-
Real-Time Performance of Industrial IoT Communication Technologies: A Review
Authors:
Ilja Behnke,
Henrik Austad
Abstract:
With the growing need for automation and the ongoing merge of OT and IT, industrial networks have to transport a high amount of heterogeneous data with mixed criticality such as control traffic, sensor data, and configuration messages. Current advances in IT technologies furthermore enable a new set of automation scenarios under the roof of Industry 4.0 and IIoT where industrial networks now have…
▽ More
With the growing need for automation and the ongoing merge of OT and IT, industrial networks have to transport a high amount of heterogeneous data with mixed criticality such as control traffic, sensor data, and configuration messages. Current advances in IT technologies furthermore enable a new set of automation scenarios under the roof of Industry 4.0 and IIoT where industrial networks now have to meet new requirements in flexibility and reliability. The necessary real-time guarantees will place significant demands on the networks. In this paper, we identify IIoT use cases and infer real-time requirements along several axes before bridging the gap between real-time network technologies and the identified scenarios. We review real-time networking technologies and present peer-reviewed works from the past 5 years for industrial environments. We investigate how these can be applied to controllers, systems, and embedded devices. Finally, we discuss open challenges for real-time communication technologies to enable the identified scenarios. The review shows academic interest in the field of real-time communication technologies but also highlights a lack of a fixed set of standards important for trust in safety and reliability, especially where wireless technologies are concerned.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Offloading Real-Time Tasks in IIoT Environments under Consideration of Networking Uncertainties
Authors:
Ilja Behnke,
Philipp Wiesner,
Paul Voelker,
Odej Kao
Abstract:
Offloading is a popular way to overcome the resource and power constraints of networked embedded devices, which are increasingly found in industrial environments. It involves moving resource-intensive computational tasks to a more powerful device on the network, often in close proximity to enable wireless communication. However, many Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) applications have real-time…
▽ More
Offloading is a popular way to overcome the resource and power constraints of networked embedded devices, which are increasingly found in industrial environments. It involves moving resource-intensive computational tasks to a more powerful device on the network, often in close proximity to enable wireless communication. However, many Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) applications have real-time constraints. Offloading such tasks over a wireless network with latency uncertainties poses new challenges.
In this paper, we aim to better understand these challenges by proposing a system architecture and scheduler for real-time task offloading in wireless IIoT environments. Based on a prototype, we then evaluate different system configurations and discuss their trade-offs and implications. Our design showed to prevent deadline misses under high load and network uncertainties and was able to outperform a reference scheduler in terms of successful task throughput. Under heavy task load, where the reference scheduler had a success rate of 5%, our design achieved a success rate of 60%.
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Vessim: A Testbed for Carbon-Aware Applications and Systems
Authors:
Philipp Wiesner,
Ilja Behnke,
Paul Kilian,
Marvin Steinke,
Odej Kao
Abstract:
To reduce the carbon footprint of computing and stabilize electricity grids, there is an increasing focus on approaches that align the power usage of IT infrastructure with the availability of clean energy. Unfortunately, research on energy-aware and carbon-aware applications, as well as the interfaces between computing and energy systems, remains complex due to the scarcity of available testing e…
▽ More
To reduce the carbon footprint of computing and stabilize electricity grids, there is an increasing focus on approaches that align the power usage of IT infrastructure with the availability of clean energy. Unfortunately, research on energy-aware and carbon-aware applications, as well as the interfaces between computing and energy systems, remains complex due to the scarcity of available testing environments. To this day, almost all new approaches are evaluated on custom simulation testbeds, which leads to repeated development efforts and limited comparability of results.
