-
Total Turning and Motion Range Prediction for Safe Unicycle Control
Authors:
Abdulla Tarshahani,
Aykut İşleyen,
Ömür Arslan
Abstract:
Safe and smooth motion control is essential for mobile robots when performing various automation tasks around obstacles, especially in the presence of people and other mobile robots. The total turning and space used by a mobile robot while moving towards a specified goal position play a crucial role in determining the required control effort and complexity. In this paper, we consider a standard un…
▽ More
Safe and smooth motion control is essential for mobile robots when performing various automation tasks around obstacles, especially in the presence of people and other mobile robots. The total turning and space used by a mobile robot while moving towards a specified goal position play a crucial role in determining the required control effort and complexity. In this paper, we consider a standard unicycle control approach based on angular feedback linearization and provide an explicit analytical measure for determining the total turning effort during unicycle control in terms of unicycle state and control gains. We show that undesired spiral oscillatory motion around the goal position can be avoided by choosing a higher angular control gain compared to the linear control gain. Accordingly, we establish an accurate, explicit triangular motion range bound on the closed-loop unicycle trajectory using the total turning effort. The improved accuracy in motion range prediction results from a stronger dependency on the unicycle state and control parameters. To compare alternative circular, conic, and triangular motion range prediction approaches, we present an application of the proposed unicycle motion control and motion prediction methods for safe unicycle path following around obstacles in numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Graph-Theoretic Bézier Curve Optimization over Safe Corridors for Safe and Smooth Motion Planning
Authors:
Soufyan Zayou,
Ömür Arslan
Abstract:
As a parametric motion representation, Bézier curves have significant applications in polynomial trajectory optimization for safe and smooth motion planning of various robotic systems, including flying drones, autonomous vehicles, and robotic manipulators. An essential component of Bézier curve optimization is the optimization objective, as it significantly influences the resulting robot motion. S…
▽ More
As a parametric motion representation, Bézier curves have significant applications in polynomial trajectory optimization for safe and smooth motion planning of various robotic systems, including flying drones, autonomous vehicles, and robotic manipulators. An essential component of Bézier curve optimization is the optimization objective, as it significantly influences the resulting robot motion. Standard physical optimization objectives, such as minimizing total velocity, acceleration, jerk, and snap, are known to yield quadratic optimization of Bézier curve control points. In this paper, we present a unifying graph-theoretic perspective for defining and understanding Bézier curve optimization objectives using a consensus distance of Bézier control points derived based on their interaction graph Laplacian. In addition to demonstrating how standard physical optimization objectives define a consensus distance between Bézier control points, we also introduce geometric and statistical optimization objectives as alternative consensus distances, constructed using finite differencing and differential variance. To compare these optimization objectives, we apply Bézier curve optimization over convex polygonal safe corridors that are automatically constructed around a maximal-clearance minimal-length reference path. We provide an explicit analytical formulation for quadratic optimization of Bézier curves using Bézier matrix operations. We conclude that the norm and variance of the finite differences of Bézier control points lead to simpler and more intuitive interaction graphs and optimization objectives compared to Bézier derivative norms, despite having similar robot motion profiles.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Adaptive Headway Motion Control and Motion Prediction for Safe Unicycle Motion Design
Authors:
Aykut İşleyen,
Nathan van de Wouw,
Ömür Arslan
Abstract:
Differential drive robots that can be modeled as a kinematic unicycle are a standard mobile base platform for many service and logistics robots. Safe and smooth autonomous motion around obstacles is a crucial skill for unicycle robots to perform diverse tasks in complex environments. A classical control approach for unicycle control is feedback linearization using a headway point at a fixed headwa…
▽ More
