-
On Minimizing Generalized Makespan on Unrelated Machines
Authors:
Nikhil Ayyadevara,
Nikhil Bansal,
Milind Prabhu
Abstract:
We consider the Generalized Makespan Problem (GMP) on unrelated machines, where we are given $n$ jobs and $m$ machines and each job $j$ has arbitrary processing time $p_{ij}$ on machine $i$. Additionally, there is a general symmetric monotone norm $ψ_i$ for each machine $i$, that determines the load on machine $i$ as a function of the sizes of jobs assigned to it. The goal is to assign the jobs to…
▽ More
We consider the Generalized Makespan Problem (GMP) on unrelated machines, where we are given $n$ jobs and $m$ machines and each job $j$ has arbitrary processing time $p_{ij}$ on machine $i$. Additionally, there is a general symmetric monotone norm $ψ_i$ for each machine $i$, that determines the load on machine $i$ as a function of the sizes of jobs assigned to it. The goal is to assign the jobs to minimize the maximum machine load.
Recently, Deng, Li, and Rabani (SODA'22) gave a $3$ approximation for GMP when the $ψ_i$ are top-$k$ norms, and they ask the question whether an $O(1)$ approximation exists for general norms $ψ$? We answer this negatively and show that, under natural complexity assumptions, there is some fixed constant $δ>0$, such that GMP is $Ω(\log^δ n)$ hard to approximate. We also give an $Ω(\log^{1/2} n)$ integrality gap for the natural configuration LP.
△ Less
Submitted 25 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Near-optimal Algorithms for Stochastic Online Bin Packing
Authors:
Nikhil Ayyadevara,
Rajni Dabas,
Arindam Khan,
K. V. N. Sreenivas
Abstract:
We study the online bin packing problem under two stochastic settings. In the bin packing problem, we are given n items with sizes in (0,1] and the goal is to pack them into the minimum number of unit-sized bins. First, we study bin packing under the i.i.d. model, where item sizes are sampled independently and identically from a distribution in (0,1]. Both the distribution and the total number of…
▽ More
We study the online bin packing problem under two stochastic settings. In the bin packing problem, we are given n items with sizes in (0,1] and the goal is to pack them into the minimum number of unit-sized bins. First, we study bin packing under the i.i.d. model, where item sizes are sampled independently and identically from a distribution in (0,1]. Both the distribution and the total number of items are unknown. The items arrive one by one and their sizes are revealed upon their arrival and they must be packed immediately and irrevocably in bins of size 1. We provide a simple meta-algorithm that takes an offline $α$-asymptotic approximation algorithm and provides a polynomial-time $(α+ \varepsilon)$-competitive algorithm for online bin packing under the i.i.d. model, where $\varepsilon$>0 is a small constant. Using the AFPTAS for offline bin packing, we thus provide a linear time $(1+\varepsilon)$-competitive algorithm for online bin packing under i.i.d. model, thus settling the problem.
We then study the random-order model, where an adversary specifies the items, but the order of arrival of items is drawn uniformly at random from the set of all permutations of the items. Kenyon's seminal result [SODA'96] showed that the Best-Fit algorithm has a competitive ratio of at most 3/2 in the random-order model, and conjectured the ratio to be around 1.15. However, it has been a long-standing open problem to break the barrier of 3/2 even for special cases. Recently, Albers et al. [Algorithmica'21] showed an improvement to 5/4 competitive ratio in the special case when all the item sizes are greater than 1/3. For this special case, we settle the analysis by showing that Best-Fit has a competitive ratio of 1. We make further progress by breaking the barrier of 3/2 for the 3-Partition problem, a notoriously hard special case of bin packing, where all item sizes lie in (1/4,1/2].
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
The Randomized Competitive Ratio of Weighted $k$-server is at least Exponential
Authors:
Nikhil Ayyadevara,
Ashish Chiplunkar
Abstract:
The weighted $k$-server problem is a natural generalization of the $k$-server problem in which the cost incurred in moving a server is the distance traveled times the weight of the server. Even after almost three decades since the seminal work of Fiat and Ricklin (1994), the competitive ratio of this problem remains poorly understood, even on the simplest class of metric spaces -- the uniform metr…
▽ More
The weighted $k$-server problem is a natural generalization of the $k$-server problem in which the cost incurred in moving a server is the distance traveled times the weight of the server. Even after almost three decades since the seminal work of Fiat and Ricklin (1994), the competitive ratio of this problem remains poorly understood, even on the simplest class of metric spaces -- the uniform metric spaces. In particular, in the case of randomized algorithms against the oblivious adversary, neither a better upper bound that the doubly exponential deterministic upper bound, nor a better lower bound than the logarithmic lower bound of unweighted $k$-server, is known. In this article, we make significant progress towards understanding the randomized competitive ratio of weighted $k$-server on uniform metrics. We cut down the triply exponential gap between the upper and lower bound to a singly exponential gap by proving that the competitive ratio is at least exponential in $k$, substantially improving on the previously known lower bound of about $\ln k$.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021; v1 submitted 22 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