In this paper, we present Vessim, a co-simulation environment for testing applications and computing systems that interact with their energy systems. Our testbed connects domain-specific simulators for renewable power generation and energy storage, and enables users to implement interfaces to integrate real systems through software and hardware-in-the-loop simulation. Vessim offers an easy-to-use interface, is extendable to new simulators, and provides direct access to historical datasets. We aim to not only accelerate research in carbon-aware computing but also facilitate development and operation, as in continuous testing or digital twins. Vessim is publicly available: https://github.com/dos-group/vessim.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2024; v1 submitted 16 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Towards a Real-Time IoT: Approaches for Incoming Packet Processing in Cyber-Physical Systems
Authors:
Ilja Behnke,
Christoph Blumschein,
Robert Danicki,
Philipp Wiesner,
Lauritz Thamsen,
Odej Kao
Abstract:
Embedded real-time devices for monitoring, controlling, and collaboration purposes in cyber-physical systems are now commonly equipped with IP networking capabilities. However, the reception and processing of IP packets generates workloads in unpredictable frequencies as networks are outside of a developer's control and difficult to anticipate, especially when networks are connected to the interne…
▽ More
Embedded real-time devices for monitoring, controlling, and collaboration purposes in cyber-physical systems are now commonly equipped with IP networking capabilities. However, the reception and processing of IP packets generates workloads in unpredictable frequencies as networks are outside of a developer's control and difficult to anticipate, especially when networks are connected to the internet. As of now, embedded network controllers and IP stacks are not designed for real-time capabilities, even when used in real-time environments and operating systems.
Our work focuses on real-time aware packet reception from open network connections, without a real-time networking infrastructure. This article presents two experimentally evaluated modifications to the IP processing subsystem and embedded network interface controllers of constrained IoT devices. The first, our software approach, introduces early packet classification and priority-aware processing in the network driver. In our experiments this allowed the network subsystem to remain active at a seven-fold increase in network traffic load before disabling the receive interrupts as a last resort. The second, our hardware approach, makes changes to the network interface controller, applying interrupt moderation based on real-time priorities to minimize the number of network-generated interrupts. Furthermore, this article provides an outlook on how the software and hardware approaches can be combined in a co-designed packet receive architecture.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
IoTreeplay: Synchronous Distributed Traffic Replay in IoT Environments
Authors:
Markus Toll,
Ilja Behnke,
Odej Kao
Abstract:
Use-cases in the Internet of Things (IoT) typically involve a high number of interconnected, heterogeneous devices. Due to the criticality of many IoT scenarios, systems and applications need to be tested thoroughly before rollout. Existing staging environments and testing frameworks are able to emulate network properties but fail to deliver actual network-wide traffic control to test systems appl…
▽ More
Use-cases in the Internet of Things (IoT) typically involve a high number of interconnected, heterogeneous devices. Due to the criticality of many IoT scenarios, systems and applications need to be tested thoroughly before rollout. Existing staging environments and testing frameworks are able to emulate network properties but fail to deliver actual network-wide traffic control to test systems application independently. To extend existing frameworks, we present the distributed traffic replaying tool IoTreeplay.
The tool embeds TCPLivePlay into an environment that allows the synchronous replaying of network traffic with multiple endpoints and connections. Replaying takes place in a user-defined network or testbed containing IoT use-cases. Network traffic can be captured and compared to the original trace to evaluate accuracy and reliability. The resulting implementation is able to accurately replay connections within a maximum transmission rate but struggles with deviations from regular TCP connections, like packet loss or connection reset. An evaluation has been performed, measuring individual and aggregated delays between packets, based on the recorded timestamps.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Differentiating Network Flows for Priority-Aware Scheduling of Incoming Packets in Real-Time IoT Systems
Authors:
Christoph Blumschein,
Ilja Behnke,
Lauritz Thamsen,
Odej Kao
Abstract:
When IP-packet processing is unconditionally carried out on behalf of an operating system kernel thread, processing systems can experience overload in high incoming traffic scenarios. This is especially worrying for embedded real-time devices controlling their physical environment in industrial IoT scenarios and automotive systems. We propose an embedded real-time aware IP stack adaption with an e…
▽ More
When IP-packet processing is unconditionally carried out on behalf of an operating system kernel thread, processing systems can experience overload in high incoming traffic scenarios. This is especially worrying for embedded real-time devices controlling their physical environment in industrial IoT scenarios and automotive systems. We propose an embedded real-time aware IP stack adaption with an early demultiplexing scheme for incoming packets and subsequent per-flow aperiodic scheduling. By instrumenting existing embedded IP stacks, rigid prioritization with minimal latency is deployed without the need of further task resources. Simple mitigation techniques can be applied to individual flows, causing hardly measurable overhead while at the same time protecting the system from overload conditions. Our IP stack adaption is able to reduce the low-priority packet processing time by over 86% compared to an unmodified stack. The network subsystem can thereby remain active at a 7x higher general traffic load before disabling the receive IRQ as a last resort to assure deadlines.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
A Priority-Aware Multiqueue NIC Design
Authors:
Ilja Behnke,
Philipp Wiesner,
Robert Danicki,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
Low-level embedded systems are used to control cyber-phyiscal systems in industrial and autonomous applications. They need to meet hard real-time requirements as unanticipated controller delays on moving machines can have devastating effects. Modern developments such as the industrial Internet of Things and autonomous machines require these devices to connect to large IP networks. Since Network In…
▽ More
Low-level embedded systems are used to control cyber-phyiscal systems in industrial and autonomous applications. They need to meet hard real-time requirements as unanticipated controller delays on moving machines can have devastating effects. Modern developments such as the industrial Internet of Things and autonomous machines require these devices to connect to large IP networks. Since Network Interface Controllers (NICs) trigger interrupts for incoming packets, real-time embedded systems are subject to unpredictable preemptions when connected to such networks.