Differential drive robots that can be modeled as a kinematic unicycle are a standard mobile base platform for many service and logistics robots. Safe and smooth autonomous motion around obstacles is a crucial skill for unicycle robots to perform diverse tasks in complex environments. A classical control approach for unicycle control is feedback linearization using a headway point at a fixed headway distance in front of the unicycle. The unicycle headway control brings the headway point to a desired goal location by embedding a linear headway reference dynamics, which often results in an undesired offset for the actual unicycle position. In this paper, we introduce a new unicycle headway control approach with an adaptive headway distance that overcomes this limitation, i.e., when the headway point reaches the goal the unicycle position is also at the goal. By systematically analyzing the closed-loop unicycle motion under the adaptive headway controller, we design analytical feedback motion prediction methods that bound the closed-loop unicycle position trajectory and so can be effectively used for safety assessment and safe unicycle motion design around obstacles. We present an application of adaptive headway motion control and motion prediction for safe unicycle path following around obstacles in numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Time Governors for Safe Path-Following Control
Authors:
Ömür Arslan
Abstract:
Safe and smooth robot motion around obstacles is an essential skill for autonomous robots, especially when operating around people and other robots. Conventionally, due to real-time operation requirements and onboard computation limitations, many robot motion planning and control methods follow a two-step approach: first construct a (e.g., piecewise linear) collision-free reference path for a simp…
▽ More
Safe and smooth robot motion around obstacles is an essential skill for autonomous robots, especially when operating around people and other robots. Conventionally, due to real-time operation requirements and onboard computation limitations, many robot motion planning and control methods follow a two-step approach: first construct a (e.g., piecewise linear) collision-free reference path for a simplified robot model, and then execute the reference plan via path-following control for a more accurate and complex robot model. A challenge of such a decoupled robot motion planning and control method for highly dynamic robotic systems is ensuring the safety of path-following control as well as the successful completion of the reference plan. In this paper, we introduce a novel dynamical systems approach for online closed-loop time parametrization, called $\textit{a time governor}$, of a reference path for provably correct and safe path-following control based on feedback motion prediction, where the safety of robot motion under path-following control is continuously monitored using predicted robot motion. After introducing the general framework of time governors for safe path following, we present an example application for the fully actuated high-order robot dynamics using proportional-and-higher-order-derivative (PhD) path-following control whose feedback motion prediction is performed by Lyapunov ellipsoids and Vandemonde simplexes. In numerical simulations, we investigate the role of reference position and velocity feedback, and motion prediction on path-following performance and robot motion.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Feedback Motion Prediction for Safe Unicycle Robot Navigation
Authors:
Aykut İşleyen,
Nathan van de Wouw,
Ömür Arslan
Abstract:
As a simple and robust mobile robot base, differential drive robots that can be modelled as a kinematic unicycle find significant applications in logistics and service robotics in both industrial and domestic settings. Safe robot navigation around obstacles is an essential skill for such unicycle robots to perform diverse useful tasks in complex cluttered environments, especially around people and…
▽ More
As a simple and robust mobile robot base, differential drive robots that can be modelled as a kinematic unicycle find significant applications in logistics and service robotics in both industrial and domestic settings. Safe robot navigation around obstacles is an essential skill for such unicycle robots to perform diverse useful tasks in complex cluttered environments, especially around people and other robots. Fast and accurate safety assessment plays a key role in reactive and safe robot motion design. In this paper, as a more accurate and still simple alternative to the standard circular Lyapunov level sets, we introduce novel conic feedback motion prediction methods for bounding the close-loop motion trajectory of the kinematic unicycle robot model under a standard unicycle motion control approach. We present an application of unicycle feedback motion prediction for safe robot navigation around obstacles using reference governors, where the safety of a unicycle robot is continuously monitored based on the predicted future robot motion. We investigate the role of motion prediction on robot behaviour in numerical simulations and conclude that fast and accurate feedback motion prediction is key for fast, reactive, and safe robot navigation around obstacles.
