively outperform Hamiltonian Monte Carlo.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2018; v1 submitted 20 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
A Divergence Bound for Hybrids of MCMC and Variational Inference and an Application to Langevin Dynamics and SGVI
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Two popular classes of methods for approximate inference are Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) and variational inference. MCMC tends to be accurate if run for a long enough time, while variational inference tends to give better approximations at shorter time horizons. However, the amount of time needed for MCMC to exceed the performance of variational methods can be quite high, motivating more fine-…
▽ More
Two popular classes of methods for approximate inference are Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) and variational inference. MCMC tends to be accurate if run for a long enough time, while variational inference tends to give better approximations at shorter time horizons. However, the amount of time needed for MCMC to exceed the performance of variational methods can be quite high, motivating more fine-grained tradeoffs. This paper derives a distribution over variational parameters, designed to minimize a bound on the divergence between the resulting marginal distribution and the target, and gives an example of how to sample from this distribution in a way that interpolates between the behavior of existing methods based on Langevin dynamics and stochastic gradient variational inference (SGVI).
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Clam** Improves TRW and Mean Field Approximations
Authors:
Adrian Weller,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
We examine the effect of clam** variables for approximate inference in undirected graphical models with pairwise relationships and discrete variables. For any number of variable labels, we demonstrate that clam** and summing approximate sub-partition functions can lead only to a decrease in the partition function estimate for TRW, and an increase for the naive mean field method, in each case g…
▽ More
We examine the effect of clam** variables for approximate inference in undirected graphical models with pairwise relationships and discrete variables. For any number of variable labels, we demonstrate that clam** and summing approximate sub-partition functions can lead only to a decrease in the partition function estimate for TRW, and an increase for the naive mean field method, in each case guaranteeing an improvement in the approximation and bound. We next focus on binary variables, add the Bethe approximation to consideration and examine ways to choose good variables to clamp, introducing new methods. We show the importance of identifying highly frustrated cycles, and of checking the singleton entropy of a variable. We explore the value of our methods by empirical analysis and draw lessons to guide practitioners.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Maximum Likelihood Learning With Arbitrary Treewidth via Fast-Mixing Parameter Sets
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Inference is typically intractable in high-treewidth undirected graphical models, making maximum likelihood learning a challenge. One way to overcome this is to restrict parameters to a tractable set, most typically the set of tree-structured parameters. This paper explores an alternative notion of a tractable set, namely a set of "fast-mixing parameters" where Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) infe…
▽ More
Inference is typically intractable in high-treewidth undirected graphical models, making maximum likelihood learning a challenge. One way to overcome this is to restrict parameters to a tractable set, most typically the set of tree-structured parameters. This paper explores an alternative notion of a tractable set, namely a set of "fast-mixing parameters" where Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) inference can be guaranteed to quickly converge to the stationary distribution. While it is common in practice to approximate the likelihood gradient using samples obtained from MCMC, such procedures lack theoretical guarantees. This paper proves that for any exponential family with bounded sufficient statistics, (not just graphical models) when parameters are constrained to a fast-mixing set, gradient descent with gradients approximated by sampling will approximate the maximum likelihood solution inside the set with high-probability. When unregularized, to find a solution epsilon-accurate in log-likelihood requires a total amount of effort cubic in 1/epsilon, disregarding logarithmic factors. When ridge-regularized, strong convexity allows a solution epsilon-accurate in parameter distance with effort quadratic in 1/epsilon. Both of these provide of a fully-polynomial time randomized approximation scheme.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2015; v1 submitted 29 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Projecting Markov Random Field Parameters for Fast Mixing
Authors:
Xianghang Liu,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithms are simple and extremely powerful techniques to sample from almost arbitrary distributions. The flaw in practice is that it can take a large and/or unknown amount of time to converge to the stationary distribution. This paper gives sufficient conditions to guarantee that univariate Gibbs sampling on Markov Random Fields (MRFs) will be fast mixing, in a pr…
▽ More
Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithms are simple and extremely powerful techniques to sample from almost arbitrary distributions. The flaw in practice is that it can take a large and/or unknown amount of time to converge to the stationary distribution. This paper gives sufficient conditions to guarantee that univariate Gibbs sampling on Markov Random Fields (MRFs) will be fast mixing, in a precise sense. Further, an algorithm is given to project onto this set of fast-mixing parameters in the Euclidean norm. Following recent work, we give an example use of this to project in various divergence measures, comparing univariate marginals obtained by sampling after projection to common variational methods and Gibbs sampling on the original parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2014; v1 submitted 4 November, 2014;
originally announced November 2014.
