-
Locality and Singularity for Store-Atomic Memory Models
Authors:
Egor Derevenetc,
Roland Meyer,
Sebastian Schweizer
Abstract:
Robustness is a correctness notion for concurrent programs running under relaxed consistency models. The task is to check that the relaxed behavior coincides (up to traces) with sequential consistency (SC). Although computationally simple on paper (robustness has been shown to be PSPACE-complete for TSO, PGAS, and Power), building a practical robustness checker remains a challenge. The problem is…
▽ More
Robustness is a correctness notion for concurrent programs running under relaxed consistency models. The task is to check that the relaxed behavior coincides (up to traces) with sequential consistency (SC). Although computationally simple on paper (robustness has been shown to be PSPACE-complete for TSO, PGAS, and Power), building a practical robustness checker remains a challenge. The problem is that the various relaxations lead to a dramatic number of computations, only few of which violate robustness.
In the present paper, we set out to reduce the search space for robustness checkers. We focus on store-atomic consistency models and establish two completeness results. The first result, called locality, states that a non-robust program always contains a violating computation where only one thread delays commands. The second result, called singularity, is even stronger but restricted to programs without lightweight fences. It states that there is a violating computation where a single store is delayed.
As an application of the results, we derive a linear-size source-to-source translation of robustness to SC-reachability. It applies to general programs, regardless of the data domain and potentially with an unbounded number of threads and with unbounded buffers. We have implemented the translation and verified, for the first time, PGAS algorithms in a fully automated fashion. For TSO, our analysis outperforms existing tools.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Lazy TSO Reachability
Authors:
Ahmed Bouajjani,
Georgel Calin,
Egor Derevenetc,
Roland Meyer
Abstract:
We address the problem of checking state reachability for programs running under Total Store Order (TSO). The problem has been shown to be decidable but the cost is prohibitive, namely non-primitive recursive. We propose here to give up completeness. Our contribution is a new algorithm for TSO reachability: it uses the standard SC semantics and introduces the TSO semantics lazily and only where ne…
▽ More
We address the problem of checking state reachability for programs running under Total Store Order (TSO). The problem has been shown to be decidable but the cost is prohibitive, namely non-primitive recursive. We propose here to give up completeness. Our contribution is a new algorithm for TSO reachability: it uses the standard SC semantics and introduces the TSO semantics lazily and only where needed. At the heart of our algorithm is an iterative refinement of the program of interest. If the program's goal state is SC-reachable, we are done. If the goal state is not SC-reachable, this may be due to the fact that SC under-approximates TSO. We employ a second algorithm that determines TSO computations which are infeasible under SC, and hence likely to lead to new states. We enrich the program to emulate, under SC, these TSO computations. Altogether, this yields an iterative under-approximation that we prove sound and complete for bug hunting, i.e., a semi-decision procedure halting for positive cases of reachability. We have implemented the procedure as an extension to the tool Trencher and compared it to the Memorax and CBMC model checkers.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Robustness against Power is PSPACE-complete
Authors:
Egor Derevenetc,
Roland Meyer
Abstract:
Power is a RISC architecture developed by IBM, Freescale, and several other companies and implemented in a series of POWER processors. The architecture features a relaxed memory model providing very weak guarantees with respect to the ordering and atomicity of memory accesses.
Due to these weaknesses, some programs that are correct under sequential consistency (SC) show undesirable effects when…
▽ More
Power is a RISC architecture developed by IBM, Freescale, and several other companies and implemented in a series of POWER processors. The architecture features a relaxed memory model providing very weak guarantees with respect to the ordering and atomicity of memory accesses.
Due to these weaknesses, some programs that are correct under sequential consistency (SC) show undesirable effects when run under Power. We call these programs not robust against the Power memory model. Formally, a program is robust if every computation under Power has the same data and control dependencies as some SC computation.
