-
Human-Algorithm Collaborative Bayesian Optimization for Engineering Systems
Authors:
Tom Savage,
Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
Bayesian optimization has been successfully applied throughout Chemical Engineering for the optimization of functions that are expensive-to-evaluate, or where gradients are not easily obtainable. However, domain experts often possess valuable physical insights that are overlooked in fully automated decision-making approaches, necessitating the inclusion of human input. In this article we re-introd…
▽ More
Bayesian optimization has been successfully applied throughout Chemical Engineering for the optimization of functions that are expensive-to-evaluate, or where gradients are not easily obtainable. However, domain experts often possess valuable physical insights that are overlooked in fully automated decision-making approaches, necessitating the inclusion of human input. In this article we re-introduce the human back into the data-driven decision making loop by outlining an approach for collaborative Bayesian optimization. Our methodology exploits the hypothesis that humans are more efficient at making discrete choices rather than continuous ones and enables experts to influence critical early decisions. We apply high-throughput (batch) Bayesian optimization alongside discrete decision theory to enable domain experts to influence the selection of experiments. At every iteration we apply a multi-objective approach that results in a set of alternate solutions that have both high utility and are reasonably distinct. The expert then selects the desired solution for evaluation from this set, allowing for the inclusion of expert knowledge and improving accountability, whilst maintaining the advantages of Bayesian optimization. We demonstrate our approach across a number of applied and numerical case studies including bioprocess optimization and reactor geometry design, demonstrating that even in the case of an uninformed practitioner our algorithm recovers the regret of standard Bayesian optimization. Through the inclusion of continuous expert opinion, our approach enables faster convergence, and improved accountability for Bayesian optimization in engineering systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Expert-guided Bayesian Optimisation for Human-in-the-loop Experimental Design of Known Systems
Authors:
Tom Savage,
Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
Domain experts often possess valuable physical insights that are overlooked in fully automated decision-making processes such as Bayesian optimisation. In this article we apply high-throughput (batch) Bayesian optimisation alongside anthropological decision theory to enable domain experts to influence the selection of optimal experiments. Our methodology exploits the hypothesis that humans are bet…
▽ More
Domain experts often possess valuable physical insights that are overlooked in fully automated decision-making processes such as Bayesian optimisation. In this article we apply high-throughput (batch) Bayesian optimisation alongside anthropological decision theory to enable domain experts to influence the selection of optimal experiments. Our methodology exploits the hypothesis that humans are better at making discrete choices than continuous ones and enables experts to influence critical early decisions. At each iteration we solve an augmented multi-objective optimisation problem across a number of alternate solutions, maximising both the sum of their utility function values and the determinant of their covariance matrix, equivalent to their total variability. By taking the solution at the knee point of the Pareto front, we return a set of alternate solutions at each iteration that have both high utility values and are reasonably distinct, from which the expert selects one for evaluation. We demonstrate that even in the case of an uninformed practitioner, our algorithm recovers the regret of standard Bayesian optimisation.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Machine Learning-Assisted Discovery of Flow Reactor Designs
Authors:
Tom Savage,
Nausheen Basha,
Jonathan McDonough,
James Krassowski,
Omar K Matar,
Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
Additive manufacturing has enabled the fabrication of advanced reactor geometries, permitting larger, more complex design spaces. Identifying promising configurations within such spaces presents a significant challenge for current approaches. Furthermore, existing parameterisations of reactor geometries are low-dimensional with expensive optimisation limiting more complex solutions. To address thi…
▽ More
Additive manufacturing has enabled the fabrication of advanced reactor geometries, permitting larger, more complex design spaces. Identifying promising configurations within such spaces presents a significant challenge for current approaches. Furthermore, existing parameterisations of reactor geometries are low-dimensional with expensive optimisation limiting more complex solutions. To address this challenge, we establish a machine learning-assisted approach for the design of the next-generation of chemical reactors, combining the application of high-dimensional parameterisations, computational fluid dynamics, and multi-fidelity Bayesian optimisation. We associate the development of mixing-enhancing vortical flow structures in novel coiled reactors with performance, and use our approach to identify key characteristics of optimal designs. By appealing to the principles of flow dynamics, we rationalise the selection of novel design features that lead to experimental plug flow performance improvements of 60% over conventional designs. Our results demonstrate that coupling advanced manufacturing techniques with `augmented-intelligence' approaches can lead to superior design performance and, consequently, emissions-reduction and sustainability.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2024; v1 submitted 17 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Multi-Fidelity Data-Driven Design and Analysis of Reactor and Tube Simulations