In this work, we propose a priority-aware NIC design to moderate network-generated interrupts by map** IP flows to processes and based on that, consolidates their packets into different queues. These queues apply priority-dependent interrupt moderation. First experimental evaluations show that 93% of interrupts can be saved leading to an 80% decrease of processing delay of critical tasks in the configurations investigated.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Continuously Testing Distributed IoT Systems: An Overview of the State of the Art
Authors:
Jossekin Beilharz,
Philipp Wiesner,
Arne Boockmeyer,
Lukas Pirl,
Dirk Friedenberger,
Florian Brokhausen,
Ilja Behnke,
Andreas Polze,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
The continuous testing of small changes to systems has proven to be useful and is widely adopted in the development of software systems. For this, software is tested in environments that are as close as possible to the production environments.
When testing IoT systems, this approach is met with unique challenges that stem from the typically large scale of the deployments, heterogeneity of nodes,…
▽ More
The continuous testing of small changes to systems has proven to be useful and is widely adopted in the development of software systems. For this, software is tested in environments that are as close as possible to the production environments.
When testing IoT systems, this approach is met with unique challenges that stem from the typically large scale of the deployments, heterogeneity of nodes, challenging network characteristics, and tight integration with the environment among others. IoT test environments present a possible solution to these challenges by emulating the nodes, networks, and possibly domain environments in which IoT applications can be executed.
This paper gives an overview of the state of the art in IoT testing. We derive desirable characteristics of IoT test environments, compare 18 tools that can be used in this respect, and give a research outlook of future trends in this area.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Let's Wait Awhile: How Temporal Workload Shifting Can Reduce Carbon Emissions in the Cloud
Authors:
Philipp Wiesner,
Ilja Behnke,
Dominik Scheinert,
Kordian Gontarska,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
Depending on energy sources and demand, the carbon intensity of the public power grid fluctuates over time. Exploiting this variability is an important factor in reducing the emissions caused by data centers. However, regional differences in the availability of low-carbon energy sources make it hard to provide general best practices for when to consume electricity. Moreover, existing research in t…
▽ More
Depending on energy sources and demand, the carbon intensity of the public power grid fluctuates over time. Exploiting this variability is an important factor in reducing the emissions caused by data centers. However, regional differences in the availability of low-carbon energy sources make it hard to provide general best practices for when to consume electricity. Moreover, existing research in this domain focuses mostly on carbon-aware workload migration across geo-distributed data centers, or addresses demand response purely from the perspective of power grid stability and costs.
