Visual Elements and Cognitive Biases Influence Interpretations of Trends in Scatter Plots
Authors:
Alexandre Filipowicz,
Scott Carter,
Nayeli Bravo,
Rumen Iliev,
Shabnam Hakimi,
David Ayman Shamma,
Kent Lyons,
Candice Hogan,
Charlene Wu
Abstract:
Visualizations are common methods to convey information but also increasingly used to spread misinformation. It is therefore important to understand the factors people use to interpret visualizations. In this paper, we focus on factors that influence interpretations of scatter plots, investigating the extent to which common visual aspects of scatter plots (outliers and trend lines) and cognitive b…
▽ More
Visualizations are common methods to convey information but also increasingly used to spread misinformation. It is therefore important to understand the factors people use to interpret visualizations. In this paper, we focus on factors that influence interpretations of scatter plots, investigating the extent to which common visual aspects of scatter plots (outliers and trend lines) and cognitive biases (people's beliefs) influence perception of correlation trends. We highlight three main findings: outliers skew trend perception but exert less influence than other points; trend lines make trends seem stronger but also mitigate the influence of some outliers; and people's beliefs have a small influence on perceptions of weak, but not strong correlations. From these results we derive guidelines for adjusting visual elements to mitigate the influence of factors that distort interpretations of scatter plots. We explore how these guidelines may generalize to other visualization types and make recommendations for future studies.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
Understanding and Shifting Preferences for Battery Electric Vehicles
Authors:
Nikos Arechiga,
Francine Chen,
Rumen Iliev,
Emily Sumner,
Scott Carter,
Alex Filipowicz,
Nayeli Bravo,
Monica Van,
Kate Glazko,
Kalani Murakami,
Laurent Denoue,
Candice Hogan,
Katharine Sieck,
Charlene Wu,
Kent Lyons
Abstract:
Identifying personalized interventions for an individual is an important task. Recent work has shown that interventions that do not consider the demographic background of individual consumers can, in fact, produce the reverse effect, strengthening opposition to electric vehicles. In this work, we focus on methods for personalizing interventions based on an individual's demographics to shift the pr…
▽ More
Identifying personalized interventions for an individual is an important task. Recent work has shown that interventions that do not consider the demographic background of individual consumers can, in fact, produce the reverse effect, strengthening opposition to electric vehicles. In this work, we focus on methods for personalizing interventions based on an individual's demographics to shift the preferences of consumers to be more positive towards Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs). One of the constraints in building models to suggest interventions for shifting preferences is that each intervention can influence the effectiveness of later interventions. This, in turn, requires many subjects to evaluate effectiveness of each possible intervention. To address this, we propose to identify personalized factors influencing BEV adoption, such as barriers and motivators. We present a method for predicting these factors and show that the performance is better than always predicting the most frequent factors. We then present a Reinforcement Learning (RL) model that learns the most effective interventions, and compare the number of subjects required for each approach.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
