-
The AI Review Lottery: Widespread AI-Assisted Peer Reviews Boost Paper Scores and Acceptance Rates
Authors:
Giuseppe Russo Latona,
Manoel Horta Ribeiro,
Tim R. Davidson,
Veniamin Veselovsky,
Robert West
Abstract:
Journals and conferences worry that peer reviews assisted by artificial intelligence (AI), in particular, large language models (LLMs), may negatively influence the validity and fairness of the peer-review system, a cornerstone of modern science. In this work, we address this concern with a quasi-experimental study of the prevalence and impact of AI-assisted peer reviews in the context of the 2024…
▽ More
Journals and conferences worry that peer reviews assisted by artificial intelligence (AI), in particular, large language models (LLMs), may negatively influence the validity and fairness of the peer-review system, a cornerstone of modern science. In this work, we address this concern with a quasi-experimental study of the prevalence and impact of AI-assisted peer reviews in the context of the 2024 International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), a large and prestigious machine-learning conference. Our contributions are threefold. Firstly, we obtain a lower bound for the prevalence of AI-assisted reviews at ICLR 2024 using the GPTZero LLM detector, estimating that at least $15.8\%$ of reviews were written with AI assistance. Secondly, we estimate the impact of AI-assisted reviews on submission scores. Considering pairs of reviews with different scores assigned to the same paper, we find that in $53.4\%$ of pairs the AI-assisted review scores higher than the human review ($p = 0.002$; relative difference in probability of scoring higher: $+14.4\%$ in favor of AI-assisted reviews). Thirdly, we assess the impact of receiving an AI-assisted peer review on submission acceptance. In a matched study, submissions near the acceptance threshold that received an AI-assisted peer review were $4.9$ percentage points ($p = 0.024$) more likely to be accepted than submissions that did not. Overall, we show that AI-assisted reviews are consequential to the peer-review process and offer a discussion on future implications of current trends
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Evaluating Language Model Agency through Negotiations
Authors:
Tim R. Davidson,
Veniamin Veselovsky,
Martin Josifoski,
Maxime Peyrard,
Antoine Bosselut,
Michal Kosinski,
Robert West
Abstract:
We introduce an approach to evaluate language model (LM) agency using negotiation games. This approach better reflects real-world use cases and addresses some of the shortcomings of alternative LM benchmarks. Negotiation games enable us to study multi-turn, and cross-model interactions, modulate complexity, and side-step accidental evaluation data leakage. We use our approach to test six widely us…
▽ More
We introduce an approach to evaluate language model (LM) agency using negotiation games. This approach better reflects real-world use cases and addresses some of the shortcomings of alternative LM benchmarks. Negotiation games enable us to study multi-turn, and cross-model interactions, modulate complexity, and side-step accidental evaluation data leakage. We use our approach to test six widely used and publicly accessible LMs, evaluating performance and alignment in both self-play and cross-play settings. Noteworthy findings include: (i) only closed-source models tested here were able to complete these tasks; (ii) cooperative bargaining games proved to be most challenging to the models; and (iii) even the most powerful models sometimes "lose" to weaker opponents
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2024; v1 submitted 9 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Increasing Expressivity of a Hyperspherical VAE
Authors:
Tim R. Davidson,
Jakub M. Tomczak,
Efstratios Gavves
Abstract:
Learning suitable latent representations for observed, high-dimensional data is an important research topic underlying many recent advances in machine learning. While traditionally the Gaussian normal distribution has been the go-to latent parameterization, recently a variety of works have successfully proposed the use of manifold-valued latents. In one such work (Davidson et al., 2018), the autho…
▽ More
Learning suitable latent representations for observed, high-dimensional data is an important research topic underlying many recent advances in machine learning. While traditionally the Gaussian normal distribution has been the go-to latent parameterization, recently a variety of works have successfully proposed the use of manifold-valued latents. In one such work (Davidson et al., 2018), the authors empirically show the potential benefits of using a hyperspherical von Mises-Fisher (vMF) distribution in low dimensionality. However, due to the unique distributional form of the vMF, expressivity in higher dimensional space is limited as a result of its scalar concentration parameter leading to a 'hyperspherical bottleneck'. In this work we propose to extend the usability of hyperspherical parameterizations to higher dimensions using a product-space instead, showing improved results on a selection of image datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Reparameterizing Distributions on Lie Groups
