-
The Sherali-Adams and Weisfeiler-Leman hierarchies in (Promise Valued) Constraint Satisfaction Problems
Authors:
Libor Barto,
Silvia Butti,
Víctor Dalmau
Abstract:
In this paper we study the interactions between so-called fractional relaxations of the integer programs (IPs) which encode homomorphism and isomorphism of relational structures. We give a combinatorial characterization of a certain natural linear programming (LP) relaxation of homomorphism in terms of fractional isomorphism. As a result, we show that the families of constraint satisfaction proble…
▽ More
In this paper we study the interactions between so-called fractional relaxations of the integer programs (IPs) which encode homomorphism and isomorphism of relational structures. We give a combinatorial characterization of a certain natural linear programming (LP) relaxation of homomorphism in terms of fractional isomorphism. As a result, we show that the families of constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs) that are solvable by such linear program are precisely those that are closed under an equivalence relation which we call Weisfeiler-Leman invariance. We also generalize this result to the much broader framework of Promise Valued Constraint Satisfaction Problems, which brings together two well-studied extensions of the CSP framework. Finally, we consider the hierarchies of increasingly tighter relaxations of the homomorphism and isomorphism IPs obtained by applying the Sherali-Adams and Weisfeiler-Leman methods respectively. We extend our combinatorial characterization of the basic LP to higher levels of the Sherali-Adams hierarchy, and we generalize a well-known logical characterization of the Weisfeiler-Leman test from graphs to relational structures.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Algebraic Approach to Approximation
Authors:
Libor Barto,
Silvia Butti,
Alexandr Kazda,
Caterina Viola,
Stanislav Živný
Abstract:
Following the success of the so-called algebraic approach to the study of decision constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), exact optimization of valued CSPs, and most recently promise CSPs, we propose an algebraic framework for valued promise CSPs.
To every valued promise CSP we associate an algebraic object, its so-called valued minion. Our main result shows that the existence of a homomorphis…
▽ More
Following the success of the so-called algebraic approach to the study of decision constraint satisfaction problems (CSPs), exact optimization of valued CSPs, and most recently promise CSPs, we propose an algebraic framework for valued promise CSPs.
To every valued promise CSP we associate an algebraic object, its so-called valued minion. Our main result shows that the existence of a homomorphism between the associated valued minions implies a polynomial-time reduction between the original CSPs. We also show that this general reduction theorem includes important inapproximability results, for instance, the inapproximability of almost solvable systems of linear equations beyond the random assignment threshold.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Weisfeiler-Leman Invariant Promise Valued CSPs
Authors:
Libor Barto,
Silvia Butti
Abstract:
In a recent line of work, Butti and Dalmau have shown that a fixed-template Constraint Satisfaction Problem is solvable by a certain natural linear programming relaxation (equivalent to the basic linear programming relaxation) if and only if it is solvable on a certain distributed network, and this happens if and only if its set of Yes instances is closed under Weisfeiler-Leman equivalence. We gen…
▽ More
In a recent line of work, Butti and Dalmau have shown that a fixed-template Constraint Satisfaction Problem is solvable by a certain natural linear programming relaxation (equivalent to the basic linear programming relaxation) if and only if it is solvable on a certain distributed network, and this happens if and only if its set of Yes instances is closed under Weisfeiler-Leman equivalence. We generalize this result to the much broader framework of fixed-template Promise Valued Constraint Satisfaction Problems. Moreover, we show that two commonly used linear programming relaxations are no longer equivalent in this broader framework.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Fixed-Template Promise Model Checking Problems
Authors:
Kristina Asimi,
Libor Barto,
Silvia Butti
Abstract:
The fixed-template constraint satisfaction problem (CSP) can be seen as the problem of deciding whether a given primitive positive first-order sentence is true in a fixed structure (also called model). We study a class of problems that generalizes the CSP simultaneously in two directions: we fix a set $\mathcal{L}$ of quantifiers and Boolean connectives, and we specify two versions of each constra…
▽ More