△ Less
Submitted 31 July, 2023; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
From Low to High Order Motion Planners: Safe Robot Navigation using Motion Prediction and Reference Governor
Authors:
Aykut İşleyen,
Nathan van de Wouw,
Ömür Arslan
Abstract:
Safe navigation around obstacles is a fundamental challenge for highly dynamic robots. The state-of-the-art approach for adapting simple reference path planners to complex robot dynamics using trajectory optimization and tracking control is brittle and requires significant replanning cycles. In this paper, we introduce a novel feedback motion planning framework that extends the applicability of lo…
▽ More
Safe navigation around obstacles is a fundamental challenge for highly dynamic robots. The state-of-the-art approach for adapting simple reference path planners to complex robot dynamics using trajectory optimization and tracking control is brittle and requires significant replanning cycles. In this paper, we introduce a novel feedback motion planning framework that extends the applicability of low-order (e.g. position-/velocity-controlled) reference motion planners to high-order (e.g., acceleration-/jerk-controlled) robot models using motion prediction and reference governors. We use predicted robot motion range for safety assessment and establish a bidirectional interface between high-level planning and low-level control via a reference governor. We describe the generic fundamental building blocks of our feedback motion planning framework and give specific example constructions for motion control, prediction, and reference planning. We prove the correctness of our planning framework and demonstrate its performance in numerical simulations. We conclude that accurate motion prediction is crucial for closing the gap between high-level planning and low-level control.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Adaptive Bézier Degree Reduction and Splitting for Computationally Efficient Motion Planning
Authors:
Ömür Arslan,
Aron Tiemessen
Abstract:
As a parametric polynomial curve family, Bézier curves are widely used in safe and smooth motion design of intelligent robotic systems from flying drones to autonomous vehicles to robotic manipulators. In such motion planning settings, the critical features of high-order Bézier curves such as curve length, distance-to-collision, maximum curvature/velocity/acceleration are either numerically comput…
▽ More
As a parametric polynomial curve family, Bézier curves are widely used in safe and smooth motion design of intelligent robotic systems from flying drones to autonomous vehicles to robotic manipulators. In such motion planning settings, the critical features of high-order Bézier curves such as curve length, distance-to-collision, maximum curvature/velocity/acceleration are either numerically computed at a high computational cost or inexactly approximated by discrete samples. To address these issues, in this paper we present a novel computationally efficient approach for adaptive approximation of high-order Bézier curves by multiple low-order Bézier segments at any desired level of accuracy that is specified in terms of a Bézier metric. Accordingly, we introduce a new Bézier degree reduction method, called parameterwise matching reduction, that approximates Bézier curves more accurately compared to the standard least squares and Taylor reduction methods. We also propose a new Bézier metric, called the maximum control-point distance, that can be computed analytically, has a strong equivalence relation with other existing Bézier metrics, and defines a geometric relative bound between Bézier curves. We provide extensive numerical evidence to demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed Bézier approximation approach. As a rule of thumb, based on the degree-one matching reduction error, we conclude that an $n^\text{th}$-order Bézier curve can be accurately approximated by $3(n-1)$ quadratic and $6(n-1)$ linear Bézier segments, which is fundamental for Bézier discretization.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Training Data Reduction for Performance Models of Data Analytics Jobs in the Cloud
Authors:
Jonathan Will,
Onur Arslan,
Jonathan Bader,
Dominik Scheinert,
Lauritz Thamsen
Abstract:
Distributed dataflow systems like Apache Flink and Apache Spark simplify processing large amounts of data on clusters in a data-parallel manner. However, choosing suitable cluster resources for distributed dataflow jobs in both type and number is difficult, especially for users who do not have access to previous performance metrics. One approach to overcoming this issue is to have users share runt…
▽ More
Distributed dataflow systems like Apache Flink and Apache Spark simplify processing large amounts of data on clusters in a data-parallel manner. However, choosing suitable cluster resources for distributed dataflow jobs in both type and number is difficult, especially for users who do not have access to previous performance metrics. One approach to overcoming this issue is to have users share runtime metrics to train context-aware performance models that help find a suitable configuration for the job at hand. A problem when sharing runtime data instead of trained models or model parameters is that the data size can grow substantially over time.