Authors:
Tom Savage,
Nausheen Basha,
Jonathan McDonough,
Omar K Matar,
Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
The development of new manufacturing techniques such as 3D printing have enabled the creation of previously infeasible chemical reactor designs. Systematically optimizing the highly parameterized geometries involved in these new classes of reactor is vital to ensure enhanced mixing characteristics and feasible manufacturability. Here we present a framework to rapidly solve this nonlinear, computat…
▽ More
The development of new manufacturing techniques such as 3D printing have enabled the creation of previously infeasible chemical reactor designs. Systematically optimizing the highly parameterized geometries involved in these new classes of reactor is vital to ensure enhanced mixing characteristics and feasible manufacturability. Here we present a framework to rapidly solve this nonlinear, computationally expensive, and derivative-free problem, enabling the fast prototype of novel reactor parameterizations. We take advantage of Gaussian processes to adaptively learn a multi-fidelity model of reactor simulations across a number of different continuous mesh fidelities. The search space of reactor geometries is explored through an amalgam of different, potentially lower, fidelity simulations which are chosen for evaluation based on weighted acquisition function, trading off information gain with cost of simulation. Within our framework we derive a novel criteria for monitoring the progress and dictating the termination of multi-fidelity Bayesian optimization, ensuring a high fidelity solution is returned before experimental budget is exhausted. The class of reactor we investigate are helical-tube reactors under pulsed-flow conditions, which have demonstrated outstanding mixing characteristics, have the potential to be highly parameterized, and are easily manufactured using 3D printing. To validate our results, we 3D print and experimentally validate the optimal reactor geometry, confirming its mixing performance. In doing so we demonstrate our design framework to be extensible to a broad variety of expensive simulation-based optimization problems, supporting the design of the next generation of highly parameterized chemical reactors.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2023; v1 submitted 1 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Distributional constrained reinforcement learning for supply chain optimization
Authors:
Jaime Sabal Bermúdez,
Antonio del Rio Chanona,
Calvin Tsay
Abstract:
This work studies reinforcement learning (RL) in the context of multi-period supply chains subject to constraints, e.g., on production and inventory. We introduce Distributional Constrained Policy Optimization (DCPO), a novel approach for reliable constraint satisfaction in RL. Our approach is based on Constrained Policy Optimization (CPO), which is subject to approximation errors that in practice…
▽ More
This work studies reinforcement learning (RL) in the context of multi-period supply chains subject to constraints, e.g., on production and inventory. We introduce Distributional Constrained Policy Optimization (DCPO), a novel approach for reliable constraint satisfaction in RL. Our approach is based on Constrained Policy Optimization (CPO), which is subject to approximation errors that in practice lead it to converge to infeasible policies. We address this issue by incorporating aspects of distributional RL into DCPO. Specifically, we represent the return and cost value functions using neural networks that output discrete distributions, and we reshape costs based on the associated confidence. Using a supply chain case study, we show that DCPO improves the rate at which the RL policy converges and ensures reliable constraint satisfaction by the end of training. The proposed method also improves predictability, greatly reducing the variance of returns between runs, respectively; this result is significant in the context of policy gradient methods, which intrinsically introduce significant variance during training.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
The Automated Discovery of Kinetic Rate Models -- Methodological Frameworks
Authors:
Miguel Ángel de Carvalho Servia,
Ilya Orson Sandoval,
Klaus Hellgardt,
King Kuok,
Hii,
Dongda Zhang,
Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
The industrialization of catalytic processes requires reliable kinetic models for their design, optimization and control. Mechanistic models require significant domain knowledge, while data-driven and hybrid models lack interpretability. Automated knowledge discovery methods, such as ALAMO (Automated Learning of Algebraic Models for Optimization), SINDy (Sparse Identification of Nonlinear Dynamics…
▽ More
