-
Evaluation and Measurement of Software Process Improvement -- A Systematic Literature Review
Authors:
Michael Unterkalmsteiner,
Tony Gorschek,
A. K. M. Moinul Islam,
Chow Kian Cheng,
Rahadian Bayu Permadi,
Robert Feldt
Abstract:
BACKGROUND: Software Process Improvement (SPI) is a systematic approach to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of a software development organization and to enhance software products. OBJECTIVE: This paper aims to identify and characterize evaluation strategies and measurements used to assess the impact of different SPI initiatives. METHOD: The systematic literature review includes 148 paper…
▽ More
BACKGROUND: Software Process Improvement (SPI) is a systematic approach to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of a software development organization and to enhance software products. OBJECTIVE: This paper aims to identify and characterize evaluation strategies and measurements used to assess the impact of different SPI initiatives. METHOD: The systematic literature review includes 148 papers published between 1991 and 2008. The selected papers were classified according to SPI initiative, applied evaluation strategies, and measurement perspectives. Potential confounding factors interfering with the evaluation of the improvement effort were assessed. RESULTS: Seven distinct evaluation strategies were identified, wherein the most common one, "Pre-Post Comparison" was applied in 49 percent of the inspected papers. Quality was the most measured attribute (62 percent), followed by Cost (41 percent), and Schedule (18 percent). Looking at measurement perspectives, "Project" represents the majority with 66 percent. CONCLUSION: The evaluation validity of SPI initiatives is challenged by the scarce consideration of potential confounding factors, particularly given that "Pre-Post Comparison" was identified as the most common evaluation strategy, and the inaccurate descriptions of the evaluation context. Measurements to assess the short and mid-term impact of SPI initiatives prevail, whereas long-term measurements in terms of customer satisfaction and return on investment tend to be less used.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
A conceptual framework for SPI evaluation
Authors:
Michael Unterkalmsteiner,
Tony Gorschek,
A. K. M. Moinul Islam,
Chow Kian Cheng,
Rahadian Bayu Permadi,
Robert Feldt
Abstract:
Software Process Improvement (SPI) encompasses the analysis and modification of the processes within software development, aimed at improving key areas that contribute to the organizations' goals. The task of evaluating whether the selected improvement path meets these goals is challenging. On the basis of the results of a systematic literature review on SPI measurement and evaluation practices, w…
▽ More
Software Process Improvement (SPI) encompasses the analysis and modification of the processes within software development, aimed at improving key areas that contribute to the organizations' goals. The task of evaluating whether the selected improvement path meets these goals is challenging. On the basis of the results of a systematic literature review on SPI measurement and evaluation practices, we developed a framework (SPI Measurement and Evaluation Framework (SPI-MEF)) that supports the planning and implementation of SPI evaluations. SPI-MEF guides the practitioner in sco** the evaluation, determining measures, and performing the assessment. SPI-MEF does not assume a specific approach to process improvement and can be integrated in existing measurement programs, refocusing the assessment on evaluating the improvement initiative's outcome. Sixteen industry and academic experts evaluated the framework's usability and capability to support practitioners, providing additional insights that were integrated in the application guidelines of the framework.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
From Unstructured to Structured: Transforming Chatbot Dialogues into Data Mart Schema for Visualization
Authors:
Mark Edward M. Gonzales,
Elyssia Barrie H. Ong,
Charibeth K. Cheng,
Ethel Chua Joy Ong,
Judith J. Azcarraga
Abstract:
Schools are among the primary avenues for public healthcare interventions. With resource limitations posing challenges to the routine conduct of health and wellness checks in Philippine public schools, the deployment of a chatbot-assisted health monitoring system may provide an alternative method. However, deriving insights from raw conversations is not straightforward due to the expressiveness of…
▽ More
Schools are among the primary avenues for public healthcare interventions. With resource limitations posing challenges to the routine conduct of health and wellness checks in Philippine public schools, the deployment of a chatbot-assisted health monitoring system may provide an alternative method. However, deriving insights from raw conversations is not straightforward due to the expressiveness of natural language that causes variances in the input. In this paper, we present a process for transforming unstructured dialogues into a structured schema. The process comprises four stages: (i) processing the dialogues through entity extraction and data aggregation, (ii) storing them as NoSQL documents on the cloud, (iii) transforming them into a star schema for online analytical processing and building an extract-transform-load workflow, and (iv) creating a web-based dashboard for visualizing summarized data and reports. Performance evaluation of this dashboard showed that increasing the number of stored dialogues by a factor of 100,000 increased the loading time for the display of roll-up, drill-down, and filter results by around only one second.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