Our contribution is a decision procedure for robustness of concurrent programs against the Power memory model. It is based on three ideas. First, we reformulate robustness in terms of the acyclicity of a happens-before relation. Second, we prove that among the computations with cyclic happens-before relation there is one in a certain normal form. Finally, we reduce the existence of such a normal-form computation to a language emptiness problem. Altogether, this yields a PSPACE algorithm for checking robustness against Power. We complement it by a matching lower bound to show PSPACE-completeness.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
A Theory of Partitioned Global Address Spaces
Authors:
Georgel Calin,
Egor Derevenetc,
Rupak Majumdar,
Roland Meyer
Abstract:
Partitioned global address space (PGAS) is a parallel programming model for the development of applications on clusters. It provides a global address space partitioned among the cluster nodes, and is supported in programming languages like C, C++, and Fortran by means of APIs. In this paper we provide a formal model for the semantics of single instruction, multiple data programs using PGAS APIs. O…
▽ More
Partitioned global address space (PGAS) is a parallel programming model for the development of applications on clusters. It provides a global address space partitioned among the cluster nodes, and is supported in programming languages like C, C++, and Fortran by means of APIs. In this paper we provide a formal model for the semantics of single instruction, multiple data programs using PGAS APIs. Our model reflects the main features of popular real-world APIs such as SHMEM, ARMCI, GASNet, GPI, and GASPI.
A key feature of PGAS is the support for one-sided communication: a node may directly read and write the memory located at a remote node, without explicit synchronization with the processes running on the remote side. One-sided communication increases performance by decoupling process synchronization from data transfer, but requires the programmer to reason about appropriate synchronizations between reads and writes. As a second contribution, we propose and investigate robustness, a criterion for correct synchronization of PGAS programs. Robustness corresponds to acyclicity of a suitable happens-before relation defined on PGAS computations. The requirement is finer than the classical data race freedom and rules out most false error reports.
Our main result is an algorithm for checking robustness of PGAS programs. The algorithm makes use of two insights. Using combinatorial arguments we first show that, if a PGAS program is not robust, then there are computations in a certain normal form that violate happens-before acyclicity. Intuitively, normal-form computations delay remote accesses in an ordered way. We then devise an algorithm that checks for cyclic normal-form computations. Essentially, the algorithm is an emptiness check for a novel automaton model that accepts normal-form computations in streaming fashion. Altogether, we prove the robustness problem is PSpace-complete.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Checking Robustness against TSO
Authors:
Ahmed Bouajjani,
Egor Derevenetc,
Roland Meyer
Abstract:
We present algorithms for checking and enforcing robustness of concurrent programs against the Total Store Ordering (TSO) memory model. A program is robust if all its TSO computations correspond to computations under the Sequential Consistency (SC) semantics.
We provide a complete characterization of non-robustness in terms of so-called attacks: a restricted form of (harmful) out-of-program-orde…
▽ More
We present algorithms for checking and enforcing robustness of concurrent programs against the Total Store Ordering (TSO) memory model. A program is robust if all its TSO computations correspond to computations under the Sequential Consistency (SC) semantics.
We provide a complete characterization of non-robustness in terms of so-called attacks: a restricted form of (harmful) out-of-program-order executions. Then, we show that detecting attacks can be parallelized, and can be solved using state reachability queries under SC semantics in a suitably instrumented program obtained by a linear size source-to-source translation. Importantly, the construction is valid for an arbitrary number of addresses and an arbitrary number of parallel threads, and it is independent from the data domain and from the size of store buffers in the TSO semantics. In particular, when the data domain is finite and the number of addresses is fixed, we obtain decidability and complexity results for robustness, even for an arbitrary number of threads.
As a second contribution, we provide an algorithm for computing an optimal set of fences that enforce robustness. We consider two criteria of optimality: minimization of program size and maximization of its performance. The algorithms we define are implemented, and we successfully applied them to analyzing and correcting several concurrent algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2012; v1 submitted 30 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