The industrialization of catalytic processes requires reliable kinetic models for their design, optimization and control. Mechanistic models require significant domain knowledge, while data-driven and hybrid models lack interpretability. Automated knowledge discovery methods, such as ALAMO (Automated Learning of Algebraic Models for Optimization), SINDy (Sparse Identification of Nonlinear Dynamics), and genetic programming, have gained popularity but suffer from limitations such as needing model structure assumptions, exhibiting poor scalability, and displaying sensitivity to noise. To overcome these challenges, we propose two methodological frameworks, ADoK-S and ADoK-W (Automated Discovery of Kinetic rate models using a Strong/Weak formulation of symbolic regression), for the automated generation of catalytic kinetic models using a robust criterion for model selection. We leverage genetic programming for model generation and a sequential optimization routine for model refinement. The frameworks are tested against three case studies of increasing complexity, demonstrating their ability to retrieve the underlying kinetic rate model with limited noisy data from the catalytic systems, showcasing their potential for chemical reaction engineering applications.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2023; v1 submitted 26 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Design and Planning of Flexible Mobile Micro-Grids Using Deep Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Cesare Caputo,
Michel-Alexandre Cardin,
Pudong Ge,
Fei Teng,
Anna Korre,
Ehecatl Antonio del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
Ongoing risks from climate change have impacted the livelihood of global nomadic communities, and are likely to lead to increased migratory movements in coming years. As a result, mobility considerations are becoming increasingly important in energy systems planning, particularly to achieve energy access in develo** countries. Advanced Plug and Play control strategies have been recently develope…
▽ More
Ongoing risks from climate change have impacted the livelihood of global nomadic communities, and are likely to lead to increased migratory movements in coming years. As a result, mobility considerations are becoming increasingly important in energy systems planning, particularly to achieve energy access in develo** countries. Advanced Plug and Play control strategies have been recently developed with such a decentralized framework in mind, more easily allowing for the interconnection of nomadic communities, both to each other and to the main grid. In light of the above, the design and planning strategy of a mobile multi-energy supply system for a nomadic community is investigated in this work. Motivated by the scale and dimensionality of the associated uncertainties, impacting all major design and decision variables over the 30-year planning horizon, Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) is implemented for the design and planning problem tackled. DRL based solutions are benchmarked against several rigid baseline design options to compare expected performance under uncertainty. The results on a case study for ger communities in Mongolia suggest that mobile nomadic energy systems can be both technically and economically feasible, particularly when considering flexibility, although the degree of spatial dispersion among households is an important limiting factor. Key economic, sustainability and resilience indicators such as Cost, Equivalent Emissions and Total Unmet Load are measured, suggesting potential improvements compared to available baselines of up to 25%, 67% and 76%, respectively. Finally, the decomposition of values of flexibility and plug and play operation is presented using a variation of real options theory, with important implications for both nomadic communities and policymakers focused on enabling their energy access.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Distributional Reinforcement Learning for Scheduling of Chemical Production Processes
Authors:
Max Mowbray,
Dongda Zhang,
Ehecatl Antonio Del Rio Chanona
Abstract:
Reinforcement Learning (RL) has recently received significant attention from the process systems engineering and control communities. Recent works have investigated the application of RL to identify optimal scheduling decision in the presence of uncertainty. In this work, we present a RL methodology tailored to efficiently address production scheduling problems in the presence of uncertainty. We c…
▽ More
Reinforcement Learning (RL) has recently received significant attention from the process systems engineering and control communities. Recent works have investigated the application of RL to identify optimal scheduling decision in the presence of uncertainty. In this work, we present a RL methodology tailored to efficiently address production scheduling problems in the presence of uncertainty. We consider commonly imposed restrictions on these problems such as precedence and disjunctive constraints which are not naturally considered by RL in other contexts. Additionally, this work naturally enables the optimization of risk-sensitive formulations such as the conditional value-at-risk (CVaR), which are essential in realistic scheduling processes. The proposed strategy is investigated thoroughly in a parallel batch production environment, and benchmarked against mixed integer linear programming (MILP) strategies. We show that the policy identified by our approach is able to account for plant uncertainties in online decision-making, with expected performance comparable to existing MILP methods. Additionally, the framework gains the benefits of optimizing for risk-sensitive measures, and identifies online decisions orders of magnitude faster than the most efficient optimization approaches. This promises to mitigate practical issues and ease in handling realizations of process uncertainty in the paradigm of online production scheduling.