This paper examines several clustering techniques to minimize training data size while kee** the associated performance models accurate. Our results indicate that efficiency gains in data transfer, storage, and model training can be achieved through training data reduction. In the evaluation of our solution on a dataset of runtime data from 930 unique distributed dataflow jobs, we observed that, on average, a 75% data reduction only increases prediction errors by one percentage point.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2022; v1 submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Fast and Safe Path-Following Control using a State-Dependent Directional Metric
Authors:
Zhichao Li,
Omur Arslan,
Nikolay Atanasov
Abstract:
This paper considers the problem of fast and safe autonomous navigation in partially known environments. Our main contribution is a control policy design based on ellipsoidal trajectory bounds obtained from a quadratic state-dependent distance metric. The ellipsoidal bounds are used to embed directional preference in the control design, leading to system behavior that is adapted to the local envir…
▽ More
This paper considers the problem of fast and safe autonomous navigation in partially known environments. Our main contribution is a control policy design based on ellipsoidal trajectory bounds obtained from a quadratic state-dependent distance metric. The ellipsoidal bounds are used to embed directional preference in the control design, leading to system behavior that is adapted to the local environment geometry, carefully considering medial obstacles while paying less attention to lateral ones. We use a virtual reference governor system to adaptively follow a desired navigation path, slowing down when system safety may be violated and speeding up otherwise. The resulting controller is able to navigate complex environments faster than common Euclidean-norm and Lyapunov-function-based designs, while retaining stability and collision avoidance guarantees.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2020; v1 submitted 5 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Probabilistically Safe Corridors to Guide Sampling-Based Motion Planning
Authors:
**wook Huh,
Omur Arslan,
Daniel D. Lee
Abstract:
In this paper, we introduce a new probabilistically safe local steering primitive for sampling-based motion planning in complex high-dimensional configuration spaces. Our local steering procedure is based on a new notion of a convex probabilistically safe corridor that is constructed around a configuration using tangent hyperplanes of confidence ellipsoids of Gaussian mixture models learned from p…
▽ More
In this paper, we introduce a new probabilistically safe local steering primitive for sampling-based motion planning in complex high-dimensional configuration spaces. Our local steering procedure is based on a new notion of a convex probabilistically safe corridor that is constructed around a configuration using tangent hyperplanes of confidence ellipsoids of Gaussian mixture models learned from prior collision history. Accordingly, we propose to expand a random motion planning graph towards a sample goal using its projection onto probabilistically safe corridors, which efficiently exploits the local geometry of configuration spaces for selecting proper steering direction and adapting steering stepsize. We observe that the proposed local steering procedure generates effective steering motion around difficult regions of configuration spaces, such as narrow passages, while minimizing collision likelihood. We evaluate the proposed steering method with randomized motion planners in a number of planning scenarios, both in simulation and on a physical 7DoF robot arm, demonstrating the effectiveness of our safety guided local planner over the standard straight-line planner.
△ Less
Submitted 1 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Technical Report: Sensor-Based Reactive Symbolic Planning in Partially Known Environments
Authors:
Vasileios Vasilopoulos,
William Vega-Brown,
Omur Arslan,
Nicholas Roy,
Daniel E. Koditschek
Abstract:
This paper considers the problem of completing assemblies of passive objects in nonconvex environments, cluttered with convex obstacles of unknown position, shape and size that satisfy a specific separation assumption. A differential drive robot equipped with a gripper and a LIDAR sensor, capable of perceiving its environment only locally, is used to position the passive objects in a desired confi…
▽ More
This paper considers the problem of completing assemblies of passive objects in nonconvex environments, cluttered with convex obstacles of unknown position, shape and size that satisfy a specific separation assumption. A differential drive robot equipped with a gripper and a LIDAR sensor, capable of perceiving its environment only locally, is used to position the passive objects in a desired configuration. The method combines the virtues of a deliberative planner generating high-level, symbolic commands, with the formal guarantees of convergence and obstacle avoidance of a reactive planner that requires little onboard computation and is used online. The validity of the proposed method is verified both with formal proofs and numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2018; v1 submitted 16 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Incremental Sampling-based Motion Planners Using Policy Iteration Methods
