-
Network Ecology of Marriage
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett
Abstract:
The practice of marriage is an understudied phenomenon in behavioural sciences despite being ubiquitous across human cultures. This modelling paper shows that replacing distant direct kin with in-laws increases the interconnectedness of the family social network graph, which allows more cooperative and larger groups. In this framing, marriage can be seen as a social technology that reduces free-ri…
▽ More
The practice of marriage is an understudied phenomenon in behavioural sciences despite being ubiquitous across human cultures. This modelling paper shows that replacing distant direct kin with in-laws increases the interconnectedness of the family social network graph, which allows more cooperative and larger groups. In this framing, marriage can be seen as a social technology that reduces free-riding within collaborative group. This approach offers a solution to the puzzle of why our species has this particular form of regulating mating behaviour, uniquely among pair-bonded animals.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Collaboration Conundrum: Synchrony-Cooperation Trade-off
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett
Abstract:
In large groups, every collaborative act requires balancing two pressures: the need to achieve behavioural synchrony and the need to keep free riding to a minimum. This paper introduces a model of collaboration that requires both synchronisation on a social network and costly cooperation. The results show that coordination slows, and cooperativeness increases with the social network`s local integr…
▽ More
In large groups, every collaborative act requires balancing two pressures: the need to achieve behavioural synchrony and the need to keep free riding to a minimum. This paper introduces a model of collaboration that requires both synchronisation on a social network and costly cooperation. The results show that coordination slows, and cooperativeness increases with the social network`s local integratedness, measured by the clustering coefficient. That is, in a large-group collaboration, achieving behavioural synchrony and strategic cooperation are in opposition to each other. The optimal clustering coefficient has no natural state in our species, and is determined by the ecological environment, the group`s technology set, and the group`s size. This opens the space for social technologies that solve this optimisation problem by generating optimal social network structures.
△ Less
Submitted 5 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Unbiased Library of k-regular, n-sized, Connected, Small Graphs
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett
Abstract:
The past decade highlighted the usefulness of social network simulations that run on k-regular, n-size, connected graphs. These can be seen as small-scale models of human social networks of large societies. By narrowing down onto k-regular graphs, the degree variation can be eliminated from the research question, which allows a focus on the isolated impact by other variables, for instance, by the…
▽ More
The past decade highlighted the usefulness of social network simulations that run on k-regular, n-size, connected graphs. These can be seen as small-scale models of human social networks of large societies. By narrowing down onto k-regular graphs, the degree variation can be eliminated from the research question, which allows a focus on the isolated impact by other variables, for instance, by the clustering coefficient or the size of the network. This paper describes the generation of a random graph library that uses a random walk graph creation algorithm that starts from the "chain of caves", which is the structure in which the clustering coefficient is at its maximum. This method finds mid and high clustering coefficient graphs, while Wolfram`s RandomGraph was useful for finding low ones. The merge of the two samples proved to be somewhat biased. After eliminating a host of network measures, the paper focused on mean graph distance as a further variable and created an unbiased subsample for each size and clustering coefficient bin.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
In A Society of Strangers, Kin Is Still Key: Identified Family Relations In Large-Scale Mobile Phone Data
Authors:
Tamás Dávid-Barrett,
Sebastian Diaz,
Carlos Rodriguez-Sickert,
Isabel Behncke,
Anna Rotkirch,
János Kertész,
Loreto Bravo
Abstract:
Mobile call networks have been widely used to investigate communication patterns and the network of interactions of humans at the societal scale. Yet, more detailed analysis is often hindered by having no information about the nature of the relationships, even if some metadata about the individuals are available. Using a unique, large mobile phone database with information about individual surname…
▽ More
Mobile call networks have been widely used to investigate communication patterns and the network of interactions of humans at the societal scale. Yet, more detailed analysis is often hindered by having no information about the nature of the relationships, even if some metadata about the individuals are available. Using a unique, large mobile phone database with information about individual surnames in a population in which people inherit two surnames: one from their father, and one from their mother, we are able to differentiate among close kin relationship types. Here we focus on the difference between the most frequently called alters depending on whether they are family relationships or not. We find support in the data for two hypotheses: (1) phone calls between family members are more frequent and last longer than phone calls between non-kin, and (2) the phone call pattern between family members show a higher variation depending on the stage of life-course compared to non-family members. We give an interpretation of these findings within the framework of evolutionary anthropology: kinship matters even when demographic processes, such as low fertility, urbanisation and migration reduce the access to family members. Furthermore, our results provide tools for distinguishing between different kinds of kin relationships from mobile call data, when information about names are unavailable.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Kinship Is a Network Tracking Social Technology, Not an Evolutionary Phenomenon
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett
Abstract:
On one hand, kinship is a universal human phenomenon that tends to align with biological relatedness, which might suggest evolutionary foundations. On the other hand, kinship has exceptional variation across the human populations, which points to cultural foundations. Furthermore, even if its foundation was biological, kinship is often too imprecise to track genetic relatedness efficiently, while…
▽ More
On one hand, kinship is a universal human phenomenon that tends to align with biological relatedness, which might suggest evolutionary foundations. On the other hand, kinship has exceptional variation across the human populations, which points to cultural foundations. Furthermore, even if its foundation was biological, kinship is often too imprecise to track genetic relatedness efficiently, while inclusive fitness theory would suggest focusing only on the closest relatives, which is not the case in most human cultures. It was the parallel validity of these contradicting arguments that led to decades of fierce debate about the definition and measurement of the phenomenon. This paper offers a new approach to kinship. First, the model demonstrates that it is possible to generate kinship networks (a) derived from the kind of basic kin connections that our species shares with other apes, but (b) driven by network rather than biological logic beyond the immediate family. Second the model demonstrates that kinship as a network heuristic works efficiently only in high fertility societies, and gives way to similarity-based friendship with demographic transition. The results explain (i) why kinship labelling is unique to our species, (ii) why kinship is universal among human cultures, (iii) why kinship terminology systems are varied across cultures, (iv) why linguistic kin assignment is imprecise, and (v) why kinship is replaced by homophily when relatives are scarce. The model offers a unifying framework to the debate between social and evolutionary anthropology concerning the concept of human kinship.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
