-
Carbon-Aware Computing in a Network of Data Centers: A Hierarchical Game-Theoretic Approach
Authors:
Enno Breukelman,
Sophie Hall,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Florian Dörfler
Abstract:
Over the past decade, the continuous surge in cloud computing demand has intensified data center workloads, leading to significant carbon emissions and driving the need for improving their efficiency and sustainability. This paper focuses on the optimal allocation problem of batch compute loads with temporal and spatial flexibility across a global network of data centers. We propose a bilevel game…
▽ More
Over the past decade, the continuous surge in cloud computing demand has intensified data center workloads, leading to significant carbon emissions and driving the need for improving their efficiency and sustainability. This paper focuses on the optimal allocation problem of batch compute loads with temporal and spatial flexibility across a global network of data centers. We propose a bilevel game-theoretic solution approach that captures the inherent hierarchical relationship between supervisory control objectives, such as carbon reduction and peak shaving, and operational objectives, such as priority-aware scheduling. Numerical simulations with real carbon intensity data demonstrate that the proposed approach successfully reduces carbon emissions while simultaneously ensuring operational reliability and priority-aware scheduling.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Towards a Systems Theory of Algorithms
Authors:
Florian Dörfler,
Zhiyu He,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Saverio Bolognani,
John Lygeros,
Michael Muehlebach
Abstract:
Traditionally, numerical algorithms are seen as isolated pieces of code confined to an {\em in silico} existence. However, this perspective is not appropriate for many modern computational approaches in control, learning, or optimization, wherein {\em in vivo} algorithms interact with their environment. Examples of such {\em open algorithms} include various real-time optimization-based control str…
▽ More
Traditionally, numerical algorithms are seen as isolated pieces of code confined to an {\em in silico} existence. However, this perspective is not appropriate for many modern computational approaches in control, learning, or optimization, wherein {\em in vivo} algorithms interact with their environment. Examples of such {\em open algorithms} include various real-time optimization-based control strategies, reinforcement learning, decision-making architectures, online optimization, and many more. Further, even {\em closed} algorithms in learning or optimization are increasingly abstracted in block diagrams with interacting dynamic modules and pipelines. In this opinion paper, we state our vision on a to-be-cultivated {\em systems theory of algorithms} and argue in favor of viewing algorithms as open dynamical systems interacting with other algorithms, physical systems, humans, or databases. Remarkably, the manifold tools developed under the umbrella of systems theory are well suited for addressing a range of challenges in the algorithmic domain. We survey various instances where the principles of algorithmic systems theory are being developed and outline pertinent modeling, analysis, and design challenges.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2024; v1 submitted 25 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Strategic Interactions in Multi-modal Mobility Systems: A Game-Theoretic Perspective
Authors:
Gioele Zardini,
Nicolas Lanzetti,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Christian Hartnik,
Saverio Bolognani,
Florian Dörfler,
Emilio Frazzoli
Abstract:
The evolution of existing transportation systems,mainly driven by urbanization and increased availability of mobility options, such as private, profit-maximizing ride-hailing companies, calls for tools to reason about their design and regulation. To study this complex socio-technical problem, one needs to account for the strategic interactions of the heterogeneous stakeholders involved in the mobi…
▽ More
The evolution of existing transportation systems,mainly driven by urbanization and increased availability of mobility options, such as private, profit-maximizing ride-hailing companies, calls for tools to reason about their design and regulation. To study this complex socio-technical problem, one needs to account for the strategic interactions of the heterogeneous stakeholders involved in the mobility ecosystem and analyze how they influence the system. In this paper, we focus on the interactions between citizens who compete for the limited resources of a mobility system to complete their desired trip. Specifically, we present a game-theoretic framework for multi-modal mobility systems, where citizens, characterized by heterogeneous preferences, have access to various mobility options and seek individually-optimal decisions. We study the arising game and prove the existence of an equilibrium, which can be efficiently computed via a convex optimization problem. Through both an analytical and a numerical case study for the classic scenario of Sioux Falls, USA, we illustrate the capabilities of our model and perform sensitivity analyses. Importantly, we show how to embed our framework into a "larger" game among stakeholders of the mobility ecosystem (e.g., municipality, Mobility Service Providers, and citizens), effectively giving rise to tools to inform strategic interventions and policy-making in the mobility ecosystem.
