-
Incompatibilities Between Current Practices in Statistical Data Analysis and Differential Privacy
Authors:
Joshua Snoke,
Claire McKay Bowen,
Aaron R. Williams,
Andrés F. Barrientos
Abstract:
The authors discuss their experience applying differential privacy with a complex data set with the goal of enabling standard approaches to statistical data analysis. They highlight lessons learned and roadblocks encountered, distilling them into incompatibilities between current practices in statistical data analysis and differential privacy that go beyond issues which can be solved with a noisy…
▽ More
The authors discuss their experience applying differential privacy with a complex data set with the goal of enabling standard approaches to statistical data analysis. They highlight lessons learned and roadblocks encountered, distilling them into incompatibilities between current practices in statistical data analysis and differential privacy that go beyond issues which can be solved with a noisy measurements file. The authors discuss how overcoming these incompatibilities require compromise and a change in either our approach to statistical data analysis or differential privacy that should be addressed head-on.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Comparative Study of Differentially Private Synthetic Data Algorithms from the NIST PSCR Differential Privacy Synthetic Data Challenge
Authors:
Claire McKay Bowen,
Joshua Snoke
Abstract:
Differentially private synthetic data generation offers a recent solution to release analytically useful data while preserving the privacy of individuals in the data. In order to utilize these algorithms for public policy decisions, policymakers need an accurate understanding of these algorithms' comparative performance. Correspondingly, data practitioners require standard metrics for evaluating t…
▽ More
Differentially private synthetic data generation offers a recent solution to release analytically useful data while preserving the privacy of individuals in the data. In order to utilize these algorithms for public policy decisions, policymakers need an accurate understanding of these algorithms' comparative performance. Correspondingly, data practitioners require standard metrics for evaluating the analytic qualities of the synthetic data. In this paper, we present an in-depth evaluation of several differentially private synthetic data algorithms using actual differentially private synthetic data sets created by contestants in the 2018-2019 National Institute of Standards and Technology Public Safety Communications Research (NIST PSCR) Division's ``Differential Privacy Synthetic Data Challenge.'' We offer analyses of these algorithms based on both the accuracy of the data they created and their usability by potential data providers. We frame the methods used in the NIST PSCR data challenge within the broader differentially private synthetic data literature. We implement additional utility metrics, including two of our own, on the differentially private synthetic data and compare mechanism utility on three categories. Our comparative assessment of the differentially private data synthesis methods and the quality metrics shows the relative usefulness, the general strengths and weaknesses, and offers preferred choices of algorithms and metrics. Finally we describe the implications of our evaluation for policymakers seeking to implement differentially private synthetic data algorithms on future data products.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2020; v1 submitted 28 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Interleaving Optimization with Sampling-Based Motion Planning (IOS-MP): Combining Local Optimization with Global Exploration
Authors:
Alan Kuntz,
Chris Bowen,
Ron Alterovitz
Abstract:
Computing globally optimal motion plans for a robot is challenging in part because it requires analyzing a robot's configuration space simultaneously from both a macroscopic viewpoint (i.e., considering paths in multiple homotopic classes) and a microscopic viewpoint (i.e., locally optimizing path quality). We introduce Interleaved Optimization with Sampling-based Motion Planning (IOS-MP), a new m…
▽ More
Computing globally optimal motion plans for a robot is challenging in part because it requires analyzing a robot's configuration space simultaneously from both a macroscopic viewpoint (i.e., considering paths in multiple homotopic classes) and a microscopic viewpoint (i.e., locally optimizing path quality). We introduce Interleaved Optimization with Sampling-based Motion Planning (IOS-MP), a new method that effectively combines global exploration and local optimization to quickly compute high quality motion plans. Our approach combines two paradigms: (1) asymptotically-optimal sampling-based motion planning, which is effective at global exploration but relatively slow at locally refining paths, and (2) optimization-based motion planning, which locally optimizes paths quickly but lacks a global view of the configuration space. IOS-MP iteratively alternates between global exploration and local optimization, sharing information between the two, to improve motion planning efficiency. We evaluate IOS-MP as it scales with respect to dimensionality and complexity, as well as demonstrate its effectiveness on a 7-DOF manipulator for tasks specified using goal configurations and workspace goal regions.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2016; v1 submitted 21 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