Authors:
Luca Falorsi,
Pim de Haan,
Tim R. Davidson,
Patrick Forré
Abstract:
Reparameterizable densities are an important way to learn probability distributions in a deep learning setting. For many distributions it is possible to create low-variance gradient estimators by utilizing a `reparameterization trick'. Due to the absence of a general reparameterization trick, much research has recently been devoted to extend the number of reparameterizable distributional families.…
▽ More
Reparameterizable densities are an important way to learn probability distributions in a deep learning setting. For many distributions it is possible to create low-variance gradient estimators by utilizing a `reparameterization trick'. Due to the absence of a general reparameterization trick, much research has recently been devoted to extend the number of reparameterizable distributional families. Unfortunately, this research has primarily focused on distributions defined in Euclidean space, ruling out the usage of one of the most influential class of spaces with non-trivial topologies: Lie groups. In this work we define a general framework to create reparameterizable densities on arbitrary Lie groups, and provide a detailed practitioners guide to further the ease of usage. We demonstrate how to create complex and multimodal distributions on the well known oriented group of 3D rotations, $\operatorname{SO}(3)$, using normalizing flows. Our experiments on applying such distributions in a Bayesian setting for pose estimation on objects with discrete and continuous symmetries, showcase their necessity in achieving realistic uncertainty estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Explorations in Homeomorphic Variational Auto-Encoding
Authors:
Luca Falorsi,
Pim de Haan,
Tim R. Davidson,
Nicola De Cao,
Maurice Weiler,
Patrick Forré,
Taco S. Cohen
Abstract:
The manifold hypothesis states that many kinds of high-dimensional data are concentrated near a low-dimensional manifold. If the topology of this data manifold is non-trivial, a continuous encoder network cannot embed it in a one-to-one manner without creating holes of low density in the latent space. This is at odds with the Gaussian prior assumption typically made in Variational Auto-Encoders (V…
▽ More
The manifold hypothesis states that many kinds of high-dimensional data are concentrated near a low-dimensional manifold. If the topology of this data manifold is non-trivial, a continuous encoder network cannot embed it in a one-to-one manner without creating holes of low density in the latent space. This is at odds with the Gaussian prior assumption typically made in Variational Auto-Encoders (VAEs), because the density of a Gaussian concentrates near a blob-like manifold.
In this paper we investigate the use of manifold-valued latent variables. Specifically, we focus on the important case of continuously differentiable symmetry groups (Lie groups), such as the group of 3D rotations $\operatorname{SO}(3)$. We show how a VAE with $\operatorname{SO}(3)$-valued latent variables can be constructed, by extending the reparameterization trick to compact connected Lie groups. Our experiments show that choosing manifold-valued latent variables that match the topology of the latent data manifold, is crucial to preserve the topological structure and learn a well-behaved latent space.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Hyperspherical Variational Auto-Encoders
Authors:
Tim R. Davidson,
Luca Falorsi,
Nicola De Cao,
Thomas Kipf,
Jakub M. Tomczak
Abstract:
The Variational Auto-Encoder (VAE) is one of the most used unsupervised machine learning models. But although the default choice of a Gaussian distribution for both the prior and posterior represents a mathematically convenient distribution often leading to competitive results, we show that this parameterization fails to model data with a latent hyperspherical structure. To address this issue we p…
▽ More
The Variational Auto-Encoder (VAE) is one of the most used unsupervised machine learning models. But although the default choice of a Gaussian distribution for both the prior and posterior represents a mathematically convenient distribution often leading to competitive results, we show that this parameterization fails to model data with a latent hyperspherical structure. To address this issue we propose using a von Mises-Fisher (vMF) distribution instead, leading to a hyperspherical latent space. Through a series of experiments we show how such a hyperspherical VAE, or $\mathcal{S}$-VAE, is more suitable for capturing data with a hyperspherical latent structure, while outperforming a normal, $\mathcal{N}$-VAE, in low dimensions on other data types. Code at http://github.com/nicola-decao/s-vae-tf and https://github.com/nicola-decao/s-vae-pytorch
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2022; v1 submitted 3 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