The fixed-template constraint satisfaction problem (CSP) can be seen as the problem of deciding whether a given primitive positive first-order sentence is true in a fixed structure (also called model). We study a class of problems that generalizes the CSP simultaneously in two directions: we fix a set $\mathcal{L}$ of quantifiers and Boolean connectives, and we specify two versions of each constraint, one strong and one weak. Given a sentence which only uses symbols from $\mathcal{L}$, the task is to distinguish whether the sentence is true in the strong sense, or it is false even in the weak sense. We classify the computational complexity of these problems for the existential positive equality-free fragment of first-order logic, i.e., $\mathcal{L} = \{\exists,\land,\lor\}$, and we prove some upper and lower bounds for the positive equality-free fragment, $\mathcal{L} = \{\exists,\forall,\land,\lor\}$. The partial results are sufficient, e.g., for all extensions of the latter fragment.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Fractional homomorphism, Weisfeiler-Leman invariance, and the Sherali-Adams hierarchy for the Constraint Satisfaction Problem
Authors:
Silvia Butti,
Victor Dalmau
Abstract:
Given a pair of graphs $\textbf{A}$ and $\textbf{B}$, the problems of deciding whether there exists either a homomorphism or an isomorphism from $\textbf{A}$ to $\textbf{B}$ have received a lot of attention. While graph homomorphism is known to be NP-complete, the complexity of the graph isomorphism problem is not fully understood. A well-known combinatorial heuristic for graph isomorphism is the…
▽ More
Given a pair of graphs $\textbf{A}$ and $\textbf{B}$, the problems of deciding whether there exists either a homomorphism or an isomorphism from $\textbf{A}$ to $\textbf{B}$ have received a lot of attention. While graph homomorphism is known to be NP-complete, the complexity of the graph isomorphism problem is not fully understood. A well-known combinatorial heuristic for graph isomorphism is the Weisfeiler-Leman test together with its higher order variants. On the other hand, both problems can be reformulated as integer programs and various LP methods can be applied to obtain high-quality relaxations that can still be solved efficiently. We study so-called fractional relaxations of these programs in the more general context where $\textbf{A}$ and $\textbf{B}$ are not graphs but arbitrary relational structures. We give a combinatorial characterization of the Sherali-Adams hierarchy applied to the homomorphism problem in terms of fractional isomorphism. Collaterally, we also extend a number of known results from graph theory to give a characterization of the notion of fractional isomorphism for relational structures in terms of the Weisfeiler-Leman test, equitable partitions, and counting homomorphisms from trees. As a result, we obtain a description of the families of CSPs that are closed under Weisfeiler-Leman invariance in terms of their polymorphisms as well as decidability by the first level of the Sherali-Adams hierarchy.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
The Complexity of the Distributed Constraint Satisfaction Problem
Authors:
Silvia Butti,
Victor Dalmau
Abstract:
We study the complexity of the Distributed Constraint Satisfaction Problem (DCSP) on a synchronous, anonymous network from a theoretical standpoint. In this setting, variables and constraints are controlled by agents which communicate with each other by sending messages through fixed communication channels. Our results endorse the well-known fact from classical CSPs that the complexity of fixed-te…
▽ More
We study the complexity of the Distributed Constraint Satisfaction Problem (DCSP) on a synchronous, anonymous network from a theoretical standpoint. In this setting, variables and constraints are controlled by agents which communicate with each other by sending messages through fixed communication channels. Our results endorse the well-known fact from classical CSPs that the complexity of fixed-template computational problems depends on the template's invariance under certain operations. Specifically, we show that DCSP($Γ$) is polynomial-time tractable if and only if $Γ$ is invariant under symmetric polymorphisms of all arities. Otherwise, there are no algorithms that solve DCSP($Γ$) in finite time. We also show that the same condition holds for the search variant of DCSP. Collaterally, our results unveil a feature of the processes' neighbourhood in a distributed network, its iterated degree, which plays a major role in the analysis. We explore this notion establishing a tight connection with the basic linear programming relaxation of a CSP.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021; v1 submitted 27 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Sparsification of Binary CSPs
Authors:
Silvia Butti,
Stanislav Zivny
Abstract:
A cut $\varepsilon$-sparsifier of a weighted graph $G$ is a re-weighted subgraph of $G$ of (quasi)linear size that preserves the size of all cuts up to a multiplicative factor of $\varepsilon$. Since their introduction by Benczúr and Karger [STOC'96], cut sparsifiers have proved extremely influential and found various applications. Going beyond cut sparsifiers, Filtser and Krauthgamer [SIDMA'17] g…
▽ More
A cut $\varepsilon$-sparsifier of a weighted graph $G$ is a re-weighted subgraph of $G$ of (quasi)linear size that preserves the size of all cuts up to a multiplicative factor of $\varepsilon$. Since their introduction by Benczúr and Karger [STOC'96], cut sparsifiers have proved extremely influential and found various applications. Going beyond cut sparsifiers, Filtser and Krauthgamer [SIDMA'17] gave a precise classification of which binary Boolean CSPs are sparsifiable. In this paper, we extend their result to binary CSPs on arbitrary finite domains.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2019; v1 submitted 3 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