-
Finito: A Faster, Permutable Incremental Gradient Method for Big Data Problems
Authors:
Aaron J. Defazio,
Tibério S. Caetano,
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Recent advances in optimization theory have shown that smooth strongly convex finite sums can be minimized faster than by treating them as a black box "batch" problem. In this work we introduce a new method in this class with a theoretical convergence rate four times faster than existing methods, for sums with sufficiently many terms. This method is also amendable to a sampling without replacement…
▽ More
Recent advances in optimization theory have shown that smooth strongly convex finite sums can be minimized faster than by treating them as a black box "batch" problem. In this work we introduce a new method in this class with a theoretical convergence rate four times faster than existing methods, for sums with sufficiently many terms. This method is also amendable to a sampling without replacement scheme that in practice gives further speed-ups. We give empirical results showing state of the art performance.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Structured Learning via Logistic Regression
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
A successful approach to structured learning is to write the learning objective as a joint function of linear parameters and inference messages, and iterate between updates to each. This paper observes that if the inference problem is "smoothed" through the addition of entropy terms, for fixed messages, the learning objective reduces to a traditional (non-structured) logistic regression problem wi…
▽ More
A successful approach to structured learning is to write the learning objective as a joint function of linear parameters and inference messages, and iterate between updates to each. This paper observes that if the inference problem is "smoothed" through the addition of entropy terms, for fixed messages, the learning objective reduces to a traditional (non-structured) logistic regression problem with respect to parameters. In these logistic regression problems, each training example has a bias term determined by the current set of messages. Based on this insight, the structured energy function can be extended from linear factors to any function class where an "oracle" exists to minimize a logistic loss.
△ Less
Submitted 2 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Projecting Ising Model Parameters for Fast Mixing
Authors:
Justin Domke,
Xianghang Liu
Abstract:
Inference in general Ising models is difficult, due to high treewidth making tree-based algorithms intractable. Moreover, when interactions are strong, Gibbs sampling may take exponential time to converge to the stationary distribution. We present an algorithm to project Ising model parameters onto a parameter set that is guaranteed to be fast mixing, under several divergences. We find that Gibbs…
▽ More
Inference in general Ising models is difficult, due to high treewidth making tree-based algorithms intractable. Moreover, when interactions are strong, Gibbs sampling may take exponential time to converge to the stationary distribution. We present an algorithm to project Ising model parameters onto a parameter set that is guaranteed to be fast mixing, under several divergences. We find that Gibbs sampling using the projected parameters is more accurate than with the original parameters when interaction strengths are strong and when limited time is available for sampling.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2014; v1 submitted 2 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Learning Graphical Model Parameters with Approximate Marginal Inference
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Likelihood based-learning of graphical models faces challenges of computational-complexity and robustness to model mis-specification. This paper studies methods that fit parameters directly to maximize a measure of the accuracy of predicted marginals, taking into account both model and inference approximations at training time. Experiments on imaging problems suggest marginalization-based learning…
▽ More
Likelihood based-learning of graphical models faces challenges of computational-complexity and robustness to model mis-specification. This paper studies methods that fit parameters directly to maximize a measure of the accuracy of predicted marginals, taking into account both model and inference approximations at training time. Experiments on imaging problems suggest marginalization-based learning performs better than likelihood-based approximations on difficult problems where the model being fit is approximate in nature.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Learning Convex Inference of Marginals
Authors:
Justin Domke
Abstract:
Graphical models trained using maximum likelihood are a common tool for probabilistic inference of marginal distributions. However, this approach suffers difficulties when either the inference process or the model is approximate. In this paper, the inference process is first defined to be the minimization of a convex function, inspired by free energy approximations. Learning is then done directly…
▽ More
Graphical models trained using maximum likelihood are a common tool for probabilistic inference of marginal distributions. However, this approach suffers difficulties when either the inference process or the model is approximate. In this paper, the inference process is first defined to be the minimization of a convex function, inspired by free energy approximations. Learning is then done directly in terms of the performance of the inference process at univariate marginal prediction. The main novelty is that this is a direct minimization of emperical risk, where the risk measures the accuracy of predicted marginals.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