△ Less
Submitted 9 March, 2022; v1 submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Safe Chance Constrained Reinforcement Learning for Batch Process Control
Authors:
Max Mowbray,
Panagiotis Petsagkourakis,
Ehecatl Antonio del Río Chanona,
Dongda Zhang
Abstract:
Reinforcement Learning (RL) controllers have generated excitement within the control community. The primary advantage of RL controllers relative to existing methods is their ability to optimize uncertain systems independently of explicit assumption of process uncertainty. Recent focus on engineering applications has been directed towards the development of safe RL controllers. Previous works have…
▽ More
Reinforcement Learning (RL) controllers have generated excitement within the control community. The primary advantage of RL controllers relative to existing methods is their ability to optimize uncertain systems independently of explicit assumption of process uncertainty. Recent focus on engineering applications has been directed towards the development of safe RL controllers. Previous works have proposed approaches to account for constraint satisfaction through constraint tightening from the domain of stochastic model predictive control. Here, we extend these approaches to account for plant-model mismatch. Specifically, we propose a data-driven approach that utilizes Gaussian processes for the offline simulation model and use the associated posterior uncertainty prediction to account for joint chance constraints and plant-model mismatch. The method is benchmarked against nonlinear model predictive control via case studies. The results demonstrate the ability of the methodology to account for process uncertainty, enabling satisfaction of joint chance constraints even in the presence of plant-model mismatch.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2021; v1 submitted 23 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Constrained Reinforcement Learning for Dynamic Optimization under Uncertainty
Authors:
Panagiotis Petsagkourakis,
Ilya Orson Sandoval,
Eric Bradford,
Dongda Zhang,
Ehecatl Antonio del Río Chanona
Abstract:
Dynamic real-time optimization (DRTO) is a challenging task due to the fact that optimal operating conditions must be computed in real time. The main bottleneck in the industrial application of DRTO is the presence of uncertainty. Many stochastic systems present the following obstacles: 1) plant-model mismatch, 2) process disturbances, 3) risks in violation of process constraints. To accommodate t…
▽ More
Dynamic real-time optimization (DRTO) is a challenging task due to the fact that optimal operating conditions must be computed in real time. The main bottleneck in the industrial application of DRTO is the presence of uncertainty. Many stochastic systems present the following obstacles: 1) plant-model mismatch, 2) process disturbances, 3) risks in violation of process constraints. To accommodate these difficulties, we present a constrained reinforcement learning (RL) based approach. RL naturally handles the process uncertainty by computing an optimal feedback policy. However, no state constraints can be introduced intuitively. To address this problem, we present a chance-constrained RL methodology. We use chance constraints to guarantee the probabilistic satisfaction of process constraints, which is accomplished by introducing backoffs, such that the optimal policy and backoffs are computed simultaneously. Backoffs are adjusted using the empirical cumulative distribution function to guarantee the satisfaction of a joint chance constraint. The advantage and performance of this strategy are illustrated through a stochastic dynamic bioprocess optimization problem, to produce sustainable high-value bioproducts.
△ Less
Submitted 4 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