Authors:
Oktay Arslan,
Panagiotis Tsiotras
Abstract:
Recent progress in randomized motion planners has led to the development of a new class of sampling-based algorithms that provide asymptotic optimality guarantees, notably the RRT* and the PRM* algorithms. Careful analysis reveals that the so-called "rewiring" step in these algorithms can be interpreted as a local policy iteration (PI) step (i.e., a local policy evaluation step followed by a local…
▽ More
Recent progress in randomized motion planners has led to the development of a new class of sampling-based algorithms that provide asymptotic optimality guarantees, notably the RRT* and the PRM* algorithms. Careful analysis reveals that the so-called "rewiring" step in these algorithms can be interpreted as a local policy iteration (PI) step (i.e., a local policy evaluation step followed by a local policy improvement step) so that asymptotically, as the number of samples tend to infinity, both algorithms converge to the optimal path almost surely (with probability 1). Policy iteration, along with value iteration (VI) are common methods for solving dynamic programming (DP) problems. Based on this observation, recently, the RRT$^{\#}$ algorithm has been proposed, which performs, during each iteration, Bellman updates (aka "backups") on those vertices of the graph that have the potential of being part of the optimal path (i.e., the "promising" vertices). The RRT$^{\#}$ algorithm thus utilizes dynamic programming ideas and implements them incrementally on randomly generated graphs to obtain high quality solutions. In this work, and based on this key insight, we explore a different class of dynamic programming algorithms for solving shortest-path problems on random graphs generated by iterative sampling methods. These class of algorithms utilize policy iteration instead of value iteration, and thus are better suited for massive parallelization. Contrary to the RRT* algorithm, the policy improvement during the rewiring step is not performed only locally but rather on a set of vertices that are classified as "promising" during the current iteration. This tends to speed-up the whole process. The resulting algorithm, aptly named Policy Iteration-RRT$^{\#}$ (PI-RRT$^{\#}$) is the first of a new class of DP-inspired algorithms for randomized motion planning that utilize PI methods.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Sampling-based Algorithms for Optimal Motion Planning Using Closed-loop Prediction
Authors:
Oktay Arslan,
Karl Berntorp,
Panagiotis Tsiotras
Abstract:
Motion planning under differential constraints, kinodynamic motion planning, is one of the canonical problems in robotics. Currently, state-of-the-art methods evolve around kinodynamic variants of popular sampling-based algorithms, such as Rapidly-exploring Random Trees (RRTs). However, there are still challenges remaining, for example, how to include complex dynamics while guaranteeing optimality…
▽ More
Motion planning under differential constraints, kinodynamic motion planning, is one of the canonical problems in robotics. Currently, state-of-the-art methods evolve around kinodynamic variants of popular sampling-based algorithms, such as Rapidly-exploring Random Trees (RRTs). However, there are still challenges remaining, for example, how to include complex dynamics while guaranteeing optimality. If the open-loop dynamics are unstable, exploration by random sampling in control space becomes inefficient. We describe a new sampling-based algorithm, called CL-RRT#, which leverages ideas from the RRT# algorithm and a variant of the RRT algorithm that generates trajectories using closed-loop prediction. The idea of planning with closed-loop prediction allows us to handle complex unstable dynamics and avoids the need to find computationally hard steering procedures. The search technique presented in the RRT# algorithm allows us to improve the solution quality by searching over alternative reference trajectories. Numerical simulations using a nonholonomic system demonstrate the benefits of the proposed approach.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Voronoi-Based Coverage Control of Heterogeneous Disk-Shaped Robots
Authors:
Omur Arslan,
Daniel E. Koditschek
Abstract:
In distributed mobile sensing applications, networks of agents that are heterogeneous respecting both actuation as well as body and sensory footprint are often modelled by recourse to power diagrams --- generalized Voronoi diagrams with additive weights. In this paper we adapt the body power diagram to introduce its "free subdiagram," generating a vector field planner that solves the combined sens…
▽ More