△ Less
Submitted 9 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Designing Optimal Personalized Incentive for Traffic Routing using BIG Hype algorithm
Authors:
Panagiotis D. Grontas,
Carlo Cenedese,
Marta Fochesato,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
John Lygeros,
Florian Dörfler
Abstract:
We study the problem of optimally routing plug-in electric and conventional fuel vehicles on a city level. In our model, commuters selfishly aim to minimize a local cost that combines travel time, from a fixed origin to a desired destination, and the monetary cost of using city facilities, parking or service stations. The traffic authority can influence the commuters' preferred routing choice by m…
▽ More
We study the problem of optimally routing plug-in electric and conventional fuel vehicles on a city level. In our model, commuters selfishly aim to minimize a local cost that combines travel time, from a fixed origin to a desired destination, and the monetary cost of using city facilities, parking or service stations. The traffic authority can influence the commuters' preferred routing choice by means of personalized discounts on parking tickets and on the energy price at service stations. We formalize the problem of designing these monetary incentives optimally as a large-scale bilevel game, where constraints arise at both levels due to the finite capacities of city facilities and incentives budget. Then, we develop an efficient decentralized solution scheme with convergence guarantees based on BIG Hype, a recently-proposed hypergradient-based algorithm for hierarchical games. Finally, we validate our model via numerical simulations over the Anaheim's network, and show that the proposed approach produces sensible results in terms of traffic decongestion and it is able to solve in minutes problems with more than 48000 variables and 110000 constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Designing Fairness in Autonomous Peer-to-peer Energy Trading
Authors:
Varsha Behrunani,
Andrew Irvine,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Philipp Heer,
John Lygeros,
Florian Dörfler
Abstract:
Several autonomous energy management and peer-to-peer trading mechanisms for future energy markets have been recently proposed based on optimization and game theory. In this paper, we study the impact of trading prices on the outcome of these market designs for energy-hub networks. We prove that, for a generic choice of trading prices, autonomous peer-to-peer trading is always network-wide benefic…
▽ More
Several autonomous energy management and peer-to-peer trading mechanisms for future energy markets have been recently proposed based on optimization and game theory. In this paper, we study the impact of trading prices on the outcome of these market designs for energy-hub networks. We prove that, for a generic choice of trading prices, autonomous peer-to-peer trading is always network-wide beneficial but not necessarily individually beneficial for each hub. Therefore, we leverage hierarchical game theory to formalize the problem of designing locally-beneficial and network-wide fair peer-to-peer trading prices. Then, we propose a scalable and privacy-preserving price-mediation algorithm that provably converges to a profile of such prices. Numerical simulations on a 3-hub network show that the proposed algorithm can indeed incentivize active participation of energy hubs in autonomous peer-to-peer trading schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Stability and Robustness of Distributed Suboptimal Model Predictive Control
Authors:
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Dominic Liao-McPherson,
Mathias Hudoba de Badyn,
Nicolas Pelzmann,
John Lygeros,
Florian Dörfler
Abstract:
In distributed model predictive control (MPC), the control input at each sampling time is computed by solving a large-scale optimal control problem (OCP) over a finite horizon using distributed algorithms. Typically, such algorithms require several (virtually, infinite) communication rounds between the subsystems to converge, which is a major drawback both computationally and from an energetic per…
▽ More
In distributed model predictive control (MPC), the control input at each sampling time is computed by solving a large-scale optimal control problem (OCP) over a finite horizon using distributed algorithms. Typically, such algorithms require several (virtually, infinite) communication rounds between the subsystems to converge, which is a major drawback both computationally and from an energetic perspective (for wireless systems). Motivated by these challenges, we propose a suboptimal distributed MPC scheme in which the total communication burden is distributed also in time, by maintaining a running solution estimate for the large-scale OCP and updating it at each sampling time. We demonstrate that, under some regularity conditions, the resulting suboptimal MPC control law recovers the qualitative robust stability properties of optimal MPC, if the communication budget at each sampling time is large enough.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2023; v1 submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Data-Driven Behaviour Estimation in Parametric Games
