-
Towards Robust Benchmarking of Quantum Optimization Algorithms
Authors:
David Bucher,
Nico Kraus,
Jonas Blenninger,
Michael Lachner,
Jonas Stein,
Claudia Linnhoff-Popien
Abstract:
Benchmarking the performance of quantum optimization algorithms is crucial for identifying utility for industry-relevant use cases. Benchmarking processes vary between optimization applications and depend on user-specified goals. The heuristic nature of quantum algorithms poses challenges, especially when comparing to classical counterparts. A key problem in existing benchmarking frameworks is the…
▽ More
Benchmarking the performance of quantum optimization algorithms is crucial for identifying utility for industry-relevant use cases. Benchmarking processes vary between optimization applications and depend on user-specified goals. The heuristic nature of quantum algorithms poses challenges, especially when comparing to classical counterparts. A key problem in existing benchmarking frameworks is the lack of equal effort in optimizing for the best quantum and, respectively, classical approaches. This paper presents a comprehensive set of guidelines comprising universal steps towards fair benchmarks. We discuss (1) application-specific algorithm choice, ensuring every solver is provided with the most fitting mathematical formulation of a problem; (2) the selection of benchmark data, including hard instances and real-world samples; (3) the choice of a suitable holistic figure of merit, like time-to-solution or solution quality within time constraints; and (4) equitable hyperparameter training to eliminate bias towards a particular method. The proposed guidelines are tested across three benchmarking scenarios, utilizing the Max-Cut (MC) and Travelling Salesperson Problem (TSP). The benchmarks employ classical mathematical algorithms, such as Branch-and-Cut (BNC) solvers, classical heuristics, Quantum Annealing (QA), and the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA).
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Solving the Turbine Balancing Problem using Quantum Annealing
Authors:
Arnold Unterauer,
David Bucher,
Matthias Knoll,
Constantin Economides,
Michael Lachner,
Thomas Germain,
Moritz Kessel,
Smajo Hajdinovic,
Jonas Stein
Abstract:
Quantum computing has the potential for disruptive change in many sectors of industry, especially in materials science and optimization. In this paper, we describe how the Turbine Balancing Problem can be solved with quantum computing, which is the NP-hard optimization problem of analytically balancing rotor blades in a single plane as found in turbine assembly. Small yet relevant instances occur…
▽ More
Quantum computing has the potential for disruptive change in many sectors of industry, especially in materials science and optimization. In this paper, we describe how the Turbine Balancing Problem can be solved with quantum computing, which is the NP-hard optimization problem of analytically balancing rotor blades in a single plane as found in turbine assembly. Small yet relevant instances occur in industry, which makes the problem interesting for early quantum computing benchmarks. We model it as a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization problem and compare the performance of a classical rule-based heuristic and D-Wave Systems' Quantum Annealer Advantage_system4.1. In this case study, we use real-world as well as synthetic datasets and observe that the quantum hardware significantly improves an actively used heuristic's solution for small-scale problem instances with bare disk imbalance in terms of solution quality. Motivated by this performance gain, we subsequently design a quantum-inspired classical heuristic based on simulated annealing that achieves extremely good results on all given problem instances, essentially solving the optimization problem sufficiently well for all considered datasets, according to industrial requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Introducing Reduced-Width QNNs, an AI-inspired Ansatz Design Pattern
Authors:
Jonas Stein,
Tobias Rohe,
Francesco Nappi,
Julian Hager,
David Bucher,
Maximilian Zorn,
Michael Kölle,
Claudia Linnhoff-Popien
Abstract:
Variational Quantum Algorithms are one of the most promising candidates to yield the first industrially relevant quantum advantage. Being capable of arbitrary function approximation, they are often referred to as Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) when being used in analog settings as classical Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs). Similar to the early stages of classical machine learning, known schemes…
▽ More
Variational Quantum Algorithms are one of the most promising candidates to yield the first industrially relevant quantum advantage. Being capable of arbitrary function approximation, they are often referred to as Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) when being used in analog settings as classical Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs). Similar to the early stages of classical machine learning, known schemes for efficient architectures of these networks are scarce. Exploring beyond existing design patterns, we propose a reduced-width circuit ansatz design, which is motivated by recent results gained in the analysis of dropout regularization in QNNs. More precisely, this exploits the insight, that the gates of overparameterized QNNs can be pruned substantially until their expressibility decreases. The results of our case study show, that the proposed design pattern can significantly reduce training time while maintaining the same result quality as the standard "full-width" design in the presence of noise.