In distributed mobile sensing applications, networks of agents that are heterogeneous respecting both actuation as well as body and sensory footprint are often modelled by recourse to power diagrams --- generalized Voronoi diagrams with additive weights. In this paper we adapt the body power diagram to introduce its "free subdiagram," generating a vector field planner that solves the combined sensory coverage and collision avoidance problem via continuous evaluation of an associated constrained optimization problem. We propose practical extensions (a heuristic congestion manager that speeds convergence and a lift of the point particle controller to the more practical differential drive kinematics) that maintain the convergence and collision guarantees.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Coordinated Robot Navigation via Hierarchical Clustering
Authors:
Omur Arslan,
Dan P. Guralnik,
Daniel E. Koditschek
Abstract:
We introduce the use of hierarchical clustering for relaxed, deterministic coordination and control of multiple robots. Traditionally an unsupervised learning method, hierarchical clustering offers a formalism for identifying and representing spatially cohesive and segregated robot groups at different resolutions by relating the continuous space of configurations to the combinatorial space of tree…
▽ More
We introduce the use of hierarchical clustering for relaxed, deterministic coordination and control of multiple robots. Traditionally an unsupervised learning method, hierarchical clustering offers a formalism for identifying and representing spatially cohesive and segregated robot groups at different resolutions by relating the continuous space of configurations to the combinatorial space of trees. We formalize and exploit this relation, develo** computationally effective reactive algorithms for navigating through the combinatorial space in concert with geometric realizations for a particular choice of hierarchical clustering method. These constructions yield computationally effective vector field planners for both hierarchically invariant as well as transitional navigation in the configuration space. We apply these methods to the centralized coordination and control of $n$ perfectly sensed and actuated Euclidean spheres in a $d$-dimensional ambient space (for arbitrary $n$ and $d$). Given a desired configuration supporting a desired hierarchy, we construct a hybrid controller which is quadratic in $n$ and algebraic in $d$ and prove that its execution brings all but a measure zero set of initial configurations to the desired goal with the guarantee of no collisions along the way.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Information-Theoretic Stochastic Optimal Control via Incremental Sampling-based Algorithms
Authors:
Oktay Arslan,
Evangelos Theodorou,
Panagiotis Tsiotras
Abstract:
This paper considers optimal control of dynamical systems which are represented by nonlinear stochastic differential equations. It is well-known that the optimal control policy for this problem can be obtained as a function of a value function that satisfies a nonlinear partial differential equation, namely, the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation. This nonlinear PDE must be solved backwards in time,…
▽ More
This paper considers optimal control of dynamical systems which are represented by nonlinear stochastic differential equations. It is well-known that the optimal control policy for this problem can be obtained as a function of a value function that satisfies a nonlinear partial differential equation, namely, the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation. This nonlinear PDE must be solved backwards in time, and this computation is intractable for large scale systems. Under certain assumptions, and after applying a logarithmic transformation, an alternative characterization of the optimal policy can be given in terms of a path integral. Path Integral (PI) based control methods have recently been shown to provide elegant solutions to a broad class of stochastic optimal control problems. One of the implementation challenges with this formalism is the computation of the expectation of a cost functional over the trajectories of the unforced dynamics. Computing such expectation over trajectories that are sampled uniformly may induce numerical instabilities due to the exponentiation of the cost. Therefore, sampling of low-cost trajectories is essential for the practical implementation of PI-based methods. In this paper, we use incremental sampling-based algorithms to sample useful trajectories from the unforced system dynamics, and make a novel connection between Rapidly-exploring Random Trees (RRTs) and information-theoretic stochastic optimal control. We show the results from the numerical implementation of the proposed approach to several examples.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Anytime Hierarchical Clustering
Authors:
Omur Arslan,
Daniel E. Koditschek
Abstract:
We propose a new anytime hierarchical clustering method that iteratively transforms an arbitrary initial hierarchy on the configuration of measurements along a sequence of trees we prove for a fixed data set must terminate in a chain of nested partitions that satisfies a natural homogeneity requirement. Each recursive step re-edits the tree so as to improve a local measure of cluster homogeneity t…