Authors:
Anna M. Maddux,
Nicolò Pagan,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Florian Dörfler
Abstract:
A central question in multi-agent strategic games deals with learning the underlying utilities driving the agents' behaviour. Motivated by the increasing availability of large data-sets, we develop an unifying data-driven technique to estimate agents' utility functions from their observed behaviour, irrespective of whether the observations correspond to equilibrium configurations or to temporal se…
▽ More
A central question in multi-agent strategic games deals with learning the underlying utilities driving the agents' behaviour. Motivated by the increasing availability of large data-sets, we develop an unifying data-driven technique to estimate agents' utility functions from their observed behaviour, irrespective of whether the observations correspond to equilibrium configurations or to temporal sequences of action profiles. Under standard assumptions on the parametrization of the utilities, the proposed inference method is computationally efficient and finds all the parameters that rationalize the observed behaviour best. We numerically validate our theoretical findings on the market share estimation problem under advertising competition, using historical data from the Coca-Cola Company and Pepsi Inc. duopoly.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Operationally-Safe Peer-to-Peer Energy Trading in Distribution Grids: A Game-Theoretic Market-Clearing Mechanism
Authors:
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Wicak Ananduta,
Sergio Grammatico,
Carlos Ocampo-Martinez
Abstract:
In future distribution grids, prosumers (i.e., energy consumers with storage and/or production capabilities) will trade energy with each other and with the main grid. To ensure an efficient and safe operation of energy trading, in this paper, we formulate a peer-to-peer energy market of prosumers as a generalized aggregative game, in which a network operator is only responsible for the operational…
▽ More
In future distribution grids, prosumers (i.e., energy consumers with storage and/or production capabilities) will trade energy with each other and with the main grid. To ensure an efficient and safe operation of energy trading, in this paper, we formulate a peer-to-peer energy market of prosumers as a generalized aggregative game, in which a network operator is only responsible for the operational constraints of the system. We design a distributed market-clearing mechanism with convergence guarantee to an economically-efficient and operationally-safe configuration (i.e., a variational generalized Nash equilibrium). Numerical studies on the IEEE 37-bus testcase show the scalability of the proposed approach and suggest that active participation in the market is beneficial for both prosumers and the network operator.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2022; v1 submitted 28 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
An asynchronous distributed and scalable generalized Nash equilibrium seeking algorithm for strongly monotone games
Authors:
Carlo Cenedese,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico,
Ming Cao
Abstract:
In this paper, we present three distributed algorithms to solve a class of generalized Nash equilibrium (GNE) seeking problems in strongly monotone games. The first one (SD-GENO) is based on synchronous updates of the agents, while the second and the third (AD-GEED and AD-GENO) represent asynchronous solutions that are robust to communication delays. AD-GENO can be seen as a refinement of AD-GEED,…
▽ More
In this paper, we present three distributed algorithms to solve a class of generalized Nash equilibrium (GNE) seeking problems in strongly monotone games. The first one (SD-GENO) is based on synchronous updates of the agents, while the second and the third (AD-GEED and AD-GENO) represent asynchronous solutions that are robust to communication delays. AD-GENO can be seen as a refinement of AD-GEED, since it only requires node auxiliary variables, enhancing the scalability of the algorithm. Our main contribution is to prove converge to a variational GNE of the game via an operator-theoretic approach. Finally, we apply the algorithms to network Cournot games and show how different activation sequences and delays affect convergence. We also compare the proposed algorithms to the only other in the literature (ADAGNES), and observe that AD-GENO outperforms the alternative.
