US News and Social Media Framing around Va**
Authors:
Keyu Chen,
Marzieh Babaeianjelodar,
Yiwen Shi,
Rohan Aanegola,
Lam Yin Cheung,
Preslav Ivanov Nakov,
Shweta Yadav,
Angus Bancroft,
Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh,
Munmun De Choudhury,
Frederick L. Altice,
Navin Kumar
Abstract:
In this paper, we investigate how va** is framed differently (2008-2021) between US news and social media. We analyze 15,711 news articles and 1,231,379 Facebook posts about va** to study the differences in framing between media varieties. We use word embeddings to provide two-dimensional visualizations of the semantic changes around va** for news and for social media. We detail that news me…
▽ More
In this paper, we investigate how va** is framed differently (2008-2021) between US news and social media. We analyze 15,711 news articles and 1,231,379 Facebook posts about va** to study the differences in framing between media varieties. We use word embeddings to provide two-dimensional visualizations of the semantic changes around va** for news and for social media. We detail that news media framing of va** shifted over time in line with emergent regulatory trends, such as; flavored va** bans, with little discussion around va** as a smoking cessation tool. We found that social media discussions were far more varied, with transitions toward va** both as a public health harm and as a smoking cessation tool. Our cloze test, dynamic topic model, and question answering showed similar patterns, where social media, but not news media, characterizes va** as combustible cigarette substitute. We use n-grams to detail that social media data first centered on va** as a smoking cessation tool, and in 2019 moved toward narratives around va** regulation, similar to news media frames. Overall, social media tracks the evolution of va** as a social practice, while news media reflects more risk based concerns. A strength of our work is how the different techniques we have applied validate each other. Stakeholders may utilize our findings to intervene around the framing of va**, and may design communications campaigns that improve the way society sees va**, thus possibly aiding smoking cessation; and reducing youth va**.
△ Less
Submitted 22 July, 2022; v1 submitted 15 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