▽ More
We propose a new anytime hierarchical clustering method that iteratively transforms an arbitrary initial hierarchy on the configuration of measurements along a sequence of trees we prove for a fixed data set must terminate in a chain of nested partitions that satisfies a natural homogeneity requirement. Each recursive step re-edits the tree so as to improve a local measure of cluster homogeneity that is compatible with a number of commonly used (e.g., single, average, complete) linkage functions. As an alternative to the standard batch algorithms, we present numerical evidence to suggest that appropriate adaptations of this method can yield decentralized, scalable algorithms suitable for distributed/parallel computation of clustering hierarchies and online tracking of clustering trees applicable to large, dynamically changing databases and anomaly detection.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Discriminative Measures for Comparison of Phylogenetic Trees
Authors:
Omur Arslan,
Dan P. Guralnik,
Daniel E. Koditschek
Abstract:
In this paper we introduce and study three new measures for efficient discriminative comparison of phylogenetic trees. The NNI navigation dissimilarity $d_{nav}$ counts the steps along a "combing" of the Nearest Neighbor Interchange (NNI) graph of binary hierarchies, providing an efficient approximation to the (NP-hard) NNI distance in terms of "edit length". At the same time, a closed form formul…
▽ More
In this paper we introduce and study three new measures for efficient discriminative comparison of phylogenetic trees. The NNI navigation dissimilarity $d_{nav}$ counts the steps along a "combing" of the Nearest Neighbor Interchange (NNI) graph of binary hierarchies, providing an efficient approximation to the (NP-hard) NNI distance in terms of "edit length". At the same time, a closed form formula for $d_{nav}$ presents it as a weighted count of pairwise incompatibilities between clusters, lending it the character of an edge dissimilarity measure as well. A relaxation of this formula to a simple count yields another measure on all trees --- the crossing dissimilarity $d_{CM}$. Both dissimilarities are symmetric and positive definite (vanish only between identical trees) on binary hierarchies but they fail to satisfy the triangle inequality. Nevertheless, both are bounded below by the widely used Robinson-Foulds metric and bounded above by a closely related true metric, the cluster-cardinality metric $d_{CC}$. We show that each of the three proposed new dissimilarities is computable in time $O(n^2)$ in the number of leaves $n$, and conclude the paper with a brief numerical exploration of the distribution over tree space of these dissimilarities in comparison with the Robinson-Foulds metric and the more recently introduced matching-split distance.
△ Less
Submitted 20 October, 2015; v1 submitted 19 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
The Role of Vertex Consistency in Sampling-based Algorithms for Optimal Motion Planning
Authors:
Oktay Arslan,
Panagiotis Tsiotras
Abstract:
Motion planning problems have been studied by both the robotics and the controls research communities for a long time, and many algorithms have been developed for their solution. Among them, incremental sampling-based motion planning algorithms, such as the Rapidly-exploring Random Trees (RRTs), and the Probabilistic Road Maps (PRMs) have become very popular recently, owing to their implementation…
▽ More
Motion planning problems have been studied by both the robotics and the controls research communities for a long time, and many algorithms have been developed for their solution. Among them, incremental sampling-based motion planning algorithms, such as the Rapidly-exploring Random Trees (RRTs), and the Probabilistic Road Maps (PRMs) have become very popular recently, owing to their implementation simplicity and their advantages in handling high-dimensional problems. Although these algorithms work very well in practice, the quality of the computed solution is often not good, i.e., the solution can be far from the optimal one. A recent variation of RRT, namely the RRT* algorithm, bypasses this drawback of the traditional RRT algorithm, by ensuring asymptotic optimality as the number of samples tends to infinity. Nonetheless, the convergence rate to the optimal solution may still be slow. This paper presents a new incremental sampling-based motion planning algorithm based on Rapidly-exploring Random Graphs (RRG), denoted RRT# (RRT "sharp") which also guarantees asymptotic optimality but, in addition, it also ensures that the constructed spanning tree of the geometric graph is consistent after each iteration. In consistent trees, the vertices which have the potential to be part of the optimal solution have the minimum cost-come-value. This implies that the best possible solution is readily computed if there are some vertices in the current graph that are already in the goal region. Numerical results compare with the RRT* algorithm.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