△ Less
Submitted 6 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Fast generalized Nash equilibrium seeking under partial-decision information
Authors:
Mattia Bianchi,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico
Abstract:
We address the generalized Nash equilibrium seeking problem in a partial-decision information scenario, where each agent can only exchange information with some neighbors, although its cost function possibly depends on the strategies of all agents. The few existing methods build on projected pseudo-gradient dynamics, and require either double-layer iterations or conservative conditions on the step…
▽ More
We address the generalized Nash equilibrium seeking problem in a partial-decision information scenario, where each agent can only exchange information with some neighbors, although its cost function possibly depends on the strategies of all agents. The few existing methods build on projected pseudo-gradient dynamics, and require either double-layer iterations or conservative conditions on the step sizes. To overcome both these flaws and improve efficiency, we design the first fully-distributed single-layer algorithms based on proximal best-response. Our schemes are fixed-step and allow for inexact updates, which is crucial for reducing the computational complexity. Under standard assumptions on the game primitives, we establish convergence to a variational equilibrium (with linear rate for games without coupling constraints) by recasting our algorithms as proximal-point methods, opportunely preconditioned to distribute the computation among the agents. Since our analysis hinges on a restricted monotonicity property, we also provide new general results that significantly extend the domain of applicability of proximal-point methods. Besides, the operator-theoretic approach favors the implementation of provably correct acceleration schemes that can further improve the convergence speed. Finally, the potential of our algorithms is demonstrated numerically, revealing much faster convergence with respect to projected pseudo-gradient methods and validating our theoretical findings.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2021; v1 submitted 20 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Time-varying constrained proximal type dynamics in multi-agent network games
Authors:
Carlo Cenedese,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico,
Ming Cao
Abstract:
In this paper, we study multi-agent network games subject to affine time-varying coupling constraints and a time-varying communication network. We focus on the class of games adopting proximal dynamics and study their convergence to a persistent equilibrium. The assumptions considered to solve the problem are discussed and motivated. We develop an iterative equilibrium seeking algorithm, using onl…
▽ More
In this paper, we study multi-agent network games subject to affine time-varying coupling constraints and a time-varying communication network. We focus on the class of games adopting proximal dynamics and study their convergence to a persistent equilibrium. The assumptions considered to solve the problem are discussed and motivated. We develop an iterative equilibrium seeking algorithm, using only local information, that converges to a special class of game equilibria. Its derivation is motivated by several examples, showing that the original game dynamics fail to converge. Finally, we apply the designed algorithm to solve a constrained consensus problem, validating the theoretical results.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
A fully-distributed proximal-point algorithm for Nash equilibrium seeking with linear convergence rate
Authors:
Mattia Bianchi,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico
Abstract:
We address the Nash equilibrium problem in a partial-decision information scenario, where each agent can only observe the actions of some neighbors, while its cost possibly depends on the strategies of other agents. Our main contribution is the design of a fully-distributed, single-layer, fixed-step algorithm, based on a proximal best-response augmented with consensus terms. To derive our algorith…
▽ More
We address the Nash equilibrium problem in a partial-decision information scenario, where each agent can only observe the actions of some neighbors, while its cost possibly depends on the strategies of other agents. Our main contribution is the design of a fully-distributed, single-layer, fixed-step algorithm, based on a proximal best-response augmented with consensus terms. To derive our algorithm, we follow an operator-theoretic approach. First, we recast the Nash equilibrium problem as that of finding a zero of a monotone operator. Then, we demonstrate that the resulting inclusion can be solved in a fully-distributed way via a proximal-point method, thanks to the use of a novel preconditioning matrix. Under strong monotonicity and Lipschitz continuity of the game map**, We prove linear convergence of our algorithm to a Nash equilibrium. Furthermore, we show that our method outperforms the fastest known gradient-based schemes, both in terms of guaranteed convergence rate, via theoretical analysis, and in practice, via numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2020; v1 submitted 25 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Asynchronous and time-varying proximal type dynamics multi-agent network games
Authors:
Carlo Cenedese,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Yu Kawano,
Sergio Grammatico,
Ming Cao
Abstract:
In this paper, we study proximal type dynamics in the context of noncooperative multi-agent network games. These dynamics arise in different applications, since they describe distributed decision making in multi-agent networks, e.g., in opinion dynamics, distributed model fitting and network information fusion, where the goal of each agent is to seek an equilibrium using local information only. We…
▽ More
In this paper, we study proximal type dynamics in the context of noncooperative multi-agent network games. These dynamics arise in different applications, since they describe distributed decision making in multi-agent networks, e.g., in opinion dynamics, distributed model fitting and network information fusion, where the goal of each agent is to seek an equilibrium using local information only. We analyse several conjugations of this class of games, providing convergence results, or designing equilibrium seeking algorithms when the original dynamics fail to converge. For the games subject only to local constraints we look into both synchronous/asynchronous dynamics and time-varying communication networks. For games subject in addition to coupling constraints, we design an equilibrium seeking algorithm converging to a special class of game equilibria. Finally, we validate the theoretical results via numerical simulations on opinion dynamics and distributed model fitting.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