World-wide Evidence for Gender Difference in Sociality
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett
Abstract:
One of the most contested questions about human behaviour is whether there are inherent sex or gender differences in the formation and maintenance of social bonds. On one hand, female and male brains are structurally almost identical, and while there are sex differences in the endocrine system, these are small, while much of gendered identity and behaviour is learned. On the other hand, sex differ…
▽ More
One of the most contested questions about human behaviour is whether there are inherent sex or gender differences in the formation and maintenance of social bonds. On one hand, female and male brains are structurally almost identical, and while there are sex differences in the endocrine system, these are small, while much of gendered identity and behaviour is learned. On the other hand, sex differences in some aspects of social behaviour have deep evolutionary roots, and are widely present in non-human animals. This observational study recorded the frequency of same-aged, adult human groups appearing in public spaces through 2636 hours, recording group formation by 1.2mn people via 170 research assistants in 46 countries across the world. The results show (a) a significant sex-gender difference in same-sex-same-age frequency, in that ~50% more female-female than male-male pairs are observed in public spaces globally, and (b) that despite regional variation, the patterns holds up in every global region. This is the first study of sex-gender difference in dyadic social behaviour across the world on this scale, and the first global study that uses direct rather than internet-based observations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Clustering Drives Cooperation on Reputation Networks, All Else Fixed
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett
Abstract:
Reputation-based cooperation on social networks offers a causal mechanism between graph properties and social trust. Recent papers on the `structural microfoundations` of the society used this insight to show how demographic processes, such as falling fertility, urbanisation, and migration, can alter the logic of human societies. This paper demonstrates the underlying mechanism in a way that is ac…
▽ More
Reputation-based cooperation on social networks offers a causal mechanism between graph properties and social trust. Recent papers on the `structural microfoundations` of the society used this insight to show how demographic processes, such as falling fertility, urbanisation, and migration, can alter the logic of human societies. This paper demonstrates the underlying mechanism in a way that is accessible to scientists not specialising in networks. Additionally, the paper shows that, when the size and degree of the network is fixed (i.e., all graphs have the same number of agents, who all have the same number of connections), it is the clustering coefficient that drives differences in how cooperative social networks are.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Peer relations with mobile phone data: Best friends and family formation
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett,
Anna Rotkirch,
Asim Ghosh,
Kunal Bhattacharya,
Daniel Monsivais,
Isabel Behncke,
Janos Kertesz,
Kimmo Kaski
Abstract:
Earlier attempts to investigate the changes of the role of friendship in different life stages have failed due to lack of data. We close this gap by using a large data set of mobile phone calls from a European country in 2007, to study how the people's call patterns to their close social contacts are associated with age and gender of the callers. We hypothesize that (i) communication with peers, d…
▽ More
Earlier attempts to investigate the changes of the role of friendship in different life stages have failed due to lack of data. We close this gap by using a large data set of mobile phone calls from a European country in 2007, to study how the people's call patterns to their close social contacts are associated with age and gender of the callers. We hypothesize that (i) communication with peers, defined as callers of similar age, will be most important during the period of family formation and that (ii) the importance of best friends defined as same-sex callers of exactly the same age, will be stronger for women than for men. Results show that the frequency of phone calls with the same-sex peers in this population turns out to be relatively stable through life for both men and women. In line with the first hypothesis, there was a significant increase in the length of the phone calls for callers between ages 30 to 40 years. Partly in line with the second hypothesis, the increase in phone calls turned out to be particularly pronounced among females, although there were only minor gender differences in call frequencies. Furthermore, women tended to have long phone conversations with their same-age female friend, and also with somewhat older peers. In sum, we provide evidence from big data for the adult life stages at which peers are most important, and suggest that best friends appear to have a niche of their own in human sociality.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Communication with family and friends across the life course
Authors:
Tamas David-Barrett,
Janos Kertesz,
Anna Rotkirch,
Asim Ghosh,
Kunal Bhattacharya,
Daniel Monsivais,
Kimmo Kaski
Abstract:
Each stage of the human life course is characterized by a distinctive pattern of social relations. We study how the intensity and importance of the closest social contacts vary across the life course, using a large database of mobile communication from a European country. We first determine the most likely social relationship type from these mobile phone records by relating the age and gender of t…
▽ More
Each stage of the human life course is characterized by a distinctive pattern of social relations. We study how the intensity and importance of the closest social contacts vary across the life course, using a large database of mobile communication from a European country. We first determine the most likely social relationship type from these mobile phone records by relating the age and gender of the caller and recipient to the frequency, length, and direction of calls. We then show how communication patterns between parents and children, romantic partner, and friends vary across the six main stages of the adult family life course. Young adulthood is dominated by a gradual shift of call activity from parents to close friends, and then to a romantic partner, culminating in the period of early family formation during which the focus is on the romantic partner. During middle adulthood call patterns suggest a high dependence on the parents of the ego, who, presumably often provide alloparental care, while at this stage female same-gender friendship also peaks. During post-reproductive adulthood, individuals and especially women balance close social contacts among three generations. The age of grandparenthood brings the children entering adulthood and family formation into the focus, and is associated with a realignment of close social contacts especially among women, while the old age is dominated by dependence on their children.
△ Less
Submitted 30 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