△ Less
Submitted 8 January, 2024; v1 submitted 8 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Approximative lookup-tables and arbitrary function rotations for facilitating NISQ-implementations of the HHL and beyond
Authors:
Petros Stougiannidis,
Jonas Stein,
David Bucher,
Sebastian Zielinski,
Claudia Linnhoff-Popien,
Sebastian Feld
Abstract:
Many promising applications of quantum computing with a provable speedup center around the HHL algorithm. Due to restrictions on the hardware and its significant demand on qubits and gates in known implementations, its execution is prohibitive on near-term quantum computers. Aiming to facilitate such NISQ-implementations, we propose a novel circuit approximation technique that enhances the arithme…
▽ More
Many promising applications of quantum computing with a provable speedup center around the HHL algorithm. Due to restrictions on the hardware and its significant demand on qubits and gates in known implementations, its execution is prohibitive on near-term quantum computers. Aiming to facilitate such NISQ-implementations, we propose a novel circuit approximation technique that enhances the arithmetic subroutines in the HHL, which resemble a particularly resource-demanding component in small-scale settings. For this, we provide a description of the algorithmic implementation of space-efficient rotations of polynomial functions that do not demand explicit arithmetic calculations inside the quantum circuit. We show how these types of circuits can be reduced in depth by providing a simple and powerful approximation technique. Moreover, we provide an algorithm that converts lookup-tables for arbitrary function rotations into a structure that allows an application of the approximation technique. This allows implementing approximate rotation circuits for many polynomial and non-polynomial functions. Experimental results obtained for realistic early-application dimensions show significant improvements compared to the state-of-the-art, yielding small circuits while achieving good approximations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Combining the QAOA and HHL Algorithm to achieve a Substantial Quantum Speedup for the Unit Commitment Problem
Authors:
Jonas Stein,
Jezer Jojo,
Afrah Farea,
David Bucher,
Philipp Altmann,
M. Serdar Çelebi,
Claudia Linnhoff-Popien
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a quantum algorithm to solve the unit commitment (UC) problem at least cubically faster than existing classical approaches. This is accomplished by calculating the energy transmission costs using the HHL algorithm inside a QAOA routine. We verify our findings experimentally using quantum circuit simulators in a small case study. Further, we postulate the applicability of…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a quantum algorithm to solve the unit commitment (UC) problem at least cubically faster than existing classical approaches. This is accomplished by calculating the energy transmission costs using the HHL algorithm inside a QAOA routine. We verify our findings experimentally using quantum circuit simulators in a small case study. Further, we postulate the applicability of the concepts developed for this algorithm to be used for a large class of optimization problems that demand solving a linear system of equations in order to calculate the cost function for a given solution.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2023; v1 submitted 15 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
NISQ-ready community detection based on separation-node identification
Authors:
Jonas Stein,
Dominik Ott,
Jonas Nüßlein,
David Bucher,
Mirco Schoenfeld,
Sebastian Feld
Abstract:
The analysis of network structure is essential to many scientific areas, ranging from biology to sociology. As the computational task of clustering these networks into partitions, i.e., solving the community detection problem, is generally NP-hard, heuristic solutions are indispensable. The exploration of expedient heuristics has led to the development of particularly promising approaches in the e…
▽ More
The analysis of network structure is essential to many scientific areas, ranging from biology to sociology. As the computational task of clustering these networks into partitions, i.e., solving the community detection problem, is generally NP-hard, heuristic solutions are indispensable. The exploration of expedient heuristics has led to the development of particularly promising approaches in the emerging technology of quantum computing. Motivated by the substantial hardware demands for all established quantum community detection approaches, we introduce a novel QUBO based approach that only needs number-of-nodes many qubits and is represented by a QUBO-matrix as sparse as the input graph's adjacency matrix. The substantial improvement on the sparsity of the QUBO-matrix, which is typically very dense in related work, is achieved through the novel concept of separation-nodes. Instead of assigning every node to a community directly, this approach relies on the identification of a separation-node set, which -- upon its removal from the graph -- yields a set of connected components, representing the core components of the communities. Employing a greedy heuristic to assign the nodes from the separation-node sets to the identified community cores, subsequent experimental results yield a proof of concept. This work hence displays a promising approach to NISQ ready quantum community detection, catalyzing the application of quantum computers for the network structure analysis of large scale, real world problem instances.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2023; v1 submitted 30 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Traffic4cast-Traffic Map Movie Forecasting -- Team MIE-Lab
Authors:
Henry Martin,
Ye Hong,
Dominik Bucher,
Christian Rupprecht,
René Buffat
Abstract:
The goal of the IARAI competition traffic4cast was to predict the city-wide traffic status within a 15-minute time window, based on information from the previous hour. The traffic status was given as multi-channel images (one pixel roughly corresponds to 100x100 meters), where one channel indicated the traffic volume, another one the average speed of vehicles, and a third one their rough heading.…
▽ More
The goal of the IARAI competition traffic4cast was to predict the city-wide traffic status within a 15-minute time window, based on information from the previous hour. The traffic status was given as multi-channel images (one pixel roughly corresponds to 100x100 meters), where one channel indicated the traffic volume, another one the average speed of vehicles, and a third one their rough heading. As part of our work on the competition, we evaluated many different network architectures, analyzed the statistical properties of the given data in detail, and thought about how to transform the problem to be able to take additional spatio-temporal context-information into account, such as the street network, the positions of traffic lights, or the weather. This document summarizes our efforts that led to our best submission, and gives some insights about which other approaches we evaluated, and why they did not work as well as imagined.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2019; v1 submitted 27 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