In this paper, we examine the potential impact of shifting computational workloads towards times where the energy supply is expected to be less carbon-intensive. To this end, we identify characteristics of delay-tolerant workloads and analyze the potential for temporal workload shifting in Germany, Great Britain, France, and California over the year 2020. Furthermore, we experimentally evaluate two workload shifting scenarios in a simulation to investigate the influence of time constraints, scheduling strategies, and the accuracy of carbon intensity forecasts. To accelerate research in the domain of carbon-aware computing and to support the evaluation of novel scheduling algorithms, our simulation framework and datasets are publicly available.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Detecting and Mitigating Network Packet Overloads on Real-Time Devices in IoT Systems
Authors:
Robert Danicki,
Martin Haug,
Ilja Behnke,
Laurenz Mädje,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
Manufacturing, automotive, and aerospace environments use embedded systems for control and automation and need to fulfill strict real-time guarantees. To facilitate more efficient business processes and remote control, such devices are being connected to IP networks. Due to the difficulty in predicting network packets and the interrelated workloads of interrupt handlers and drivers, devices contro…
▽ More
Manufacturing, automotive, and aerospace environments use embedded systems for control and automation and need to fulfill strict real-time guarantees. To facilitate more efficient business processes and remote control, such devices are being connected to IP networks. Due to the difficulty in predicting network packets and the interrelated workloads of interrupt handlers and drivers, devices controlling time critical processes stand under the risk of missing process deadlines when under high network loads. Additionally, devices at the edge of large networks and the internet are subject to a high risk of load spikes and network packet overloads.
In this paper, we investigate strategies to detect network packet overloads in real-time and present four approaches to adaptively mitigate local deadline misses. In addition to two strategies mitigating network bursts with and without hysteresis, we present and discuss two novel mitigation algorithms, called Budget and Queue Mitigation. In an experimental evaluation, all algorithms showed mitigating effects, with the Queue Mitigation strategy enabling most packet processing while preventing lateness of critical tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 6 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
PIERES: A Playground for Network Interrupt Experiments on Real-Time Embedded Systems in the IoT
Authors:
Franz Bender,
Jan Jonas Brune,
Nick Lauritz Keutel,
Ilja Behnke,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
IoT devices have become an integral part of our lives and the industry. Many of these devices run real-time systems or are used as part of them. As these devices receive network packets over IP networks, the network interface informs the CPU about their arrival using interrupts that might preempt critical processes. Therefore, the question arises whether network interrupts pose a threat to the rea…
▽ More
IoT devices have become an integral part of our lives and the industry. Many of these devices run real-time systems or are used as part of them. As these devices receive network packets over IP networks, the network interface informs the CPU about their arrival using interrupts that might preempt critical processes. Therefore, the question arises whether network interrupts pose a threat to the real-timeness of these devices. However, there are few tools to investigate this issue. We present a playground which enables researchers to conduct experiments in the context of network interrupt simulation. The playground comprises different network interface controller implementations, load generators and timing utilities. It forms a flexible and easy to use foundation for future network interrupt research. We conduct two verification experiments and two real world examples. The latter give insight into the impact of the interrupt handling strategy parameters and the influence of different load types on the execution time with respect to these parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Interrupting Real-Time IoT Tasks: How Bad Can It Be to Connect Your Critical Embedded System to the Internet?
Authors:
Ilja Behnke,
Lukas Pirl,
Lauritz Thamsen,
Robert Danicki,
Andreas Polze,
Odej Kao
Abstract:
Embedded systems have been used to control physical environments for decades. Usually, such use cases require low latencies between commands and actions as well as a high predictability of the expected worst-case delay. To achieve this on small, low-powered microcontrollers, Real-Time Operating Systems (RTOSs) are used to manage the different tasks on these machines as deterministically as possibl…
▽ More
Embedded systems have been used to control physical environments for decades. Usually, such use cases require low latencies between commands and actions as well as a high predictability of the expected worst-case delay. To achieve this on small, low-powered microcontrollers, Real-Time Operating Systems (RTOSs) are used to manage the different tasks on these machines as deterministically as possible. However, with the advent of the Internet of Things (IoT) in industrial applications, the same embedded systems are now equipped with networking capabilities, possibly endangering critical real-time systems through an open gate to interrupts. This paper presents our initial study of the impact network connections can have on real-time embedded systems. Specifically, we look at three aspects: The impact of network-generated interrupts, the overhead of the related networking tasks, and the feasibility of sharing computing resources between networking and real-time tasks. We conducted experiments on two setups: One treating NICs and drivers as black boxes and one simulating network interrupts on the machines. The preliminary results show that a critical task performance loss of up to 6.67% per received packet per second could be induced where lateness impacts of 1% per packet per second can be attributed exclusively to ISR-generated delays.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2021; v1 submitted 10 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Towards a Staging Environment for the Internet of Things