An asynchronous, forward-backward, distributed generalized Nash equilibrium seeking algorithm
Authors:
Carlo Cenedese,
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico,
Ming Cao
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose an asynchronous distributed algorithm for the computation of generalized Nash equilibria in noncooperative games, where the players interact via an undirected communication graph. Specifically, we extend the paper "Asynchronous distributed algorithm for seeking generalized Nash equilibria" by Yi and Pavel: we redesign the asynchronous update rule using auxiliary variables…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose an asynchronous distributed algorithm for the computation of generalized Nash equilibria in noncooperative games, where the players interact via an undirected communication graph. Specifically, we extend the paper "Asynchronous distributed algorithm for seeking generalized Nash equilibria" by Yi and Pavel: we redesign the asynchronous update rule using auxiliary variables over the nodes rather than over the edges. This key modification renders the algorithm scalable for highly interconnected games. The derived asynchronous algorithm is robust against delays in the communication and it eliminates the idle times between computations, hence modeling a more realistic interaction between players with different update frequencies. We address the problem from an operator-theoretic perspective and design the algorithm via a preconditioned forward-backward splitting. Finally, we numerically simulate the algorithm for the Cournot competition in networked markets.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
A Douglas-Rachford splitting for semi-decentralized equilibrium seeking in generalized aggregative games
Authors:
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico
Abstract:
We address the generalized aggregative equilibrium seeking problem for noncooperative agents playing average aggregative games with affine coupling constraints. First, we use operator theory to characterize the generalized aggregative equilibria of the game as the zeros of a monotone set-valued operator. Then, we massage the Douglas-Rachford splitting to solve the monotone inclusion problem and de…
▽ More
We address the generalized aggregative equilibrium seeking problem for noncooperative agents playing average aggregative games with affine coupling constraints. First, we use operator theory to characterize the generalized aggregative equilibria of the game as the zeros of a monotone set-valued operator. Then, we massage the Douglas-Rachford splitting to solve the monotone inclusion problem and derive a single layer, semi-decentralized algorithm whose global convergence is guaranteed under mild assumptions. The potential of the proposed Douglas-Rachford algorithm is shown on a simplified resource allocation game, where we observe faster convergence with respect to forward-backward algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2018; v1 submitted 28 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
On the convergence of discrete-time linear systems: A linear time-varying Mann iteration converges iff the operator is strictly pseudocontractive
Authors:
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Filippo Fabiani,
Franco Blanchini,
Sergio Grammatico
Abstract:
We adopt an operator-theoretic perspective to study convergence of linear fixed-point iterations and discrete- time linear systems. We mainly focus on the so-called Krasnoselskij-Mann iteration x(k+1) = ( 1 - α(k) ) x(k) + α(k) A x(k), which is relevant for distributed computation in optimization and game theory, when A is not available in a centralized way. We show that convergence to a vector in…
▽ More
We adopt an operator-theoretic perspective to study convergence of linear fixed-point iterations and discrete- time linear systems. We mainly focus on the so-called Krasnoselskij-Mann iteration x(k+1) = ( 1 - α(k) ) x(k) + α(k) A x(k), which is relevant for distributed computation in optimization and game theory, when A is not available in a centralized way. We show that convergence to a vector in the kernel of (I-A) is equivalent to strict pseudocontractiveness of the linear operator x -> Ax. We also characterize some relevant operator-theoretic properties of linear operators via eigenvalue location and linear matrix inequalities. We apply the convergence conditions to multi-agent linear systems with vanishing step sizes, in particular, to linear consensus dynamics and equilibrium seeking in monotone linear-quadratic games.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Projected-gradient algorithms for generalized equilibrium seeking in Aggregative Games are preconditioned Forward-Backward methods
Authors:
Giuseppe Belgioioso,
Sergio Grammatico
Abstract:
We show that projected-gradient methods for the distributed computation of generalized Nash equilibria in aggregative games are preconditioned forward-backward splitting methods applied to the KKT operator of the game. Specifically, we adopt the preconditioned forward-backward design, recently conceived by Yi and Pavel in the manuscript "A distributed primal-dual algorithm for computation of gener…
▽ More
We show that projected-gradient methods for the distributed computation of generalized Nash equilibria in aggregative games are preconditioned forward-backward splitting methods applied to the KKT operator of the game. Specifically, we adopt the preconditioned forward-backward design, recently conceived by Yi and Pavel in the manuscript "A distributed primal-dual algorithm for computation of generalized Nash equilibria via operator splitting methods" for generalized Nash equilibrium seeking in aggregative games. Consequently, we notice that two projected-gradient methods recently proposed in the literature are preconditioned forward-backward methods. More generally, we provide a unifying operator-theoretic ground to design projected-gradient methods for generalized equilibrium seeking in aggregative games.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.