Authors:
Jossekin Beilharz,
Philipp Wiesner,
Arne Boockmeyer,
Florian Brokhausen,
Ilja Behnke,
Robert Schmid,
Lukas Pirl,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
Internet of Things (IoT) applications promise to make many aspects of our lives more efficient and adaptive through the use of distributed sensing and computing nodes. A central aspect of such applications is their complex communication behavior that is heavily influenced by the physical environment of the system. To continuously improve IoT applications, a staging environment is needed that can p…
▽ More
Internet of Things (IoT) applications promise to make many aspects of our lives more efficient and adaptive through the use of distributed sensing and computing nodes. A central aspect of such applications is their complex communication behavior that is heavily influenced by the physical environment of the system. To continuously improve IoT applications, a staging environment is needed that can provide operating conditions representative of deployments in the actual production environments -- similar to what is common practice in cloud application development today. Towards such a staging environment, we present Marvis, a framework that orchestrates hybrid testbeds, co-simulated domain environments, and a central network simulation for testing distributed IoT applications. Our preliminary results include an open source prototype and a demonstration of a Vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communication scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A Scalable and Dependable Data Analytics Platform for Water Infrastructure Monitoring
Authors:
Felix Lorenz,
Morgan Geldenhuys,
Harald Sommer,
Frauke Jakobs,
Carsten Lüring,
Volker Skwarek,
Ilja Behnke,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
With weather becoming more extreme both in terms of longer dry periods and more severe rain events, municipal water networks are increasingly under pressure. The effects include damages to the pipes, flash floods on the streets and combined sewer overflows. Retrofitting underground infrastructure is very expensive, thus water infrastructure operators are increasingly looking to deploy IoT solution…
▽ More
With weather becoming more extreme both in terms of longer dry periods and more severe rain events, municipal water networks are increasingly under pressure. The effects include damages to the pipes, flash floods on the streets and combined sewer overflows. Retrofitting underground infrastructure is very expensive, thus water infrastructure operators are increasingly looking to deploy IoT solutions that promise to alleviate the problems at a fraction of the cost. In this paper, we report on preliminary results from an ongoing joint research project, specifically on the design and evaluation of its data analytics platform. The overall system consists of energy-efficient sensor nodes that send their observations to a stream processing engine, which analyzes and enriches the data and transmits the results to a GIS-based frontend. As the proposed solution is designed to monitor large and critical infrastructures of cities, several non-functional requirements such as scalability, responsiveness and dependability are factored into the system architecture. We present a scalable stream processing platform and its integration with the other components, as well as the algorithms used for data processing. We discuss significant challenges and design decisions, introduce an efficient data enrichment procedure and present empirical results to validate the compliance with the target requirements. The entire code for deploying our platform and running the data enrichment jobs is made publicly available with this paper.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2021; v1 submitted 1 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Fingerprinting Analog IoT Sensors for Secret-Free Authentication
Authors:
Felix Lorenz,
Lauritz Thamsen,
Andreas Wilke,
Ilja Behnke,
Jens Waldmüller-Littke,
Ilya Komarov,
Odej Kao,
Manfred Paeschke
Abstract:
Especially in context of critical urban infrastructures, trust in IoT data is of utmost importance. While most technology stacks provide means for authentication and encryption of device-to-cloud traffic, there are currently no mechanisms to rule out physical tampering with an IoT device's sensors. Addressing this gap, we introduce a new method for extracting a hardware fingerprint of an IoT senso…
▽ More
Especially in context of critical urban infrastructures, trust in IoT data is of utmost importance. While most technology stacks provide means for authentication and encryption of device-to-cloud traffic, there are currently no mechanisms to rule out physical tampering with an IoT device's sensors. Addressing this gap, we introduce a new method for extracting a hardware fingerprint of an IoT sensor which can be used for secret-free authentication. By comparing the fingerprint against reference measurements recorded prior to deployment, we can tell whether the sensing hardware connected to the IoT device has been changed by environmental effects or with malicious intent. Our approach exploits the characteristic behavior of analog circuits, which is revealed by applying a fixed-frequency alternating current to the sensor, while recording its output voltage. To demonstrate the general feasibility of our method, we apply it to four commercially available temperature sensors using laboratory equipment and evaluate the accuracy. The results indicate that with a sensible configuration of the two hyperparameters we can identify individual sensors with high probability, using only a few recordings from the target device.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
